New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
Honestly, at this point Celebrimbor was ready to give everything up as a lost cause. His terminal curiosity and urge to solve problems aside, he had, by this point, utterly lost his appetite to investigate further what had been advertised to him as a funny relationship experiment, but had turned out to be a veritable psychological and interpersonal minefield.
Which would have been bad enough on its own, but on top of that - to extend the analogy further –Annatar staunchly refused to tell him where the bombs were buried, and Celebrimbor kept stepping on every single one with dream-like surety.
It was a mess.
They had a few very spirited arguments about it, where Celebrimbor wanted to refuse to continue the charade, and Annatar obstinately refused to break it off, with Celebrimbor retracting his support and participation, and Annatar faulting him for leaving him alone in this – which was all discussed in a very calm and mature manner and did in no way involve shouting, badly disguised emotional blackmail and chucking the blame at each other like a bomb with a burning fuse.
(Why why why did bombs keep coming up whenever Celebrimbor thought about the two of them?)
(The idea surged, and he quickly buried it again because he truly didn’t have the time to think about what this implied.)
The very picture of a good relationship it was, truly.
As it was, they didn’t fall out for good.
However, was no denying that the experiment was putting a strain on their relationship that hadn’t been there before. A strain that Celebrimbor viewed with increasing worry, because he wasn’t entirely sure how long they could keep pushing this until something gave, be it someone’s temper or something going even more wrong than usual.
As it was, they also didn’t discontinue the experiment, very much against their better knowledge – mainly because Annatar had always been as obstinate as a mountain troll, but ever since he had an endocrinological system, his moods had become three times worse than usual. There was no convincing him to stop and Celebrimbor – very aware of the flimsy reasoning involved – guessed that it was better if he stayed involved so that Annatar at least wouldn’t be alone in the moment when he inevitably ran this wreck of a venture full-speed into a mountainside.
That being said, if common sense had ever been involved in this venture, it had, by now, packed its bags and flounced of to an extended sojourn at the beaches of Harad with a very rude gesture. So. Well. That was that.
At least they still had other projects to take their minds of the insanity of interpersonal relationships, and Celebrimbor had never been happier about it.
They had even made progress with the speaking device that Annatar wanted to create for Wraith. They had jury-rigged a sound-to-speech device with the help of the Faculty Of Information Technology (Signal Technology, to be exact), but subsequently run into the problem that vocalizations of cats were simply too limited to express the variety of concepts that Wraith now understood. Anything beyond “hungry”, “pet me”, “go away” or ideas of a similar level were simply not expressible in the capped number of variants of meowing, hissing, and yowling that cats could generally produce.
“Hm,” Celebrimbor said. “Sound-to-speech isn’t feasible if you have too few sounds as input.”
Annatar frowned at Wraith. “Looks like it.”
“I wonder if she would be able to practice osanwë.”
“She is,” Annatar said with a shrug, as if that wasn’t the most spectacular biological reveal of the last millennium.
Celebrimbor blinked. “She is?”
Annatar made a brief, encouraging gesture with his hand, along the lines of, Go ahead, try it.
Celebrimbor focused on Wraith.
Can you hear me?
—I can not hear with my mind. I can perceive your thoughts, if that is what you mean.
Celebrimbor stared at her, wide-eyed. “It works!”
“Of course it works,” Annatar said flatly. “I just told you so.”
“Yes – but.” Celebrimbor blinked. “The cat can do osanwë! Why? Not even the great eagles or dolphins can do it!”
—Compare me to oversized chicken and hairless water dogs one more time, I dare you.
Celebrimbor glanced at her. “I – that’s remarkable.” He looked at Annatar. “What have you been doing to her brain?”
Annatar shrugged. “It wasn’t a conscious thing. Ainur sometimes shape the world around them. Aulë could bring rare earths to synthesize simply by standing in one spot for too long. Vairë was even worse – the rare times when she showed her face, cause, effect, and coincidence started … acting up. Melkor …” he trailed off.
Celebrimbor went still.
“He distorted reality,” Annatar finished.
“As in –”
“Space-time, yes. Think a black hole, but it walks around in Tirion and bothers people. And that was after we had reined ourselves into appearances that wouldn’t break the minds of mortals like our primordial forms would have done.”
Celebrimbor stared at him. “That is terrifying.”
“Yes, and that was the being that your grandfather chose to mouth off to.”
“My grandfather was very intelligent. Nobody said he was wise.”
“No.” Annatar sighed. “Probably not. To return to the topic at hand: we have a way of influencing our surroundings. The effect is far more pronounced in Valar than in Maiar, but apparently I have a way of causing …”
“Intelligence development?”
Annatar shook his head. “No, that is too specific. I think … development in general. I know processes. I know optimization and error elimination. I wouldn’t be surprised if something of it rubbed off on my surroundings.”
“Well, here’s a cat that is self-aware, uses advanced reasoning and is capable of osanwë. I’d say that this hypothesis is fairly close to being proven.”
—You can talk to me, Wraith thought, disgruntled. I’m right here.
“That solves the problem of speaking to the Eldar,” Celebrimbor mused, rubbing his chin. “But still, there are the Khazad and all humans to be considered.”
—That, and overusing osanwë gives me a headache.
Annatar waved it off. “You’re not used to it yet,” he said aloud. “It will get better with time.”
In response to this, Wraith made a nightmarish retching face: bug-eyed, tongue lolling and squinting outward, what in all hells, for Varda’s sake –
She gagged, and for one moment Celebrimbor thought she was going to throw up right there on the floor.
“Wraith,” Annatar said flatly.
What, she tapped on her card, her nightmarish grimace still a frozen rictus on her face.
The Maia threw her a look, then turned to Celebrimbor, who was standing near the desk, drumming his fingers on the top and consciously ignoring the bug-eyed cat.
“If there only was a way to translate thoughts to speech.” Celebrimbor frowned, looked up. “Didn’t you mention that you were working on something like that?”
Annatar’s face went through a very complicated expression that Celebrimbor couldn’t even hope to begin to decipher. “I abandoned the project.”
“Why?” Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow.
“It didn’t work.”
“It didn’t work? An idea of you did not work?”
Annatar waved it off impatiently, then turned back to Wraith, who was staring up at him out of the turbulent seas of her word-cards, her face once again normal, thank fate.
The cat slapped her paw down on her cards, forgoing osanwë in favour of a more paws-on approach. What-are-you-looking-at-me-for? The-answer-to-your-incapability-is-not-lying-here-on-the-floor.
Annatar inclined his head to one side. “Right now, I’m wondering whether I should take a hint that fate sent me and just leave you as pleasantly silent as you are now. That way, at least humans and dwarves are safe from you.”
A-R-S-E.
“Takes one to know one,” Annatar replied.
I-learn-by-example. What-is-your-excuse?
Celebrimbor, who had turned around to fiddle with the impractical speech device in a lone corner of the room, chortled. Cat and Maia turned to stare at him as one.
“Excuse you?” the Maia said, annoyed.
Silence-on-the-peanut-gallery! Wraith slapped out on her cards.
Celebrimbor raised one eyebrow. The cat knew allegories and metaphors and idioms, and even knew how to use them, in this specific instance, however – “How do you know this particular expression, Wraith?”
Why?
“Well, this is very much thespian vernacular, and this I do not see Annatar using.”
The-B-A-R-D-taught-me-of-course. The cat was looking very self-satisfied.
“You are in contact with Deukalion?” Annatar asked sharply.
Naturally. The cat licked her paw, then went on to drum out her answer on the cards. He-is-very-sociable-and-amusing. It-is-a-nice-change-from-my-usual-company. He-is-entertaining-for-a-two-legs. He-also-teaches-me-interesting-vocabulary.
Celebrimbor raised one eyebrow. “Ah, so you didn’t learn cursing out of books after all.”
Of-course-not.
“Ah, so that’s why you’re getting more and more insufferable,” Annatar said. “I should have known.”
Hardly-as-insufferable-as-you-two. How-is-mastering-mating-coming-along-by-the-way-O-great-and-O-M-N-I-P-O-T-E-N-T-master?
Celebrimbor hadn’t heretofore known that cats were able to look smug. He quickly reasserted this mistaken assumption, then reached out to keep Annatar from saying something to an animal that he would regret. It was hardly fair for a Maia to get into an argument with a cat. The blasted little monsters always won, and Annatar’s self-respect would never recover.
*
“I’m thinking about abandoning the project altogether,” Annatar growled later as they were climbing the stairs towards Celebrimbor’s rooms.
“Out of sheer spite?” Celebrimbor asked. “Come on, you are better than that.”
Annatar’s expression told him that, no, the Maia absolutely wasn’t better than that, and that he wouldn’t dream of taking the high road if he could dropkick Wraith over the city walls instead.
“But on another note,” Celebrimbor continued. “How in all of the world did Daeror manage to get a hold of your cat?”
“Search me,” Annatar grumbled. “I’ve been wondering about it myself and regretting the fact ever since I came to know it. Blasted cat,” he said, then added, with feeling, “And blasted bard.”
“Well, look at it from the bright side: Daeror has finally found something other than our private life to occupy his time.”
“Yes, he graduated from snooping around in my non-existent sex life to indoctrinating and corrupting my cat. Joy of all joys,” Annatar said unenthusiastically as they stopped in front of the door leading to Celebrimbor’s rooms. “The world has taken a turn for the better, truly. The Blessed Age must be upon us. Eru threw away the keys to the Doors of the Void. The Dagor Dagorath has been cancelled. Rejoice.” A pause. “One of these days I going to strangle him.”
“Yes, yes,” Celebrimbor waved it off. “Between letting him steal your food and teaming up with him to destroy a career of another of his rivals. We’ve had that conversation about barking and not biting.”
“I have a feeling that you are not taking me seriously.”
Celebrimbor looked at him while he turned the key in the lock. “As a person and partner? Very much. As an incarnation of divine vengeance come down from the Outer Spheres upon the head of a mouthy bard? Not so much. I’ll believe it when I see it.”
Annatar was silent. “You have a very skewed picture of me.”
Celebrimbor shrugged. “I’d like to think that I know you fairly well after spending nearly every day side by side with you for the last five centuries. Disprove it, and I’ll be the first to admit being wrong.” He turned around while stepping backwards into the door, raising an eyebrow in a challenging unspoken Well?
Annatar evaded his gaze. He didn’t reply.
*
They didn’t speak further of Daeror, Wraith, or Annatar’s debatable tendency-and-or willingness to divinely smite people that got on his nerves. Instead, they discussed their Ring project a bit further, but not even this could raise Annatar’s spirits.
The Maia had been strangely withdrawn ever since they had entered the tower and gave monosyllabic answers to everything Celebrimbor said.
The elf tried to keep the conversation going, attempted not to let the dampened mood get to him, but at some point, he realized that it was a lost cause tonight.
“What is wrong?” Celebrimbor asked.
Annatar looked up from where he had sat in his custom spot in one armchair, one knee drawn up, arms looped around his leg, chin resting on top of his knee, staring out of the window and watching the sunset.
It was a strange change ever since the Maia had started incarnating. He was doing these little things now; things that people who didn’t know him as well probably wouldn’t even have noticed, but showed to Celebrimbor that the Maia’s actions were no longer nearly exclusively determined by willpower and his desire of how to present himself. He flinched involuntarily, for one, when he was unpleasantly surprised by someone touching him. He had – unwittingly, Celebrimbor believed – adopted mortal body language. Whereas before the Maia had always moved and stood with perfect poise, each posture nearly as intentional and perfected as the pose of a marble statue, he now did things that were as small and mundane as shifting his weight from one leg to the other when he was weighing options. Or tapping his fingers when he became impatient.
Or, most notably, adopting a completely locked and walled-off posture when he was uncomfortable, either because something was gnawing at his mind or because he wanted to discourage people from getting too close to him.
Other people wouldn’t have noticed it, let alone realized the significance. But Celebrimbor had, for lack of a better word, been Annatar’s second shadow for five hundred years now, and vice versa. They had lived in each other’s spaces, in each other’s heads, even.
On a purely rational level, Celebrimbor had known that changes were to be expected if the Maia chose to live as an Incarnate, even if only temporarily. However, on an instinctual level, the fact kept throwing him off-balance every time he became aware of it. He had gotten to know someone, and that someone had acted very differently in a thousand little nuances – to a degree that a thousand trivialities added up to no longer entirely recognizing the person who wore his friend’s – his partner’s face. It was disquieting on a very deep, very instinct-guided level.
He had experienced it before in people he had known – or believed to have known very well.
His father. His grandfather. His uncles.
With the Oath. With the War. Brutal caesuras that had sliced the timeline of his life into a Before and After without a chance to mend the gap, or what the tear had done to the people that had been caught in the middle of such a timeline-sundering event. People went into the event, people came out of it. They remained the who they were, and were at the same time entirely changed.
The same had happened to Annatar. In the process of stepping into the material world, which implied getting closer to what happened there, to let it touch him, he seemed to have retreated from it more and more – as if compensating for his loss of defences on one front by throwing up wall upon wall on another.
Discomfort might have been one explanation for it. But – and this kept nagging at Celebrimbor’s mind night after night – why was the Maia so dead-set on continuing the experiment in this case? His line of reasoning (and this had been bothering Celebrimbor for months) fell apart at the first prod. Obstinacy well and good, but not even Annatar was so headstrong to do something he hated for no other reason than … just because. In fact, he had often in the past refused to do things he did not like and made a grand point of it. If all the Maia felt was discomfort and disgust, he should have – he would have broken this experiment off. So there must have been something else – a powerful third driving force that pushed the Maia seemingly in two directions at once.
Approach and withdraw. Reveal and hide. Wanting to continue, but not being able to take a single step forward.
Wanting to be known, and yet dreading to be seen. Hiding. Holding back.
Celebrimbor blinked. His thoughts had run off with him again. He must have stared at the Maia for quite some time, because Annatar was still looking at him with an expression that was approaching the tipping point from expectation into annoyance.
“Was there something you wanted?” Annatar asked. His voice was measured. He could still do that. Very well, better than any other people Celebrimbor knew. Control. Or, Celebrimbor thought with a glance at Annatar’s curled-up, walled-off, defensive posture, his limbs like a wall in front of his torso, the illusion of it.
“I asked what was wrong,” Celebrimbor said.
“And I told you that nothing was wrong,” Annatar replied.
Celebrimbor breathed out. “Yes. But perhaps I was hoping for a different answer than a lie.”
Annatar bristled. Uncurled his position, opened it, straightened. Shifting from defence to attack.
Celebrimbor supressed a humourless smile. “I’m not looking for a fight tonight.”
“Then why are you insinuating that I lied to you?” Annatar asked. His anger flared, quietly and surreptitiously, like coals someone had blown air onto.
“I am not insinuating. I am stating a fact. I did it because I can see that something is clearly off,” Celebrimbor said simply. “And because I had hoped that after five centuries living with you – and loving you, might I add – we had reached the point where we could be honest with each other.”
Celebrimbor’s father and his grandfather before him had been praised for their craftsmanship. They had been known and remembered by history for their ability to assemble, to build, to create. Regarding their personalities and deeds, was remarkable that it was the lesser-known fact that they had just as great a talent – if not greater – to disassemble, to take apart, to destroy. Not necessarily with actions, although they had racked up an impressive tally on that front, too.
No, the deadliest weapons that both men had wielded in their lives were not blades, but words.
Curufin had not known it, and neither had his wife, but Celebrimbor had been just outside the room often enough when they had had one of their many rows. He had witnessed his mother throwing out desperate argument after desperate argument, and having her grievances swiftly and lethally turned around on her by Curufin, until she was permanently on the backfoot, on the defence. His father had loved her fiercely, but his pride had never borne criticism well, however well-founded or justified it might have been. In arguments with her he had been merciless, dismantling her like a faulty apparatus in his workshop. Dispassionately, clinically, mercilessly.
It was a very, very little-known fact that Celebrimbor had inherited this dubious talent. He didn’t use it very often. In fact, doing so made his skin crawl, because in those moments, whenever he caught a reflection of his face in the window, or an echo of his voice, it was not himself he heard and saw, but Curufin or Fëanor. He bit his tongue more often than not, sought to mediate and de-escalate.
However, the fact remained that he could look at people and in front of his inner eye, he saw, as clearly as any construction plan, the steps he could have taken to utterly dismantle a person: the weaknesses, the faultlines, that – if pushed hard enough – could shatter someone into pieces.
It was an eerie thing, and he tried not to think about what it said about him that he knew how to do this. The important thing was that he didn’t do it.
Excepting extraordinary circumstances – like a being that he loved more than any other still not being forthright with him after years and years. It had been a knife-cut on Annatar’s side, however unintentional. The Curufinwës had never had many reservations about stabbing back, and Celebrimbor was no exception.
Annatar’s flinch told Celebrimbor that the hit had landed as intended. Good.
The elf waited for the Maia to deny the claim again. To argue that he had been truthful. To rise in righteous anger and demand that Celebrimbor stop accusing him. However, Annatar did no such thing. He remained seated where he was, tense and silent.
“It has been nearly five months now,” Celebrimbor said. “As entertaining as this back-and-forth has been at times, I begin to tire of it. You wall yourself off, you give me flimsy reasons for unreasonable actions that I could poke a hole into without even extending any effort. You are scarred, in more ways than I probably know of even now. You have trouble opening up, and I do not believe for a minute that it is because you are merely ashamed of your scars or uncomfortable revealing a body that is as little the true you as a coat I choose to wear is my true me.” Celebrimbor eyed him with a sharp look. “Do not insult either of our intelligence further by claiming that everything is alright, because it is as clear as day that it isn’t. If you do not want to speak of it – fine. But in this case, say so. Be honest.”
A long silence fell.
“It is not that I do not want to speak of it,” Annatar said, not meeting his eyes.
Celebrimbor waited, then inquired, “But?”
Another silence, agonized and drawn out.
Annatar clutched his own hands. His knuckles were bloodless in the fading light. Incarnate, insecure. Just above the wrist: the hem of his robes, hiding everything from view that wasn’t his face or his hands.
“I –” Annatar broke off.
Darkness flooded the room like dark water. The sun vanished behind the mountains.
Annatar stared at the small table between them, eyes fixed, expression frozen, visibly fighting a battle of wills in his own head.
“I –” he tried again.
Celebrimbor remained silent, motionless.
Night fell as quickly as the stroke of a henchman here, at the dying end of October. The moon and stars were hidden by thick, low-hanging clouds.
At last, Annatar spoke. His words, when they came, were choked like the sky, nearly inaudible:
“I am afraid.”
“Why?” Celebrimbor asked.
For a while, nothing happened.
Just silence.
He felt the exact moment when Annatar dropped his Incarnation. Something about the Maia became at once less and more present. A hum of power thrummed through the room. Annatar’s eyes flashed golden. The centre of gravity seemed to shift, light and sound and gazes and attention bent towards the Maia.
If someone didn’t know Annatar, it could have easily been construed as a threat.
But Celebrimbor did know Annatar. Had known him, for a very long time. He saw it for what it was. Not the drawing of a weapon in preparation for an attack. But the donning of armour, of drawing layers and layers of walls around him.
Celebrimbor watched him, not speaking a single word.
Annatar looked up at last. “Tyelperinquar,” he said. The silence broke like glass. “There is something I need to tell you.”
I did NOT WANT to write a revelation scene in this.
But somehow EVERYONE and their DOG on AO3 ended up wanting it and waiting for it, so HERE WE ARE.
Even though this will give everyone EMOTIONAL WHIPLASH ONCE AGAIN and is going to COMPLETELY THROW OFF MY GROOVE.
I hope you are HAPPY NOW.
