New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
“How do you stand this?” Annatar asked and made a wide gesture with so much verve that he very nearly knocked over the pitcher of water standing in the middle of the table. “My moods are all over the place, I seem to have lost any and all control over my emotions, and I get angry at people, animals, and inanimate objects! Over nothing!”
“Come now,” Celebrimbor said placatingly. “I’m sure it’s not that bad –”
“‘Not that bad’?” Annatar echoed. “Just yesterday I wanted to pick a fight with a doorframe for being in my way and catching my elbow!”
“Well, and that is life with male hormones for you,” Anthere, a Haradrim master of silversmithing who happened to be sitting next to the Maia, said blithely. “Try having two X chromosomes and being put through the endocrinological wringer on a monthly basis.”
“No, thank you,” the Maia replied, burying his face in his hands. “I’m not a masochist.”
“In this case you have just revoked your right to complain in my presence.” Anthere shrugged, then went back to the newspaper in front of them. Gildiriel, who was sitting next to them, nodded in understanding solidarity.
Through a gap between two fingers, Annatar caught Celebrimbor’s eyes over the table of the refectory and threw him a baleful glare.
Celebrimbor lifted both palms. “No comment.”
Annatar groaned and rubbed his temples. “Another day of this, and I’m going to have to ask someone to put me out of my misery.”
“What is that I hear? Who wants to be put out of misery?” Daeror sauntered up to the table and plopped down next to Annatar.
“Me, now that you are here,” the Maia said, glancing at the bard through the gaps in his fingers before averting his face again.
“I love you too, darling – oh, chestnut stew with candied almonds! Wonderful! I’m starving!” Daeror pulled Annatar’s plate towards him and started to eat.
Celebrimbor watched the exchange with raised eyebrows. Gildiriel and Falda threw him questioning looks. Sindrian looked like he expected a bomb to go off any second, and also like he wanted to defenestrate his partner at the next possible opportunity. Daeror, for his part, continued munching on the Maia’s lunch. Annatar, his face once again hidden in his hands and entirely dedicated to a unique moment of wallowing in self-pity, didn’t notice.
“So, what’s new at the guild?” the bard wanted to know.
“Er,” Falda said.
“Well,” Gildiriel threw in.
“You know,” Throndûr said.
Then all three looked at Celebrimbor.
The elf closed his eyes, counted backwards from three, then opened them again. “It’s fine. Everything’s fine.” Pause. “We’re fine.”
“Hm-hm,” Daeror said, dangling his spoon between two fingertips. “Very convincing.” He turned to Annatar and nudged him in the ribs with his elbow. “How’s your quest for carnality treating you?”
Annatar opened one golden eye, which reminded Celebrimbor of a disgruntled dragon, and squinted at the bard. “Do you really have to ask?”
“You know me,” Daeror said. “I’m always interested in how my best friend is doing.”
“I am not your best friend.”
“That’s not for you to decide, honey. So, how’s it going?”
“Wonderful,” Annatar bit out from between clenched teeth. “I get to enjoy the most illustrious facets of corporeality. The only time I had more fun in my life was Celebrimbor’s birthday five years ago when his aunt gave me a half-hour dressing-down for daring to stand mere five metres away from her daughter.”
“To be fair, if I had a daughter, I would tell her to stay away from you as well,” Daeror said amusedly between two spoonfuls of stew.
“You know, I was never more relieved than I was when I learned that your sexual orientation would rule out you ever having natural children.”
“Aw, come now.” Daeror waved it off, brandishing his spoon dangerously. “You’d love the little tykes. You’d be the divine uncle, reading to them, bouncing them on your knees, showering them with gifts –”
“Er, no?” Falda cut in. “Have you met him? He’d totally be the evil cousin. He’d either terrorize them, or raise them to be absolute goblins, subverting your parenting efforts every time he met them.”
“There you go,” Annatar said. “Listen to Falda, she knows what she’s talking about.”
“That’s just posturing,” Daeror said. “I’m sure you love children.”
“Yes, about as much as five-hour operas and flea-bitten dogs.”
“I always knew you had heart for the arts and the strays.”
Annatar glared. “Oh, shut up and go back to eating your – wait, is that my dinner?” He stared down at the now empty spot of table in front of him, then to the bard, who was by now two-thirds through the abducted stew.
“Technically, it was your dinner,” Daeror corrected. “Now it is mine.”
For a moment, Annatar seemed unable to process the sheer audacity of the bard. “One of these days,” he muttered at last, averting his face and massaging his temples as if fighting off a headache.
“One of these day’s you’re going to do what?” Daeror asked with a broad smile. “Admit how much you love me?”
“I was going more for the concept of committing of crimes that usually get you a life sentence,” Annatar ground out. “I have great hopes that extenuating circumstances would annul all charges in this case.”
“Oh, come now. Surely a few hormonal dysbalances are no reasons for murder.”
“You have no idea.”
“Aww, buddy. It gets better with time, you’ll see.” Daeror threw an arm around Annatar’s shoulders, which made the Maia flinch so hard that he nearly dropped the glass of water he had just raised.
Celebrimbor noted that both he and Sindrian had half-risen from their seats, both of them poised to intervene in what could only end in dismemberment if Daeror kept prodding the Maia like that.
Surprisingly, though, Annatar undertook no such attempt. He just stared at Daeror. “Why are you touching me.”
“Because you’re my friend,” Daeror explained patiently.
“I’m not your –”
“And I wanted to show my support for your current quandary.”
“You are the root of my current quandary!”
“I can still be sympathetic.”
“Be sympathetic without touching me, then.”
“See, I think that’s one of the reasons why you are always so prickly. You were probably left alone very much as a kid and –”
“I have never been a child, you absolute turnip.”
“ – emotional neglect, parental abandonment, yadda, yadda, inability to express your own inner turmoil in a productive manner, out of touch with your emotions –”
Celebrimbor’s and Sindrian’s eyes met. Sindrian raised an eyebrow in a silent question. Celebrimbor nodded imperceptibly.
Both of them leapt to their feet simultaneously. Sindrian grabbed Daeror by the collar and yanked him away from the Maia. “We have got to go now.”
“What a coincidence, so do we,” Celebrimbor said, rounding the table and pulling Annatar to his feet, who, once again, flinched.
“Wait, why?” Daeror rasped out, strangled.
“Because we do,” Sindrian said, dragging him away mercilessly. “You still have to finish the new composition before Yule, remember?”
“But Yule is more than ten weeks aw –”
“We’re leaving,” Sindrian repeated. “See you soon.” He hastily waved at the people at the table, who silently lifted their hands in a mute good-bye, then proceeded to drag Daeror out of the refectory under the stares of the assembled Guild of the Jewel-smiths.
“How about we leave, too?” Celebrimbor asked, trying to push the Maia in the direction of the exit. Annatar, however, dug his heels in.
“Later,” he snarled.
“But –”
“I want to eat something first. The bloody bard stole my food and courtesy of being stuck in a body, I am hungry.”
Well, that was a viable reason. Also, Celebrimbor was absolutely not keen on dealing with a Maia that was hungry and angry.
“Good,” Celebrimbor allowed. “Get your dinner. But then we’ll talk.”
“Again?”
“Yes, because I noticed something interesting.”
“What?”
“Later. As you said: stew first, discussions after.”
*
“So, what did you notice?” Annatar asked when they exited the guild hall to take a much-needed breath of fresh air.
Celebrimbor threw him a side-glance. “There’s been a change ever since you’ve taken to truly Incarnating. Other than wanting to challenge doorframes to fights, I mean.” He raised an expectant eyebrow.
Annatar looked back. “I don’t have the slightest inkling what you are referring to. My life has been a consummate maelstrom of misery and misfortune ever since I have begun wearing this body. So if there are facets to this form of torture, I have probably missed it.”
“You don’t tolerate touch anymore. That is to say, you tolerate it even less than before,” Celebrimbor amended.
Annatar stared off into the middle distance. “Do I now?”
“Yes. You nearly jumped and ran when Daeror put his arm around you, and you even flinched when I pulled you to your feet in the refectory. That was most certainly not the case before.”
Annatar thought about this, then nodded. “That is … true. I’m not surprised, though.” He threw Celebrimbor a glance, then averted his gaze and sighed. “Ever since I took to wearing this body my perception is more limited than ever before, and yet there is so much of everything – not in spectrum or depth or finesse, but in obtrusiveness.” Annatar closed his eyes and pressed his fingers to his temples as if fighting off a headache. “It is as if the world has lost any and all filters. Everything is immediately there – on my skin, in my eyes, ears, brain – I constantly feel like I have a Vala speaking directly to me, but on all channels of sensory input. It’s breaking my nerves. Metaphorically and literally.”
Celebrimbor was silent for a moment. “For the sake of expedience, I will just pretend that we have already had the discussion about not needing to continue this experiment.”
“Yes, thank you.”
“I will also refrain from pointing out that failure would have nothing to do with stopping.”
“Let us agree to disagree and move on.”
Celebrimbor sighed. “Fine. Then what now?”
“I simply need to get used to it,” Annatar said. “Which would be a lot easier if your world wasn’t so terribly unpleasant.”
Celebrimbor opened his mouth to comment on something to do with the fact that Annatar hadn’t even experienced true mortal discomfort in his assumed form – he had been neither wounded nor sick – then recalled what he had said about pretending to have already had essentially useless discussions, and shut it again.
He thought for a minute, weighed his options, came to a conclusion. “Annatar?”
“Hm?”
“Have you ever had a massage?”
*
“That was weird.”
“Oh, come off it. You were out like a light after half an hour.”
“Yes, because I hadn’t slept in two days.”
“And? You could have left and gone to bed. You didn’t. Instead, you decided to stay and conk out on me on my sofa. And then your cat came and started to occupy the rest of me, and I couldn’t get up for two hours.”
“I was merely focusing very hard.”
“For two full hours?”
“Yes.”
“On what?”
“Solving Wraith’s mind-to-speech issue.”
“And?”
“I’m still working on it.”
“Sure.”
“I mean it. I’m working on it.”
“You liked it. Just admit it.”
“Hngh.”
“Come. Come. Say it.”
“Fine. It was … tolerable.”
“Great! That’s great! Which means we have made progress!”
“Huh.” Pause. “Yes, I guess it does.”
“Which means that we can go on to the next step.”
“Meaning?”
“Have you ever done a sleepover?”
“No. As much as three weeks ago, I hadn’t even slept. Be it over, under, or in conjunction with any other spatial direction.”
“Great. Which means that you’ll coincidentally get to know a dose of mortal youth culture, seeing how you missed out on so many things, what with literally never having been a kid, and all, as Daeror was kind enough to point out.”
“Why are you repeating this nonsense.”
“Because you deserve it and because my sympathy for your self-inflicted predicament is rapidly decreasing. Also, because you need to be able to suffer sleeping in the same bed with me before you are sleeping with me. Escalating difficulty curves, Annatar. Escalating difficulty.”
“… fine. How does this work?”
*
“I feel like you should have warned me,” Celebrimbor said on the next morning.
Annatar opened one eye and raised one arm in a disgruntled manner to shield his face from the light of the late autumn sun, a silvery white disc hanging low in the sky, dousing everything in the room, the white sheets especially, in an ephemeral, nearly dream-like blaze of white and pale gold.
“Warned of what?” he asked.
“That you are a cephalopod in Maiarin shape,” Celebrimbor said. “And about as clingy as one.”
“What?” Annatar sat up abruptly, the blanket pooling in his lap. He was wearing the same robes as always, which was ridiculous in so many ways, not least of them that he shouldn’t have been able to sleep in them without dying of heatstroke. But it wasn’t bad enough that Annatar had decided to strategically kill himself by overheating, no –
“You clung to me the entire night. I tried to shift away, but you kept following me.” Celebrimbor squinted at him. “You know, I never would have taken you to be the snuggling type.”
The Maia spluttered. “I am not – that’s a preposterous claim. You have no way to prove that.”
“I do, because I was awake the entire time.” Celebrimbor sat up, too, rubbing his eyes. “Also, how are you in a mortal body and still a living furnace? I was so hot that I had to throw off my blankets and sleep without them, and it’s the middle of October!” He looked out of the window. “Look, there’s snow on the mountains!”
Annatar gave him a How is this my problem-look. “Why, I thought you’d be rejoicing over our rousing success. I can obviously stand your physical proximity just fine.”
Celebrimbor raised his eyebrows. “Oh, quite. That’s progress, I guess.”
“Of course it is progress,” Annatar said archly. “So what is the next step?”
“Don’t get ahead of yourself. Suffering physical contact when you’re semi-unconscious is like being applauded for your ability to suffer after sleeping through an atrocious play. How is now that you are awake? Are you still feeling clingy?”
“I am not clingy.”
“Take it up with your subconscious and leave me out of it.” Celebrimbor waved it off. “So how are you feeling now?”
Annatar paused. He frowned. He looked aside as if computing a difficult equation. “I,” he said. “I have nothing against being close to you in an awake state. Your proximity has always been – tolerable.”
Celebrimbor stifled a snort-chortle (a snortle?) in the palm of his hand. “Careful, you’re going make me swoon here. Keep it up and I may feel the need to cover my ankles around you.”
“Why your ankles?”
“Oh, you raided the bookstores for romance novels and you didn’t get to that?”
“No. In the books there seemed to be always rather more uncovered than just ankles. It was very disconcerting.”
“Yes… I believe you.” Celebrimbor squinted, and made a mental note to introduce Annatar to Vanyarin romance novels. “Speaking of clothing.” He pointed at Maia’s robe. “Let’s get you out of that.”
Annatar shrunk back. “Why?”
“Because we’re practicing escalating difficulty, remember?”
Annatar gave him a diffident look.
Celebrimbor inclined his head to one side. “Start with something long-sleeved if this is about the scars. But dress lighter, by the sun and stars. Surely a change of clothes is within the realm of the possible?”
Annatar heaved a sigh. Watching him, you’d think he’d been asked to skip merrily to the gallows. Then the outline of his robes blurred, leaving behind light trousers and a long-sleeved shirt, slightly loose around his slender frame, and made of white cotton. There was also a thin, white necktie that was wound around his throat, replacing the high collar of his robes. It looked very incongruous and still way too warm for the room. It also looked –
Celebrimbor blinked.
“What,” Annatar said.
“Nothing,” the elf said. “It’s just … you look. Different. Without the bulk of your robes.”
Annatar looked down at himself. “I look like a homeless person.”
“Balderdash, you look like someone who is dressed casually for the first time in his life.”
“That’s another way of saying I look like a homeless person.”
“That is rubbish. I quite like it, in fact.”
Annatar frowned, obviously surprised and appalled in equal measure that there were people who liked appearances that were any less refined than being dressed to the nines. “You do?”
“Yes,” said Celebrimbor. “It makes you look less uptight. More approachable. Also kind of …” He trailed off.
Annatar raised an eyebrow in a silent question.
Celebrimbor waved it off. “Forget it.”
They looked at each other.
“And now?” Annatar asked.
“Now we are going to enjoy a lazy morning because we don’t have classes to teach.”
“We are going to do nothing? Why?”
“Because it’s nice and because I want to.” Celebrimbor threw himself back down on his pillow and stretched. “No students. No grading. No one asking me questions. Just – a free day. Wonderful.”
Annatar stayed in his upright, sitting position. Celebrimbor could basically feel his stare. “Let me reiterate,” the Maia said. “You are going to do nothing? Out of your own free will?”
“Yes. Care to join me?”
“No, I think I’ll pass. I could be doing something useful with my time instead.” Annatar threw back the covers and made to slide out of bed, but Celebrimbor caught him by the hem of his shirt.
“Wait.”
The Maia halted.
“We can do something useful,” Celebrimbor said.
Annatar twisted around a bit further until he was looking down at the elf. “And what might that be?”
“We can explore your physical incarnation further. For science of course.”
“Is that code for pawing at me?”
“No. Yes. Maybe. What I really wanted to know –” Celebrimbor sat up and scooted closer to where Annatar was sitting. “Is this form ticklish?” He poked Annatar in the side and to his never-ending delight, the Maia flinched away from him. “It is!”
“Stop that.”
“I don’t think so, we need to verify the finding.” Celebrimbor poked him again. Annatar almost folded in half in his attempt to get avoid the contact.
“Stop that.”
“No, no no, we need an n big enough to make deviations from the standard statistically relevant. A few more hundred attempts should do it.”
“What –”
Celebrimbor tried again, and Annatar slapped his hand away, leaning backwards, until he was almost flat on his back. The elf only laughed harder and mercilessly followed after him. “Oh, that’s the cat’s pyjamas, I’d never have thought –”
Something weird happened. One moment, everything was as always. In the next, sky and earth seemed to invert positions, did so again, bouncing gravity like a ball between them, and next thing Celebrimbor knew, their positions were inverted and Annatar was pinning him to the mattress, one lower arm braced on Celebrimbor’s breastbone, the other pinning Celebrimbor’s wayward left hand against the cushion. The Maia’s eyes were darker than usual, he looked like he was about to breathe fire. All in all, it was very much like being pinned by a mountain. Or a dragon. A very annoyed dragon.
“Stop. That,” Annatar growled.
Celebrimbor blinked. This had felt less like being flipped over by a physical being, and more like gravity inverting rapidly two times; a primordial force of the universe that was so strong that everything else had to shift and move around them, one singular living being less than even a momentary consideration.
“That was impressive,” he said.
“Impressive?” Annatar raised an eyebrow.
“Yes. I keep forgetting how ridiculously powerful you are.”
Annatar look offended. “Excuse you?”
Celebrimbor shrugged. “It’s not as if I get a daily demonstration.”
“I didn’t know that you wanted the floorplan of your city overturned and redrawn in real life. That can be arranged, Tyelperinquar.”
“I have no doubt that you could,” Celebrimbor said. “But you wouldn’t, which is exactly my point: you’re literally all bark and no bite.”
Annatar let go of the elf in order to sit up straight, flustered like a bird puffing up its plumage. “Excuse you?” he repeated.
Celebrimbor sat up, grinning lopsidedly. “Ah, come now, why are you surprised? Scaring apprentices is no achievement, and when it came down to it, you never did anything to anybody. I mean, look at Daeror. He’s been annoying enough to make me consider violence, yet you do not so much as raise your voice when he half-crawls into your lap, gets in your face, or steals your food. You are either the biggest impostor I’ve ever known, or the laziest fighter of all time.”
“I’ll have you know –”
“Which is why I know that I won’t get into trouble for doing this.” Celebrimbor poked him again.
Annatar lunged.
There was a brief, fairly hopeless scuffle with a fairly predictable end.
“You keep pushing me,” the Maia growled.
“I do,” Celebrimbor said. “And it says so much about you that instead of responding romantically – like, I don’t know, pinning me with a kiss or something – you put me into a multi-joint lock instead. I can’t move at all—where did you even learn that?”
“Is that relevant?”
“Yes, because I was convinced that you were as abysmal a fighter as you are a lazy one, relying on superior power to win, instead of actual ability.”
“Excuse you?!”
“I am excused, thank you. Can you let me go now? My elbows are starting to hurt, and I don’t think my lower back is supposed to do that.”
Annatar did so, but with a glower.
Celebrimbor sat up, rubbing his shoulders and his arms with a grimace. “Well, at least we found out that you are absolutely fine tolerating touch as long as it is executed in the name of winning a fight or applying violence. Which is not exactly what I was going for, but I guess we have to take it.” He sighed.
Annatar blinked. “What were you going for?”
“I told you. A romantic scuffle. Touching a bit, perhaps kissing. Punishing me for overstepping, if you’re feeling a bit evil.” Celebrimbor grinned and waggled his eyebrows.
Annatar did not grin back. “Why on earth would I kiss you in response to you getting on my nerves?”
Celebrimbor’s grin faded. “Has it occurred to you that this might be a hopeless case?”
They shared a long, long look.
“I’m not hopeless,” Annatar said after a long while, which was almost hilariously disjointed from everything else, especially because it was such a blatant false claim.
"Well. If you say so.” Pause. “Do you.” Pause. Celebrimbor awkwardly gestured between them. “Want to lie down a bit? You know? Together? Romantically – as – er – a means of furthering the investigation about your limits of comfort?”
Annatar frowned. “But we’re not doing nothing.”
“No, we’re testing out whether you’re only an octopus while sleeping or whether you’re able to stomach physical contact when you’re awake. Which is very important if you are ever going to have sex.”
The Maia thought about this. He exhaled, blowing a wavy strand of hair away that had fallen over his forehead. “Fine.” He threw himself down again. “How do we do this?”
“Oh, that’s easy.” Celebrimbor laid down next to him and threw one arm and one leg across the Maia, pulling him in.
Annatar squirmed like a trapped cat. “What – why. What are you doing.”
Belatedly, it occurred to Celebrimbor that the Maia might feel trapped for real. If the last few weeks had demonstrated anything, it was that Annatar was pulling an entire train of baggage with him when it came to physicality and intrusion into personal space. Also, there was still the Angband thing which they weren’t really talking about.
Celebrimbor felt his stomach turn. Varda, if there had been any comfortable mood in the room when the morning began, it was out of the window. The air was laden with discomfort and awkwardness.
“Forgive me.” He pulled back. “Should I … move away?”
The most awkward silence yet filled the room. Annatar breathed out and noticeably forced some tension from his frame. “No. It’s fine.”
“Should I refrain from touching you?”
“No, it’s fine.”
“What you did just now didn’t look fine to me. At all.”
“It’s fine,” the Maia retorted, rather snappish now. “Just - don’t constrain me. That’s all.”
Celebrimbor buried his face in his hands. Stars, what are we doing here?
Celebrimbor asking the question that could have been the summary of this entire fic.
On another note, I live for Daeror's and Annatar's dynamic, I could write these two all day.