Acing This Thing Called Romance by Prackspoor  

| | |

Scars and Living Things


Well. So maybe he really was his father’s son.

The thing was –

The thing was.

The thing, that he should have seen coming and yet, for some reason didn’t, was as follows:

Everything had been going swimmingly.

Summer rolled into autumn. The seasons turned, and with it, the leaves of the trees from green to red and golden and brown. Things had, as far as weird relationship discussions were concerned, calmed down. Annatar had stopped springing romance tropes upon Celebrimbor, and they had reverted to a thankfully normal rapport. Gone were the times of walking around each other on eggshells, of stilted conversations, and even more stilted discussions. Annatar was back to being, well, Annatar: sharp humour and even sharper intellect, biting commentary and all, and Celebrimbor was very, very glad for it.

Then his aunt got wind of the entire sex thing.

He should have known. What with Daeror had said about bets going on, and the relentless rumour mill that seemed to feed from the same sources in the entirety of Eregion – also, she was the daughter of someone whose epessë was literally the Far-Seeing. She had a scyring mirror, for Varda’s sake.

So. His aunt knew. About the rumours. About the thing. Which would have been bad enough on its own.

But.

His aunt, as it happened, also hated Annatar with a conviction and deep-seated loathing that was usually reserved for the meeting of step-children and step-parents between Noldorin families and those of the Moriquendi.

So it shouldn’t have been surprising that upon one of Celebrimbor’s duty visits to Lórien Galadriel pulled him aside and asked, “Is it true?”

“Is what true?” he had retorted with the famed eloquence and audacious pretence of ignorance exclusively reserved for Fëanor’s kith and kin.

Galadriel’s eyes had narrowed. “You know what I mean. This Maia of yours. I counselled you to keep your distance. You didn’t heed it.”

“Yes, because I’m an adult and I make my own decisions.”

“Don’t talk back to me like that. I’m still your elder. Besides, I worry for you. I worried for you as soon as that Maia first stepped into your city and beguiled the guilds down to the last apprentice. And now I must hear that you seek an even deeper union with him.”

Celebrimbor died a bit inside at this choice of words. He tried not to show it. “Aunt,” he said. “Those are rumours.” And then, because he was his grandfather’s grandson and he was his father’s son, he added, “And even if it weren’t so, what I do or don’t do with him remains for me to decide.” And gave her that look. That one. The one that had made sure that his enemies would have come after Fëanor right to the ends of the universe to rip off his limbs one by one.

Galadriel had responded with a fixed stare. “Telperinquar. I do not care how old you are. I am not watching you gleefully running to your own ruin. I invoke the authority of the elder of our shared lines. I forbid it.”

There. There it was.

His aunt should have known better than to say that, knowing Celebrimbor’s lineage.

His grandfather had created the Silmarils after he had been told that “one doesn’t simply capture the light of the Two Trees”. When his uncle Maedhros had been told that one couldn’t parley with Morgoth, he’d gone anyway and spent the next decade alternating between Angband’s torture chambers and hanging from cliff faces. When his father and his other uncle Celegorm had been told to leave Doriath and Dior alone, they – well.

Long story short, the line of Fëanor had a long and loving history with reverse psychology.

Which his aunt, being all-seeing and old and wise, should have known. Did know.

So in all honesty, for everything else that was to follow, she only had herself to blame.

 

*

 

“Are you telling me that you suddenly want to sleep with me because your aunt told you ‘no’?”

“That is exactly what I’m telling you,” Celebrimbor said, dragging Annatar along by his sleeve. “And before you say anything: I will not argue about this with someone who basically tried to guilt-trip me into sex. You have no moral high ground to make any arguments from.”

“I’m not objecting,” Annatar said, trying to keep pace with Celebrimbor’s incensed speed. “I’m just surprised, because earlier you said that you needed an emotional motivator to initiate sexual relations.”

“I find spite to be an excellent emotional motivator,” Celebrimbor said.

Annatar thought about this for a few seconds. “Yes. I can respect that,” he allowed.

However, when they had reached Celebrimbor’s bedchamber and were standing across from each other, two paces apart, the bed a looming presence in the background, the Maia was suddenly oddly diffident. He kept throwing the bed sides glance as if it might suddenly rear up and trample him under its wooden legs like an enraged cow.

“So,” he said slowly. “You want to do this now?”

“Sure, no time like the present,” Celebrimbor said, throwing off his shoes, then freezing and squinting at Annatar. “Wait, are you having second thoughts?”

Annatar made an undefined gesture, the meaning of which could not be guessed at. “I mean,” he said, trying to sound nonchalant and succeeding in coming across as stiff as a plank, “I did not have a lot of time to prepare.”

“Prepare?“ Celebrimbor blinked. “Excuse me, did you want to bring notes and flip charts? This isn’t some mountaineering excursion. You don’t need rope and ice cleats. I mean, a case could be made for rope, but –”

“What?”

“ – I don’t think either of us is into that, and anyway, it would be good to start with the basics.”

“Basics? There’s an advanced level to all of this?”

Celebrimbor, realizing that Annatar’s pathological ambition was about to suplex them through the coffee table once again – if not now, then later – hurriedly said, “No! I mean – there are variants. Variants that are equally viable and practicable according to personal tastes, but are not comprising an itemized list that has to be ticked off in order to be able to say that you had sex,” he finished without taking a breath.

Annatar looked torn. “I see.” He looked at the bed again. “So. Now?”

“Yes, now. If you want to, that is.” Celebrimbor gave him a sceptical look. “If you don’t want to, say it, because in this case we’re stopping this immediately.”

Annatar dithered. “I – no. That’s not it. It’s just – is this the right moment you were speaking of so grandly? It doesn’t feel like it.”

“I have graciously decided to forgo the necessity for emotional investment in the interest of getting back at a meddling relative.”

“That seems rather petty. And immature.”

“I can’t always be the better man in any relationship. I have enough work to do with you on that account as it is.”

Annatar glared.

Celebrimbor wiggled his eyebrows. “You know it’s true.”

Annatar knew it was true, and thus didn’t respond, but glared harder.

“So then,” Celebrimbor said, clapping his hands in the enterprising manner of a Dwarf about to try his final throw in the Tree-Trunk Chucking Competition (held annually at Erebor, growing in popularity, and always a hoot for the spectators). “Let’s get to it. And you out of these robes.”

Annatar looked down at himself, taken aback. “Out of my robes? Why?”

“Yes. You don’t usually have sex clothed. It tends to get in the way, especially if you’re as buttoned up as you are.”

“I do not see the necessity for it.”

“You will. A surprising amount of good sex is good logistics – starting with getting as many things that could hamper you out of the way as is possible.”

Annatar was silent. He didn’t look convinced.

Celebrimbor grinned at him. “Just let me do the work. You’ll see.” He leaned in and kissed the Maia on the nose, then took the hem of Annatar’s uppermost robes (white, long-sleeved, trailing the ground on the back, open to the front) and pushed them off. Annatar dubiously pulled his arms out of his sleeves, letting the garment pool on the floor.

Celebrimbor leaned in. “Come now, what’s that face? One would thing I’m leading you to the gallows.” He raised an eyebrow. “Want me to stop?”

Annatar pondered this, then shook his head. “No. Go ahead.”

“Well, I’m not doing this alone. You’re going to do some work as well.” Celebrimbor put his index finger against Annatar’s clavicle and slowly pushed him backwards until they were at the bed and the Maia bumped against the mattress, sitting down rather harder and less gracefully than he was wont to do. “You can undress me, while we’re at it. There’s no reason not to make this enjoyable.”

Annatar looked up at him. “Al…right?”

“Yes.” Celebrimbor glanced down at himself, down to loose undershirt and trousers as he was. “Since I do have a bit of a head start, though, I think it’s only fair to catch you up first.” And with that he pushed Annatar back and followed him down.

They had done this before, to some extent, but never with the conscience of a roadmap in mind – of things they wanted to do, of boundaries they wanted to cross for the first time. In a way, it was new and exciting and –

Celebrimbor unbuttoned Annatar’s brocaded vest, pulled them both upright until he was sitting in the Maia’s lap and was able to shuck it off. Then, to make use of their position, he grabbed the hem of Annatar’s tunic right under it, and with a flourish, pulled it over the Maia’s head.

And apparently that wasn’t the end of it, because Annatar had yet another shirt under that. Well, it wouldn’t stay there long. Celebrimbor bit the inside of his cheek with a grin, pulled it up, off, and –

“What the fuck?” it escaped him. He reared back.

Annatar looked up at him, blinking slowly.

Celebrimbor stared down at the Maia.

“Annatar,” Celebrimbor said slowly, steepling his fingers in front of his face in an effort to suppress his rising disbelief and irritation, “are you creating new layers of clothing as we go?”

The Maia had the grace to look guilty.

 

*

 

Celebrimbor whirled around, throwing out his arm. “Do you have any idea how off-putting this is? If you hadn’t wanted, you should just have told me!” He didn’t yell, but it was a close thing.

Annatar, never one to remain in abashed silence for long, countered with equal irritation: “It was not about not wanting! I’ve told you three times now!”

“Then why did you keep summoning clothes? By Varda, I am feeling like a sexual abuser here!”

“It’s not about you!” Annatar, always great at reaching new frontiers, was the first to actually begin shouting. “I have no idea why I was doing it!”

“What, you’re telling me it wasn’t premediated like all the rest of the things you do –”

“Stop being such a vindictive idiot!”

“Then stop being dishonest with me!”

“I wasn’t being dishonest with you!”

“Then WHY were you doing it!”

“I have no idea! Maybe it is because of the scars or because I am not used to settling into a body and not being able to get out, and being seen –”

“Wait.” Celebrimbor cut him off, deadly calm all of a sudden. “What scars?”

 

*

“Oh, stars.”

“What.”

“We need to stop this.”

“We do not. I am trying to do something completely unnatural for my race, which you were kind enough to point out. It stands to figure that there would be slight – ah – complications.”

“If that is what slight complications look like for you, I do wonder about your definition of full-blown trauma.”

“Can you stop talking like that.”

“I am only being honest.” Celebrimor gently put down Annatar’s bare arm, who drew back into the cradle of his crossed legs and shook his sleeve back forward. He kept staring at the arm, though, as if he could still see the scars that were criss-crossing the skin everywhere, to the point that there was more burn-scar tissue in the shape of chain links than unblemished skin. Which was madness, because how did one put scars onto a being that didn’t even have a permanent physical form to begin with?

Well, if anyone at all in this universe knew the answer to that question, it would be Morgoth. Celebrimbor had never met the Destroyer, not even seen him from afar. As real as his influence on Arda remained, Morgoth himself had  always retained the quality of a spectre in his mind – an aura of unreality, an ethereal horror, an insubstantial nightmare.

Oh, he knew of Angband, and he knew its survivors, since plenty of them had found their way to Eregion after the end of the First Age. And yet. A fortress did not a Dark Lord make. Angband could have been a place of terror even without a nightmarish god lurking in its bowels. Living things were capable of great cruelty even without malicious divine intervention. But now? This? Seeing the proof that the Destroyer had inhabited this world, realized in the very real scars in the skin of the Maia across from him made Celebrimbor’s skin crawl. He’s met Morgoth. Stood before him. Met his gaze – and what must that have been like?

“What did you do to earn them?” he asked haltingly.

Annatar inclined his head. “What makes you think that one needs to earn scars in Angband? Little is given freely there, but pain was always readily available in abundance.”

The crawling got worse. Celebrimbor rocked his weight a bit where he was sitting cross-legged across from Annatar on the mattress of his bed. “Are you – I mean. It was bad, wasn’t it?”

“Yes.”

Celebrimbor waited, but Annatar made no move to elaborate. “You don’t want to talk about this, do you?”

“Whatever gave you the idea?” Annatar replied, raising an eyebrow.

Celebrimbor threw him a look. “There is no need to be snide.”

“Just as there is no need to treat me like a kitten that needs coddling. We could both stop doing needless things. I feel like it might improve the atmosphere.”

Celebrimbor glared. “May I cordially remind you that it was not me who brought us into this situation? I didn’t keep pushing both of us into having sex, when you were neither willing nor ready, contrary to what you told me.”

“I was surprised. I will be able to deal with it going forward.”

“‘Beat your own instincts and trauma into submission with a blunt object’, you mean.”

“Would you stop using that word?”

“I’m going to stop using it when it stops being correct.”

“Tyelperinquar.” Annatar’s tone was a warning.

“Annatar.” Celebrimbor glared at the Maia. “Continuing on with what is obviously an undertaking riddled with difficulties for you is a bad idea. You should talk to someone about this. If not Angband itself, then the… consequences that you are clearly suffering from even now.”

Annatar wasn’t looking at him. He was, in fact, staring very fixedly at a point on the wall slightly above and to the right of Celebrimbor’s left shoulder. “I talked to you.”

“I am not a psychologist.”

“I consummately loathe psychologists.”

“Yeah, well, that is another one of your problems you should probably talk to a psychologist about.”

Annatar kept staring at the wall with worrying intensity. Celebrimbor turned around and found out that the Maia had quite successfully begun burning a scorch mark into the plaster with his gaze. “Hey, stop demolishing my room.”

Annatar blinked, then looked at him.  “I apologize.”

“Thank you. I’d still appreciate it if you left my accommodations standing.” Celebrimbor dropped his chin into the palm of his hand. “But really, going over this with someone who is actually trained to help you deal with it would be so much better than talking to me.”

“But I do not want to talk to anyone else,” Annatar said, matter-of-factly. “In fact, I feel a strong desire to stop speaking of this, even with you. Besides, I do not need help. I need to get this done and out of the way.”

“Burying stuff and ignoring it won’t make it go away.”

“Look who’s talking.”

“Hey, I at least don’t deny that I’m a few Silmarils short of a full set.”

“Yes, and what are you doing about it?”

“I am perfectly functional in my day-to-day life, this is hardly comparable.”

“Oooh, evasion and denial. Trauma signs.”

“Annatar.”

“This for that, Tyelperinquar.”

Celebrimbor sighed. “You’re still not going to drop this, aren’t you?”

“No. Failure is not an option.”

Celebrimbor sighed.

 

*

 

“Okay.” Celebrimbor folded his hands in front of his face as if summoning a spirit of luck and patience. “I’ve been thinking.”

Annatar, who was perched in a chair across from where the elf was sitting cross-legged on the bed, leaned forward. “And?”

“I think we need to start small, if we’re ever going to get somewhere with this. And I mean really, really small.”

Annatar inclined his head. “Meaning?”

Celebrimbor fixed him with a boring stare over the tips of his fingers. “You have a huge issue with your physical form, even though it isn’t in any way truly Incarnate. Any kind of mortal intimacy, however, is about nothing but physicality. So we need to get you used to settling into a body, before we try anything fancier.”

Annatar’s eyebrows rose. “As in –”

“As in truly Incarnating, yes. Living as an Incarnate. With bones, blood, muscles, the works.”

Annatar grimaced. “Is that truly necessary?”

“Considering the issues you’re having?” Celebrimbor threw him a look. “I’d say it’s that or throwing the towel.”

Celebrimbor was aware that if he wanted Annatar to give up, he shouldn’t have worded it as a challenge. The thing was, even he was beginning to see it as a project and a problem, and, most of all, a poser that he wanted to crack.

To hell with sensible decisions and prudence.

Likewise, to hell with their ambition and the inability to call it quits, because both of their lives were going to be so much harder from now on.

 

*

 

“How are you holding up?”

“It’s terrible. There is always something that is off about this sack of organs that is either uncomfortable, malcontent, or lacking. All. The. Time. I hate feeling hungry. Or tired. How can you even stand it?”

“We don’t. That’s why we like to eat and sleep a lot, mostly. And get grumpy when we don’t.”

“Terrible. Simply terrible.”

“You’ll manage.”

 

*

“I succeeded in sleeping yesternight.”

“Oh! Finally! How was it?”

“Terrific. I had a nightmare.”

“Oh. About?”

“I was wading through a sea of corpses under a blood-red sky choked with black clouds. The dead were clawing at my robes, trying to drag my down into their churning, frothing mass of decomposing flesh and blood, and wanting me to atone for my sins.”

“…ah.”

“Quite.”

“Maybe… your subconscious is trying to tell you something?”

“I wouldn’t know. We’re not exactly on speaking terms.”

“True.” Pause. “Would you truly not consider trying to get an appointment with a counsel—”

“No.”

A sigh. “Oh well. It was worth a try.”

 

*

“Must I?”

“You must.”

“I feel the need to point out that no matter my state of Incarnation, I remain a spirit of fire and thus my nature remains diametrically opposed to that of water.”

“Come on. You’re a big Maia. The hot spring isn’t going to bite you.”

“Why are you like this.”

“This is harder for me than it is for you, believe me.”

“There are moments when I despise you, Tyelperinquar.”

“Get in line. There are a lot of people who have older bones to pick with me.” A pause. “So, are you getting in or what?”

“I hate water.”

“I know. See it as a possibility of accommodating yourself with yet another physical sensation you’re suspicious about. Broadening your horizons. Get out of your comfort zone.”

“I don’t want to get in or out of zones, no matter how comfortable. I want to get back to work and be productive.”

“So you’re not getting in?”

“No. I’ve changed my mind.”

“Okay. Fine. Can’t be helped then.”

“What do you mean it can’t – ack!”

Splash.

“You know, at times I find that a friendly nudge helps people getting over themselves.”

“I’m going to kill you, Tyelperinquar.”

“Murder is not a viable method of dealing with anger and disappointment.”

“Perhaps the method hasn’t been tested enough.”

“I has. Now be quiet and atone for your sins, or I’ll send the nightmare corpses after you.”

 

*

“We’ve made progress, I’d say.”

“If you mean that I feel the urge to crawl out of my own skin only every five seconds instead of every other …”

“Everything can be a victory. You just have to set the bar low enough. I mean look at you – that’s what? Two full days in which you haven’t reflexively dematerialized at some point? I think you’re getting used to having a body.”

“You’re saying it like it’s a good thing.”

“Where’s your enterprising spirit? Remember, it was you who wanted to see this through at all costs, not me.”

A sigh. “Yes. No need to remind me.”

“I think we can go a step further now.”

Annatar frowned. “What do you mean?”

Celebrimbor threw him a long look. “Have you ever heard about hormones?”

Watching an Ainu rummage through millions of years of stored memories was quite the sight to see. If the gears in Annatar’s head had been whirring any faster, they would have surpassed the speed of light and thrown off the continuum of cause and effect.

“Yes,” he said at last. “But only out of books. I wasn’t interested in the phase when animals were created; it was the purview of Oromë and his followers. My forms didn’t ever make use of them. So no, I don’t how they work in a living body from personal experience.”

“Time to find out, then. They’re important. For one, they are the reason why sex works for Incarnates.”

“Wait,” Annatar said. “They are the key to everything? And you are telling me this only now?”

Celebrimbor threw him a sympathetic look. “Annatar, considering that you were having trouble with Incarnation to start with, how do you think confronting you with Incarnate brain chemistry from the beginning would have gone?”

Annatar grimaced. “Not well,” he admitted at last. “And you think it is going to work now?”

“I don’t know. But at least you can settle into an Incarnation for more than a full day now. There’s no telling how you are going to deal with having something other than your will pulling the levers in your mind. Only one way to find out.”

Annatar’s expression was one of deep suspicion. “That sounds very much like handing the reins of a racehorse to an absolute madman.”

“At times it very much is. Then again, I am an Incarnate, and I can deal with it just fine. I have faith that you are going to manage it, too.”

Annatar let out a long, suffering breath. “Off to the library then.”

“The library?”

“Don’t look at me like that. I am talking about Biochemistry, not Psychology. I need to look at the chemical formulae if I’m to know what kinds of molecules I’m supposed to reverse-engineer into this current form.”

Celebrimbor gave an amused snort. “You make it sound so romantic.”

“Well, you know me: the consummate romantic.”

“Obviously. Well, then. To the library.”


Chapter End Notes

I'll have you know that I've never in my life been prouder of a sentence than "his ambition was about to suplex them through the coffee table".


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment