Acing This Thing Called Romance by Prackspoor  

| | |

Bonds Between


Celebrimbor rose late the next morning, owed to the fact that he had lain awake until after dawn thinking about the turn of events from yesterday. Thankfully, there were no lectures scheduled on Saturdays, so he had the entire day to himself. He threaded a silver chain through Annatar’s pendant, then put the necklace on. He eyed the pendant ruefully – after being so happy about the gift, the early morning had taken a distinctly uncomfortable turn and thrown a shadow upon the lovely moment. Nothing to be done about that now, though.

After getting dressed he went in search of Annatar.

It turned out to be a long search. The Maia wasn’t at any of his usual haunts, and when noon had long passed and Celebrimbor still hadn’t seen neither hide nor hair of him, he was beginning to grow the slightest bit unsettled. He ran his fingers through his hair, looked around, and his eyes finally homed in on one of the house-keepers of the tower.

Trust the ones cleaning up after absent-minded academics to know about the goings-on in the guilds.

Celebrimbor walked over to the half-elven woman who was just dusting off the marble bust of Findréana the Wise, and cleared his throat. “Siódwhen! Excuse me?”

Siódwhen turned around. “Master Celebrimbor. Good day. How can I help you?”

“Ah, I was just wondering – have you seen Master Annatar around? I need to speak to him, yet I seem to be unable to find him.”

The woman frowned. “Hm. Not in some time, no.”

Celebrimbor’s shoulders sank.

She gave him an apologetic look, but then her face brightened suddenly. “Ah, but I just remembered! Emrys told me that he had seen him walking in the direction of Psychology – he seemed to find it noteworthy, since Master Annatar only ever seemed to stick to the hard sciences.”

Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow. “Thank you, then I shall look for him there.” He nodded at her, then walked off in the direction of the faculty of Psychology – also in the Third Ring, but at the other end of the guild halls.

Talk about the housekeepers taking note of everything going on, indeed.

 

The tip turned out to be worth its salt. Annatar was indeed in the building of Psychology – in fact, he was holed up in the library, sitting at a table in a remote corner, almost hidden behind piles and piles of books and scrolls.

When Celebrimbor hesitantly walked closer and caught sight of the titles, his heart sank:

The Soulbond – The Social Impact Of Elven Matrimony and Its Effects On The Psyche.

Laws and Customs of the Eldar.

Between Mind And Matter – The Inextricability and Reciprocal Influence of Psychological and Physical Aspects in Eldarin Relationships.

Bridging The Gap – Being an Account and a Critical Analysis Of Interspecies Relationships Found Among the Eldar and the Problems They Pose.

Between Fane and the Profane – The Relationships of the Eldar with the Gods: From Worship to Pupil to Marriage, Drawing Upon Examples Provided by Míriel Therindë, Artanis Finarfien, and Elu Thingol.

And that was only the uppermost part of the pile that Annatar had apparently read through in the ten hours since they had parted ways.

Celebrimbor cleared his throat.

Annatar looked up at him. “Good morning.”

“It’s seven in the evening, actually.”

Annatar looked at the sun beyond the arched windows, which had already made its way a good distance towards the west. “Ah,” he said. And nothing more.

Celebrimbor waited for a few moments, then gestured at the pile of books. “Should – er. Should we talk about this?”

Annatar eyed the fortress of parchment and paper that he had built around himself like he was seeing it for the first time. He blinked. “I … have done some research,” he said slowly.

“Yes, I can see that,” Celebrimbor said slowly. “That being said, I was under the impression that you had a very personal problem last night and I’m not sure whether research will solve it.”

Annatar gave him an offended look; obviously, research solved everything in his opinion, and if it didn’t, you simply hadn't been looking hard enough. The implication that some problems couldn’t be tackled by time, effort, and a strategic approach seemed to be a personal affront to the Maia.

Celebrimbor sat down next to him. “Annatar, we need to talk.”

Annatar looked at the remaining pile of books. “I’m not done researching yet.” He drew the tome he had been reading closer.

Celebrimbor reached over and closed it firmly, letting his hand rest on the cover. “Annatar.”

The Maia gave him an annoyed look.

Celebrimbor held his gaze. “Talk. To. Me.”

“About what.”

“Oh, I don’t know,” Celebrimbor said. “Why you’ve set foot in a faculty you’ve been avoiding like the plague, claiming that any sound science is inherently predictive and follows hard rules, and that any branch of study that relies on empirical conclusions is for quacks, and yet now I find you raiding their library? About the fact that you have taken an interest in Eldarin relationships that is so sudden and rushed that I can’t be good? Also, the trifle that the one thing that caused this was a drunk bard claiming that every romantic relationship needed to contain sex to be considered complete? Does any of that sound relevant?”

Annatar didn’t reply. Instead, he glowered at the books in front of him intensely enough that one of the scrolls started issuing a curling whisp of black smoke at one corner. Celebrimbor hurriedly grabbed it and pulled it out of the Maia’s line of sight.

“Enough of this,” he said and got to his feet. “Everything in here is flammable, and you are clearly not in a mood to be around flammable things right now. Come on, we are going on a walk.”

“Do I have a say in this?” Annatar asked flatly.

“No. Now pack up and come with me.”

 

Celebrimbor took them outside. Firstly, because he wanted to talk in private and the parks of the city were the best place to achieve this short of being cooped up in his bedroom. Secondly, because there had been enough summer rains to ensure that nothing in the parks would spontaneously combust if Annatar stared at it for too long.

“You understand that personal relationships are personal, yes?” Celebrimbor said, while they were walking along the path in the shadow of the trees. Golden-green light filtered through the foliage and the dappled light and shadow flitted over them. “There is no one-size-fits-all solution and there is certainly no objectively correct, single method to approach this stuff.”

Annatar nodded. “I do. It’s just – did you notice that there is hardly anything personal in our personal relationship? I know almost nothing about your past, you know almost nothing about me.”

Well, case in point. That much was true.

“Everything we do is work together,” Annatar said with an angry gesture that was frankly mind-boggling to Celebrimbor, because up until now he had thought the Maia had enjoyed what they were doing together.

“Not everything,” he said, a bit defensively.

“Don’t be facetious,” Annatar said tersely. “Ninety percent of our time together are taken up with some project or another.”

“Yes?” Celebrimbor raised one eyebrow. “And I didn’t see that being a problem up until now. Why does it have to be one now?”

“My point being,” Annatar said, now sounding a lot more annoyed than concerned, “is that the thing that we have – whatever it is – hardly deserves the term relationship in a …” He paused, seemed to struggle against something, then forced out, “ – in a romantic sense.”

“So we have something unusual.” Celebrimbor shrugged. “Again, where is the problem?”

Annatar stopped, turning to look at Celebrimbor. “The problem, if you want to call it that, is that you are the one being I feel the closest relation to in this world, my own kin included, and yet there seems to be this vital, this gigantic part of mortal relationships that we haven’t even touched with a ten-foot-pole. You are one of the Eldar, Tyelperinquar.”

“Yes, and?”

“Are you not missing anything?” Annatar said. “Is there nothing more that you want?”

“…no,” Celebrimbor said slowly.

“Truly?”

“No,” Celebrimbor replied, now getting a bit curt himself in tone. “Also, if you think that we have a lacking relationship, sex is hardly going to solve it. That’s like having a child to save an already failing marriage,” he said flatly. “If you feel like there is something missing – like being open with each other about our pasts – then we should address that, and that only, and not introduce another possible stumbling block into it.”

“I know. I am not an idiot, Tyelperinquar.”

“You seem to have a hard time taking me at my word, though.” Celebrimbor said. “Why are you so obsessed with this, all of a sudden?”

Annatar took a deep breath, looked at some invisible thing in the middle distance to the left, then at his shoes, then, finally back up at Celebrimbor. “Truth be told – I keep forgetting that you are not – that we’re not the same.” He averted his gaze again. “I meant it when I said that I feel a kinship with you that I did not even have with my brothers and sisters in Aman. And this is why I have to remind myself that however much we resonate with each other, we are not the same. We are different creatures with different needs. Our approach to the world, our very place in it, our ties to existence, they are so different that comparisons are hardly possible. You need entirely different things in this world than I do – I begins with air, sustenance, and rest, and it extends to other things too numerous to enlist.

“I know we keep pushing the fact aside, and I enjoy it as much as you do – but there are limits to playing pretend, and robbing you of existential needs is one of them. However much I would like, I cannot take you to the place among the stars from where my kin created this world and show you all those things I so badly want to show you. I cannot bring you somewhere where you cannot breathe and will freeze to death, just as I cannot keep you awake every night however much I would enjoy your company for all hours of the day, because you will be harmed. And that is only the physical side of you. But you have soul, too, and this side of you has needs, as well.”

At last, he looked back at Celebrimbor and directly into his eyes. “I do not want you to miss out on something vital just because you chose me as your partner. And I also do not want you to take some noble high road and forgo things you want and need, just because I cannot give them to you. Or worse – I could give them to you, and you simply never ask. Which you do all the time. Because believe it or not, in a few centuries living by your side, I’ve come to know you and your idiotic self-sacrificial tendencies. Like when you fought a Balrog on a suicide rescue mission and afterwards nearly hollowed your soul out with a Ring of Power. So excuse me for taking your assurances with a grain of salt.” He took one, deep breath. His gaze was like the focused radiance of the sun lancing straight into Celebrimbor’s soul. “I don’t want sacrifice to play any part in what we share.”

Annatar stopped talking. His speech ended like a ribbon that had been snapped.

Celebrimbor stared at him. He felt a pang in his chest that momentarily robbed him of his breath. He also briefly wondered whether he had just suffered minor cardiac arrhythmia, or if his heart had just truly, poetically, and very painfully, broken a bit.

“And yesterday – brought it all to the forefront of your mind, I guess,” Celebrimbor ventured carefully.

Annatar gave a one-shoulder shrug, now staring darkly at the ground ahead of his shoes, as if it had personally offended him.

Celebrimbor gave a deep sigh, then stepped forward and pulled the Maia into an embrace, to which Annatar yielded with the grace and flexibility of a Haradrim obelisk. Celebrimbor remained unfazed. There were moments when he had to let Annatar have his moods, and there were moments when he simply had to out-obstinate him. This was one of the latter occasions.

He tightened his hold on the Maia, waited, and – there, finally – Annatar gave in. The stony tension vanished from his shoulders and at last he leaned into Celebrimbor, albeit a bit grudgingly.

“Believe it or not,” Celebrimbor said quietly, “I thought long and hard about my choices with you. You’re telling me nothing new here. I also know that I need to be more upfront about asking for things and drawing boundaries – for myself and others.” He took Annatar’s shoulders and gently pushed him back so they were an arm’s length apart and he could look the Maia in the eyes. “But you must believe me when I say to you here and now, in full conscience of everything you said, that I want this. With you, as we are, and not in any other way.”

Annatar didn’t reply. One corner of his mouth twitched, almost dismayed. “Very well.”

“Besides,” Celebrimbor added in a lighter tone. “It’s not as if I haven’t tried out a few things before. It’s fine, but nothing to write home about.”

At that, Annatar’s head jerked up and he gave the elf a flabberghasted look. “What?” The utterly betrayed look in his face made Celebrimbor nearly laugh out loud.

Instead, he quirked up one eyebrow and grinned. “Well, excuse me for not living like a monk and waiting until you came running along.”

“But –”

“No ‘but’s.” Celebrimbor began to amble away, his hands in the pockets of his trousers.

Annatar hastily followed after him. “Tyelperinquar –”

Celebrimbor didn’t halt or slow his steps. “What?” he said amusedly.

“You can’t just say something like that and walk away!”

“Why? Did you want details?” Celebrimbor raised his eyebrow up even higher. “Those were private occasions.”

“No, but –” Annatar floundered and broke off, visibly shaken – it was a mix of umbrage, disbelief, and uncertainty that was very nearly endearing, but absolutely very amusing to see on the otherwise so inflappable Maia. “When?”

“Long ago.”

“How long ago?”

“Long.”

“And who was –”

“Again, this is private.”

“Tyelperinquar!”

“Don’t tell me you’re jealous, now,” Celebrimbor said.

Annatar opened his mouth, then closed it again.

Celebrimbor stared at him. For about three seconds, he managed to keep a serious face, then he snickered and pulled the Maia into a sideways hug. “Oh, come here now, you. You know as well as I do that nothing in my past could compare to what we have right here, right now.”

“Well, I don’t know that, do I?” the Maia replied tersely.

“Take it as another lesson in believing me when I say things.”

“But –”

“Shush. Jealously doesn’t suit you.”

“I don’t care.”

Celebrimbor suddenly stopped, turned around and Annatar nearly walked into him. He lifted up the pendant around his neck with two fingers. “I never would have accepted this, or anything like it, from anyone else. I never married. If you don’t believe my words, take a look at my fëa. The breaking of a soul-bond leaves a permanent scar. I don’t have one.” His words were spoken lightly, yet there was a challenge underneath.

Annatar looked, for once, suitably abashed. “I don’t – there’s no need. I believe you.”

“Good. Then why are we having this conversation?”

Annatar’s jaw tensed. “I – do not. Like,” he ground out between clenched teeth.

Celebrimbor waited.

“The thought.”

Waited some more.

“Of you. Being with someone else.”

Celebrimbor smiled wryly. “I happen to have had a life before you arrived here.”

“I know, it’s just –” Annatar broke off, then something in his face that had been open and wild and vulnerable slammed abruptly shut. “This is ridiculous. Forget it.” He crossed his arms and walked away.

Celebrimbor stared after him, and just then it occurred to him that he just had made light of the experience of a creature – who had by all appearances and by his own admission – never formed a close personal bond with anyone before. And of course it was uncomfortable to hear that you might need someone more than they might need you. That you were, safe for one person, utterly alone, and they were not. That you were completely reliant on one connection, while someone else had hundreds. That they were something unique to you, whereas you were just one more person in a line of predecessors – no matter how special this one thing right now might be.

It was in this moment that Celebrimbor realized that he had, absolutely and thoroughly, made an ass of himself.

“Annatar!” He ran after the Maia. “Annatar, wait!”

To his credit, Annatar did turn around and wait, though his expression had gone distinctly sour. He raised one eyebrow in an acrid, silent question: What?

Celebrimbor stepped up close to him. “I was being an idiot. I didn’t mean to make light of your experiences and situation.”

Annatar just looked at him. “I see.”

“If you need to talk about this, we can.”

“I’d rather not.”

“That’s fine.” Celebrimbor stepped a bit closer still, a silent question. Annatar allowed it. Celebrimbor took his arms at the elbows, slid his hands down further, until their fingers were entwined. Still, the Maia did not move. His face was closed off and distant.

“Come,” Celebrimbor said quietly and stepped backwards.

Annatar’s expression didn’t change, but he followed.

Celebrimbor drew them off the paved walkway, along a winding grassy path between bushes and wildflowers, trees and undergrowth, until they came to small clearing, where a gazebo made of white wood was secreted away, wrought in the ornamental, elaborate style of the Galadrim.

Running around the inner circumference of gazebo, there were benches, and it was there that Celebrimbor lead them. It was evenfall and the ambient light had changed to a soft lilac. Crickets were clittering in the grass, which was higher here than on the wide, neatly trimmed meadows out in the open. Fireflies were flitting between the silver-grey trunks of the trees.

“Why are we here?” Annatar asked, sitting down with a skeptical expression.

“Because I want to have a private conversation.” Celebrimbor sat down next to him, not letting go of Annatar’s hands.

The Maia eyed him up and down. “Which would be about…?”

“Us, as it were.”

Annatar very slowly raised one eyebrow. “And what exactly is it that you want to talk about?”

Celebrimbor leaned in, until he could whisper in the Maia’s ear, “Teach me how to say that you’re the only one for me.”

Annatar pulled back a bit, frowning. “What?”

“If a Maia were to commit themself completely to another – how would they say it?” Celebrimbor held his gaze. “Valarin is the language of the things that are. You cannot lie in it. How would you say it, in Valarin?”

Annatar tensed. “You don’t use the language lightly, Tyelperinquar. There is a reason that it is not spoken even by the Valar these days. It shapes reality. It binds the soul. What you speak in it becomes true, whether you intended it or not.”

“I am aware,” Celebrimbor said quietly, running his thumb over Annatar’s fingers. “How would you say it?”

Annatar hesitated. “Tyelperinquar –”

“Tell me.”

Silence. A soft wind rushed in the leaves above them. The sky was turning to dusky colours above them, lilacs, oranges, and golds intermingling as the sun sunk lower and the shadows deepened.

“Êzarai – “you”, second person singular absolute in the nominative,” Annatar said, speaking quietly. His voice sounded slightly hoarse. “The absolute clusivity is necessary here because of what you want to express with the sentence. Aras-amûn – “for me”, first person singular in the donative. It’s a case that does not exist Quenya. A combination of dative and accusative would be the closest you have in your language. Khuzdul has it, incidentally, which is logical, seeing how it is descended from Valarin. Used when indicating that someone is giving something to someone, or something existing for someone’s benefit.”

“Or someone,” Celebrimbor added.

“Or someone,” Annatar agreed. “Then – ônozhar-virai. “The only one”. Its meaning is exclusive already, but you need to add the absolute suffix nonetheless –”

“— because there needs to be clusivity agreement between “you” and “the only one”?” Celebrimbor ventured with a smile.

Annatar’s eyes flitted to him and suddenly – wonder of wonders – a very tentative smile of his own flitted across his lips. “Correct.”

“And the verb?”

“You know that one already.” Annatar said and made small, encouraging gesture. “Go on. Finish it.”

“We’d need … ah, sumurîth, because we need the equative “to be”, not the existential one. Also the state of being refers to an animate being. So – arthissû.”

Annatar nodded.

Celebrimbor quietly went over the sentence and the grammar in his head one more time. “Donative,” he mused. “The Gift-Giving Case.” He looked up at Annatar. “What a fantastic thing to have in a language. I wish Quenya had it.”

“Well, the world was created in Valarin, and Arda was a gift for those who came after us. I should say that it is very much embedded into the core of the language.”

“A language for gifts,” Celebrimbor said quietly. “How fitting.” He raised his eyes to meet Annatar’s, regarding him pensively with his head slightly tilted to one side. “Close your eyes.”

“Why?” Annatar looked at him quizzically.

“Because you gave me a wonderful present last night, and I want to give you a gift of my own in return.”

Annatar still stared at him. “What gift?”

“It’s a surprise. Close your eyes.”

Annatar did so. Celebrimbor leaned in until they were almost nose to nose. He closed the distance. Kissed Annatar’s forehead. Then his nose. Then his lips. Then he leaned forward even further.

And whispered one sentence into the ear of his beloved.

Annatar’s eyes flew open.

Briefly, the evening light turned from soft lilac to the electric silver-blue of lightning. The leaves in the trees rustled, the bushes bent, and the flowers around the clearing bowed outward in a ring, when a shockwave of pure potential was released.

“There,” Celebrimbor said quietly into the few inches of space between their faces. “Truth. Absolute and unalterable.”

Annatar’s eyes were wide, his mouth slightly open. “Are you quite mad, Tyelperinquar?” he asked, his voice thin and breathless.

Celebrimbor smiled. “Oh, Annatar, I just spoke a truth that already existed. It didn’t need Valarin to bind my soul to yours.”

Annatar’s eyes were still on his face, wide with incredulity and shock; all the defences he had woven around himself blown wide open, gone, shattered, lost.

Celebrimbor leaned in again. Hardly any space between their lips remained. “I have been yours for a very long time.”

Annatar’s lips moved, as if he was trying to say something, but no sound came out. Which was just as well, because frankly, they had talked enough.

Celebrimbor closed the distance.


Chapter End Notes

Hmm hmm sexy Valarin yum yum yum.

Also:
What Celebrimbor and Annatar should be doing: talk about their feelings
What they are actually doing: going off on grammar tangents


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment