Acing This Thing Called Romance by Prackspoor  

| | |

The Venerable Art of Good Communication


It was not immediately obvious that something was off in the wake of the catastrophic conversation in the refectory. Annatar and Celebrimbor held their lectures, they worked on their projects, and generally pretended that the Lunch They Were Not Talking About had never happened.

However, the was some kind of metaphorical negative space that they avoided in their time together, some glaring hole that was defined by an absence where there should have been something. Like, for example, the lunchtime conversation. Making fun of Daeror and his ridiculous questions. Or the snickering dismissal of the fact that they had been the gossip of the entire city.

Instead, there was nothing.

There was no mention of the incident on either part, not even to express righteous annoyance.

Annatar was very withdrawn and taciturn. He spoke little and he smiled even less. His brow seemed to be constantly furrowed in a mixture of annoyance, intense focus, and badly hidden tension. He also tended to spend a lot of time alone when he wasn’t otherwise occupied by his teaching duties.

Celebrimbor tried to sit this one out, he really did (mostly because he was in no way, shape, or form, keen on reopening some old can of worms). But when August rolled into September and Annatar was still not back to normal, he realized that sitting this one out would be about as fruitful as trying to wait for a mountain to crumble to dust.

It was, in a way, logical that everything Maiar said or did operated on much, much larger timescales than the affairs of Incarnates. They lived for billions of years after all; holding a grudge or being depressed for a few centuries was for them probably the equivalent of being slightly put out for an afternoon. In the spirit of being inclusive and accepting, Celebrimbor tried to honour foreign traditions and behaviours wherever possible. Unfortunately, though, he was kind of invested in the well-being of his friend, and he was also kind of getting fed up with stumbling from one minor crisis into the next and spending weeks on end hoping that things would get less tense again. Maybe there was some childhood thing hidden there – inability to stomach conflicts, striving to resolve them as quickly as possible, desperate to keep a functional simile of a familial network around oneself –

Oh, who was he kidding? Every last member of the dynasty of Finwë had been sent on their way with a cart-load of pathopsychogical baggage. Celebrimbor wasn’t so delusional as to think that he might be the single one to have been left out.

So, long story short, he was going to need to do something about this. Again. Oh joy.

 

*

Annatar liked cats. It was one of the few facts about him that were actually known far and wide, and probably the one thing about him that was in any way comparable to Simple Things Incarnates Liked Too.

Cats, as it were, also liked Annatar. They flocked to him in an almost eerie way, and Celebrimbor couldn’t remember a time when the Maia hadn’t owned a cat. Or the other way around, if you subscribed to that particular school of thought.

However, Annatar didn’t have cats as normal people did. Or, the cats didn’t latch onto him like they latched onto other people, i.e. demanding foot, demanding pats on the head, and bringing in the occasional mouse or bird.

Oh, they started out like this, alright. But the longer they were around the Maia, the weirder they became. Celebrimbor didn’t know whether it was a conscious or an unconscious thing happening, whether Annatar was doing it on purpose, or whether he simply radiated something as unchangeably and factually as the sun radiated heat. The thing was, the cats, at some point, became way too smart.

They began to open doors. Not with handles. With keys. They started sitting next to people, and listened in on conversations. One time, Celebrimbor had seen one cat sitting on Annatar’s desk and staring at a pile of exams in higher mathematics that the Maia was currently grading as if it was reading them.

Annatar had been curious about this as well when Celebrimbor pointed out the weird behaviour, as it obviously hadn’t happened before. “Or, at least I hadn’t noticed,” he said, glancing at the cat with interest. “It’s not as if I have been around normal animals for extended periods of time before.”

Celebrimbor didn’t have time to ask what kinds of abnormal animals the Maia had been around in his time. The cat chose this moment to let out what could only be described as a disdainful snort and upended the inkwell right over the abysmal work of the student with a swat of the front paw.

Annatar had raised both eyebrows, making no move to intervene or clean up the spreading mess on his desk. “Interesting,” he had said. “I feel like there’s something to gained from following this further.”

Celerbrimbor didn’t necessarily agree; he didn’t feel the need to instruct cats in the sciences. Getting normal academics to work together already much resembled the proverbial and perpetually doomed attempt at herding cats. Adding the actual little devils to the mix seemed like a step in the wrong direction.

Annatar was of another opinion, clearly, which is why he set out to test how far he could take the uplift attempt of the feline species.

Since a species uplift, however, necessarily depended on being able to communicate, and because cats weren’t known for either their varied vocal abilities (short of howling) or being able to hand-sign (no opposable thumbs), Annatar had had to come up with another method.

He had created cards. Cards, first with images, then with short words the cat could tap with its paw to communicate its ideas. In the beginning, he had used simple, concrete concepts: Cat, human, elf, food, drink, hunt, want, not-want, hungry, tired. From there on, he had progressed to more extensive and increasingly abstract vocabulary: happy, sad, danger, hunt, mouse, dog, friend, enemy, yes, no.

The progress of the cats was baffling; within a lifetime spent alongside Annatar, they progressed quickly through all of those, and ended up with a vocabulary of around one hundred words that they could reliably use.

Two years ago, Annatar had acquired a small black cat that had been born with remarkable intellect for her kind. It took her about half a year to learn to operate doors, faucets, and keys; a year to identify when people were speaking about her and react accordingly (biting, swatting, or purring); and now at two years, Annatar had set his plan in motion of having a proper conversation with her.

Celebrimbor therefore decided to look for Maia and cat in Annatar’s rooms, and to no one’s surprise, found them there, both feline and Ainu engaged in deep thought. Annatar was sitting cross-legged on the floor, a veritable flotilla of cards strewn all about him, whereas the black cat was perched across from him and pointed at a card that said (Celebrimbor did a double-take) projection, then at ability, then wrong.

This meant nothing to Celebrimbor, but apparently it did mean something to Annatar, because the Maia had steepled his hands in front of his mouth and nodded. “Fine.”

Celebrimbor knocked on the door frame. “Am I interrupting?”

Annatar looked up. “No,” he said in the same moment that the black cat tapped the card saying Yes.

Celebrimbor raised an eyebrow.

Annatar threw the cat a side-glance. “We talked about this.” Then to Celebrimbor, “Come in.”

Celebrimbor took a few steps closer, taking in the organized chaos of cards spread about. “Hard at work, I see.”

Annatar nodded. “I’ll have to find a more efficient way to communicate soon. It’s very time-consuming for Wraith to tap out her thoughts, and I am running out of floor space.”

“If only we had a brainwave-to-speech emulator,” Celebrimbor said, ironically.

“I am working on it,” Annatar replied, absolutely unironically.

“Ah,” Celebrimbor said, to whom this was news. “Let me know how that one goes. We might be able to help the mute Angband survivors if you succeed. It would be a great translator, as well.”

“Hmh.” Annatar nodded, not looking at Celebrimbor, but at the cards.

Celebrimbor waited for a few moments. Annatar made no move to get up and greet him properly. He sighed. “Can I sit down?”

“Yes, yes. Take a seat.” The Maia still wasn’t looking at him.

Celebrimbor sat down, looping his arms around his legs, which he loosely crossed at the ankles. “I haven’t seen you around a lot lately.”

“I’ve been busy.”

“Talking to a cat?”

“Among other things.”

“Care to elaborate?”

A pause. “No.”

Celebrimbor shuffled a bit closer and leaned forward, looking at Annatar’s face in profile until the Maia at last deigned to turn his head and look directly at him.

“What,” he asked flatly. Not angry, not even miffed. Just – flat. Toneless.

“I worry about you,” Celebrimbor said, who was done walking on eggshells and dancing around the oliphaunt in the room. “Something is off, but I cannot tell what or why or how to make it better.”

“Not everything is upon you to make better,” Annatar replied, still in that flat tone.

“Yes, but this one thing is, isn’t it?”

Annatar didn’t respond.

“Annatar, are you alright?”

“Yes,” he said. In the same moment that the little black cat reached out and one paw landed firmly on the card No.

Celebrimbor raised both eyebrows this time. “Your cat seems to be of a different opinion.”

“Wraith is way too opinionated.”

Said Wraith narrowed her yellow-green lamp-like eyes, then stood up and resolutely swatted a bunch of cards in quick succession. Tell-friend-if-not-you-then-I-do.

In the few moments it took Celebrimbor to process that the cat had managed to get if-operators down pat, Annatar replied cooly, “I could take away the cards. Let’s see how well you do with sign language then.”

Wraith shot the Maia a glare and marched over to a row of individual letters that had been laid to spell out words that weren’t contained among the cards. G-O-F-U-C-

Celebrimbor coughed into his fist. “You taught her to swear?”

“Not me,” Annatar said. “She got that from the books.”

Ah. So the cat was reading books. Celebrimbor filed the information away for a later time. He turned to the cat. “What’s wrong with him?”

“Tyelperinquar –” Annatar began, but Wraith had already begun drumming out her answer. Twolegs-brood-day-weeks-months-duration-cat-know-not-reason-but-posture-sad-smell-wrong-alone-no-mates-no-happy-cat-worry-ask-no-answer-no-help-very-S-T-U-P-I-D.

“Ah, so we’re in much the same position,” Celebrimbor said. He turned to Annatar, “Care to enlighten me?” he asked.

Annatar closed his eyes as if he was summoning every last bit of patience that remained to him.

“It’s nothing,” he said in the same moment Wraith slammed her paw down on the card lie. Then again, for emphasis. Lie-lie-lie-lie then, stop.

“Traitor,” Annatar said.

L-I-A-R, Wraith spelled out.

“You’re a matched set,” Celebrimbor commented drily. “Congratulations.”

Annatar stared at the cat. The cat stared back. Neither one blinked.

Celebrimbor sighed. “This isn’t about you still worrying about withholding something from our relationship that I might need or want, I hope?”

“No.”

Celebrimbor looked at the cat, who stared at Annatar intensely for a few seconds, then slowly, suspiciously patted truth.

“I also hope it isn’t about plotting Daeror’s murder.”

“No.”

Wraith patted doubt. Annatar shot her a dark glare.

Celebrimbor sighed. “Alright – I mean, it’s not alright. Don’t murder him.”

“I won’t.”

Half-truth, Wraith commented.

Celebrimbor threw the Maia very, very serious look, who threw up his hands in exasperation.

“I won’t harm him, alright?”

A few seconds passed in silence.

“But it’s still about the sex issue?” Celebrimbor ventured without much hope for negation.

Annatar opened his mouth, then abruptly closed it again and got to his feet. “Let’s take this somewhere else,” he said curtly. “I am not going to this in front of a furry lie detector with delusions of grandeur.”

Wraith narrowed her eyes. Better than-no-fur-being-with-H-A-N-G-U-P-S-A-B-O-U-T-mating.

“Yes, you too,” Annatar growled and marched over to the door.

Celebrimbor followed. Before he went outside, he turned around and threw a quick “thank you” back over his shoulder at the unexpectedly helpful cat.

Wraith, however, being a cat and all, had obviously used up her daily amount of friendliness. G-E-T-L-O-S-T.

Oh well.

They left.

 

*

“So,” Celebrimbor said, leaning back in his chair. They were back in his rooms, where they could hopefully talk in peace. “What’s the problem?”

Annatar was sitting across from him, leaning sideways, one arm propped up on the armrest, his splayed fingers resting against his temple and supporting his head, while conveniently hiding half of his face from view. “There is no problem per se.”

“But?”

“It doesn’t concern you,” Annatar said.

Celebrimbor felt his patience fraying at all this avoiding and stalling going on. “Since this particular problem causes you to hole up in your rooms and cut nearly all contacts, and I happen to care about you and also happen to want to have you around, I’d say it very much does concern me,” he said tersely. He waited a few more seconds, which was all that his overstrained Fëanorian patience would grant him. “Out with it,” he added, sounding rather more snappish than he was usually wont to.

It took another few nerve-fraying moments for Annatar to finally get over himself and reply. “I’ve been thinking about what Daeror said.”

Here we go. Valar have mercy.

Celebrimbor raised an expectant eyebrow. “Yes, and?”

“I – have been thinking.” Annatar said haltingly. “About my own reactions to these questions and implications.”

Celebrimbor was silent. This was new. He waited for the Maia to continue, and after some moments, he did.

“There is an instinctual revulsion that I do not understand. It is baseless, because revulsion or fear are either learned through experience – think a child touching a hot stove – or the result of genetical programming taking place over thousands of generations – like fear of dangerous animals like snakes or spiders,” Annatar went on, speaking more fluently now that he was able to depart from the personal aspect and dive into the abstract analysis part of the issue. “I do not have any such genetic pre-programming. I also have no previous experience that would warrant my aversion to the thought of sexual intercourse. Which is why I don’t understand it.”

Silence.

Celebrimbor waited a few more seconds to give him a change to continue, but when Annatar said nothing, he sat up a bit straighter. “That’s it? You don’t understand it?”

Annatar glowered at him. “I am not a creature of instinct, Tyelperinquar. I have no traits or reactions that aren’t intentional or premediated. I should not have. But I do, and I don’t understand why and I do not like it.”

Celebrimbor frowned. “You probably also do not know why you like cats and don’t like dogs, and I doubt it was a conscious decision on your part. Or the fact that you avoid eating meat for no other reason than preference. You don’t take issue with those things, do you?”

“No.”

“Could it be that over the years you might have simply shaped a personality – like every other living being does?” Celebrimbor asked. “Surely not everything you say or do is premediated. That would also mean that you came here with the intent of seducing me instead of spontaneously falling in love with me, which I find insulting on a personal level.”

Annatar had the morose expression of someone watching an axiom which they had been basing their doctoral thesis on being poked full of holes. To his credit, he managed the mental turnabout. “I guess you are correct,” he said sullenly. “Perhaps some of it isn’t strictly logical or premediated. Though that still doesn’t explain why that idea evokes such a ridiculously strong reaction.”

“You are allowed not to like things.”

“I know, but the intensity of the dislike –” Annatar broke off.

“—hits too close to a phobia for your liking, and you cannot stand the thought of being afraid of something,” Celebrimbor finished. “Am I right?”

The glower on Annatar’s face said it all.

Celebrimbor sighed and massaged his temples. “You know that this is not a weakness or something similarly ridiculous? People have preferences. People avoid unpleasant things all the time. Often enough, avoiding these things does not even influence your life otherwise.”

“I know. And I do not care. I am not an Incarnate who has their life decisions decided by instinct or lust or fear or some other ridiculous befogged notion.” Annatar ground his teeth. “I do things because I want to do them or because I have to, but I do not avoid things because I am afraid of them.”

“Maybe fear doesn’t factor into it, have you considered that? Maybe Daeror had the right idea and Ainur are simply not cut out for sex.” Celebrimbor shrugged. “Why would you? You don’t need to reproduce, you are spiritual beings first and foremost. It seems only logical to me that you wouldn’t find sex appealing, perhaps even running contrary to your nature. You also don’t throw a fish into the middle of the desert and tell it to have a good time.”

“Then why am I not indifferent about it?” Annatar said, slamming one hand down on his armrest. “It makes no sense! Besides, Melian was able to have a daughter, so it must be endurable.”

“The fact that you use the term ‘endurable’ says a lot more about the depth of the issue than you are letting on.” Celebrimbor blinked. “Also – Bauglir’s hammer – please don’t tell me that this is an issue of not wanting to be outdone by distant relation of yours.”

Gloomy silence.

Celebrimbor ran his hands down his face. “Valar have mercy.” How is this my life right now?

He’d had his own fair share of childish challenges back in his youth, and more than once fallen flat on the nose for it. The issue reminded him of nothing so much as being goaded by older youths into jumping from a fifty-foot-high cliff, not actually wanting to do it – in fact, being desperately terrified by the mere idea – but then pride and stubbornness and the need to prove yourself came together in a stupendously idiotic amalgamation and you jumped anyway. (Subsequently fluffing the jump and nearly breaking all your bones, of course.) But that had been ages of the world ago, and neither of them was young by any measurement of time, and yet they were still having this conversation.

“This isn’t funny,” Annatar said tetchily.

“Do you hear me laugh?” Celebrimbor threw him a glare over his fingers, then let his hands sink.

“You’re not taking this seriously.”

“Oh, I am. But you are taking this way too seriously. You do not like to have sex. So what? Move on, do something else.”

“There is nothing banal about this. If it can be done by one Ainu, it can be done by every Ainu, and I should be able to do it as well,” Annatar ground out from between clenched teeth. “The fact that not reason or better knowledge should make me avoid something, but something like – like instinct or discomfort is not acceptable.”

Celebrimbor let his head fall back against the headrest of his armchair, staring at the ceiling. He was, well and truly, at a loss for words. “I don’t know what to tell you,” he said, still speaking to the ceiling. “I honestly do not know how to help you with this. It’s evident that this is a problem for you. I don’t want to make light of it. But even understanding your issue requires a mental approach that I cannot emulate, not being an Ainu myself. I simply cannot tell you how to solve this.” Celebrimbor righted himself again, looking at the Maia.

“I wasn’t expecting you to,” Annatar replied evenly. “Which is why I kept the problem to myself.”

“Which doesn’t bring us even one step further.”

A shrug. “I have been researching possible solutions. There might be one.”

“Which would be?”

“I’ve been to the Psychology library,” Annatar began.

“Again?!”

“So what? Even Psychology has its merits,” the Maia grumbled. “Few and far between though they might be.”

“I’m beginning to think we might have more need of Psychology than even I ever thought.”

Annatar ignored it. “There is a thing called Exposure Therapy –”

“What.”

“—leaving aside the implications of pathopsychological issues, because that is simply ridiculous, the methodology of confronting a source of discomfort seems sound, even in non-pathological circumstances.”

“You are joking, right?” Celebrimbor stared at Annatar. A pause. “Please tell me you are joking.”

He wasn’t.


Chapter End Notes

They're simply the worst.
Not Wraith, though. Wraith is bloody damn great.


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment