Acing This Thing Called Romance by Prackspoor  

| | |

A Logical Approach To Seduction


“This is a terrible idea,” Celebrimbor said.

“It is a systematic, logical approach to a known problem,” Annatar said, twirling the pen in his fingers. “It is therefore an excellent idea.”

Celebrimbor lifted his head from where he was despondently sprawled on his back across his bed. “Tell me that you’re not making a schedule for this right now.”

Again, Annatar did in no way oblige the plea and assent; rather he nodded, then wrote down something in the notebook on the little side table where he was sitting in his chair near Celebrimbor’s dark fireplace.

“You know,” Celebrimbor said, letting his head fall back down. “I for my part am already not getting much out of sex as it is, but what you are doing now would kill eroticism even for nymphomaniacs.”

The Maia gave no indication whatsoever that he had heard. Or cared.

“What do you propose would be a reasonable start to expose myself—?” Annatar asked.

Celebrimbor nearly choked where he was lying on the bed.

“… to the issue at hand,” Annatar finished, flatly.

It took Celebrimbor a few seconds to get the goings-on in his trachea sorted out again. He had to change position; it wouldn’t do to suffocate. He rolled onto his stomach. “Is that a serious question?”, he asked weakly.

Annatar looked at him. “Yes.”

Celebrimbor sighed, then raked a hand through his hair. “How about you just – ah, try it and see how far you get?”

Annatar thought about this, frowned, then nodded. “Must needs, I guess. When do you have time?”

Celebrimbor, having already been balanced precariously close to the edge of the mattress, fell out of the bed. He spent three undignified seconds staring at the ceiling, then he sat up and crawled his upper body back onto the bed. “I beg your pardon?” he said weakly.

Annatar was still staring at him, clearly wondering where the Noldoʼs sanity had gone off to in order to spend the afternoon. Which was just as well, because Celebrimbor was wondering the very same about the Maia. Always nice if you were on the same page with your friends and loved ones.

“Excuse me,” Annatar said, “were you under the impression that I was going to ask someone else?”

Celebrimbor was silent for a few seconds. “No,” he said at last. “It’s just that I wasn’t thinking you were going to ask at all.”

“Well, I need to be getting somewhere with this, and seeing how you’re my partner you are the obvious choice. I’m sure we can fit it in somewhere. This won’t take too much time, will it?” Annatar stared at the pile of papers in his lap. “Do you think we could fit it in between the evening lecture on organic chemistry and midnight when we need to go to the workshops to get the light-stones out of their saturation solution?” He glanced up at the elf.

Celebrimbor let down a disbelieving wheeze, then dropped face into his hands. “I – Annatar. I don’t know how to put this. You – oh Stars. You don’t do it like this. You know, you usually wait until the time is right, the atmosphere is good, the mood is there … this isn’t something you squeeze in between two meetings and a coffee break.”

Annatar looked disgruntled. “Why not? I also don’t wait until the mood is right before doing the final exams of a class. It needs to be done; thus it gets scheduled and it gets done. We’re not doing this for the fun of it, after all,” he added with a sinister glare at his notes.

Celebrimbor slumped into himself, humourless, helpless laughter wringing itself from his throat like water from a towel twisted to the point of torture. “We’re not doing this for the fu—okay, okay. I understand. I’m sorry. I understand. This is no laughing matter, clearly.”

“It is not. Which is why I am surprised that you are laughing.”

“I am not. Not really.” Celebrimbor climbed to his feet. “I am merely running out of emotions that befit the occasion.”

Annatar arched one eyebrow. “I see,” he said in a tone that made it very clear that he didn’t see at all.

A brief silence.

“So,” the Maia asked again. “Do you have time?”

Celebrimbor stared straight ahead at a point in the wall where he had put a groove into the plaster when he and three friends had hauled his wardrobe in here, many centuries ago, when he had moved into these rooms. It was a great groove. Very stylish, very captivating.

How is this my life right now, a voice said inside his head.

The groove didn’t react to his staring, as inanimate dented plaster was wont to do. Which meant that after a minute or so, Celebrimbor was running out of excuses to keep staring at a blank wall.

“Aren’t you going to ask me whether I want to do this?” he said weakly.

Annatar froze. “I—” And fell silent. “You don’t?” he asked.

“Not like this, no.” Celebrimbor walked over to the Maia and threw himself into the second armchair.

“Why?”

“Because there is such a thing as emotional investment into a thing, and for some people this investment is a prerequisite to sexual intercourse, lest it be very, very uncomfortable.”

Annatar was silent. The gears in his head were turning. Celebrimbor almost thought he could hear them whirring at a high, rapid pace. “I see,” he said at last, pondering. “Hm. That is.” More pondering. “Unfortunate.”

A bellow that might have been a laugh or might have been a sob or might have been a cry for help escaped Celebrimbor’s mouth. He chortled into his hand. Ah, a laugh, then. “Yes,” he said. “Very unfortunate, I know. We Incarnates never fail to disappoint.”

“That is not what I meant,” Annatar said. “I just thought – I just thought you didn’t care about it.”

“Yes. Meaning the act itself in isolation,” Celebrimbor said. “But much like the right pinch of salt makes an otherwise bland dish nice, I do like a bit of emotionality on the side if I am going to tangle in the sheets with someone. Actually, emotional attachment is the sole reason to do it – for me, at least.”

“Aha.”

“Just so.”

“I see.”

“I’m glad you do.”

Silence. Annatar was sitting hunched forward, his chin resting on his fist, which was a pose that reminded Celebrimbor very much of the Noldo in Rumination that his grandmother had created out of dark marble, two ages of the world ago, on the other side of the Sundering Seas.

“And what now?” the Maia asked, at last.

Celebrimbor shrugged. “What do I know? I’m not going to twist myself into knots over a point of pride for you. Especially if you are going to go about it like this.” He grimaced. “Create a good moment and we might get somewhere.”

“Create a good – wait, are you telling me to seduce you?” Annatar blinked.

“Call it what you will, but you’re not getting me into bed with a project proposal.”

“Why not? I thought you liked experiments.” The Maia sounded almost petulant.

“Yes, in the workspace, not on the mattress.”

“I fail to see a meaningful difference.” Annatar frowned. “But fine. Fine. So. You want to be … seduced.”

“Wrong. I want to want to do this, if we’re going to do it at all. How you go about this is completely up to you.”

“And how on Arda would I make you want to do anything?” Annatar asked, his tone half-aggravated.

Celebrimbor inclined his head slightly to one side. “I don’t know, Lord Charisma-is-my-middle-name, how do you want to make people spend time with you?”

Annatar glowered. “This is completely different from building relationships with no strings attached.”

“But it isn’t. It always comes back to the same few things. Make people comfortable, make them feel liked and wanted, and show them that they’re going to have a good time with you. Show me why I should sleep with you. Bring your arguments, but not with bullet points and milestone planning.” Celebrimbor halted, then threw the Maia a warning look. “And I swear to Eru, if you run over to Economy and come back to me with a sales pitch, I’m never speaking to you again.”

Annatar frowned. “I wouldn’t do that.” Pause. “How else am I supposed to do it?”

Celebrimbor raised both eyebrows. “Why are you asking me this? You are the hyperintelligent Maia who wants to sleep with me. I’m sure you’ll to think of something.”

“I am trying – which is why I wanted to make a plan that you agreed with.” Annatar chucked his pile of papers onto the table.

Celebrimbor inclined his head to one side. “Annatar, I know you love the rational approach to things. I know you like planning things out. But have you ever tried – what is it the young folk say nowadays? Ah – have you, you know, ever tried winging it?”

“No, because I’m not Eönwë,” Annatar said flatly.

Celebrimbor tried very hard to keep straight face. He fought against himself, his facial muscles, and lost. He wanted to remain serious, but frankly it was a brilliant joke, and the deadpan delivery was the cherry on top. He hid an aborted guffaw behind his fists, trying and failing badly to disguise it as a ponderous cough. “Fowl play,” he replied.

“Then stop egging me on.”

“Annatar!”

The Maia threw him a blank look, but then the corners of his mouth twitched.

“You are terrible,” Celebrimbor said, no longer bothering to hide his own grin.

Annatar shrugged. “And yet here we are.”

“Yes, discussing my own seduction. I feel like the writer of a comedic play and the fool in the main role at the same time.”

“So, the author of your own disaster?”

“Quite.” Celebrimbor passed a hand over his eyes. “In any case, I think it would do you – and me, by the by – a lot of good to approach this less like a maths problem that needs to be solved, and more spontaneously and adhering to your gut feeling.”

Annatar gave him the dubious look of someone whose one possession in life was a hammer, and who was thus determined to make every problem look like a nail. (Or a maths problem.)

“At least try it,” Celebrimbor said. “It’s hardly going to be worse than scheduling sex between chemistry and a laboratory appointment.”

 

One day he was going to learn not to tempt fate by saying things like these.

 

One day.

 

Argh.

 

 

Two weeks later

 

“Let me reiterate,” Celebrimbor said. “You do not need to create some kind of performance. You do not need to tick some boxes that sound like you raided a romance novel for inspiration.”

“A paltry novel? I raided an entire bookstore will almost nothing to show for it. You Incarnates, I swear –”

“We happen to be individuals! I don’t even like flowers, they make me sneeze! And poetry I don’t get, though I can appreciate the effort that went into it. Still – I’m not Maglor. Or Falda. Or Narvi. I can tell if something rhymes, but that’s about it. The candlelight dinner was nice – well, until Wraith knocked over the candles and set the table on fire.”

“Well, I’m hardly to blame for that.”

“I – ” Celebrimbor broke off and turned away, making a few desperate steps into the middle of his room.

Annatar didn’t move. He was resting his chin in one hand, the fingers of his other hand were drumming impatiently on Celebrimbor’s desk.

Celebrimbor turned on his heel and spread his arms in the universal gesture of defeat. “You know what, forget it. Forget everything I told you. I take everything back. This was a terrible idea. We created this awful situation where there is this horrible backdrop of expectations and tension and hackneyed gestures that go nowhere and have nothing to do with who we are or why we even like each other. This is – this is like a bad theatre play.”

“I noticed,” Annatar said drily.

“Did you now? The way you were acting made me wonder whether you were even still yourself.”

“You told me to be spontaneous and go with my gut feeling.”

“Yes, under the mistaken assumption you have the ability to do so.”

“I can be very spontaneous.”

“Yes, if I give you two hours to plan out your spontaneity beforehand,” Celebrimbor said.

Annatar gave him an offended look.

Celebrimbor returned the glare.

“This is ridiculous,” Annatar said at last.

“I’m glad we finally agree on something.”

“Good.”

“Good.”

Pause.

“So now what?”

Celebrimbor looked at the Maia. “There is no chance that you are just going to let this go, isn’t there?”

There was a brief moment in which Annatar’s mind visibly consulted with his stubbornness, his pride, and his inability to lose or give up in any way, shape, or form – and, as a belated invitee to the discussion, his better judgement. Predictably, there was a vote, and predictably, Better Judgement was outvoted three to one.

Annatar steepled his fingers in front of his mouth.

“Consider,” he said, giving Celebrimbor a boring look over his fingertips. “What if you viewed it as helping me out?”

“Wait, are you trying to appeal to my better nature in order to get me to sleep with you?” Celebrimbor said disbelievingly.

“Well, see it that way – maybe I do have a problem, however inexplicable its origins might be.”

“Stop. You are not traumatized. You said so yourself.”

“I was in Angband in the First Age. Also, and much more pertinently, I am a teacher at a school for what is allegedly higher education. I spend my days around students. I am traumatized by default.”

“You are not,” Celebrimbor countered. “Especially not if it’s only in moments when it is convenient for you.”

“Don’t you always speak of fixing things?” Annatar asked, his head cocked to the side in what the Maia supposedly thought was a coquettish and endearing expression. “You could fix me, how about that? Very much in tune with your plans. Also, very desperate and very romantic.”

“Annatar, you need to stop reading these weird romance novels. They are doing things to your mind. It’s disconcerting.” Celebrimbor paused, studied the Maia’s expression with sudden suspicion. “You’re not being serious, are you?”

Annatar slumped back in his seat. “No, I’m not. But you should have seen your face.” He grinned.

Celebrimbor hid his face in his hands. “Please, for the love of Varda, stop doing this. I’m utterly off-kilter as it is, you do really not need to add in trash novel tropes.”

“Well, let us just say,” Annatar said airily, taking his notes and beginning to scribble something else down into that blasted schedule of his, “that I like you keep you on your toes.”

Celebrimbor threw Annatar a look. “And here I was, thinking you’d prefer to get me on my back.”

It was, admittedly, a low blow. However, the look on the Maia’s face, his splutter, and the fact that Annatar drew a jerky, stark black line of ink over the entirety of his meticulous notes, effectively ruining them, made it absolutely worth it.

Sweet, sweet revenge.

Maybe he was his father’s son, after all.


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment