Acing This Thing Called Romance by Prackspoor  

| | |

In the Name of Academic Interest

In which Celebrimbor notably does not commit murder. (Yet.)


That should have been the end of it. And would have been, if Daeror would have been able to keep his mouth shut.

As far as Celebrimbor was concerned, if he had ever, only for just one moment in his life, entertained the thought of sending someone backwards through time and into the dungeons of Angband –

Not that he had.

Not really.

He wasn’t a good person, but he wasn’t that bad.

But if it had been the case – in this highly hypothetical scenario – and if Celebrimbor were the type to exact vengeance (which he was not, not every Curufinwë was dragging his personal vendetta around with him like a ball on a chain, thank you very much) – if all of that were true and things being as they were – well.

WELL.

 

Anyway.

 

Things were going well. Annatar and Celebrimbor were more or less back to normal. Which meant that they were talking about normal things again, Annatar had rediscovered his disdain for armchair psychology, and every now and then they would even engage in, er, more romantic activities, without the sordid subject of obligatory relationship sex making a reappearance.

Celebrimbor should have known better.

Bad things had a tendency to not stay dead.

Things were going well until they weren’t, which was exactly what happened.

 

Frankly, everyone involved would have been better off if it were somehow possible to separate Annatar and Daeror like two hostile pre-school children. As it was, that wasn’t an option, because unfortunately Daeror was a grown Noldo who could and would make his own decisions. Annatar, on the other hand, was a lesser god, and could be confined to his rooms about as much as a dragon of Morgoth could have been leashed by hempen rope and wooden stake. (Certainly, it would have made for a funny and entertaining attempt, and the dragon might even let you do it, if only out of curiosity for what in tarnation you were even up to, but eventually it would get bored and annoyed and either take off immediately, or roast you first and abscond afterwards.)

As an added point, in a twisted way that was utterly incomprehensible from an outside perspective, Daeror and Annatar liked each other. Annatar would be caught dead rather than admitting it, but Celebrimbor knew him well enough to a) know what true dislike looked in the Maia and this wasn’t it, and b) correctly identify the constant ribbing and squabbling as a really weird way of friendly socializing.

It probably helped that Daeror was offensively good at everything to do with music, and touted by some as the Second Coming of Maglor. (Which was incorrect, because as far as Celebrimbor knew, there hadn’t even been a First Leaving. Being lost was not the same as being dead.) Annatar, who wasn’t much one for making music himself, was, however, always on board when the task came to testing the limits of possibilities, no matter the branch of expertise. Seeing how in tune (ha-ha-ha) Daeror was with music, Annatar took it upon himself to teach him a bit of the divine approach to it, including reality-distorting effects, which resulted in a sudden and very dramatic increase in quality of Ost-in-Edhil’s symphonic orchestra (and they had been fantastic to begin with), as well as the premiere of an opera that just as surprisingly absolutely fell through with the critics – and no, the fact that visiting maestro was an archenemy of Daeror’s from his time in Valinor had nothing to do with that.

Long story short, there was no way of keeping Daeror and Annatar apart forever.

Which was why it was a matter of time until the peace abruptly ended.

 

It happened on a day in mid-August, long enough for Celebrimbor to have let his guard down around Daeror once more, which was always and forever a mistake.

“Hello, hello,” the bard said one day, when he was – once again, always, forever – intruding upon the Mírdain in the sunlight-flooded refectory where communal meals of the guildmembers were taken. He sat down next to Sindrian, who threw Celebrimbor an apologetic look, as if asking for forgiveness in advance for everything that was about to happen.

“Don’t you have your own guild?” Annatar asked with a raised eyebrow. “Or were you finally thrown out of your own faculty?”

“Ah no, but it’s always so refreshing to come here. So much quiet studiousness, so many intellectual and brooding minds bent on problem-solving, such an air of welcoming for strangers.” Daeror leaned across the table, stole a piece of whitebread from Annatar’s plate, took a bite and leaned back. “How are things at the Mírdain?”

“Worse, now that you are here,” Annatar said, pulling his plate further away and out of Daeror’s reach.

“I’m glad to hear that.”

“I’m sure you are.”

Daeror’s eyes slid over to Celebrimbor who had been trying – honest to Eru trying – not to get involved in this, then down to his chest.

“Nice necklace,” he commented.

There followed a brief, awkward moment where everyone in their immediate surroundings was staring at the gold-and-silver pendant that had slipped out of his partially unlaced shirt collar (August was merciless in Eregion, and Celebrimbor had committed the grave error of dressing for the weather).

It wasn’t that Celebrimbor had hidden the pendant. However, he also had not called any conscious attention to it, seeing how Annatar had wanted to keep both the gift and its circumstances quiet.

Celebrimbor, who had frozen in the motion of guiding a forkful of grilled mushrooms to his mouth, hesitated briefly, then said, “Thank you.”

“It’s very nice,” Daeror went on, narrowing his eyes. “I would even go so far as to say that it is an example of outstanding craftsmanship.”

Daeror, had, as per Celebrimbor’s suspicions, probably an intelligence quotient that put him somewhere in the 99.9th percentile of Arda’s population. Unfortunately, the bard was also using 99.9 % of this outstanding intellect to snoop out absolutely inappropriate things and draw the worst (i.e. correct) conclusions in any given situation where no conclusions were supposed be drawn.

Celebrimbor could see the gears turning behind the bard’s green eyes with worrying speed, then one eyebrow rose higher, higher, higher, until the second one deigned to join in, and even the corners of his mouth at last joined the ascension effort. Put in normal terms, the bard levelled a surprised look at him, followed by a slow and satisfied grin.

“Ah, I see. So this was the secret present you were given in private after everyone sitting below the salt was gone.” Daeror crossed his arms. “Pretty.”

If you asked Celebrimbor, it should be made illegal to speak so obnoxiously and so very obviously in italics. He didn’t reply, but his expression darkened the slightest bit. “Yes.”

“And only that?”

Celebrimbor let his fork sink. “I should think that such a gift is quite sufficient.”

Daeror raised his hands in defence. “I would never dare imply that it was not. It was just. Well, you know. Does that mean it is official now?”

Out of the corner of his eyes, Celebrimbor could see Annatar freeze. Sindrian’s expression was suddenly more than a shade worried.

“What is official?” Celebrimbor asked and congratulated himself on a very even tone of voice.

“Well! What a question!” Daeror made a wide, sweeping gesture, that encompassed both Annatar and Celebrimbor. “You two have been dancing around the oliphaunt in the room for long enough. I should like to think that you both manned up and – hm, not put a ring on it, surprisingly enough… it is a necklace – but I digress. I am talking about making your union official!”

“Daeror, please,” Sindrian groaned.

“Shush, I want to know this.” Daeror held up a finger.

Celebrimbor gave him a stone-faced look. “We have done and will do nothing of the sort.”

“Why not?”

“Because it is private.”

“But surely it’s not a secret.”

“No. But it is private.”

“So you could say something, but elect not to.”

“Correct.”

“You’re evil, Tyelpo.”

“I’m just not someone who sees the need to turn every private occasion into a performance in a play, unlike some other people I could name,” Celebrimbor responded curtly.

Daeror blinked. “No need to be so snappish. I was just curious. And jesting – if you’re familiar with the concept.”

“Were you?” Celebrimbor inclined his head.

“I don’t truly think you are evil. I might reconsider, though, if you keep looking at me like that.”

Celebrimbor just harrumphed then went back to his food.

“Dear me, don’t give me that side-eye! I wasn’t out to steal anyone’s inheritance, by Nienna’s tears!” Daeror exclaimed. “I merely wanted to give you my best wishes.”

“You have my thanks,” Celebrimbor said flatly.

“And you my heartfelt congratulations. It was about time. Empires have fallen and risen in the time it took you two to get a move on.”

Annatar threw Daeror a narrow-eyed glance. “You make it sound like everyone was just waiting for something to happen.”

“Maybe everyone was.”

“Does that mean we were the gossip-magazine entertainment for the entire Guild?”

“Not only the one guild, believe you me,” Daeror replied off-handedly. “The entire city, more like, with a good bit of Khazad-Dûm and Lórien thrown in, although the latter would never admit it. You should have seen the betting pools! Did you know that there were bets that you were merely having the entire city on and never had any interest on each other? The absolute chaos of it! Will they? Won’t they? Not to mention the more outlandish speculations – that Annatar would now spirit the city away behind a magic girdle like Melian. Oh – or entice Celebrimbor away and seduce him to live in a grove in the woods, though, who would ever choose a wooden hut over this city is beyond me. Well, I guess logic didn’t much factor into it. Projection, on the other hand, did. A lot. Oh, and of course there was the question of succession.”

“What?” Annatar looked up.

“I’ll admit it belongs among the more outlandish guesses,” Daeror said with a shrug and a grin. “There has been a bet whether you, Annatar, would use a bit of, ah, shapeshifting to produce an heir and thus secure the legacy of the line of Finwë.”

Celebrimbor choked on his food. Annatar dropped his fork.

For a few seconds, there was awkward silence at the table, wherein everyone pretended they had not heard what had just been said.

Annatar was the first to gather his bearings and picked up his cutlery again. “Nonsense. Delightful speculations, I’m sure, but ultimately nonsense,” he said dismissively. Celebrimbor very resolutely stared at a groove in the wooden surface of the table.

“Hm yes, that’s what I thought, too,” Daeror said. “Though you must admit, you are a good subject of speculation. We haven’t had an Eldarin-Maia couple since Thingol and Melian, and they weren’t exactly forthcoming about their relationship, either.”

“Maybe,” Celebrimbor ground out, “because these things are private.”

Daeror waved it off. “Yes, yes. But you must understand that this piques the interest of people. It’s new, it’s unusual, it’s exciting. It’s like a fairytale out of the books, to quote our dear Gildiriel. It’s natural that they would take an interest.”

“‘They’ meaning ‘you’, I suppose,” Annatar said flatly.

“Among others, yes. I’m interested. Of course I am. Surely you must know that you are interesting.”

“Oh, Daeror,” Annatar said, assuming the most drawling, bored, pseudo-flirtatious tone must have ever been uttered aloud on this side of the Sundering Seas. “Flattery will get you everywhere.”

“That is very good to know.”

“Are you familiar with irony?” Annatar asked. “I should introduce the two of you sometime, you would get along like a house on fire.”

“I’ve been tangling with her since before even you got acquainted with her, Annatar,” Daeror said with a broad grin. “You learned humour only after arriving here. That being said, I do have a question.”

“Oh no,” Sindrian groaned. “Daeror, just leave it.”

“He just said that flattery will get me everywhere,” Daeror retorted.

“He also said that you should learn to notice irony.”

“Oh, I notice it, alright. I just choose to ignore it if I do not care for it.”

Sindrian buried his face in his hands.

“So,” Daeror said and turned to Annatar. “I must admit I was a bit surprised at the reaction my question on Tyelperinquar’s birthday caused. It led me to believe that some of the assumptions I might heretofore head about the Holy Ones were wrong. I was thus wondering: what is the Ainur’s stance on sexual relations?”

Absolute silence. Celebrimbor did not throw his knife across the table, which he thought to be an admirable display of restraint. Annatar looked like his soul had left his body and left behind an empty husk.

“Do you enjoy it all, or avoid it when you can? Is it somehow seen as debasing yourself by, I don’t know, mingling with lowly Incarnates, or do you find fulfilment in it? I mean, Melian must have at least seen the utilitarian end of things, because she did have a daughter. Though nothing ever says whether she saw the, ah, deed itself as something enjoyable or more like a means to an end. I understand that no one thought to ask her, it’s not a question you usually put to a lady. And while I have all the respect in the world for Lady Melian, no such inhibitions hinder me around you, Annatar, so I was wondering whether you could tell me more about it.” Daeror rested his chin in his hands. “In the name of academic interest and my own terminal curiosity.”

If Celebrimbor agreed with anything that had been said, at all, it was that Daeror’s curiosity was about to become very terminal very quickly indeed.

“Or is it something you would have to force yourself to do – I recall you saying that you did not want to get the Incarnate world smeared onto you at every turn?” the bard continued. “What kind of degree of Incarnation would sex demand of an Ainu, anyway? Would you have to overcome your inhibitions against becoming too much a part of the material world or – ”

That was it. Celebrimbor was going to murder this man.


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment