The Fall of Arnor; Book One "Out of the Bree-land" by Diane Finnis-Robb  

| | |

Chapter One; "A Meeting at the Four Greenfields"

-In which Many Important Folk are Drawn Together for a Chance Meeting


   Early springtime in the Bree-land1 had grown less bright. Traffic along the East-West Road had slowed for generations and the small community that lived between the Hill and the Crossroads saw fewer and fewer travelers these days. The Dwarves, who claim to have had a mighty hand in the Road’s construction, used it seldom now to travel from their homes in the Blue Mountains to their far-distant and more ancient halls in the Iron Hills. For at this time, or so the Breelanders had heard, Men and Elves, in their unceasing struggles with the Dark powers, had brought war once again to the North of Middle-earth and all the old paths east had become uncertain. So now fewer and fewer folk came across the fields into the Bree-land from a road so filled with dangers.

   They went east still, the venerable Dwarf traders from the Blue Mountains who had formerly made the Breelanders prosperous, but by longer paths. Around the settlements west of the Baranduin where many of the Periannath (or Little People) who had left the area of the Hill some three hundred years before2 had built a pleasant home for themselves copying the peaceful (and, until recently, quite successful) Bree-land model. But the Little Folk in that land were not as open to strangers as the Breelanders had been, so Dwarven travelers went wide west of their settlements and crossed the mighty Baranduin at the South Crossing, some two-hundred and fifty miles southwest of the Bree-land and quite far enough to affect the trade.

   Now just where the Dwarves went from there is uncertain and, for those outside of the Bree-land who may have reason to care for such things, it was still the subject of much debate. Khazad-dûm, great and prosperous hall of Durin through two ages of Middle-earth, still thrived of course, though the old Elvish kingdom of Hollin on its western face had been razed by war in an earlier age. The old gate there had been closed and the Dwarves of Khazad-dûm traveled only east and north to the Iron Hills now. They avoided the Men of Arnor, the sundered North Kingdom, for war had come into that land from the dark fortress of Angmar that was called Carn Dûm. The Dwarves were certainly no strangers to war, but they saw little profit in this conflict and kept their distance. And so it was that the Breelanders now saw no profit from Dwarven gems and gold and mithril as the Elves of the north and the Men to the east and south did.

   Despite this slowing of trade the Hill and its surrounding villages, which folks more simply called “the Bree-land”, had remained quite calm and peaceful for many hundreds of years. The main village was on the southwest side of the Hill and quite pleasantly situated near to the crossing of the two Roads and surrounded by a wide and cultivated hedge of which the Breefolk were very proud. This settlement always had a large inn and stables to serve travelers and many other small businesses as well. There were perhaps fifty houses on the hillside and within the Hedge and they even had a small tower (though it might stretch the definition to call a forty foot building a tower) near the inn which held a great Clock.3

   This device and its little tower had, in fact, predated the community there and had been built by the Sea-kings as their Road came south and the cornerstone was laid. It would be more accurate to say that the Bree-land had grown up around the Clock than to to say that it was theirs. But while the Clock had not functioned within the living memory of any Breelander such an unusual device was quite uncommon in that part of the world at this time, and so one should not be surprised at the pride which all the neighboring folk took in it; for the Clock, to their minds, made their village into a city and, to many other minds as well, a place of some importance. While they still had hourglasses and sundials and other such older tools to accurately judge the day’s time many Breelanders quite commonly would express it using the phrase “of the clock” as it sounded much more civilized and echoed back to the day when their land certainly had much greater importance.

   Proud of their home and the peace that it had brought them, the Breefolk were an odd and isolated community,4 belonging to nobody but themselves (and more accustomed to dealing with hobbits, dwarves and other odd inhabitants of the world than most Big People were or are now). The Big People of the Bree-land were brown-faced, dark-haired, broad, shortish, cheerful and independent. But there were also, and particularly in the main village of the Bree-land, quite a large number of hobbits.

   Through long centuries the war of the Northmen against the Witch-king of Angmar had remained many leagues still from the Breelander’s doorstep, even as the last throne of the Sea Kings5 at Fornost had fallen in the winter of the previous year. No news and no travelers came from that direction and the North Road became silent and forbidding, and grasses grew over its stones. Now, with the springtime, people came timidly into the Bree-land and cast their eyes warily that way as if expecting to see doom riding down it from the dark and unknown lands of the North.

   ‘And so there’s to be fewer folks heading north with all those troubles there,’ said old Tom Truetunnels on one auspicious night at the Four Greenfields.6 Tom and his family had been Breelanders for many generations and had been proud of the fact that they refused to move west with all those Marish-folk, Fallowhides and Stoors and other uprisers to their foolish experiment across the Brown River. But that was before war had come to the lands of Arnor, a war that the Kingdom of Men seemed to be losing, and some other of Tom’s neighbors were not quite so sure about their position and of the town’s safety as he purported to be.

   ‘And I say fewer’s the better for us here. No, let the troubles of those folk in the north stay in the north, I say, for it's not the business of a Breelander, and not from the makings of our own. No, it's Elvish folk and their Elvish ways which stirs up these troubles and make things unsafe for travelers. But it’s those travelers...’ he said with a gleam in his eyes upon making his rather polished point, ‘those travelers that bring their own troubles into our lands, do they not?’

   And there was some approvals to this notion, for Tom was holding a small but very seriously concerned court of his neighbors in The Four Greenfields, the largest inn of the Bree-land and the closest to the Crossways. The Greenfields was, for generations, Bree-land’s most famous public house having been laid in the town’s west end and nearest to Tharangond,7 the crossing stone of where the East-West Road meets its younger North-South counterpart. This made it an ideal gathering spot in old days when the Road saw much more use of course, for it was the first inn to be found coming east through the Hedge-gate. An old stone building, unique for having two stories and a large stable, green window shutters and even paned glass to many of its windows. But now, in years of fewer travelers coming over the Road, it gained greater importance for being adjacent to the Clock- tower, the town’s greatest landmark. Many townsfolk were heard to say, “meet you under the Clock” which was, of course, a way of saying, “meet you at the Four Greenfields.”

   Tom Truetunnels was perhaps playing on the feelings of his more frightened and doubtful neighbors in his comments. For present there that night, and throughout the Bree-land, the townsfolk, who were at the time comprised more of the ‘Little People’ than the ‘Big Folk’, held a certain healthy disapproval for the wars of Men. These wars had brought them nothing but suffering (if only in the commercial sense) for some six-hundred years or more. Many of his neighbors felt that if war had finally come then, much like their distant relatives west in the Shire, it might be time for them to leave.

   But not all those people assembled at the Four Greenfields that night were Breelanders nor were they ready to accept the rather loudly stated opinions of old Tom Truetunnels. Towards the back of the public room where Tom spoke rather openly to his neighbors (and anyone else who might have half a mind to listen), back in the darkest and most removed spot available to travelers, three quite tall gentlemen sat in a rather curious and complete silence, huddled in large greycloaks as if they were keeping away the rain. Careful observers (and, if the truth be told, there were precious few of those at the Four Greenfields on this particular evening) might have been surprised by their company; for though no one could attest to just when it was they had arrived, not a single person in the room had heard them speak to one another as they sat there apart from the crowd. Occasionally one would look deeply, sharply even, at another, but no words were spoken by them which any Breelander had yet heard.

   Until Old Tom Truetunnels spoke his piece and seemed to have gained the assent, if not the full out praise, of many people around him. Just until then.

   ‘Their troubles, you say?’ replied the tallest of the three. He stood up as he spoke, perhaps out of anger or perhaps out of the simple cordiality involved in joining Old Tom’s conversation (for that would be a regular courtesy in any publichouse at the time). Kindness might have been in his manner then, even if it could not exactly be found in his deep and resonant voice. There was some surprise caused by his approach and in his person and his demeanor, and all of the other folk listening to Tom would have trouble discussing the man clearly with their friends later (though , of course, being Breelanders and in considering the events which would come over the following week, they would indeed discuss him for a very, very long time thereafter). His cloak may have seemed old and tattered, but clearly this was not a regular traveler to the Bree-land, well certainly not of the kind that Tom Truetunnels might call ‘regular’, and many in the crowd found his outspokenness quite as surprising as his looks.

   There was a fire in his eyes, deep and grey as they were, and a spark seemed to kindle under his brow as he spoke; ‘So the troubles of Men and Elves mean little to you over troubles of trade and a good harvest, do they?

   ‘And perhaps that is as it should be. Perhaps all of your perceived prosperity might best be measured in the number of pints this barman might sell,’ he said, cordially gesturing toward the proprietor at the center of the room and meeting his eye. ‘But where will you be when there is no one left to sell them to, I wonder?’ he said to the barman. ‘Where will you all be when the joys of this world mean nothing to those who have taken them from you?’ he said to the crowd.

   ‘For you and all the Peoples of the North, Halflings8 and Elves and Dwarves and Men, you now live in a time of choice. War will come. War, greater than what you know now, and even the broadest campaigns of this time will seem as skirmishes to tomorrow’s generals. How will you address it, I wonder? Now is your time to resolve yourselves and know your minds. Will the gossip and cautions of local shopmen and short-sighted farm-keepers guide your steps, or will the boldness of kings charge your hands?’

   He paused here, looking back at the expressions of his companions as if he were somehow being scolded for having said too much. ‘Yes,’ he said quietly, sitting again, ‘I wonder how you will address it.’

   Now old Tom Truetunnels was a builder like his father before him and not some shopman or farmer as the tall wassird seemed to suggest, but beyond that this talk didn’t sit with him; was he being called short-sighted by some stranger? Well, that just simply would not do.

   ‘We don’t know much about the ‘boldness of kings’ here-abouts, greymantle, but wars we have seen come and go, and far too many to suit us as a peaceable folk,’ Tom replied. ‘True, I suppose, that there’s a horrible land with a horrible Witch-king away to the north and the Big Folk of the Old Kingdoms will fight him to their deaths, so it seems. Sad and horrible,’ he said with genuine regret in his voice, ‘but far from us and in a cause not of our making,’ he added with reinforced conviction. ‘You say, whomever it is you may be, that their war is ours, but the Folk of the Bree-land have never seen it nor given into it in one way or the other; no, the Big Folk come up or down their road to the war, some fewer come back as those that goes, but no war has touched us here in the Bree-land since the Stone was first lain in the crossways and the Clock first built.’

   Smiling then, and perhaps a bit too sure of himself and his opinion, he stood as the stranger had, cordially in that same way, but with the emphasis of his argument.

   ‘What would you say then, traveler, to that? Is it not peaceable for a folk to stay out of some war not of their making?’ Said Tom.

   The quiet this discussion caused in the otherwise busy commonroom of the Four Greenfields was sudden and quite complete. And it may rightly be said that understanding this discussion goes a long way to understanding the times and the people assembled there at this most particular moment on an early spring day in the nineteen-hundred and seventy-fifth year of the Third Age of Middle-earth. For many people who were auspicious in the coming days of that Age were, by coincidence (if that is what you wish to call it), gathered here yet unbeknownst to one another and, though it would be to the great surprise of the rather straightforward if simple Tom Truetunnels, the arguments offered here went far to shape opinions of the Wise for many hundreds of years to come.

   The three tall Men (if Men they were) continued to sit in locked silence, even if the previous speaker’s long and bushy eyebrows seemed to wrinkle at Tom’s question. He had, in Tom’s standing address, been rather specifically called to answer, and some tension fell amongst the room when he himself did not stand to respond; after all, old rules of a public debate still held sway even in provincial places like the Bree-land and standing-to in any publichouse carries a very ancient response of standing-back.

   The grey old fellow did not stand. He did not need to, for the voice of the traveler, somber at first, held the attention of everyone in the common room.

   ‘Peaceable? Most certainly,’ he said. ‘And it is a wise and just folk who will seek peace when so much strife confronts them. Is it peaceable for rabbits to hide in their holes while predators are abroad? Peaceable indeed. And wise too, when the night seems so full of dread. But is it a want for peace or a healthy fear that guides them? And, moreover, is it wise, in fear or in the cause of peace, to disregard the plight of one’s neighbor for the security of one’s own fortune? Is it the wisdom and desire for peace that guides your lack of action, or a fear for your own safety?’

   This rather direct assault on the bravery of Breelanders met with some immediate gasps of surprise and some grumblings of anger, but the old man continued without concern.

   ‘Now fear, it might be said, is also wise in these times. For the Witch-king that you speak of is very fearsome indeed and, if my own fears are correct, he is only one finger on the hand of a much greater Menace than you might imagine. If you do stay your hand in war out of fear then you should know that your fear is well warranted.

   ‘But fear will not stop the dark times that are coming to all the lands of the North. Fear will not stop the Witch-king and his creatures from riding through all the ‘peaceable’ lands of Middle-earth and destroying the lives and fortunes you have found here. Will you not resist your fear and instead find courage in allegiance? Will you not stand with those who would protect you? Is the Bree-land not part of the North Kingdom?’

   Now this last bit of his argument, whether the speaker knew so or not, had been a debate in the Bree-land for many hundreds of years. For the town indeed had its origins with the Kings-out-of-the-Sea and the construction of their North-South Road long ages before. When the Tharangond was first set, the Clock-tower built and a sentry post laid at the meetings of the two great Roads it was certain that a town would quickly emerge. And it had, for the four fields at either quarter of the roads’ crossing were fertile as like an island in the empty lands around it. So it was that in those days they were inhabited by descendents of the first Men who had wandered there after the changing of the world. These early town-fathers were not servants of the Sea Kings and, at that time, paid them no allegiance. The Kings of Númenor came and they built their Road and their Clock-tower, but it was these others who benefited greatly from the trade there over many long years. And for many generations of men and kings no tariffs were levied, no taxes drawn, and the Breelanders were left free to govern themselves as long as the roads remained open.

   And so the Road did remain open through many long troubles in other regions of the world. And here a thriving community grew in relative peace while turmoil besieged the greater realms. News was heard, bad news most often, but bad times themselves had stayed out of the Bree-land until quite recently.

   While there was no official connection between the Bree-land and the Sea Kings the first townsfolk felt a certain loyalty to the Silver Crown which had later come into question. In the town’s earliest days there was one great Sea King and he and his sons had used the North-South Road to move their warriors against the Dark Lord in far-off Mordor. And that war had been won, but at great cost, for the old King had died and now the Númenóreans had split their lands between the two sons with a kingdom in the North, Arnor, and another, Gondor, away in the South. That first northern king, Isildur of Arnor, was by all accounts a very great hero, but he had never returned from his war with the Dark Lord. The Breelanders heard the tales of this Isildur for many long years and even took a certain pride in telling them to others. After all, everyone loves to tell stories of the heroes from their own lands and, perhaps by dying so far away and never bothering the Breelanders, he made for the most excellent model of a king that anyone might wish for. No Breelander ever doubted the lordship of Isildur, who had never really bothered them with his own troubles, and so to him all proper respect was given. But his death, many hundreds of years ago, slowed the travel of warriors along the North-South Road and people of the Bree-land lost interest in, or connections to, Isildur’s heirs. And still no taxes were ever drawn nor demands made upon the Breelanders, so business at the Crossways went on much as it had before. Breelanders believed in their king but felt and acted quite curiously free of any kingship. To many, this was the most excellent of arrangements.

   It was an arrangement that continued for another eight hundred years and, while soldiers still came and went occasionally through the town, the Road in the direction of the South was not patrolled and went untended; the grass grew long on the paving stones and people began to call it the Greenway. Then, in the declining years of Eärendur, the last reigning king of Arnor who left no clear successor, the northern realm was split yet again into three parts by his sons.9 And so news was heard again in the Bree-land; bad news as usual, but for Breelanders it seemed more the worse, because the Crossways and the position of their small community, lay rather squarely at the boundary for each of these fledgling nations. Which created the question still much in debate today; claimed by three kings it had never known and paying taxes to no one throughout their long history, was the Bree-land truly part of any kingdom?

   This had all happened some eleven-hundred very long years before the discussion at the Four Greenfields of course, and no reason had yet come about to resolve the issue. It is quite important to remember that questions like these seem to take many, many long generations to resolve, particularly when discussed in no place more official than a local publichouse.

   But it should also be noted that this division of kingdoms occurred at a time when the population of the Bree-land began to change. As if three squabbling brother kings surrounding them were not distraction enough, trouble was brewing on the Eastern Road past the mountains and a dark Shadow had fallen on Greenwood the Great so that Men, returning from travel in that direction, began to call it Mirkwood. Trade to the east was all but abandoned. Old relationships between the First Men here in the western lands of the North and their old brethren to the east were forgotten. At this time the Common tongue of travelers began to grow (some proud Breelanders would suggest it happened here, at the Four Greenfields and the cornerstone of the Tharangarond, first10) and many Peoples, fearing the Darkness growing to the East, settled in Bree-land, tripling the town’s size within two generations. Most of these new people were hobbitlya, or so the First Men of old had called them, but here, as they came to the Bree-land about ten hundred years ago, they were simply referred to as ‘the Little People’, and they had very little interest in a king they had never met.

   Tom Truetunnels, proud nineteenth scion of a grandsire who first walked into the Bree-land and made it his home during that time, was less than pleased with being compared to a rabbit and, of course, felt that he had great argument to give about the town’s allegiance to some king whose name he’d never come to know.

   ‘Well, we’re part of the North to be sure, but we’re that part which wants no part of any king, if you ask me,’ said Tom. ‘And why should we? We’ve seen nothing of any king here in the Bree-land for many lifetimes and have had quite enough nuisance from the squabbling of the Three Kings’ soldiers along our borders. Now those squabbles are over, their tall towers have tumbled down and all those soldiers lie in their mounds out West of here. I’m sorry for that, truly sorry, but, sad though that may be, their troubles, brought upon themselves, is ours no more. I’ve seen no Witch-king nor goblins here in the Bree-land and I’ll warrant we never shall.’

   ‘In that you might be wrong, sir,’ said a calm voice from near the fire. This came from one of the many Little Folk gathered there that night, though he seemed alone and stood apart from most of the rest. He was dressed in a peculiar fashion (for a hobbit of the Bree-land at least), all muted greens and browns, a supple leather waistcoat rather than the usual brightly dyed cloth, and an oddly triangle-shaped grey-green cap, which sat on his head and shaded his eyes.

   ‘For I’ve seen them in my rounds in the north of Chetwood. Orcs that is. Of a Witch-king, well, I can’t say anything about that other than they’ve got some kind of a king I’m sure, even if Breelanders do not,’ he said.

   ‘Now, Ben,’ said Tom, ‘save your long tales of the wild for those that buy your wares. I’ve seen the pelts you bring to market each month, but there’s not a Mammoth Wolf, giant batwing nor an Oliphant in the lot.’ This seemed to quiet the young hobbit, whether out of shyness or respect or simply because he chose not to argue. Either way, Tom Truetunnels was pleased with the results.

   ‘No, I say again, it's the Elves and the Sea Kings that have caused all their own troubles and, no matter who might tell us otherwise,’ he said, pausing to look back at the rather argumentative stranger in the corner, ‘those troubles will not touch us here. Leave well enough well alone, I say.’

   And with that, and a rather long and self-congratulatory last gulp of his ale, he left them all to be the wiser.

 

*****

   Nights like these at the Four Greenfields were the reason why Buttercup Blueburrow so very much loved her job. It was hard work of course, serving food and drink to thirsty customers, and the inn was uncommonly crowded for this time of year, making her chores run quite late into the evenings. But travelers here brought new life to the otherwise drab little town with their tales (and sometimes songs!) of far off lands. Stories of people and places that Buttercup herself had often imagined yet knew she would never see in her own lifetime. The townsfolk were largely boring to a girl of her age and (as her aunt had called it) her rather dreamy disposition. That old Tom Truetunnels, like most of his friends, was a gossipy sort and no one ever heard anything good or exciting in all of his talk (to which she was unwillingly treated on most nights of the week). But tonight, by whatever fortune, the inn was nearly full with all manner of travelers and the half-overheard conversations in the common room were proving quite a distraction from serving drinks and food to all these wonderful strangers.

   The room itself (for she was certain it wasn’t due to the food served there) was the most popular gathering spot in the Bree-land and many people from the surrounding areas came there whenever business brought them to town. The townsfolk, lacking anything more exciting to do with their evenings, came there most nights as they always had in hope of hearing news from the world around them. But, being Breelanders, they preferred only good news or small gossip and expected that it should come from somewhere not too far from their very own doors.

   Now there were three fireplaces in that room which made it an exceptional place for gathering. Two were lit but recently in this early hour of a spring evening and only with a low blaze, yet people still pulled tables around them and there were always loose chairs there which they huddled together for their more private conversations. Amidst all of that the room itself was still quite large and in its center Collum Gilleyfoil, the Four Greenfield’s proprietor, had built a great serving station filled with bottles and flasks and barrels of all of the drinking stock put plainly in sight for his guests. Then, piled around and about that collection of wares, he had arranged the majority of the house’s tankards and mugs and other vessels so that everyone assembled might be reminded that here, in the middle of their talking, was a place to drink. It became quite popular (as one might expect) therefore to do both in the commonroom and so, showing the initiative to improve on a good idea, the owner had built a long oval table surrounding this whole serving area so that customers might come for their drinks easier (but still be prohibited from nipping the odd drop or two for themselves). He jokingly, or at least in joking with Buttercup and her other co-workers, called it “the henhouse”; because in time this part of the room, perhaps more so than the fireplaces, became popular for the townspeople as a spot to gather where they might watch the coming-and-goings of travelers and other outliers, talking their gossip and giving their viewpoints to any who might listen. It was there Collum spent most of his nights, talking with guests while pouring out the drink, and so, being one of the Big Folk himself (and in fact quite taller than most in the town), he built the surrounding table of the Henhouse Man-size and to elbow’s height where someone of his own size might want to comfortably rest his drink. Many of the townsfolk were Little People of course, so they had taken the matter of the table’s height not as an insult and, quite matter-of-factly (as hobbits usually do) they had solved the problem on their own. Large stools were fashioned by the hobbits, taller than themselves but with ladder-like rungs, so that the smaller Breelanders might also have a spot in the room’s center. Given the shape of these round ladder-like stools, and as good natured jab at the owner’s name, this was called “sitting at the Column” and became the favored vantage point by many of the regulars.11

   On this particular night there were only six or so of those regulars surrounding the Henhouse and the majority of the other tables in the room held an odd sampling of total strangers, local acquaintances, curious country folk and occasional visitors. There were a few nightly visitors like Bert Thistleberry, the town cooper and Harry Flownsey, the baker’s son. Tom Truetunnels and his cronies, who had been coming here for decades and felt it somehow undignified to “sit at the Column”, preferred to huddle nearer to the fireplaces no matter the weather and, as Tom’s own example had shown, cared little for the opinions of strangers in the room about them. Buttercup avoided Tom and his older friends as much as possible, mostly because she found them dull but also, as Collum himself had said, ‘their need to share their own opinion exceeds their need of drink and, remember, there’s no profit to be had from their opinion.’

   Fern Sarnside and his friends were another small group she shied away from. Fern was a gangly, dark fellow from near the eastern gate of the village and he had a sneaky eye that a girl of Buttercup’s age knew well as a caution. He had some companions join him many nights this past month who were (if one could imagine it) much worse. Sallow-faced, oily-skinned and stern-looking, their clothing was always rugged and dark and they spied at every tankard or mug she brought them as if they might carry it off in their near empty satchels. They weren’t armed as travelers often are (and Collum certainly discouraged long blades here in the commonroom), but they had small, cunning knives on their belts; impractical for cutting meats and dark like their clothing. She did not like to think what uses they had for such blades and, distrusting Sarnside as she did, gave him, his friends, and his usual table over near the rear door, a wide berth. They went to Collum for their needs and he (or so she believed) trusted them even less.

   Flomi was at his usual spot by the back as well, though, as ever, he needed little to no attention. He sat there most every night, drinking quite slowly, and working away at his little scraps of pelt and paper. He drank much more sparingly than the reputation of his race, but Buttercup had always found him to be very kind in his way, and this also did not live up to the stories she had heard of Dwarves. But he had lived here at the Four Greenfields for many long years and taking care of him and his little eccentricities was quite familiar to her by this point. Other Dwarves might, on rare occasions, come and go, but Flomi, and even his father before him it was said, were a steady fixture in this small community and, in all the years she had served him, he never offered tales of his past or his time in travel.

   Ben Floxleaf was in tonight and he was quite another matter. Buttercup hoped to talk with him when she could, for Ben was the farthest traveled hobbit that any Breelander had ever heard of and, while he was not a braggart by any stretch, he knew much more of the goings-on around these lands than any merchant or wayfarer who had ever bothered to visit the Four Greenfields more than once. His folk had come out of the North many long years ago, with the first Hobbit settlers in the Bree-land, leading many of them over the mountains it was said, but they had never made a home here. He, and his fathers before him, roamed and tracked and hunted game through the lands north and directly around the Bree-land and brought such a steady trade of their catch here to town that most other hunters had put the practice aside. Ben, a favorite of Buttercup’s, was here in town for many long days in the summer, but this was a bit early in the year for her to see him and his funny cap show up in the commonroom. She had no time to greet him with more than a smile just yet however as business was so brisque that evening. He smiled back to her, although his smile, or so it seemed to her, looked quite sad.

   There were also the three old gentlemen near the back who had just made such a stir by arguing with old Truetunnels. They had been shown the most of Buttercup’s attention that evening for they were, up until that point, clearly the most exotic travelers she had ever seen. Wassirds, as the townsfolk called them, came sometimes to the Bree-land, but none had ever been seen in Buttercup’s time here. One, the tallest one who had stood up to speak with that windbag Tom and towered so high above him, was clad in darker greys and his boots and his cloak looked very weathered and had seen many miles (or so she believed, though she had never strayed more than a league or so from town herself). His beard was as long as Tom Truetunnels was tall (thicker and cleaner-looking too) and she fancied that in earlier days it had been dark like her own hair but denser, fuller and grown rich in whatever distant land he came from. It was grey now, if not quite silver, and only his bushy eyebrows showed a hint of the rich color he might once have had.

   ‘Buttercup! Here, girl!’ called Collum from the corner of the serving station where she usually retrieved drinks for the guests. She promptly gathered up the loose plates from where she had been standing listening to the men talk and hurried over just as quick as can be.

   ‘Now, girl, no need to look as if you’re in haste, for I’m not cross with you,’ Collum said with an almost conspiratorial softness. ‘No, it's your sharp ears for listening to these folks that I need most at the moment.’ As he spoke he took three small and delicately wrought cups from the shelf high above the bar, wiping them carefully and eyeing them for any small imperfection. In the three years Buttercup had worked here at the inn she had never seen these particular vessels put into service, didn’t even know they had existed, and now she found herself quite enchanted by their elegant beauty which so differed from every other cup in the house.

   ‘But I’ll need you to listen carefully to me now, girl,’ Collum continued, ‘and to tell me everything you hear upon return.’

   As he said this he reached into his own knapsack that lay on the floor beneath the counter. She was surprised again to see that it seemed mostly packed, as if ready for a very hasty exit. It was at this time she also noticed a sheathed longsword laying alongside the cudgel that Collum normally kept behind there for the threat of unruly guests or late-night squabblers. This kind of behaviour happened rarely enough, and talk of the cudgel, or “Collum’s Peacekeeper” as it had been called, amongst the townsfolk kept any troubles to a minimum. But the sword hidden there, and the loaded knapsack, indicated that the proprietor might be secretly prepared for a whole different level of business on this one particular evening.

   From the bag’s center, sheltered there like a precious keepsake, he pulled a small drinking skin and doled out three portions of what looked like a golden wine into the three small vessels. He cautiously cupped his large hands over the whole procedure and she watched carefully as the wine seemed to capture the light of the candle more brilliantly than the polished metal of the cups.

   ‘Now,’ said Collum, speaking quite carefully as he poured out the wine, ‘you are to take these three drinks to our three wizened grandfathers over there. Have no fear of them, girl, though I’ll grant they look as stern as a set of statues off there in the snug by themselves.’

   He put the cups on a tray and then, rather ceremoniously (if such a word was ever used to describe drink service at the Four Greenfields) he covered them with a fresh cloth napkin from his own pocket.

   ‘Put the tray on the table, Buttercup, and, before you reveal the drinks, you’ll need to say something quite strange so that these particular customers will receive what you’ve offered. I’ll teach it to you. You don’t mind learning a small smattering of an old language, do you, girl? I’m sure you’re up to the task.’

   Buttercup was, she knew that she was, and was quite pleased to be asked to perform such a wonderful job and meet these three strange men from afar, but at just that moment she was interrupted as Collum’s quick brown eyes darted from her face to the doorway, uncharacteristically registering some surprise. She turned her own dark head to follow.

   Now there were many travelers at the inn on this particular night and, as mentioned, many strange folk in the commonroom from various parts unknown. Like any publichouse in any small city, townsfolk and wayfarers are usually cordial to one another but mix only cautiously and, here in the Bree-land, this was still generally the rule. The Breelanders, with a population composed of both Little People and the Big Folk, were (quite unknown to themselves) perhaps the most diverse of communities in all of Middle-earth at this time. Many travelers used the Roads throughout the town’s long history and whether they were soldiers or merchants, hunters or thieves, Halflings or Men, Elves (so some say) or Dwarves (in happier times) they had all walked through the town’s streets since the Thangorond was first laid and the Clock first built. Yet still the farmers generally spent their time amongst other farmers, the shopkeepers and tradesmen held to their own company and so on, so travelers were either openly invited through the cordial nature of the regulars or they sat away in their own corners as the three tall gentlemen in the back had done for most of the night. It was quite uncommon then, quite uncommon indeed, to see two newcomers enter the inn that were so distinctly unlike one another as those two that now stood in the doorway as Collum, Buttercup and almost all the other folk present looked on in dumbfounded surprise.

   The first, which is to say the largest, was a Man of great size and girth. His bare arms were massive as the limbs of an oak tree and the long staff he carried in one of them looked as if it had grown branchlike from his own bronzed skin. He wore a long, unsleeved garment of supple, stitched leather with a girdle of plaited straw and bullrushes held by a wide, tooled-leather belt which was graven with the crude images of many heroes and many beasts. At his unclad knees and chest and shoulders he was covered with a prickly hair of the color of a rich riverbed and this same hair grew in coarser patches to long braided plaits from beneath his stony chin and along the top of his broad head with great explosive bursts on his brow.12 He was not a young man if judged by the length of his beard but his eyes, even from across the room, showed a childlike innocence and wonder as if he was entering a publichouse for the very first time.

   Despite the unusual dress and appearance of the man, it was his companion, different in every way imaginable, that caught the interest of everyone in the commonroom that night. For next to the broad man, half his height and quite as lean as his longstaff, stood an Elf-child.

   An Elf! Here in the Bree-land! Such a thing had not been seen in the memory of any Breelander nor in the memories of their fathers. Elves were not entirely foreign to folks of the North at this time of course, and were not yet wholly estranged from Men. Travelers, and even some Bree-land outliers like brave Benbow Floxleaf, told stories of encountering them in far-away lands or in their hidden halls. Some of the best songs, and certainly some of Buttercup’s favorites, came from Elvish legend and some of their words still crept into the vocabulary of the soldiers who rode through the Bree-land in brighter days. Even the cornerstone, Thangorond, was said to be an old Elvish word. But no Elf had ever walked into the Four Greenfields, nor any other part of the Bree-land, that any of the townsfolk could recall. In another age perhaps, when the great kingdom of Hollin was in bloom and Elves still roamed freely in the west of Middle-earth, before the Sea-kings came and the North-South Road was built they might have gathered here and spoken many long stories to the First Men who had later settled this town. But remaining so long unseen, like Isildur, the Bree-landers’ truant king, Elves were certainly held in very high regard by all the town’s inhabitants. But no one ever really expected to see one walk through the door.

   And this Elf, like his companion, was certainly not someone anyone at the inn this night would have imagined. He was a child apparently (though upon later discussion the more thoughtful Breelanders like Buttercup would come to realize that immortality and childhood presented them with a puzzle quite beyond their grasp), yet he stood with an authority and an assertiveness like that of a high lord. His golden hair was long and straight, as if untrimmed since birth. But to say that it reached the middle of his back would seem no great thing in a boy so small. His clothing was very fine, as if the dust from traveling would not dare to touch it, and his cloak had a rich grey-green color that was unusual in this part of the world. He stood very proudly and at his side was a long dagger with a bone handle. On his back there was an overly large wooden sword. But his eyes, his eyes were bright in that way which songs recall; so bright that Buttercup was quick to look away, her face oddly flushed. There was such beauty in that boy that she had never encountered before and knew, in some part of herself, it would be impossible to ever forget.

   ‘Oh, the fat’s in it now, my girl,’ Collum said quietly from behind the bar.

   ‘So, we need to do this thing now more than ever. Here we go!’ He snapped a quick sharp fingersnap before her face to regain her attention. ‘So you’ll take this tray, as I’ve said, and you’ll set it upon their table and then what?’

   ‘I’m not to take the napkin up before I say something to the old fellows?’ she replied.

   ‘Very good, dear girl. You’re the natural I’ve always thought you to be,’ Collum said. ‘Now we’ve not much time, so repeat after me; ‘La Kho...’

   ‘La Cho...’

   ‘Kho, Buttercup. It’s a hard sound.’

   ‘La Kho.’

   ‘Ka laad!’

   ‘Ka lad...’

   ‘No, with strength, with heart, with emphasis! It's an oath, girl. Calad!’

   ‘Ka Laad!’

   ‘Fine, girl. But the strength is on the ‘Ca-‘. Now the second part is simple and quick; Drego morn!’

   ‘Drego morn!’ she repeated loudly.

   ‘Oh, that’s fine, it is,’ Collum said, putting up his hands and returning to his conspiratorial tone as he looked cautiously about them. ‘Now repeat it all back to me without telling everyone in the room.’

   ‘Lacho calad! Drego morn!’13 Buttercup said, as a keen and quite unexpected light came into her eyes.

   She felt flush again, but in quite a different way then she had with the sight of the Elf-boy; warm to the sound of the words on her tongue in a way that she would never have expected and, then at least, still in her naive girlhood, had no way to understand. Were they Elvish words, she wondered? There was a harsher tone to them than she would think to find in Elf-talk, but there was no mistaking their beauty or the rallying feel that these words put in her belly. Had she done it right? Even before Collum smiled so broadly she knew that she had and those words had seemed to come from some distant place in her that only he could see. She couldn’t wait to speak them to the three old travelers and hear their response. It was like a blaze had been kindled by these words that only Collum and the three old gentlemen might help her understand.

   ‘As I thought, girl,’ Collum said with a sly smile. ‘You’re a natural.’

 

*****

   Something was amiss here at the Four Greenfields, no disputing that, but Ben had only half a heart to give it his attention. He was comfortable here, well, comfortable enough for any town he’d ever seen from the inside anyways, and there were friends here from his father and even his fathers before that. Those venerable old Floxleafs were no true townsfolk either. They were outsiders as he himself was. Still it is said that all wanderers need a home somewhere and the Bree-land was the closest to a home that Benbow Floxleaf and his forefathers had ever known.

   Probably he should be bothered by this talk tonight of no kingly allegiance. He had met the king’s men on more than one occasion in his travels and thought them to be both kind and just in wild places, a quality which Ben found very admirable indeed. Probably he should be bothered by such short-sightedness from his own people here in the Bree-land who ought to know better. He also knew (as the Breelanders did not) that very real threats lay just beyond the furthest farmhouse and it was only a matter of time before they came a-knocking. Perhaps he should tell them more about the Witch-king and the things he had seen on dark nights, not two day’s ride to the north of this inn.

   But tonight his mind and his heart (which were never truly far apart) and his hopes and his prayers (which were essentially the same thing), went to worriting about his dear Rosie who lay outside with a fever.

   It was Benbow’s usual custom to come into the town every month or so during the spring and early summer. Game was plentiful then and he could bring the pelts and meats to market easily, trading as he would to slowly build his winter stores. But while he liked the Four Greenfields well enough and some (though certainly not all) of the people he met there, he seldom stayed at the inn, preferring to make his camp outside the town with Rosie. Beds made him uncomfortable and towns made Rosie moreso. Usually they would camp in the valley of the Combe east of the Hill, alone and away from townsfolk at night and then come in to trade pelts on the weekends for provisions and to keep up on the news during the day.

   In more prosperous times, as the travelers were more plentiful and while game was high, Ben would stay for a month or so and provision Collum Gilleyfoil, the inn’s proprietor, with fresh meats. He liked hunting close to the town and the Chetwood and some of the lands to the west were still dense enough so that he need never travel far for deer and rabbit and even wild boar for the more distinguishing guests at the Four Greenfields’ table. During these times he might bring Rosie to town overnight and ask Collum to look after her. And she grew to tolerate and perhaps even like the Big Man as she never did with others. Once he even overheard Collum speaking to her softly in the Elvish when he thought no one was listening. Ben didn’t know more than a few words in that language himself, so he had no idea what the Man had said, but it was clear the comfort Rosie took from the sound of it. Ben was glad for that and hoped Collum might help with her now, so he’d taken a room here at the Four Greenfields in the hope more Elvish talk might ease Rosie through her fever. Now he was patiently waiting for Collum to finish his business with Buttercup, the serving girl, so that he might enlist the man’s help.

   But the arrival of a young Elf-lord here in the commonroom, well, that was something Benbow Floxleaf would never have expected. What might have brought him, and his wild giant of a companion, here into the Bree-land (other than Ben’s own good fortune) he could not have guessed. But Ben, whom the Breelanders believed to be half-wild himself, had some experience with the High People and he felt certain, given half the chance, he might be able to ask the lordling to help with Rosie.

 

*****

   ‘Beothalion, my dear friend,’ the Elf-child said calmly and scornfully in perfectly smooth Sindarin, ‘please close your gaping jaw. I fear that you are drawing the flies which are so abundant in this dreadful place.’

   The big man looked immediately flushed with embarrassment, but could not keep his eyes from darting around the dimly lit room at all of the strange sights. Nor could he keep his nose from continually crinkling at the delightful new smells. ‘I will, I will indeed, Tawar,’ he responded in a more broken and guttural version of the same Elven tongue. ‘I will very happily close my jaw around some of the savory foods I’m smelling here. What a wonderful place you have brought us to!’

   ‘There are smells to be certain,’ his friend replied. ‘I have never encountered such a strange assortment of offenses. How do these people live in these horrid and close conditions?’

   ‘We should sit, brother,’ Beothalion said. ‘We draw attention to ourselves in the doorway and I look forward to hearing the speech of Men. And that of these other small creatures! Not Dwarves, certainly. What do you think they are?’

   ‘We call them i pheriain in the halls of my uncle, though they are very rarely spoken of and have no place in our songs,’ Tawarengil said as he motioned toward a small table near the door. ‘They have been gone from the Vale of Anduin for some time and I have never met any of my people who have encountered them or, if they have, must never have felt them worthy of report.’

   ‘Ah, but you and your folk are notoriously harsh in the valuing of others, or we should not be here,’ the man said as they both drew up to a small (and, for Beothalion, certainly too small) table. ‘But look on them with favour,’ he said, pointing to one of the small stools with his wooden staff. ‘At least they have provided you with accommodations suited to your stature!’ He said with a roaring laugh that the elf, try though he might, could not help but enjoy.

   Only Beothalion, his true friend since his early childhood, could jibe Tawarengil in this way. Such inferences from any other person regarding his childlike appearance would make him quite lose his carefully checked temper. Though he was certainly unlike anyone Tawarengil had ever known, there was no question in the elf’s mind that the wild man loved and knew him best. They had met in the first years of Tawarengil’s life, in his first misled adventure (of the many) and even then the wild man (at that time a boy himself) had shown him trust and kindness that was rare among the Woodland Elves of Tawarengil’s home. Together at that first meeting, some fifty summers ago, they had saved one another from certain death and formed a friendship that none of Tawarengil’s family could understand (and of which they certainly did not approve).

   Still, Tawarengil, while he looked very much like a boy, was not, and his friend, while he had grown well into his adulthood, was much more childlike in his own approach to the world. It may very well have been a mistake to bring him along on this adventure and Tawarengil, in private thoughts that even his friend could not guess, was fairly certain he would regret it.

   ‘Ale, I have heard of, Tawar,’ the man said, sitting uncomfortably but agreeably on the too small chair, ‘differing from the mead of my Fathers and as unlike from place to place as the very land around it. Imagine! A drink which reflects the very land and people who have made it! I am excited by ale,’ he said, looking around the room and sniffing to catch the aroma from any full cups at the tables near him.

   ‘And the herbs! I grill meats on occasion, though killing, as you know, sits uneasy with me. But the smells from these kitchens! As we came up the Road those smells have been quite irresistible. Where does this herblore come from?’

   ‘Well, from the Elves originally, of course,’ Tawarengil offered with his usual pride and disdain. ‘Long ages ago the Fathers of Men learned the art of herb-oils and of curing from my People and, while they seem to have fallen to crude use here, there is no denying that the cooking of game in this land holds some echo of those skills and even some attention to capturing the flavor of the land itself. That is as it should be. But,’ he said, looking contemptuously at the Men at the table next to them and sniffing rather loudly as he made a sad and sour face. ‘I cannot say that other of the lessons we taught their forefathers regarding odor have still held as fast.’

   Beothalion, for his part, had never experienced Men other than the vague recollection that he had of his mother’s folk before and, at the age of six summers, the adoption by his Father. Men’s customs, like his Father’s customs (who died some few months after this adoption), were quite unfamiliar to the wild man and he had lived for the many long years of his life outside of their contact. While it was not the language of his Father he had a passably good understanding of the Man-speech, Westron, for Huandain, his loyal servant, knew many of their words and the other friends who visited his home also brought many insights into the strange behavior of Men they had encountered. Of course Huandain and the others could not really speak the words of Men, their throats were not fashioned for such sounds, but Tawarengil had done his best to refine his friend’s knowledge over the years and in their weeks together now upon the Road. Beothalion was now impatient and more than ready to try this ‘Common Speech’ in what seemed to him such a large cluster of people.

   ‘We should stop talking Elf, Tawar,’ he said carefully in his new and cautious tongue. ‘They see us as strange enough, but none will talk with us if we keep talking Elf. And I do wish to talk.’ He looked so comical then, this giant of a man sitting carefully on this small little chair with his eyes darting about the room at all the new faces. Tawarengil found himself wondering how many faces Beothalion had ever seen. Other than his stable of animal friends certainly not even a dozen. How different his quiet life was from Tawarengil’s own time within the Halls of Thranduil, his uncle. Now, at Tawrengil’s request, he was seeing a much larger world than he had ever been prepared for.

   ‘Soon enough, brother,’ he said, returning to their common Sindarin. ‘There are Dwarves here. I’m ambivalent towards Men, and while I’ve no particular feelings in regard to i pheriain, I am most rightly distrustful of Dwarves.’

   ‘Only one, by my nose,’ the big man said as he rather too overtly gestured to the Longbeard at a table far in the back of the commonroom, ‘and he seems rather too engaged in his own business to care much for ours.’

 

   This was very true. Though traveling Dwarves were quite rare to the Bree-land in these days some few tradesmen had settled in these lands alongside the Men and Halflings many years ago, plying their skills as smiths and wrights and masons. Here, unlike many other settlements in the North, they were accepted (if not entirely welcomed) and their talents were valued (if not exactly embraced). For no Man nor Halfling of the Bree-land could cut stone like a Dwarf and the builders, those like bigoted old Tom Truetunnels himself, could not do their job half so well without Dwarvish hands to lay the proper foundations.

   This particular Dwarf of note, and he was the only member of his race to be in attendance at the Four Greenfields on this particular and auspicious evening, sat where he usually did, at a small table away from the fire, and did as he usually did, writing curious marks on torn and irregular sheets of paper by candlelight. Beothalion was quite correct in his assessment that this Dwarf cared nothing for the conversations of the people in the commonroom on this night (or on any other night, for that matter).

   What Beothalion could not know however, for he had never seen a Dwarf before in all of his lifetime, was just how rare it was to see one openly engaged in the act of writing. Certainly the Breelanders took no surprise at this regular behavior from their town mason for they were, on the subject of Dwarves, almost equally naive. But Tawarengil, though he also had never really seen a Dwarf himself, knew enough to see this as a behavior quite suspicious.

 

   ‘Try not to gesture so broadly, my brother,’ Tawarengil said quietly to his friend, returning to Sindarin. ‘There are many eyes on us here, as we both suspected, and I think it would serve best to let the curious come to us. Have you noticed the three tall travelers toward the back?’

   ‘Indeed,’ Beothalion said, more comfortable in the elvish language. ‘Are they Men? Certainly they are nothing like the other menfolk we have seen in this town; tall and, while coarsened by years, are yet lively beyond their age. They have no smell that I can read from here, but their eyes are bright like your own.’

   ‘Brighter, brother. For they have seen the Western shore that only a very few of my people have ever seen,’ Tawarengil said, with some uncharacteristic respect. ‘They are the Istari, if I am correct, and my folk have welcomed one of them into our halls before. But not one of these three. Beothalion, we must speak with them, but we must be cautious.’

 

*****

   ‘Wonderful!’ The grey gentleman said from under his bushy eyebrows, ‘a delight to weary ears. Girl, who taught you these words?’

   ‘My employer, sir,’ Buttercup responded, pleased that her recitation of the speech seemed to bring the old man such joy. ‘He bid me to say these words to you and then to present you with this!’

   With a careful (but, perhaps, just a bit overstated) flourish, the serving girl removed the cloth napkin from the vessels. They shone brightly as they caught the light of a nearby lantern. Immediately there was a smell that came up with the raised napkin like Buttercup had never encountered before and had not, to her surprise, noticed when Collum was pouring out the liqueur; not a pungent or savory smell like most of the ales or dinner dishes she served here at the inn, but something much more, well, wholesome and refreshing she might call it, as if all the smells of springtime had been held under the cloth and were just waiting to burst forth. For a moment, until the voice of the old gentlemen awakened her, Buttercup felt the flavor of the aroma had awakened some memory of high towered cities and still waters which she had never seen or known before.

   ‘Now this is a most curious and unexpected delight, my dear,’ the old greybearded gentleman said interrupting her reverie, and he and his companions exchanged looks that sat somewhere between surprise and suspicion. ‘Most curious and unexpected indeed. And,’ he said, looking crossly at his still silent friends, ‘we shall certainly enjoy them and most graciously thank your master for such a generous gift.

   ‘But,’ he added softly, ‘perhaps you might stay a moment and tell us more of this employer of yours.’

 

*****

   If Flomi the stone-mason did not notice the three old gentlemen nor their brief argument with Tom Truetunnels it would certainly come as no surprise to the inhabitants of the Bree-land. Though he was kind and cordial enough (for a Dwarf, anyway) in most of his daily business relations, the regulars at the Four Greenfields took Flomi for something of an oddball and a loner.

   Now of course this judgement of their neighbor was not, strictly speaking, very fair. Not many of them, other than the innkeeper Collum Gilleyfoil or outliers like Benbow Foxleaf, had been treated to much more than a passing conversation with Dwarfish folk other than Flomi in these days when the East-West Road was less travelled. Perhaps his behavior was not very odd at all for a dwarf and he should not be taken so much as a loner but rather as a person sadly alone being the only one of his kind in their rather small and not-entirely-welcoming community. But whether his unique separateness was a predilection of Flomi’s own or a characteristic of his People, most Breelanders had come to realize, if not even respect, that Flomi the Dwarf was not someone who came to the common room of the Four Greenfields for conversation.

   Yet they could, as a rule, count on his attendance there most nights. For thirty years or more Flomi had lived amongst the Breelanders as a stone-mason and for much of those same thirty years he had lived at this inn, back since Collum’s grandfather, Craidic Gilleyfoil, owned the place. He kept the same small room at the Four Greenfields during all this time, even though his business had grown well and his stone yard, just outside the town to the northwest, certainly provided him room and ample money for better lodgings. He ate most every night and early mornings here in the common room, he laundered his clothing and stabled his ponies here at the inn and each month, or so it was said, he left a small gemstone, worth far more than a monthly rate, for the proprietor. But this last part was very much in dispute by all of Flomi’s neighbors. For the stories of extravagant Dwarven wealth are, of course, complimented by the stories of their stinginess and the gossip-tenders of the Bree-land, not having taken much opportunity to know their neighbor any better, were not certain which of these legends to apply to Flomi.

   If there was great wealth from the dwarf hidden somewhere here at the inn or away at his stoneyard, no one of the Bree-land had ever seen it. There was talk of an attempted burglary of his room at the inn some ten years ago or so, at about the time young Collum came to the town to run the Greenfields for his aged grandfather. But Collum had become quite friendly with the mason since (a probable cause or effect of this generous tip that the Breelanders gossip of), so no information could be gleaned from him regarding the incident. But the legend of the innkeeper’s cudgel, the Peacekeeper, also grew about this time and Collum certainly made all townsfolk and travelers aware that he was ready to use it to keep the peace here at the Four Greenfields and throughout the Bree-land for his honored guests.

   Of the dwarf’s other odd habit, the curious writing and copying of marks on strangely-shaped pieces of paper, there was also some conjecture (though the subject itself was certainly not as interesting as the idea of a hidden trove of gems there within the publichouse). Very few Breelanders were lettered of course; it was hardly considered a useful talent amongst people living in such a small and close-knit community. But of those literate few who had seen Flomi at his work in the common room the general consensus was that this must be the language of Dwarves, for none of the characters of his writing were recognizable to Bree-land’s most learned. As such, they were completely indecipherable and therefore, among the most gossipy of Breelanders, they became the target of the wildest speculations; the most popular of which, as should come to no surprise, was that Flomi the mason was making a treasure map.

   The Breelanders, who knew so very little of Dwarves, even of this one who had been their neighbor for decades, were, if one should give them some credit, at least half right.

 

*****

   It was at this time that quite a number of things happened.

   ‘Tawarengil, my friend, what is that?’ Beothalion said as his wrinkling nose caught the scent of the liqueur Buttercup had revealed at the other side of the room. ‘What is that wonderful drink she gives them?’ And he stood to his full and quite obtrusive size looking over to the table where the serving girl and the three Istari were gathered.

   ‘Beothalion,’ the elf whispered sharply, ‘would you please sit down. I’ve asked you to be cautious here among all these-’

   ‘I will, I will, Tawar,’ said Beothalion. ‘Don’t worry. I will be very cautious indeed. But I must learn more about that wonderful aroma. I know! I shall go and ask the proprietor for it. You said we could purchase food and drink and such things here, but I never knew that there would be such wonderful drinks!’

   He set his longstaff aside, for he rightly assumed that would be a most unfriendly way in which to approach a barman, and moved with anxious and long strides to the area at the center of the room where the proprietor still stood watching the girl and the three old men.

   ‘Beothalion-’ Tawarengil whispered between his teeth sharply.

   ‘Do not worry, brother,’ the big man said, only half turning around so that his nose might still face the direction of the liqueur’s aroma, ‘I will get one for you as well.’

 

   Flomi the Dwarf, who looked up from his work to notice that his own drinking vessel was quite over-long in being refilled, let his eyes glance around the room for the serving girl. It was then at last that he caught sight of her and, much more importantly, the three old gentlemen to whom she was talking in the back corner of the common room. And then, to his much greater surprise, he also noticed the young Elf near the door.

   He looked over to his friend Collum who was, uncharacteristically, ignoring this elf and his other customers as he kept his own eyes on the young mistress Buttercup. Noting the innkeeper’s wariness (something he had come to trust in their years together) Flomi hastily began to gather up his work on the table in preparation of an exit. He risked another glance over to Fern Sarnside and his suspicious-looking new companions. They were watching all of the same developments, but their attentions seemed more drawn to the elf on the other side of the room.

 

   ‘Oh, it is only three years that I’ve been here, sir,’ Buttercup told the old man, laughing coyly, ‘but many like yourself judge me a bit more mature for my experiences, and I thank you kindly. Now Collum, well, he was here at the inn since I was a child. Certainly a dozen summers or so by all accounts that I’ve heard. But as gentle a master as any girl in this town might wish for, by my own account at the least.’

   ‘Well that is favorable tidings indeed, girl, for any master who should put such trust in people as he has shown in you is deserving of praise. So,’ the old gentleman said as he raised his cup and motioned for his companions to do the same. ‘Mellon, eithel govannen!’14 he proclaimed in a rich voice that was just loud enough for anyone (including the proprietor) to hear. Then he took a deep draught of the cordial while his accusing eyes bid his friends to do the same. They did so, cautiously, but with the same oath (spoken much more quietly).

   ‘Oh, now that is lovely talk as well,’ said Buttercup. ‘Is it Elvish? For we don’t hear that talk here nowadays, though,’ and at this she drew closer to the grey gentleman who had treated her more cordially than these other more stand-offish friends of his. ‘I do hope that young Elf-lord near the door has something of it to say. I imagine that the sound of it might be lovely indeed...’ and at this her voice trailed off and her face became, quite beyond her control, embarrassingly flushed once again.

   ‘Yes, indeed,’ the old man said. ‘His arrival is certainly unlooked-for and might have something new to tell us all.’ At this the old man’s brow wrinkled and his thoughts seemed to darken.

   ‘But,’ he said, smiling up at the girl and turning his mind back to the subject at hand, ‘I should like to thank your master for this generous gift. And I find myself puzzled, though no longer suspicious given your wonderful recitation, that I know nothing about him. Perhaps you can tell me more before we meet?’

 

   ‘Oh, this is bad,’ Collum thought as he watched the girl talking with the old wizard. ‘I sent her to listen, but she’s already fallen into the trap of letting them ask all the questions. Well, it was a gamble showing my hand in this way but, if I learn nothing else, their toast tells me that my guess was aright. So probably the time has come.’ He then cautioned the quickest of glances toward Flomi and saw that the Dwarf was beginning to package up his own night’s work.

   ‘Wise fellow,’ he thought. ‘Didn’t think he even noticed they were there, but now he’s already getting ready for the long-expected trip. As I said, the fats in it now,’ and moving to the other side of the serving table where his longsword and knapsack lay hidden, he was startled to see the big woodsman who had so silently approached.

 

   ‘Beg your pardon, my lord, but do you mind if I ask, have you come West from the Homely House?’

   Tawarengil, who had been quite preoccupied with his friend’s lack of wariness, had not even noticed the pheriainth approach (and, though he hadn’t thought of it at the time, he later came to realize that this quietness in itself marked him as a much more unusual creature than he had earlier credited). He was perhaps as startled by the approach as he was the question.

   ‘Nidhin mened, periain,'15 he replied, cautiously testing the listener.

   ‘I am sorry, my lord, but I’ve no gift for your language, though it is a pleasure to hear it spoken in these days. May we speak in Westron, as you did with your friend there, and if it’s no imposition to yourself?’

   ‘You have sharp ears, little one,’ Tawarengil said (though, in truth, the pheriainth was not so much shorter in stature than he), ‘to have overheard that brief exchange. I suppose we both should trust and welcome such a chance meeting... despite other distractions.’ He looked past the pheriainth towards Beothalion and his halting talk with the innkeeper, to the three Istari who seemed to be watching his friend, and then to the Dwarf who seemed to be, rather hastily, gathering up his possessions.

   ‘You are most courteous to a stranger to ask of familiar halls in strange places. And at a time when so many behaviors of Men seem so strange to me. Yet your question does surprise me. I had not heard of i pheriain knowing of Imladris.16 Will you join me and tell me of Master Elrond’s House and how you know it?’

 

   ‘The Dwarf, you say?’ the old man responded.

   ‘If there truly is anyone, sir, who knows him best, it would be he,’ Buttercup continued. ‘Collum knows and meets every traveller that comes through the Four Greenfields. He says, “it’s all part of the job and just the common sense of being cordial”. Still, he’s got less time for the townsfolk than even I do myself, though I might say he is much better at not showing it. But little Flomi there, who is our stonemason, is the only person I’ve ever known him to spend his idle hours with. Most say it is because he knew Collum’s grandfather, old Cradaic who owned the Greenfields before him. Though some there are, some that don’t know Collum so well I’d say, that think it's only because of the little fellow’s money.’

   ‘Well, that could explain it, I suppose, in either case,’ he said, drawing the girl to talk further. ‘Though it is surprising that such a man, in such a small town as this, has learned the old language, offers gifts from the Elven folk and yet has the friendship of Dwarves. Yes. He definitely seems a man worthy of meeting,’ and he looked to the others as he said this.

   ‘Oh, he even knows some Dwarfish talk, I’m sure,’ Buttercup said. ‘I’ve heard them on a time or two talking a few words none of us might understand. Coarser than the Elf-talk that I’ve heard, but pretty in its own way. Old sounding it was, and rumbling and fast and flowing, like a deep running well where the water is dark and unexpected but cool to the taste.’

   The old grey traveler smiled then with a very kind smile and Buttercup felt her heart unexpectedly warmed just as she did a few minutes earlier when Collum had first taught her those strange and wonderful words to say. ‘You are a most observant girl. A “deep running well” indeed, and to be uncovered in the most dry-seeming of places. May you and your line be blessed with such incautious insights for many lives to come! Now, I should like to meet this employer of yours!’

 

   ‘Hello! Is this your house?’ The big man asked as he caught Collum’s eye. He had his hands open in front of him at waist height and a very odd smile on his face, as if he was trying to present himself in the very least threatening manner possible yet had little experience with how that might be done.

   ‘It is that, I suppose,’ Collum replied, opening his hands before him as well in the hope of making this stranger more comfortable, and then dropping them with a shrug of his shoulders, ‘or at least it is my responsibility to tend to those that come here. So one might say I belong to the house more than it belongs to me,’ he added with a broad smile. A long-played joke perhaps, but Collum always found it useful to greet new travelers, especially strange ones like this, with some small self-effacing humour.

   It went nowhere.

   The smile on the man’s face dropped quite suddenly and turned to bewilderment. ‘Do you mean it is long for you? It seems not so big,’ he said hesitatingly and looking absently around him. This drew some cautious laughter from the other townsfolk close enough to overhear their talk, but the slowness of the stranger’s speech made it clear to Collum that this was a man who had only a small understanding of the Common Tongue and, despite what these foolish townsfolk might think, a very full possession of his wits.

   ‘Does he speak the Elf-tongues, perhaps,’ Collum thought. At this he looked past the man’s broad shoulders to see that his traveling companion, the young Elf lord, was beginning a conversation with Ben Floxleaf. ‘Yet another surprise, those two talking, though Ben knows Elves better than most here and perhaps better than I. On a different day I might try the Elder Tongue with this fellow, but I’ve risked enough on this night of surprises already. This is no time to tip my hand further by speaking Sindarin to a stranger,’ he thought cautiously to himself.

   ‘Well, this place is only so long as it is storied, my friend, and, having a few stairs up and down, it is has just as much length and stories such that I can manage,’ he continued, keeping up the droll, joking character of his conversation for any townsfolk who might be listening. ‘But you are more long, and at least half again as wide, as most all of our beds. What might I manage for you?’

   ‘There,’ the wild man pointed with his arm off to the last place in all of the world that Collum would like to have attention drawn. ‘There they have something I would much like to have!’

   ‘Well, that’s our young girl Buttercup that is there,’ Collum deflected without looking, ‘and she can bring food and such to you and your young lordship presently. But if you are in a haste-of-thirst from travel then I am, indeed, your friend in need.’

   ‘Thirst! Yes! That is it. Tell me, Friend-in-need, what is that they thirst for?’

   This brought more open laughter from the regulars and (while he was glad the distraction was working) some amazement from Collum; it was a very great surprise that this tremendously large and clearly dangerous individual showed no anger at the snickering and condescension of the Breelanders around him. ‘Quite a wonderful temper in one so large,’ he thought. ‘This is a person of some note and of some manner, despite his rough appearance.’ But the innkeeper’s ruse, for a while at least, needed to be maintained if Collum and his charge were to escape the town safely and without undue gossip. So he kept up the banter for the other Breelanders to hear and be comforted by.

   ‘I should think, that like many, they thirst for a comfortable bed and a reprieve from long hours on horseback,’ Collum said, ‘though the tall grey-clad one in their party seems to thirst for controversy, and that’s a dish we have very few requests for here at the Greenfields. All here thirst for comfort, my large friend, or at the least some time away from discomforting concerns. So, now, what can I provide that might give you either of these joys?’

   ‘Hum,’ the big man uttered in a deep note as he seemed to deeply ponder this longer speech and what it all might mean. ‘Bed I need not and horse I have not, for he stayed at our own home many days walk from here. ‘Controversy’ is new to me. I may ask of it later, but will not request it if that is something you have little to share. Green fields I have seen coming here, quite green indeed. They did comfort me much in my travel but, being a stranger, I did not concern myself with them much in the seeing. But yes, as you say, thirst I have—‘

   ‘Oh, this is no fool,’ thought Collum as the people around them began to laugh at the big man’s halting speech. ‘Innocence of the talk of Men can show much wisdom in the offing. But I am in need of more subterfuge now than bold innocence and must end this distracting talk quickly.’

   ‘Well, though I can’t solve the problems of your travels, friend,’ Collum broke in, ‘I can solve your problems of thirst. Allow me!’

   And at this he grabbed an appropriately large tankard and turned toward a barrel of fairly good (which is to say, the best that his house had to offer) red wine for the stranger. And the barrel was conveniently located near his own hidden longsword.

 

   ‘Mostly we are called Hobbits, sir, though the people of the Bree-land here mostly just distinguish between the Big Folk and the Little Folk,’ Ben told the Elf. ‘They’ve all got quite a good relationship here in that way. ‘Halfling’ is something I’ve heard a time or two and, if I might say, I would be fine for me to not hear it again. But ‘Theree-ay-en- neth’ as you say it is something I’ve only heard at the Homely House. That’s what put it in my mind that you might come from there.’ At this Ben’s prepared speech had mostly run its course and, while he was encouraged that the Elf had asked that he join him, Ben could see his talk wasn’t holding the young lord’s attention. ‘You see, my Rosie, she’s from there. The Homely House, that is...’

   As Ben spoke the Elf’s focus was on his large friend at the serving counter and, following his gaze, Ben saw that the tall old gentleman, the one who had talked of the Witch-king earlier, had also taken an interest in the two odd travelers. He was approaching Collum and the large man in conversation, but his eyes were set here.

   ‘It seems,’ the young Elf said as he rose from the table and picked up his companion’s heavy longstaff beside him, ‘that if we are to talk further we will need to join my friend Beothalion. He is quite naive in regard to public places and apt to become confused by the manners of townsfolk. Tell me, do you know the name of the grey-father there who joins my friend? For I would speak with him.’

   The young Elf-lord did not wait for any answer and began to walk forward to the serving counter. Ben wasn’t certain what he should do; was he being asked to join them and to make introductions? He did not know the old man of course, though he did recognize the effect his speech seemed to have on Collum and a few other Breelanders. Certainly the man and his friends were no more ‘townsfolk’ than Ben, Collum or this Elf were. That was clear from a glance. A wassird he most likely was, though Ben knew little of these mysterious individuals beyond their name. But now the young hobbit felt himself being pulled along in the wake of this eventual meeting with no clear idea of what he was doing there; he just wanted some comfort or advice for his dear Rosie.

   But this indeed was the trouble of chance-meetings, particularly where elves and wizards were involved. For matters which interest them are usually old and deep so that one’s own concerns often become enmeshed or overwhelmed in a much longer story.

 

   Flomi tried to catch Collum’s eye for a brief instant as he exited through the back of the commonroom, but the man was engaged in serving the large woodsman and his back was to the Dwarf. Collum also did not see the wassird approaching from another corner of the bar. Certainly his friend knew who these old fathers were and what their arrival at the Four Greenfields must mean to their own endeavor.

   ‘So all has been made ready for our hasty departure. Good!’ He thought. ‘ I have grown long tired of this dwelling place of dimwits and dirt-grubbers and will be glad to prove my findings. Three decades of exile here serves five generations of debt when I’m proven aright.’

   Much of what he would need to take with him was already hidden in their secret hoard and little other than a fresh change of clothing was left in his room here at the inn. They had prepared for this moment, he and his friend. So Flomi decided to go straight to the stables and check upon his ponies, and also Collum’s great grey mare, to have them fitted for a quiet exit within the next hour. He crossed out of the rear doors and down the darkened lane to the stables doing a mental inventory of the small items that would be left in his room for others to discover. Nothing too familiar here, but he must stop by the stoneyard for a few last important items and to remove other traces. ‘Collum will have much to say on this topic,’ he thought, ‘but I will not leave without stopping there.’

   What the dwarf did not see nor consider in his abrupt exit was the dark, skulking figure who followed him out the backdoor of the inn and waited in the shadows, watching him and his urgent walk to the stables.

 

*****

   ‘It smells very fine, friend! Very rich. Like earth in the shadow of big hills and like fruit that is sweeter when hard to find. I will enjoy it with much thanks!’ Beothalion said, taking the offered tankard of wine and enjoying the laughter of the Breelanders gathered about him. ‘But, tell me,’ he said more quietly, pointing back to the table that Buttercup had just served, ‘how may I have some of what he was drinking?’ I will happily pay for my friend Tawarengil and myself.’

   ‘There is no coin you might produce, good fellow,’ a deep voice said behind Collum and to his left, ‘for the worth of that custom cannot be measured in such a way and greetings, like the one that was, are only freely given.’

   Collum saw that the tallest of the three wizards, the one who spoke so openly about allegiance to the King, had left the others behind with Buttercup to follow the invitation. ‘Good,’ he thought, ‘but why is he engaging this stranger? Is it because of the young Elf-lord? Is he to play a part in this somehow? And if so, how do I get all these silly Breelanders out of here so that we might talk?’

   ‘That was well spoken, Master Wanderer,’ the young Elf-lord said as he approached from the other side, a shy-looking Ben Floxleaf silently dogging his steps.

   ‘There,’ Collum thought, ‘all the fat into the fire of it now. Watch as the sparks fly.’ And at this he risked a quick glance towards Flomi’s table to discover him gone. ‘Out the rear door, wisely,’ he thought. ‘It seems our time has come.’

   Now for those Breelanders still scattered about the room, those townsfolk who had found the odd assemblage of foreigners quite satisfactory for an evening's entertainment, this now was really too much. Giant wildmen, outspoken and old wizened pilgrims and even Elves would be enough for them to discuss for many days throughout the springtime. But having such folk actually gather here, why the very idea of their own happy commonroom becoming a meeting place for such potential troublemakers, quite exceeded ‘interesting’ and began to border upon ‘disturbing’. They moved cautiously away from the gathering knot of strangers.

   ‘Mae l’ovannen,’17 the Elf continued in his own lovely, flowing (but, for the Breelanders, entirely incomprehensible and disconcerting) language. ‘Elen síla lúmenn’ omentielvo!’18

   ‘Le nathlam hí,’19 the old man responded. ‘Peditham hi sui vellya?’20

   ‘Yes!’ Beothalion said excitedly. ‘We should talk the Common Tongue here, my friends, and I should dearly love to learn it the more!’

   ‘You’ve a fine ear for it already, my friend,’ the old man said, ‘and I wonder of the tale in how you came to learn it last.’

   ‘O, I will tell you it gladly, friend. For I am excited to speak of-‘

   ‘I believe that might wait, Beothalion,’ said the Tawarengil in Westron, raising a slow but warning hand, ‘for it is somewhat long in the telling and I believe that introductions should come before tales, is that not so, Oldfather?’

   Now the nearest Breelanders became quite dumbfounded at all this foreign talk and lordliness so that they quietly left their place “at the Column” for more comfortable corners of the room. Better to be amongst their own folk and away from whatever strangeness the Road had brought here to their hearth. Collum did his best to seem equally annoyed (for he knew that gossip might follow much faster than any fugitive might run on horseback), but he was finally quite happy that the arrival of these strangers might give him sufficient cover to end his vigilance here at the Four Greenfields.

   ‘Ben,’ he said innocently (and worrying for poor Ben at having to suffer it in his own much more genuine innocence), ‘do you know these folk?’

   Ben thought for a moment, hard and cautious. Mostly, he thought just how he wished he’d never entered either this town nor this conversation with all these lordly gentlemen. He wondered more than a bit at Collum’s ruse, for clearly the man knew more about folk like this than he was willing to let on, more than Ben himself; but Collum had always been a mystery that Ben was comfortable to leave unsolved. Apparently Benbow Floxleaf, wanderer, outlier but a familiar face as he was, could now be used as foil so that Collum might keep his own mystery and his distance. Ben liked Collum well enough of course, but no one enjoys feeling used. And then he thought about his Rosie and how she suffered and how that had brought him here.

   ‘I do not, Collum,’ he said, ‘though I am happy to say that I’ve met the Elder Folk before,’ half-bowing toward the young-looking Elf, ‘and know them to be honorable beyond a question. And,’ gauging his voice a bit louder for the benefit of the Breelanders, ‘givers of gifts with quite spectacular, though sometimes worrisome, value. I’ve had little trade with them, if that’s to your question, but nothing but trust at every meeting.

   ‘As to these other gentlemen,’ and at this he somehow found it proper to bow just a bit lower towards the other old gentlemen still sitting quietly in the rear of the commonroom, ‘I’ve nothing much to say. They seem kind and well-spoken in dark times and, to my mind, that makes them a people worth knowing.’

   And then he looked long into the eyes of the old grey-cloaked man before him, the one who had spoken up earlier when old Tom Truetunnels seemed to argue for timidity.

   ‘Still any fellow, stranger or no, who will speak openly for peace and freedom, and even courage in defending our own borders is deserving of my friendship. So, hello, sir!’ He said addressing the old man and bowing even lower. ‘I am called Benbow Floxleaf, son of Robow, hunter and tender in the realm of Arnor that is North of the Bree-land and an honest tenant of Arvedui, the King of the North Realm.’

   Many townsfolk did not know Ben very much nor very deeply of course, but none had ever heard him talk in this, well, lordly kind of way. Another odd and complete silence followed. It seemed a night for these moments to happen. As the Breelanders backed away even further Collum started to believe that things might actually work out in his favor. Distractions had been created and liaisons had been formed. What that might mean for his own enterprise was still uncertain, but help had apparently come unlooked-for. And that was a reward of faith.

   And then he thought of Flomi’s empty chair and, seeing that there was a missing companion at Fern Sarnside’s table, he began to worry.

   ‘Master Gilleyfoil!’ the old man said (so that others might hear), ‘may I ask for six tankards of that fine red wine to share with these fellow travelers here who are so graciously spoken in such times? Is there some sideroom to be had for our kindly conference? For while this lord,’ and at this he gestured to the woodsman and the Elf, ‘and his companion are very new to this land, I am quite certain wisdom comes with them. This hobbit, with his experience and his shrewdness, also has much to tell and,’ he said, looking sharply around at the townsfolk huddled about the room, ‘after my last attempt at discussion here, I and my friends would dearly like to learn better talk from sharper folk.’

   Then, while he held their attention with such a brisque comment, he produced a small but very shiny coin and placed it upon the table near Collum’s hand. ‘Who knows?’ He said, ‘perhaps you yourself might even join us?

   'Now come, friends,’ the old man said as Ben, Beothalion and the Elf-child joined them and Collum hastily picked up the offered coin, ‘let us share tales of our journeys and delight in this meeting unlooked-for. Chance, if you would call it that, should not go unanswered.’

 

End of Chapter One


Chapter End Notes

Notes on Chapter One

   Here at the end of each chapter I will collect some notes which may prove interesting to some of you or, at the very least, helpful to readers who may be newer to Tolkien. Some of these will be more personal, covering as they do my reasons for selecting certain names or locations, and others will be translations of the languages and key locations.

   There are many excellent sources for the material of Tolkien’s world to be found online and I’m sorry to say that I have not kept careful enough track of these in my research; it would be impossible for me to go back and credit them accordingly now, but I will try to mention those that I can and a few of the best will be listed in my appendices. The majority of the information does come directly from the work of Tolkien and his son Christopher and my readings of all the official tales and notes for Middle-earth.

   In addition there is an expanded appendix for this project which will appear in another document. It is mostly derived from the original sources at the end of LoTR and found in The Silmarillion though it accompanies my own histories for the new characters created in this story.

1)  This, of course, is the old name for the land of Bree as found in LoTR. According to Tolkien, Bree means “hill” and has references to Celtic word bre for “hill”. No distinction is made between the town gathered there at the crossing of the roads and all the surrounding lands, so I have used this to create the idea of an undeclared territory of hill lands divided into four sections. The one here called “Bree-land” will eventually, by the time of the War of the Ring, simply be known as “Bree”.

2)  This refers to the founding of the Shire in the western lands of old Arnor in 1601 of the Third Age. The Shire calendar is not used in the Bree-land at this time.

3)  This is a much later addition to the manuscript. In the writing of Chapter Twenty, as more importance was becoming placed on the people of the Bree-land, I felt the need to give them a clocktower. Hobbits have pocket-watches by Bilbo’s time of course, so this is not as anachronistic as it might first seem. Clearly the technology would’ve been created outside of the Shire (possibly dwarvish?), but for hobbits to have it in the Shire it probably came to them from Bree. I doubt that there is a clock in Bree when Frodo first comes to the town; something may have happened to it and, indeed, something may happen to it while I am writing this story. But adding it here in the opening chapter sets up many possibilities that I will utilize later.

4)  Some of the text here is rather freely cribbed from the Professor’s earliest descriptions of Bree found in The History of Middle-earth (which will later be referred to as HoME). This is the first instance in which I’m using rather more obscure passages from the earlier drafts as “Easter Eggs” for deep Tolkien fans but, I must confess, as this started out as role-playing game of sorts, this was intended as a device for keeping a sense of the Professor's language in my own writing and amusing the reader/player.

5)  An older name given to the Númenóreans by other Men of Middle-earth.

6)  This name, which works so well for describing the lands around the Crossroads, actually comes from the first bar I ever visited as an adult. It was in the suburbs of Detroit, near my old high school, and had the atmosphere of a cozy Irish pub. Utterly forgettable beyond that.

7)  This name was originally for the cornerstone of the North-South Road where it crosses the older West-East. It is not a true Elvish name, but a bastardization of some Sindarin words. I’ve chosen to remove it from the crossroads, which I make to be some half mile or so from the Clocktower, but here it serves better as a founding stone of the town.

8)  There was a curious choice made here in having Olórin (who we will discover this wizard to be) refer to hobbits as “Halflings.” This is, to my mind, among his earliest encounters with them as a people and story in which he first takes notice of some of their fine attributes. The beginning of his interest in “Hobbit-lore,” if you will.

9)  The tale of Eärendur has always interested me and will wind its way into this story. His death was in 861 of the Third Age, so 1100 years before the events you will read of here.

10)  I know of no other place mentioned for the origins of the Westron language so it seems appropriate to suggest it might be here. Certainly the Bree-folk have a tendency to take credit for many things in LoTR and, according to Tolkien, in some of those things they are quite deserving of such credit.

11)  My own little play on the creation-theory of a bar within the history of Middle-earth, something I would also credit to the diverse community of Bree.

12)  This bit is cribbed from James Joyce’s ULYSSES, my other great obsession. The description of “the Citizen” in Episode XII seemed just perfect for setting the mood of this character and I wanted some little Joycean Easter Eggs where I can manage them.

13)  ‘Lacho calad! Drego morn!’ “Flame light! Flee night!” the Battle cry of the Edain of the North. From the Gondorian Sindarin.

14)  ‘Mellon, eithel govannen!’ "Friend, well met!"; Sindarin 

15)  ‘Nidhin mened, periain’ “It is my wish to go, Halfling"; Sindarin

16)  Imladris is, of course, another name for Rivendell.

17)  ‘Mae l’ovannen’ “You are well met!” (Reverential) Sindarin

18)  ‘Elen síla lúmenn’ omentielvo!’ “A star shines on the hour of our meeting” This is a Quenya greeting, very old, and there is some proving of himself to be seen here in Tawarengil using it after a more colloquial Sindarin expression. He would expect the wizard to know it of course, but it shows himself to be more mature than his appearance.

19)  ‘Le nathlam hí,’ “You are welcome here.” Olorin reples in Sindarin

20)  ‘Peditham hi sui vellya?’ “May we speak as friends now?” also in Sindarin


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment