The Fall of Arnor; Book One "Out of the Bree-land" by Diane Finnis-Robb  

| | |

Chapter Five; "Gathering Concerns"

-Wherein a Newly Formed Fellowship Walks Westward in the Sunshine, Talking More Freely, and a Darker Meeting from Some Weeks Before is Likewise Recounted


   Drowsily leaning upon his mound of morning acquisitions, Milo Fastknots waited for his master as the sun began a slow descent into the west behind him. ‘He had better come soon,’ Milo thought, ‘or this mad-eyed pony might have me for an afternoon meal.’ Twenty paces away, still keeping her cautious distance, Benbow’s fat white pony stood glaring at the young hobbit from out of the shade of an ash tree.

   ‘Yes, and I see you as well,’ Milo said to the pony in an aggrieved but, hopefully, compassionate voice. It wouldn’t do at all, he thought, to have this stubborn animal leave him now, here in the open when they had come so far together from the Hedge-gate and accomplished so much of his master’s wishes.

   They had all stood together now in this glade waiting for two hours or better and he could see that the pony was growing restless. Milo had chosen this spot in which to meet the others not so much out of his master’s command but because he knew it was familiar to Benbow and the pony. His master had been vague as to a specific location, but Milo knew that Floxleaf would know exactly where to find them.

   ‘We’ve been here before, you and me,’ he told the pony. ‘Remember? Two and three times last summer when your master had his camp here. It was me came and saw him then. Why, I even brought you an apple that one time.’ And he had. If not last summer then in the fall. But at some time. Milo did not, as a rule, seek friendship with many folk, but he respected Benbow Floxleaf, a favorite of his master’s, and knew how much Floxleaf loved that pony. And anyone could see how that pony loved no one but Benbow Floxleaf.

   Caitelyn, content to now be in the open lands after her trauma with the fire, grazed comfortably as an ambassador in the middle of the glade with her new friend somewhere between the Milo and the angry pony. She would not take sides in this open dispute, but seemed to be keeping a watchful eye on just what might happen next. Still Milo was certain that the mare’s trust in him was the only thing keeping the pony from leaving. ‘See her? Sure you do. She knows to wait for her master,’ he said. ‘And, like as not, that’s just what we’re all going to have to do.’

   Hours before he and the horse and the pony had stopped at the first well-provisioned farm west of the town; Motho Greenhands’ prosperous mushroom plantation not more than a mile west of the Hedge. It was at that time but an hour or two past the dawn, no later than nine of the clock back in the Bree-land, and a few of the farmhands were about as Milo and his two charges came up the lane from the Road. Some others, he soon learned, had seen the smoke rising in the town in the evening and had set off to help. One of those that remained, Binto Fairbairns, knew Milo well and greeted him coming towards the small house shared by the workers. As Binto stood in the lane Milo could see behind him the two long buildings of Motho’s mushroom farm, the two-story barn and its little corral and, of course, the stone turret that had been built just beside the barn; a tower that no hobbit could see any purpose for having.

   ‘Hullo, Fastknots,’ Binto said, as the two hobbits came closer together, ‘what brings you here this morning with such sizable company beside and a fiery commotion behind you? That is your master’s horse, I see, but do you have another pony of your own these days to look after as well?’ he said, looking past Milo and the great grey mare to see the white pony coming cautiously up the lane behind, still at her distance.

   Fairbairns was a young hobbit, of about Milo’s age, with sand-colored hair and brighter, wiser eyes than most of the townsfolk. Binto’s own family, the Fairbairns of the Sarn Fields, had worked the lands south of here long years before Greenhands had come into his wealth and it was something of disappointment that their son now had to work the newcomers' fields for his own livelihood. Binto, wise enough in his situation, had no great love for his employer but a careful tongue in the matter and that quality had earned him a position of authority on the farm whenever Greenhands himself was away. Milo liked Binto Fairbairns quite well, and respected him, but he would have to be careful with him. Binto was sharp, no one’s fool, and he made his own decisions, though those decisions were always in fairness to his master’s wishes, whether he liked the miserly mushroom merchant or not.

   ‘That pony there belongs to Ben Floxleaf,’ Milo replied. 'Do you know him?' 

   'Sure I do,' binto replied. 'But only enough to wish him a good day. He doesn't have much call to hunt around these parts.' 

   ‘My master and Whodekin Ben1 have a great need to see both their mounts saddled and ready. Something I was hoping old Bottom-to-Hand might help with.’

   ‘Hmmmm, were you now?’ Binto said, cautiously. ‘Well, you’ll get no help from him in any hurry today. He’s been to the town these past four days and I suspect that big cloud of smoke we saw this morning behind you means he’ll be there a few more. What’s all the rumpus?’2

   ‘Fear and fire and, it seems, foes where we least expected,’ Milo replied. ‘Some person set fire to the stables last night and, worse even, murdered old Guldir, the stable-master, who never hurt no one.’

   ‘Murdered!’ Binto cried. ‘Stars in the sky, who would do such a thing as that here in the Bree-land?’

   ‘None in the Bree-land that I should know of, but that’s why my master and Ben are off to catch the culprits. Murdered he was, his throat cut wide and the great stables burned about him. We’d not have found the poor man if the killer hadn’t done it just outside the building. Then the whole of the place was set to oil and torch, livestock and whomsoever else still inside. The folk of the town, and maybe even old Bottom-to-Hand was amongst them, though I cannot say that I saw him myself, but the whole folk of the town worked through the night or the Four Greenfields and many other buildings would’ve caught in the blaze. Now this villain, or villains, have gone west, we hear, running before the Sun, and my master has sent me out while the timbers of the stables were still a-smoulder to ready his provisions. He will give chase and those villains will pay when he meets them.’

   Binto, for all of his sharp mind and honest work, did not really make it into town that often so Guldir, the stable- master was unknown to him, but such a tale of fire and murder had a rather blood-curdling effect for any hobbit and a phrase such as as ‘running before the Sun’ put the fear of Goblins in the mind of any Northerner . Milo considered Binto to be a very likeable ‘country hobbit’, and while he told no lies, he knew that scare tactics, particularly in a time of need, were quite motivational with such folk. He could see the terror and interest in the young hobbit’s eyes, and, taking a cue from his master, closed in on how to use it.

   ‘Now Collum and the hunter Ben Floxleaf would give pursuit, but their own saddles and gear were lost in the blaze,’ Milo continued, seeing just how far he might go with his plea. ‘They’ll ride west to find these killers and burners, and I’m here to set their kip and speed them on their way.’

   He paused here and, later, over the years in which other folk more social than Milo would come to tell the story, they would often wonder if he knew to pause on this moment of his own or if it had been as an instinct he had picked up from watching his master. But pause he did, and he looked long into Binto Fairbairn’s eyes to make his point.

   ‘I’d have a horse’s saddle, another saddle for a pony, what provisions you can spare for long travels and even your master’s great horse himself that he might speed my own master in keeping the town’s justice, Binto. You’d have the full promise that each and every aid you will give me my master will pay in full and at fair price. But I’ve no time to wait for sluggardly mushroom-lords like old Bottom-to-Hand nor a leisurely ride back into town to ask his permission. I’ve worked all night in a blazing barn and walked all morning guiding frightened beasts, so I’ve no vigor nor time to discuss matters much further. Will you aid my master and, if you’ve not understood already, all of the Bree-land in our hope of justice?’

   It is doubted by most everyone who ever knew him that Milo Fastknots had ever spoken this much to any one person in all his previous life. But he would certainly come to speak many other long and quite rousing speeches in his future.

 

*****

   When the company came up to the small grove of trees where Collum waited they saw him sharpening a longsword; a very bad omen to Ben’s mind. He had never seen the innkeeper carry such a blade before, but there was a sureness to the man’s behavior that showed he was most certainly no stranger to the weapon. Long, steady strokes of the wetstone against the steel made a quiet soft sound in the glade and, though barely noticed, it gave a fresh rhythm to the company’s approaching pace.

   ‘Any news from the Hedge-gate?’ Ben asked the man as they drew closer.

   ‘None. I slipped past unrecognized quite easily enough. I fear that my former neighbors haven’t yet given much thought about watching their door. Currently, or so I should think, it is still all of you and poor Flomi whom they blame.

   'When they find that we’ve all slipped their vigilance the blame will assuredly be set. Perhaps then they will become more watchful.’

   ‘Though I have never encountered such a large group of these little folk before,’ Alatar commented, ‘‘watchful" is not how I should describe them.’ He nodded courteously toward Benbow at this. ‘With no offense meant to master Floxleaf, of course, who has proved a most cautious guide. He has taken us well west of the suspicious eyes of your townsfolk and now we wonder, each of us I should think, where you, Ohtar, would lead us next.’

   ‘This is just so, Dúnadan,’ Tawarengil said rather more curtly. ‘My curiosity over the events of the evening runs strong, and I would gladly lend aid where I may in answer to your hospitality, but my own way lies west to answer Círdan’s call. What is your destination and moreover, now that we are free of your bothersome neighbors, what will you tell us of yourself?’

   The tall man sheathed his blade at these questions and at the open, wondering looks of Ben and the others. He then buckled the sword a bit higher upon his hip and reached down for his pack on the ground before him. Shouldering it he said, ‘my lord Tawarengil, oldfathers and young masters, my way does indeed go west for a time just as your own may. If you will walk with me here in the open lands then I will tell you more as we travel. I am glad of such company and happy for your assistance this past day, however, I must remind you, only Benbow here is under any plea bond to my cause. You all may part as you wish. Some of you, I am certain, will understand if that makes me slow to reveal all of my purposes.’

   Ben saw him look here for a moment at Olórin, but the grey wizard said nothing. So Collum turned his back on the group and began walking in long deliberate strides out of the glade. But not too quickly that they could not follow.

   ‘Milo is some hours ahead of us and probably has provisions for Ben and I only, following the instruction I gave him,’ Collum said as the others came beside him.

   ‘He’s a sharp young fellow, your Milo,’ Ben said, ‘and I think I shall be able to catch him up. He knows many of my own campsites within a day’s ride, but won’t go too far off the road with my Rosie growing suspicious.’

   ‘Good, Ben,’ Collum replied. ‘Lead us then, if you will.’ He then turned a bit to the others who followed and began speaking to them more directly.

   ‘The day is bright,’ Collum said to his new companions, ‘and these lands west of Bree are still free. This may change soon as the Witch-king moves his war over all the North, but for now we are safe to speak more openly as we keep stride.

   ‘I was born to be given the name Ohtar, true, but as you wise fathers may well know, that name was one that meant only ‘soldier’ or ‘warrior’ in Old Adûnaic. Yet now that is the name of my house and I am the twenty-seventh in my line to carry it since my ancestor served King Isildur.’3

   ‘Yes,’ Alatar said, ‘we suspected as much from your earlier telling. It was your grandsire then who brought Narsil home to the North when Isildur fell.’

   ‘It was, Oldfather,’ Collum replied, ‘and my family has served beside the rightful heir of Arnor since that day. We are honored in this, called “setya ohtar”, but our service to Isildur’s line has been in secret for some generations.’

   ‘Since the reign of Eärendur,’ Alatar suggested, ‘or so we should gather from your telling.’

   ‘That is so,’ the man replied, ‘and your knowledge of our history is keen to have surmised it.’

   ‘But mine is not,’ the young Elf-lord interrupted abruptly. ‘The tales of Men and of the Kings of Men do not travel to the Greatwood, Ohtar, and of “King Sea-servant”4 or whomever I and my companion know nothing. Yet it may be that the Wise,’ he said, turning toward Alatar and the other Istari, ‘have guessed at some larger truth here through this lineage. Still, Beothalion and I at least remain blind to it and to this man’s purposes.’

   ‘Patience, my young lord,’ Olórin replied. ‘This story may be revealed in time, but we must let it come as it will. Patient is the step of wisdom.’

   Tawarengil looked harshly at the old wizard then, and color, not of anger but of some other passion, came into the pale skin of his childlike face. Ben thought for a moment of the Elves of Rivendell whom he had met; how high and calm they had seemed, how separate their faces were from their inner thoughts. But those elves were tall and lordly, ancient to hear tell of it. He had never seen nor spoken with a young Elf-lord until last night and had never really considered the Elves as they may be in their youth. If Tawarengil felt some rebuke in Olórin’s comment, he said nothing of it and turned his face away to the path ahead.

   ‘It was after the reign of Eärendur, eleven centuries ago,’ Collum continued in a friendly way, addressing the question, ‘that the realm of Arnor was split, my lord Tawarengil, divided between his three sons. This is not in accordance with our traditions, but there was great turmoil in the North and a fragile peace was brokered by the arrangement.’ He paused here for some time as they continued walking, his eyes ahead to the way west as they came out of a copse and into the rolling and unsettled lands just beyond sight of the Road. Ben still had the lead, winding them easily through the uneven ground, for he knew the land better than Collum who, familiar in a wood as he was from many journeys, saw it still through the eyes of history.

 

   For three or four leagues ahead the land appeared less hilly than it was behind them toward Bree-hill. It was dotted with other small clusters of trees that seemed to stretch toward one another and reclaim the fertile and less rocky ground from here to the south and then again as it broadened off toward the north and that wide expanse of open, harder lands. Some of these trees, as Ben and Collum certainly both knew, were of very great age indeed, part of the once mighty forest that was said to cover the landscape before the Kings out of the Sea came to take these territories as their own. In many places these few great relics of an ancient and mighty forest had been left standing through the long ages of Man’s incursion and they had (very recently indeed, by the tree’s own accounting of years) sired new growth in the now unpopulated lands; majestic and massive beech and oak, willow and hawksborne and hazel, birch and rowan and maple and fir -great trees that had once served as great landmarks of Arnor’s old estates and farmlands now long abandoned- were reaching out to one another with generations of their children, some many hundreds of years old now themselves, trying to restore the peace that the land once knew. Arnor’s hold over the land, the sculpting and design of her great cities, plazas and cultivated fields, its roads and mills and watchtowers still visible in Ohtar’s mind from the histories of his people was vanishing and the great trees were coming back as if Man’s dominance had never been. And the trees, out of their contempt or their mercy, seemed to barely notice Arnor’s passing.

The sun was high now, beginning to dip slowly towards the far-off mountains west at the edge of the world, and for all that distance ahead the lands became a vast and rich band of green. For it was springtime in the North, and peace had reigned in the western edge of Eriador that lay before them for most of that age. Collum stopped for a moment on some higher patch of ground to look as far west as his eyes might reveal, hoping to glimpse the ribbon of Baranduin, the brown river, as it ran through the lands to the west. But he could not see it from here, and the way ahead seemed to him the more uncertain.

 

   ‘I understand this desire for peace,’ he said at some length, as if there was some great report, or even some show of great fatigue and a quiet acceptance in the statement. The others paused in that moment sensing his unease. But as soon as their eyes fell on him he smiled slightly and continued with his walking and the telling of his tale.

   ‘Peace at the expense of custom did purchase time for the North. But now, with the fall of Fornost to the Witch-king this past winter, it seems as if this dearly-purchased time has ended and all of the lands of old Arnor will be overrun.

   ‘Yet our past and, I must still believe, our hope for the future, remains.

   ‘Eärendur was a mighty prince in his youth who came late into his kingship. Even in the time of his father our people in these lands had diminished greatly through the War and our trade with our neighbors and even our own kin to the South had grown sparse. We kept no ships and sent few caravans or messengers beyond our own borders. In isolation distrust of neighbors often will grow, and so it was in Eärendur’s time.

   ‘But great precautions had been set in Arnor to preserve our past. Many important histories and artifacts of our people were brought out of Númenor by Elendil and Isildur to be housed in Annúminas. But how safe were they as our people became so much the fewer? Holding the splendor and history of Isildur’s folk in the North became the chief concern for many of my people by Eärendur’s time.’

   Olórin, with low and somber voice, interrupted. ‘Some might say, Ohtar, that this was a subject of contention between the realms of Gondor and Arnor and that the people of both lands had become covetous of the heirlooms of Númenor.’

   ‘This may be as you say, Wisefather,’ the man replied, ‘but I and my ancestors before me have been soldiers and as such take great care before questioning the motives of kings.’ He grew quiet again at this, not stopping in his motion forward as they followed Ben’s lead, but looking for a time over his left shoulder to the lands of the south.

   ‘So it is said that true men follow their own heart’s calling and hope that true kings will know their own heart’s wisdom. And so it was wished in the time of Eärendur and in the time of my grandsire Ohtar, the ninth of our name.

   ‘Great protectors of the realm and of its artifacts had laboured long years to ensure that the legacy of Elendil might survive the harrowing of the Northlands, the division of lands and the dwindling of its people. Before the kingdom was ever split many great items of Númenor were removed from Annúminas to be hidden and protected.’

   ‘One might say this was folly, Ohtar,’ Alatar offered, ‘that artifacts and history should never be separated and hidden from their people. For pride and learning are the true value to be found in these things. Therefore, what good is it to protect empty parcels if they can no longer advantage the people they were meant for?’

   ‘I have no answer for this, Oldfather,’ Collum said. ‘It is a wisdom and a question beyond my service and my duty as a soldier.’

   ‘Men, or so it seems to me, cling like misers to their history,’ Tawarengil replied casually. ‘Your love of your own stories will never alter the fragility and weakness found in your bodies.’

   ‘The Gifts of Ilúvatar cannot be understood by all, Tawarengil,’ said Pallando, the third and most withdrawn of the three wizards, ‘it would be unwise to question the traits which may seem to come along with such a Gift.’

   Beothalion, uncharacteristically quiet all this time, spoke up. ‘I do not know of this gift, Tawar, but I am most certainly jealous of our friend, the innkeeper. To have such a knowledge of his history! How deep his stories go!’

   Pallando smiled at this, saying, ‘the Men of Númenor are indeed fortunate to have a history that is richly written, young one. But the Men of Middle-earth have a history no less illustrious for it being secretly spoken only by the few who guard it. May you come to hear some of it in your time!’

   Ben had been trying (with some difficulty) to sort all of this storytelling in his head. ‘Forgive me if I’m a bit slow here, Collum,’ he said, ‘but I don’t quite see what all of this old history has to do with poor Gildur or your missing dwarf stonemason.’

   ‘Then you have certainly been paying better attention to the trail than to the tale, master Floxleaf,’ said the grey wizard with what seemed to Ben like a blend of humor and impatience. ‘For surely this stonemason, as unlikely as it might seem, holds a key to all of this history.’

 

*****

   ‘Finally!’ thought Rosie as she caught the faint sound of Ben’s voice away to the east. ‘What a time he’s been!’ He was downwind and she could not yet catch his familiar scent, but her ears where still sharp through the fever and she knew he was not further than six or seven hundred rangar5 behind her, talking calmly as if there had been no fire and no smoke and no flight to trouble him in this long and terrifying time since they came to the town. She loved this about Ben, though it caused her much frustration; his voice was always calm and reassuring no matter what the distress and dangers of their life and travels together had brought to them.

   She could hear two or more speakers with him, but could not yet hear their steps. She wanted to bolt off and meet him, to leave her new friends and this other scowling hobbit behind, but she was still too frightened by the fire last night and by the dark-figured Man who had set it.

   So she backed further away from the sunlight of the glade and into the shadow of the trees. Her new friends were startled at this and raised their heads to listen, wise as they were. Even the scowling hobbit had the good sense to stop his talking and stood up noiselessly, taking a large stick and a rock to his hand to defend himself and his new possessions against any intruders.

 

******

   ‘The most troublesome thing are the runes,’6 Flomi thought to himself on that stormy afternoon five weeks before, ‘for the hand of them is like none I’ve ever seen, though they carry an indication of familiarity with the original.’

   Now it should be said here that runes were not, by any means, a common thing in the West of Middle-earth in that Third Age of the world. The ways of the East were, as they should be, quite unknown to Flomi; he could not speak to what Men knew in those distant lands and he did not wish to learn more of them or of their ways; for the Dwarves had shunned the East since the breaking of the world and they have never once looked back.7

   So it was that in all the known lands between the Blue Mountains and the Iron Hills, even south to the Bay of Belfalas (as far south as any dwarf had been said to travel), that Flomi and his grandsires were thought to be the among the last of the rune-masters. And, like many of the skills of his People, they shared this art with no one. For Dwarves make many secret languages, understand many mysteries and have many secret names for things, but they are cautious by nature and leave no written traces of all that they know.

   How the Seer, Malbeth,8 whose work Flomi was currently translating, had come into his awareness of runes was still quite unknown. It was quite unnatural for a Man to write of them as he had over one hundred years before. ‘I should like to have met that man,’ Flomi had often thought, ‘for I have never seen his like amongst these silly Breelanders.’ The complex picture-language used by the Seer was not true rune-craft of course. But his writings had disclosed a set of picture symbols, dwarfish in their making, and so the great mystery of Flomi’s family, and of their involvement with the Men of Arnor, had been opened again during his father’s lifetime.

   But this new set of runes which troubled Flomi so, like to but differing from the Seer’s own writings, were of course, not entirely derived from the Dwarvish. They were, without doubt, drawn from Malbeth’s work echoing rhyme and meter and therefore rooted in the work of Flomi’s own grandsire,9 but they incorporated some unique variation in style and they indicated, perhaps, that some other influence then Flomi or his father had formerly seen in Malbeth’s writing until this-

   ‘Might I join you by the fire, master Dwarf,’ a soft and well-mannered voice said, startling Flomi from his work. He looked up quickly and saw a man, as tall as Collum was himself, standing in the center of the dimly-lit commonroom. He wore a traveler's cloak, black as night and dirty from the road. His boots were tall, riding boots certainly, nearly as tall as a hobbit, and he held in his hands dark gloves which he appeared to have just removed. At his side there was a longsword, also dark and without ornament, but Flomi thought little of this, as the roads were less safe for travelers than they had been a year ago. He wore no other trappings that might make him out to be a soldier, but he had a soldier’s bearing even here in the empty commonroom, and his request carried as much command as it did formal courtesy.

   He did not smile as he spoke; no smirk of authority that might make Flomi more cautious than he should be, but his face held the semblance of kindness and his manner was open. He was clean-shaven, unusual in the Men that Flomi had met here in the North, and his hair was a dark-brown as Collum’s own was, but lank and tied-back neatly from his face.

   ‘You had better, traveler,’ Flomi said to the man. ‘For it is an unseasonable night and I fear that the hostelers here may have left for the warmth of their beds and we, their guests, must fend for ourselves.’

   Walking the lonely paths now to the Foundations, still well before the dawn of his first morning since leaving the Bree-land, and heading towards the safety that he and Collum had prepared for, Flomi regretted that act of courtesy; he had come to realize that this, and not the burglary twelve years past, was the moment when they had been discovered. But it was only now that he began to realize the full severity of his situation and the danger that his courteous gesture had put them in.

 

*****

   The seven travelers were walking north of the Road through brief clusters of trees that gave them some cover from prying eyes, though they expected nothing as dangerous as that here in the open lands to the west of Bree-hill. Benbow was now leading them up a small incline toward another copse of trees, mostly ash and fir and older rowan.

   As they came to the hill Tawarengil paused to look ahead and the rest of the party, already keyed to his instincts, stopped as well.

   ‘Your servant is there, Innkeeper,’ the young Elf-lord said pointing, ‘and this Floxleaf of ours has found him quickly enough. But there are still many questions I would ask you.’

   ‘Your questions come as no surprise, my lord,’ Collum said, ‘nor do Ben’s skills. But more talk must wait until we have sent my man Milo on his way. He’s a great keeper of secrets that one, but I will not see his life further imperiled with harmful knowledge.’

   ‘He’s a sharp one, Collum,’ Ben said, ‘and while I don’t quite understand this peril you're speaking of, I couldn’t agree more.

   ‘Ho! Youngster,’ Ben called loudly as they came up the short hill. ‘Your master and I bring guests, so put your throwing stones aside and keep your hands open for greetings.’

   When they came into the glade atop the low hill Ben was in the front. Milo was standing beside a small heap of supplies and two great horses were in the shade behind him. A short fat pony came briskly walking, almost trotting, towards Benbow and nuzzled right up beside him.

   ‘Hello, Rosie, girl,’ the hobbit said to the pony as he smiled broadly and left the other travelers aside. ‘You look very fine now after last night’s scare! But you should keep out of this sunshine, girl.’ He pulled a small apple from his pocket and fed it to the delighted pony, looking into her eyes with great concern.

   ‘Well met, Milo,’ Collum said, walking towards his servant and looking at the pile of supplies and then over to the two horses. ‘You have done much better than expected, I see.’

   ‘I hope that’s so, sir,’ the young hobbit said, looking around to see all the other travelers. ‘I’ve tried to anticipate your needs without raising too much a stir. But I’d not thought there’d be so many of you...’

   ‘Nor had I,’ Collum said, ‘but one cannot always foresee what providence holds.’

   ‘As you say, sir,’ the hobbit replied. ‘I’d gone to Greenhands’ farm for the saddles, which seemed the safest and shortest path, sir. Motho himself was away, but I nudged his man Fairbairns into a loan of Greenhands’ great stallion, thinking you might like a second mount for greater speed.

   ‘There’s only the one saddle for a horse, I’m afraid,’ said Milo, looking around to the others, ‘but I’ve also got Greenhands’ own smaller fancy saddle that Benbow’s pony might take to. I’ve carried it myself as she won’t let me near enough to fit. There was even a man-sized walking stick, sir, though I’ve no idea how old Bottom-to-Hand came by such a thing. I’ve got us some water skins, some wine and blankets for cold nights and additional bags with salted meats. Even two small pots for cooking or the boiling of water in a pinch. A fair stock on short notice for a long journey in open lands.

   ‘And it will be a long journey, won’t it be, sir?’ Milo asked his master.

   ‘Yes, lad,’ he responded softly, smiling at the young hobbit and bending to place a hand on his shoulder. ‘And it will be up to you to keep watch over Buttercup and the inn, if not the whole town of the Bree-land, while I’m away. Are you feeling up to the task?’

   Milo looked at his master quite seriously then. He saw the longsword at his belt and felt the change in the man, knowing as Buttercup had, that his master was finally, as he had always expected, going off to some fate or another and not coming back. Then he looked down at the ground, furrowing his brow with a sense of deep determination. The thoughtful pause was long, but those who knew Milo Fastknots were accustomed to such moments of silence.

   ‘Well, if the truth is to be told, sir, I’m a bit tired from such a long night as we’ve had and fretting over Benbow’s pony who looked like to eat me.’

   Then he lifted his gaze, rubbed his eyes a bit, and straightened his back. ‘But this bit of sunshine here has been restful enough, and I’ve had some cool water back at the farmhouse. I’ll manage, sir,’ he said resolutely. ‘What would you have me do?’

   Collum smiled at this and looked over to Ben and then to the three wizards traveling with them. If they heard, or remarked at the man’s exchange with the hobbit, there was little indication; except, perhaps, with Olórin, the grey wizard, who seemed to smile slightly to himself.

   ‘Then back to the Bree-land with you, my friend,’ Collum said with a smile. ‘I have left some instructions and some instruments for you in the care of Buttercup. She will be the new mistress at the Four Greenfields and, I expect, she should have great need of you by nightfall. Heed her well and give her careful counsel when you may. There will be plenty of money there for old Motho as payment for his horse and his provisions and your sound purchases there will dispel many wild rumors.

   ‘It’s my hope that we’ll draw all trouble out of the Bree-land for a short time, but trouble along the Roads returns quickly enough and I trust you to show the other Breelanders how to deal with it. There’s more strength in some there than any of them know, but it will take a quiet and strong voice like your own to awaken it.’

   Milo smiled broadly at this praise and looked around at the others.

   To Ben he said, ‘you take care of that smart pony now, master Benbow. She looks sharp and cross at most anyone but you yet, the way I hear it, it's your prancing pony which saved our town.’

   ‘I will indeed, Milo,’ Ben said, ‘and you take care of yourself as well. You're a brave hobbit to take on your master’s work, but just the one I’d want for the job.’

   Milo looked very happy and more than a little embarrassed by this praise. Then he set his jaw and, without looking at the others, walked out of the glade and back towards the town.

   ‘Anar caluva tielyanna!’ Collum called to the young hobbit as he walked away. ‘The sun shall shine upon your path!’

 

*****

   ‘Oh, I do not concern myself much with bad weather,’ the dark traveler said as he came closer to the fire, ‘but I have far to travel and my mount is happy for the comforts of this town’s stables. I had heard the place was filled with Halflings, so you can imagine my surprise at seeing one of Durin’s Folk sitting here cozily by a fire. Are you a gentleman of the road?’

   ‘Acchh! Would that were so,’ Flomi said with a smile. ‘No, I came here some years past to serve in my father’s place. I am the town’s stonemason, and a quiet and uneventful life that work is in a town filled with hole-delvers; it provides ample enough raw employment, but requires little art or ambition.’

   ‘I see,’ the man replied, looking briefly over to Flomi’s table and the writings and notes scattered about him. He then settled his eyes on the small wine cask Milo had left there for Flomi’s refreshment.

   ‘May I offer you a drink, traveler?’ Flomi said. ‘As I have said, they seem to have closed the commonroom around us and gone off to early beds. But I am left with wine enough for the both of us. Allow me!’

   At this he stood up and went to Collum’s serving station in the middle of the room. It was now well past sunset and Flomi found himself wondering yet again about how many hours had gone by since Milo had left him to concentrate on his work. If anyone had come in since that time he could not remember or had not heard and (most accurately) had not cared. The opportunity to focus on the current pieces of the translation had been, as always, foremost in his mind. He did not wish to be discourteous to this other guest but, in a way, he was growing angry at Buttercup and the others for leaving him to play the part of host. Perhaps he would have a word or two with their master after all about them abandoning their posts and leaving him as greeter.

   But the commonroom was dark now, with no extra candles or unnecessary fires lit, no townsfolk hereabouts with their chattering and gossip, and it no doubt looked very discouraging for others to enter. It was a wonder that the stranger had found his way here on such an unusual night. ‘But a traveler on the road must be met with courtesy,’ Flomi thought to himself at the time. ‘That is an old and important custom, even if all these bothersome Breelanders have forgotten it.’

   As he went behind the service station to fetch a cup from one of the lower shelves there, Flomi happened to look through the darkened doorway that opened into the hall. There he saw Gildur, the stable-master, standing quietly in the shadows with his eyes focused on the traveler. Flomi’s eyes, like any dwarf’s, were untroubled by shadows and it surprised him to see a sword buckled to the old man’s hip and his hand, calmly but carefully, resting upon the hilt.

   Flomi quickly looked again to the man at the hearth. Suddenly he became terrified; he had walked away from his work and left a stranger within its reach! But the man casually stood there warming his hands, his face never leaving the blaze of the fire. If he was aware of the scrutiny of others he regarded it not at all and, more importantly, he gave the pages that Flomi had left out on the table not the slightest bit of his attention.

   ‘But the Breelanders clearly sense danger from the man,’ Flomi thought at the time, ‘and both Guldir and Milo have learned more than a few cautions from their master. I must in turn learn from their instincts.’

   ‘Will you tell me, traveler,’ Flomi said as he returned to the hearth and began to pour out wine for the guest, ‘some tales, perhaps, from the Road?’

   ‘Tales, master?’ the man said frankly. ‘No, I will tell no tales, for they are doubtful things in the best of times and slanted things when there is conflict about. No tales, but some news of the outside world I can bring you if you wish. Are there lands and peoples that you would like to hear of? Or have your years here amongst these Breefolk curbed your interest in the gathering concerns of broader realms?’ He took the wine Flomi offered him, lifting his cup in thanks (and a salute, that Flomi later thought rather perfunctory and military in fashion), but he offered no words of greeting as travelers usually do.

   Flomi sat across from the man and took up his own cup in return. He tried to sound quite casual as he talked, but he also used the time to start gathering up his notes and returning them to the safety of his satchel.

   ‘Well, we have had fewer travelers at the inn than expected this springtime,’ he said, ‘but perhaps it is the trouble up north which makes it so. My own folk have given a wide berth to this part of the Great Road for some years. Have you seen many dwarves upon your travels? Can you tell me of them?’

   The man sat back and away from the fire at this question, turning his chair to face Flomi’s while the dwarf busied himself with gathering up the pages spread about. His face was calm and relaxed, and he took another very small sip of his wine and looked deeply into the dwarf’s eyes before responding. ‘I can indeed, master Stonemason,’ he said calmly. ‘It would be my pleasure to share with you.

   ‘Of the Peoples of the Iron Hills I know very little,’ he said, ‘their lands are high and guarded and they have now, as ever, little traffic with Men. It is said that the dragons are stirring again in that part of the world. But these may be tales only and, as I have said, I offer no tales.

   ‘The dwarves of Khazad-dûm go abroad east of the Misty Mountains and still have great renown with my People for their smith-craft and especially for their ores.’ At this he paused for a moment and looked long into Flomi’s eyes. ‘But the true wealth of Hadhodrond is not measured in gold or gems and it is seldom seen in the wider world,’ he said flatly, letting his voice trail off. But Flomi said nothing.

   ‘Your kin of the Blue Mountains still travel wide with their goods,’ he continued in an easier fashion, ‘but they are as wary as ever. If they come but seldom to this spot of the world it is because they have little concern with its conflicts. Once, long ago, they involved themselves with the wars of Men and have learned to regret it. They make very great weapons still, or so it is said, but they keep them only for themselves and the guardianship of their homes.

   ‘I have heard that they make excursions into the north of Ered Luin now,’ he said. ‘What will they find there? Are Nogrod and Belegost truly gone? Do the ice-drakes roam and sleep atop the ancient riches of the Khazâd, or does something older and deeper wander those lost halls? Oh,’ he said, smiling in that broad and disarming way that Flomi had caught a glimpse of earlier, ‘it is an exciting time to be a dwarf in the wider world, master Stonemason.’

   At the time Flomi was quite shocked by all of this information and, as he thought back upon it now he knew that this was the first step the black rider had taken toward drawing him out and, perhaps, to reading things in Flomi’s own background. How quickly the Man had decided that Flomi and his folk came from the Blue Mountains seemed remarkable now in the dark night as he fled from the potential danger in the Bree-land.

   ‘Your knowledge of the Dwarves is surprising, traveler,’ Flomi had said. His caution of the man was still high though he had stopped putting away his papers to better hear the news. ‘And your knowledge of our history all the moreso. May I ask how you have come by it? Are there dwarves in your party perhaps?’

   ‘No,’ the man said softly, ‘I travel alone more often than not. But I have met many of your folk along my way. And, like yourself, I feel history to be the most important of studies. Now, what else would you hear from my travels?’

   ‘Well,’ said Flomi, ‘any news of the North if you have it. For it may soon concern us here in the Bree-land, although these townsfolk wish to remain ignorant of it.’

   At this the rider, taking on a more somber face, drew another sip of his wine saying, ‘I can speak of fallen Fornost, if you’d like, but it is a harrowing tale that many would forego on dreary nights beside a fire. The son-and-heir of Elendil in the North has fled and he will not come again. Word tells that he is already lost in the frozen wastes. His sons are spread to the lands west of here, but they fight among themselves about how to rally troops which they no longer have and how to sue for aid which none will give them. The North Kingdom of old has fallen, for there is no strength at its center and there has not been in many a century. It is sad, is it not? That the valor of the North was so easily spent in southern wars and family squabbles. Angmar is the true force in the lands north of here, and their might is not the might of Men.

   ‘How will this little hedgetown of pig farmers and rabbit-folk fare against the might of Angmar, you ask?’ the rider said darkly, his smile gone and his eyes lit in the fire’s blaze. ‘Not well, I should think, if anything should be here to draw the Witch-king’s attention. Is there? I wonder,’ but his voice traveled off at this, as if daring Flomi to question him further. Seeing that this did not happen, the rider quickly went on with his report.

   ‘Don’t mistake me. I am happy for the wine you’ve offered, the stable for my horse, and the chance to share a roaring fire on a cold night, but no one should think themselves safe here. In the months to come the open roads might be a better place.’

   ‘Is there no hope to be found in the Elves?’ Flomi asked fearfully. ‘It is said that they are rallied to the North-king’s aid and will ride out against Angmar’s host...’

   ‘Is this a third question, master?’ the rider asked, raising his brow a bit. ‘I have paid for my room here, and for my stable, but I have enjoyed your wine and your fire and I am now your guest. I would gladly give you my thoughts on this third matter,’ he said, pausing just a bit and meeting Flomi’s eyes directly again, ‘but I am a traveler who keeps the Old Customs of the Road.’

   Flomi, thinking at the time that he knew the Old Customs better than most, let his curiosity (which is usually a quite rare, but often deep-running trait among dwarves) get the better of his caution (which is a quality that he now wished he had come by earlier) and said to the rider;

   ‘Please, Rider, for you seem quite learned and I hear only little from the few who pass this way. Tell me more, if you may.’

 

*****

   Once Milo had left the other travelers began to gather around Collum as he began to look over their provisions. Ben, gently brushing his hand through Rosie’s hair, watched from a little distance.

   ‘You are part of quite an interesting People, Master Floxleaf,’ Olórin said, walking towards Ben and still looking off toward the other now-departed hobbit, ‘with an integrity found in some individuals that goes quite unnoticed in the larger groups.’

   ‘Oh, he’s a fine lad, Milo is, sir,’ Ben said, a bit surprised to be singled out for conversation while so much interest was (and clearly should be) directed at Collum. ‘But I shouldn’t judge all of us by the Breelanders, nor by Milo or myself; hobbits are just hobbits to themselves, alone or in groups, wise or simple or anywheres between.’

   ‘Ho, ho!’ Olórin said with a mighty laugh, that Ben had not expected from this serious-looking, wizened old man. The others turned their heads at this surprise as well and, for half of a moment, Ben thought he was perhaps being made sport of. But he looked into the wizard’s eye, saw the genuine delight there like a welcoming ray of morning sun, and knew this was not the case. ‘Wise or simple, indeed! Well, master Floxleaf,’ he said smiling, ‘I am very happy to learn from you that I do not in fact know the full meaning of either of these things after all!’

   Rosie lifted her head at this and gave a long neighing sound as if she too found something Ben had said quite funny. At this, Beothalion, who seemed to be mostly standing around admiring the collection of goods which Milo had brought them, came walking over.

   ‘She is very happy with your new friends, little Benbow,’ the wildman said as he approached them, ‘and, yes,’ he said, addressing the pony, ‘I should be sorry for my lack of greeting. Goheno nin, cinnog mairo. Gi suilon. I eneth nîn Beothalion.’10

   At this Rosie gave off a gentle, contented noise and lowered her head to the big man’s outreached hands.

   ‘You speak the Elfish!’ Benbow said most happily. ‘Thank you, Beothalion, for that kindness! Rosie was raised with the elf-folk, you see, and it brings her great joy to hear it spoke, but I’ve not the skill myself. It is a great comfort to the both of us now, for she has not been feeling well...’

   ‘Yes,’ Beothalion said, looking into the pony’s eyes and holding his finger, very gently, inside of her ear, ‘she has a... hotness?...fever. I thought it might just have been the fire. You did well to give her shade, but she needs... palátā glae ... I don’t know what you call it...’

   ‘“Palmarosa?”’ Olórin said. ‘Yes. Gingergrass, they call it here in the North. Yes. Well, I’m no great herb-master, but it should be quite plentiful here I should think.’

   ‘Gingergrass?’ Ben said, trying to keep up with all this new information (most of which concerned him much more greatly than any stories of Sea-kings, or Witch-kings or the lost wars of Men). ‘Why, it's fair common from here to the Brown River, to be sure. Thank you, masters, for you’ve wisdom regarding my poor Rosie that I’m too blind to see for myself.’

   ‘Oh, she is wise, little Benbow,’ the wildman said, ‘and sorry that you can not hear her. But she knows you mean her very well.’ And as he said this he kept stroking the pony under her jaw and smoothed the hair up between her ears.

   ‘Do you...’ Ben was wide-eyed as he seemed to be seeing the big wild man for the first time all over again, another surprise for him in a day filled with many. ‘Do you speak her language?’

   ‘Speak?’ Beothalion said with an almost comic wonderment to his face. ‘No, I can not speak her language, little Benbow. I have not the... mouth for that.’ At this Rosie let out another long neighing sound, one Benbow had always taken as a laugh, and she shook her head gently. ‘Haha!’ Beothalion said laughing with her. ‘No, she is wise and so she listens well, but speaks her way. And I listen to her better than you might, but,’ he said, keeping one hand on Rosie and placing another on Benbow’s head, ‘she might be wiser than us both! Haha!’

   ‘Is it not said that the birds of every district, nay almost every nest, speak unalike?’11 Olórin said.
   ‘I do not speak to birds, Greystalker,’ Beothalion said with great seriousness, ‘for only the Eagles can be trusted, and I have not met any eagles yet.’

   ‘“Wise and simple and anywheres in between” indeed!’ Olórin said with a laugh as he walked off to join the others.

 

*****

   ‘Círdan Nówë, doomsayer of Nargothrond, does indeed call the Peoples of the North,’ said the rider, ‘and perhaps I shall answer him myself. He was ever a friend to the Númenóreans and so holds some desire beyond hope to save Elendil’s heir-sons yet a third time.’ The rider turned towards the fire at this, but his eyes seemed blacker now than Flomi had noticed them before. The disarming manner that the dwarf had seen earlier now had vanished and, with this third question of their conversation, Flomi then felt a new openness in the black rider that he found to be... disconcerting. As he considered it now along his walk to safety, it quite nearly terrified him.

   ‘He is the Eldest of his folk to remain in Mortal Lands,’ the rider said as he gazed deeply into the hearth’s small blaze. ‘What would it be like to look into those eyes? I wonder.’ And there was deep silence between them now, on a cold day before a fire when the world seemed uncertain.

   ‘But this was not precisely your question, master Stonemason,’ the rider then said, turning his eyes back to Flomi and taking another longer drink of his wine. ‘“Is there no hope to be found in the Elves?” you asked me, and that is a very old question indeed. Very, very old.

   ‘Dwarves have never sought such help of course, so I can only imagine that you ask on behalf of your townsfolk, these men and hobbits, and that is a very neighborly position to take in this moment. Quite companionable. I commend you for it. Is there more wine?’ he said then, rather suddenly smiling.

   ‘Why, yes,’ Flomi said, ‘certainly, traveler. Allow me.’ He took the cup from the rider then and filled it again from the small cask by the table. But this time he did not turn his back on the man. ‘Here you are.’

   ‘I thank you, master,’ the rider said, ‘and I accept this kindness as freely given. Now, as to that third question,’ and at this he settled comfortably back into his seat, crossing his long leather-clad boots before him, and took another small sip of the wine.

‘Throughout the Onslaught of Angmar, the Elves of Lindon under Círdan supported the ragged remnants of old Arnor and its squabbling kings. They assisted Arveleg and the men of Cardolan to drive off the wild Hill-men and, for a time, diverted the wrathful tide flowing out of Carn Dûm, which Men call the Red Maw. And for a time that line held. For a time.

   ‘But Elves are fickle and caring little for the protection of Men, Elves make poor jailers. They wandered, as they will, back to their shores or into their forests. And so the onslaught came again and Arveleg was killed and Amon Sûl was thrown down and then the line was moved again. Later and with Círdan’s help again, Arveleg's young son, Araphor, drove Angmar's armies from Fornost and the North Downs. Combining forces with Rivendell, and the Galadhrim who joined them from beyond the Misty Mountains, they pushed forward and the line was moved again. And for a time Angmar was silent. For a time.’

   ‘For many hundred of years that was, rider,’ Flomi said, ‘a time only, yes, but a good measure of it in the lives of Men.’

   ‘And now I commend you on your knowledge of the history of my race, master Stonemason,’ the rider said with a wry smile, ‘long years it was but a poor time in the lives of Men indeed. Pestilence and famine ruled the land, not king nor Elf-lord. Wights then walked in open lands made desolate by drought and blight. Men survived by shutting themselves away from others. Your own people, heartier than most, saw this as an opportunity no doubt, for Dwarves have never placed much trust in Men and likely preferred the Roads free of them for a time. But where were the Eldar? They suffered not from Pestilence, but did they hold the line still?

   ‘And all that time Angmar waited. For the Witch-king is deathless as Círdan is, so what care should either have for the brief lives of Men? You ask of hope from Elves now, but what hope did they offer then? Again I ask you, is it not sad? That the valor of the North could be let to wither simply because there is no hand to tend it? And you ask if there is hope to be found in the Elves.’

   The rider remained silent for a time, and Flomi did not interrupt that silence. Beside him on the table was his satchel, half-filled with the papers he had begun to put away, his open inkwell and three different brushes for marking. Flomi’s wine glass was in his hand, but he paid little notice of it as ever. In his other hand he held a small piece of carpenter’s plumbago,12 rarely used in his works, but he stroked it often, liking the familiar smoothness of its texture to his hand. He could feel the warmth of the fire beside them, but also a growing coldness around the stranger who sat before him. He thought to stoke the fire, to perhaps add another log, for now he noticed a chill in the room that he had not felt before. But he let the fire burn and he waited for the rider to finish.

   ‘Círdan offers hope,’ he said finally in a slow and deliberate voice, ‘and calls for the North People to stand. He sends his ships along the coast to Forochel in hope that Elendil’s heir Arvedui may be found and returned to a hopeful people. That is the “hope” he offers; the return of a defeated king, the questionable heir of a sundered line, to a routed folk who have no strongholds left, so that they might stand against all manner of dark men and creatures that pour forth from Angmar. That they might stand and hold a line that he and his own people have many times forsaken while they take their Long Retreat to Lands-Beyond-the-Seas. That is the only hope this town, and all the North, can expect from the Elves; that they will be used to block the tide so others might escape to lands from which we are forbidden.

   ‘I have said it before, master Stonemason,’ he said smiling and then taking another small sip of his wine, ‘it is an interesting time to be a Dwarf in the wider world, but it is a poor time to be a Man of the North.’

   And so the coldness Flomi had felt in the room entered into his heart. He had been engrossed in the puzzle of the translation for most of his life, and certainly the quiet time he had spent here in the Bree-land had not made him think much of the larger world. But he could not deny the feeling of truth in the rider’s words nor could he ignore the fear they caused within him. He took another long drink of wine against the coldness.

   ‘Hope, nor tales filled with hope, I cannot bring to you, master Stonemason,’ the rider said. ‘Bards are a better cure than travelers for dark thoughts on cold nights, and I am no bard.

   ‘But,’ he said then with a smile, returning to the easier though commanding tone of voice, ‘I can offer you some small thing, if you’d like it, in answer to the fair wine and fire that you’ve offered me. A simple thing really, but you might find some use for it.’

   At this he reached into a pocket on his breast and drew forth a small wooden rod with a metallic tip. He held it forward in his right hand for Flomi to see; the tube ended in a fluted nib made of brass, but formed into a shape and manner Flomi had not seen before. More peculiar, the rod itself seemed hollow yet natural, a wood that he had never seen before.

   ‘Is it a pen?’ he asked. Yet he did not take it from the rider’s hand.

   ‘Yes,’ the rider replied. ‘The wood is called Acidosasa I am told, and holds ink just as a well might do, feeding it into the nib as pressure demands. I’ve no hand for this kind of work, nor use for such fine implements myself,’ he said smiling, ‘and one seldom meets travelers in this bare land who have the skill. Will you take it,’ the rider asked, ‘as payment for the wine and the fire?’

   Flomi reached forward and took the item from the rider’s open hand.

   ‘I thank you, traveler,’ he said without hesitation and what he believed to be proper graciousness, ‘it is a fascinating tool, and I look forward to trying it.’

   At this they both raised their wine and drank deeply. After which the rider eased back into his chair, studying Flomi’s face intently. ‘Now,’ he said smiling, ‘ it is my turn for questioning, I believe.’

 

*****

   ‘The animals seem at ease here,’ Collum said to the others after seeing to Caitelyn and her new friend. Bingo Greenhands’ horse was a great roan gelding with a mixed coat of chestnut and white. If he had a name then, Milo had not shared it and Collum had not heard tell of it. But he seemed to be happy out here in the open land, in fact both the horses seemed content to stand off in the cool of the trees and munch on grasses; but Ben’s pony would not leave his side as the group of travelers settled into the glade to talk.

   ‘We have made better time than I hoped,’ the man said, ‘so now we can spare a little of it to talk more openly.’ He sat down on the saddle that Milo had left amongst the provisions and encouraged the others to do the same in that friendly way that Ben had become so accustomed to. The three old wizards, however, remained standing.

   ‘I think we should begin with your town’s stonemason, Ohtar,’ Alatar said, ‘for that seems to be who we are following. Tell us, what strange circumstance brings a Dwarven rune-master into such an unusual role?’

   ‘Flomi, and the other scribes of his family,’ Collum began, ‘have a long entanglement with the line of Isildur here in the North, Oldfather. Their contract to Arnor stretches back through many generations of my family, though how that may be measured against the lives of dwarves I cannot say. For much of that time they have worked on their own, as is their way, translating and deciphering text of secret matters from our heritage that others thought forgotten. But forty years ago some of those secrets became revealed suddenly and Trochi of the Blue Mountains, Flomi’s father and predecessor, came to the Bree-land to discover more. My family has protected them here ever since.’

   ‘A dwarf master of letters I might believe, Innkeeper,’ Tawarengil said, ‘for it said that the Naugrim have many secret skills and a love of history is among them. But a lore-master who spends his days cutting stone for farmers? This seems quite incredible!’

   ‘I don’t understand, Tawar,’ Beothalion said, sitting on the grass beside him. ‘I have heard of the dwarves, though I have not yet met one. But what are runes? Are they writing? You have shown me this thing, and it seems to be a marvel, but I have no head for writing. Is the dwarf a master of writing? Is this what they call runes?’

   Pallando came forward again and replied to this. ‘No, young one, rune-craft is not the writing of signposts that you have seen nor even the recording of song that your friend here may have shown you. Many might mistake it as such. But runes are...’ he paused here for a long moment, closing his sea-green eyes in thought. ‘Tell me, young one, do you talk to the friends and ancestors that have been carved into your belt?’

   At this idea Beothalion looked down to his waist and the belt, the only piece of ornament which he wore. Ben looked too, for he had noticed it before but had not wished to comment with so many other mysteries at hand. The belt appeared to be very old, much, much older than the wildman himself did, and the tooled-leather had an intricate design of crudely rendered animals and the faces of Men. ‘Ancestors’ the wizard had called them and now, noticing things this way, Ben saw a great likeness between these rough, hairy faces and that of the gentle wildman that he had come to know in the past day. They were stern, these graven faces, much sterner than Beothalion’s nature according to how Ben saw it, but they were clearly his People. It was at this moment, and for the very first (if not the last) time that Ben thought about the power he had seen in his new friend; and how he would very much not like to see him when he was angry.13

   Beothalion thought for a long moment and even Tawarengil, who seemed very impatient with all of these stories which only stalled his original purpose, looked thoughtfully at his friend.

   ‘It is the belt of my fathers,’ he said, wrinkling his brow as if this question asked deeper questions that he himself had a mind to do. ‘And so I do talk to the faces there. In times. Alone. "Privately," you call it?’

   ‘Yes,’ Collum said, looking deeply at the wildman but with a care he had not shown openly before. ‘Privately is our word.’

   ‘Privately, then,’ Beothalion said, ‘But I think that the word I want would be... deeper somehow.14 But, yes, friend, I do talk with them, In times.’

   ‘And do they answer you when you speak? Do you hear their voices?’ Pallando asked.

   ‘No. They do not. Though I would wish it might happen,’ Beothalion said with an empty, almost sad, look to his eyes.

   ‘That is the difference between a rune and a writing, young one,’ Pallando said. ‘And I deeply hope for you that someday you should come to hear the voices of your ancestors.

   ‘But we speak of rune-craft now,’ he said, turning toward the others, ‘it is a much, much older art than many imagine and the Eldar and the Edain do not practice it in this age of the world. I am glad to hear that the Khazâd still do, toward whatever purpose.’

   ‘Well, certainly not to the purpose of the People of Arnor,’ Olórin said, ‘and it is certainly not something that they would practice nor reveal outside their own fortified halls. No, Pallando, I think that this dwarf’s skill with history and letters might be more important to Isildur’s heirs than his deeper knowledge of the Flame of Aulë.’15

   ‘And in this you would be right, Greyfather,’ Collum replied. ‘There are old texts, revealed again in our- or, I should say, mine own- lifetime which open deeper histories for my People. Flomi and his sires have been a part of that mystery since its beginnings.’

   ‘And he fled?’ Alatar said. ‘Before the killing at the stables, you believe. What was the cause of this?’

   ‘Many signs of gathered attention since Fornost fell,’ Collum said, ‘but, moreover, six weeks ago, while I was away, a black rider came to the Bree-land.’

 

*****

   And now Flomi knew, finally, what the rider had meant by ‘keeping the Old Customs’; for he had offered his fire (meager and inconsequential in springtime as it seemed), he had offered his stock (the common and rather poor red winyard that was served as the house wine here at the Four Greenfields) and he had asked his questions to an unnamed traveler; he had shown kindness to the man, which was fair custom, but until now had not considered it as transactional. In accepting the gift of the writing implement Flomi had not considered the meaning; he had completed the transaction of materials. Now he must answer to the established transaction of the questions he had asked and allow the traveler three of his own. They had made a Bargain.

   Now it should be said here that the Old Rules of Customs, much like the Importance of Threes themselves, was not something to be found recorded anywhere in the writings of Men, Dwarves, Elves or (though it might seem the more surprising) even Hobbits. No one could step back from an implied transaction, look at a document, and cite the conditions neatly nor could one establish their very relative and very often case-specific usage. No arbiters could argue scope or violation, no tribal-heads nor governors could complain about the limits of their jurisdiction, and, even more importantly, everyone who lived in the West of Middle-earth at this age of the world, knew they were bound by these Rules even if they could not, with any true certainty, recite them. It was not exactly correct to think of them as archaic or forgotten, because they lived very much inside the everyday cordiality of all the Peoples of that part of the world. But they were not a known equation, not a matter of historical record or law, and as such they were very important in their observance.

   Flomi, who knew the histories and the laws of this part of the world better than most, did not need any such document; he knew that he was now bound to the rider. Flomi had given material gifts and asked three questions. Now, with the writing implement, he had taken a material gift in return and, again in return, he was indebted to answer three questions; a Bargain. It surprised him to be caught in this way and he knew, quite certainly, that there was danger here; for what else could be said of such a clever trap in such an unexpected place on such a dark and unseasonable night. But now, seeing with awake-eyes the danger that the other Breelanders had only sniffed at, Flomi felt ready to face it.

   ‘Ah. Yes. As it should be, rider,’ he said, hoping the resolute tone of his voice would make him appear bolder, ‘for Custom is important to chance-meetings like ours, is it not? But...’ Flomi paused here for a long moment to let the rider’s anticipation mount.

   ‘Yes?’ the rider said, his impatience showing for the first time.

   ‘Well, it seems that you set conditions on our talk from the first, offering to “tell me no tales.” Yes. Well, I thank you for that,’ Flomi said, ‘for you are correct; tales are untrustworthy things and your news of the world served me much better. But I live without news here in the Bree-land, and I also stand at a great distance from my People and their tales, as you may surmise. Yet I have a deep love of histories. 

   'So.

   ‘I can offer no news for your questions, having none of importance in such a small town, nor tell you no tales for your questions, for they would prove untrustworthy by your own esteem. So I will give you only histories in response.

   ‘It may seem weary and unfortunate to you, I’m afraid,’ Flomi said, ‘but I am also no bard nor traveler. I have only history to disclose.’ As the fire in the hearth burned low between them the two figures looked long to one another’s eyes; each unflinching.

   ‘Very well, master Stonemason,’ the black rider finally said. ‘Let us start with your history.’

 

*****

   ‘I was not present at this time,’ Collum continued, ‘for clues and evidence in our task often comes from far sources and I had established the habit of riding out of town monthly to discover any new information and meet with other folk of my kindred who were tasked in collecting it. So I did not see this man myself...’

   His voice trailed off here for a moment, uncharacteristic of Collum, or so Ben thought, and he was uncertain as to what motivated it. But the moment did not last.

   ‘But I am certain,’ he said finally, ‘that this man was not an insignificant ruffian out of Angmar nor even some lieutenant who happened upon the Bree-land quite by mistake. No. His manner was wiser than that, his language, though I heard it not myself, more precise, and his cunning sharper than fine-honed steel. I have met men like this on the battlefield and, mighty as they may be, they are far more dangerous in conversations in commonrooms. No. I am convinced that the Black Númenóreans ride now openly in the North and they are aware of Flomi’s work.

   ‘That, my lord Tawarengil, is who follows my friend, who directed my other friend Guldir’s murder, and who called for the torch at our stables last night,’ Collum said, looking straight at the young Elf-lord’s eyes as if daring him to have a remark.

   ‘Fathers, masters,’ he said, looking to the others with an imploring face as the sun began to slide closer to the treetops in the west, ‘I am oath-bound, for eight generations of my family’s honor, to not disclose the story of Flomi’s work. Some of you, I think, guess at its importance. I may not, by word nor nod nor other gesture, confirm your guesses. But this I know; he is followed by no mere cutthroat nor arsonist. They have decided to come for him. It may be that the appearance of so many great peoples at our quiet little inn last night forced their hands. I had not expected any of you, yet in the week before I had prepared us both to leave quickly. Yet they have come fast for whatever reason, and right on our heels. I know in my heart that Flomi and his work are not safe and, when we have concluded with our talk, I must fly to his aid.

   ‘Any may join me and, certainly, those who do will learn more. Those who will not are forgiven for their curiosity if they will forgive me for my caution.’ And at this he looked straight toward Tawarengil, standing now to emphasize his point.

   ‘But I will tell you all,’ he said looking deeply into the Elf-lord’s eyes, ‘that Flomi, son of Trochi, holds the true hope of the north realm of Arnor in his hands, unexpected as that may sound. Círdan may call all the free-People, but will they come? If the Witch-king could be pushed back, if Fornost could be retaken, would it matter? Could we Men of the North hold these lands again? No.

   ‘Friends, I am a soldier from a line of soldiers and I believe that the North is lost and that our future is uncertain. It is our history that matters.

   ‘Will you help me to save it?’

 

*****

   ‘Accch! History is not personal, traveler,’ Flomi replied, almost chuckling at his having stymied the rider, ‘and the history of the Dwarves, as a learned man like yourself might already know, is a secret. So it must be the history of my time in this town that you wish. Very well.

   ‘I am still quite young as it goes with dwarves in the wider world, for I have seen only one hundred and thirteen moonrises.16 Most of my people do not venture forth at my early age. But I was precocious as a lad and remain that way even through today. I came to this town some three decades ago to continue my father’s work. He too was a stonemason.’

   ‘Indeed,’ the rider said, smiling. ‘Charming. I have seen very few works of stone in this little village, however. I should think two generations of stout dwarves might make a fortress of a place like this.’

   ‘Oh, there is good stone here in the neighboring hills for any of my People to find,’ Flomi said, ‘but the Big Folk of the Bree-land are not good builders and the Little Folk, while quite industrious in their way, are hole-dwellers and seldom need much from me. My work here for the town affords me a little income and all the comforts I might need, but with little effort nor cause for ambition. So,’ Flomi said, smiling to himself as if he thought he found a particularly useful response, ‘I turn my spare hours to histories, which I love, and even the collecting of tales, which you, admittedly, do not.’

   ‘From the comfort of a cozy fire and a roadside inn, tales might seem like histories, master Stonemason,’ the rider said, smiling back, ‘but travel in the wider world often disproves this and may disappoint.’

   ‘As you say,’ Flomi replied. ‘I am a rather more suspicious audience for tales than these Breelanders of course, and care little for their local histories. But do I hear a second question in that, rider?’ Flomi asked.

   ‘No, no,’ the rider said, ‘I will take your comfort here by the fire as answer enough. But,’ he said, getting up and drawing more wine from the cask in preparation of his next question and filling Flomi’s cup as well, ‘I would like more history, real or no, from this little niche of the North. Now the Nogothrim tell no histories of themselves, as you have said, but perhaps you have other histories of my own people in these lands that might amuse me?’ And at this he lifted his glass a bit inviting Flomi to do the same.

   ‘Acchhh,’ Flomi said, lifting his glass in return and, carefully, taking the very smallest sip of his wine without letting his eyes leave the rider’s, ‘the glories of these People have fallen, rider, just as you say. I know little, nor care little, for the sundered and squabbling kings of this land. And no dwarf, nor elf I should imagine, would feel otherwise; for they were nothing but sad relics of former glories to our eyes. Sad, yes, because they were great once indeed; the North Kingdom of Arnor before the Great War in the South brought a lasting peace to these lands that profited dwarf and elf and man.

   ‘You say that we saw opportunity in the Years of Plague, that we were happy to find less Men on the Road, but this is not so. Hardier we Dwarves are, true, and less imperiled by this pestilence than Man or Hobbit, but not as safe on our way as we had been when Elendil’s true heirs held sway in the North. In the days of my greatsires the people of the Blue Mountains and, aye, even of the distant Iron Hills which now seem so remote, traded openly with Men and even Elves (though our grievances there are older and might never be resolved). Before Hollin fell to the south we had trade with the Eldar, but Sauron destroyed that peaceful kingdom long ago, and our western gate became shut for more than an age. Histories tell it now remains so. But, through the Road we traveled again, while Men held it, and all three of the kindred held great relations together again.

   ‘For a time,’ Flomi said sadly. ‘While Men of the North held the Road.’

   There was a long silence between the two then and each took another small sip of wine. After much time the rider spoke. ‘Sad, I say again, that the valor of the North could be left to wither so simply,’ but there was a darkness in his eyes as he said it, though they never left the fire, and his voice remained cold.

   ‘One last question then, master Stonemason,’ he said, ‘as you seemed to have taken much of the news that I gave to you and turned it to histories.’ At this he stood from his chair and drew closer to the fire, his ungloved left hand holding his goblet up and his right hooked in the center of his swordbelt. He smiled lightly to Flomi’s direction, but his eyes shot quickly towards the entrance to the commonroom and then back to the dwarf.

   ‘It has been a merry meeting and I hope that my reliance on the Old Customs has not proved too disarming on such an unseasonable night,’ he said, ‘for I have, truthfully, enjoyed our talk much more than I do this horrid wine.’ At this he tipped his mug a final time and smiled very broadly.

   Flomi laughed at this, nervously perhaps, and then drank with him. And the rider asked his final question:

   ‘I travel north soon,’ he said, ‘and I seek... things of history. Old things of my People. Tell me, master, in all your histories of the North, have you heard of “The River Gliding which leaves these inland realms”?’17

   Light had not yet come up in the eastern sky as Flomi neared the seven birch trees. Perhaps further behind him it had come to the hills and less wooded areas. He could hear birdsong back away in that direction and the stirrings of morning that these things might, on any other day, peacefully herald. The seven birches stood tall and white before him, so tall in fact that he doubted dawn was far from reaching their uppermost branches. He now knew, though he had not even guessed a week ago when first he had come here, that he was in terrible danger. He now knew that his father, and his greatsires before him and every dwarf in his family since they had first become involved with the Princess of Arnor, had been in a terrible danger that he had never foreseen. He knew what he should have guessed on that night six weeks before when the black rider had come to the Bree-land; that he was watched and measured by the Enemy. He was now certain that the work, which he had formerly found to be only challenging and amusing and a legacy of his family, was of grave importance to Great Powers.

   ‘So,’ he said to himself, ‘this is their war, Men. But it is our history. I should very much like to have known the truth of it earlier, but now I see how the concerns run deeper. Collum is stead-fast, a friend who will protect me, and our place of defense is secured. He will join me soon and, together, with full openness regarding the severity of the situation, we will, I am convinced, solve the puzzle of our ancestors.’

   And then, aloud in the darkness, as if mustering himself, he said, ‘and woe be to those who will hinder us in this task!’

   If the sound of his voice informed the hunters he did not know. He did not hear a cry of command or the snap of bowstring, or the wrishing of the air before the first arrow hit him full in the back.

 

End of Chapter Five


Chapter End Notes

Notes on Chapter Five

1)  This is a bastardization of the name “Hödekin (also spelled Hödeken, Hüdekin, and Hütchen)”, a kobold (house spirit) of German folklore. According to the legend recorded by folklorist Thomas Keightley in 1850, Hödekin always wore a felt hat down over his face and was a helpful little sprite; his name means "Little Hat". For reasons we’ll see later, this connection is important.

2)  Oh, I couldn’t resist. “What’s the rumpus?” is, of course, a quote from the Coen Brothers' film MILLER’S CROSSING, but rumpus itself seems such a Tolkien word, such a Hobbit-like word, that I needed to work it in here somewhere.

3)  The Númenóreans do not have surnames and were often given the names of respected predecessors. Men would be given the name of their fathers only if they were of a great lineage. My supposition here is that the man who returned Narsil and brought with him the tale of Isildur’s death was given great honor and the label of soldier indeed became a title carried by his sons.

4)  Tawarengil is helping Ben and the rest of us here by translating Eärendur’s name. But he may just be showing off his Quenya.

5)  For my purposes here Rosie should be recognizing Ben’s voice from about half a mile off. This would be about 800 ragnar. Measures of distance in most cases are converted as nearly as possible into modern terms within Tolkien’s work. "League" is used often because it was the longest measurement of distance: in Númenórean reckoning (which was decimal) five thousand rangar (full paces) made a lár, which was very nearly three of our miles. Lár meant "pause," because except in forced marches a brief halt was usually made after this distance had been covered. The Númenórean ranga, which comes from the Quenya word for “stride” was slightly longer than our yard, approximately thirty-eight inches, owing to their great stature. Therefore five thousand rangar would be almost exactly the equivalent of 5280 yards, our "league.”

6)  Here it seems necessary to insert some discussion of runes as we think of them and how that might apply to Tolkien’s legendarium; for, rather simply put, I do not believe that the written languages of western Middle- earth (other than the secret language of the Dwarves) was runic. Indeed, in every Germanic language, the word “rune” (from Proto-Germanic runo) means both “letter” and “secret” or “mystery,” and its original meaning, which likely predated the adoption of the runic alphabet, may have been simply “(hushed) message.” I’ll deal with this later in the writing, but it should be clear to every Tolkien fan that most languages in the Second and Third Age, even the language of Mordor, used Elvish script and letters of an Elvish alphabet to convey messages. We see it even in the Black Speech on the Ring itself. So Flomi is speaking to some other part of the material that is more purely pictographic or runic. But, again, this will become more clear as we move the story forward.

7)  This little aside about the Dwarves and the East is based on the idea, from The Silmarillion, that the “evil” Dwarf-lords of the First Age had come out of the East.

8)  Malbeth can be found in the appendix for LoTR of course and was counselor to Araphant, the 14th king of Arthedain. He made two very significant prophesies regarding the North kingdom and his role in this story is somewhat expanded beyond those.

9)  The term “grandsire” among the Dwarves is not to be confused with “grandfather” as is often the case with other races. In regard to Flomi’s family this goes many generations back, but also carries a more specific relationship that we will learn more about later.

10)  “Forgive me, little horse. I greet you (informal). I am Beothalion.” -from Sindarin.

11)  This quote can be found in the first book of The History of Middle-earth and comes from a passage of Tolkien’s earliest writings for the legendarium; a section linking "The Cottage of Lost Play" with "The Song of the Ainur."

12)  An archaic name for graphite that, to my ears, sounds rather Dwarvish.

13)  Yes, The Hulk TV show. But, again, this is fan-fic and I simply cannot not resist the occasional Easter Egg.

14)  I’ve always been attracted to how Tolkien, as a devout Christian, handles the subject and practice of his faith in the Legendarium. This subject will, of course, come up again, but this seemed an appropriate spot to deal with it in regard to the customs of Beothalion’s people; those among him in the party seem to recognize the idea “prayer” in his talk of “private” conversation with his ancestors.

15)  Rune-craft, as might be obvious to readers at this point, will play a large part in the story. But I refer to it here as a principle skill granted to the Dwarves by their maker.

16)  We know from the Hobbit that the Dwarven Calendar is lunar based (like the Hebrew one). Unlike the Hebrew calendar, the Dwarven New Year starts on Durin’s Day, which is the day that begins the last cycle of the Moon. When on this day both the Sun and Moon may be seen in the sky together. That places Durin’s Day, anytime between about Oct. 7 and Nov. 6, on the last day before the astronomical new moon as the moon sets just before the sun.

17)  This is a clue to our deeper mystery, so I will not say much. But, for those Tolkien detectives out there, it comes from a poem in "The Cottage of Lost Play" and can be found in the History of Middle-Earth Vol. I


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment