The Fall of Arnor; Book One "Out of the Bree-land" by Diane Finnis-Robb  

| | |

Chapter Three; "Questions Amid the Ashes"

-Wherein the People of the Bree-land are Aided by Strangers, Some Cautious Questions are Asked, Many Histories are Told, Careful Alliances of Purpose are Drawn and a Prancing Pony Saves the Day


   It was well past the middle of night and drawing towards the morning when the desperate work of saving the Bree- land stables came near to its end. Buttercup had hauled buckets and worked pumps1 alongside the other townsfolk in those first frantic hours and she was now dog tired. Collum had pulled her away from the hard labor of managing the blaze an hour before and sent her to the kitchens to help prepare whatever meal might be had for all who had turned out and battled the fire.

   ‘I’ve told the cooks to empty the stores if need be,’ he told her, ‘and I’d like you to make sure they’re not holding back. All of the people here, just like yourself, have done hard, hot work and if they’d not put their shoulders to it so fast we’d have lost the inn and possibly a good part of the town itself. The Little People will be hungry no matter what the hour, and I think it safe to say that all will be thirsty. Give them all that they may ask, and do not wait for me to begin.’

   And with that he went running back to where the Big Folk like himself were busy using earth and tarps of hide, tamping down the last timbers which remained burning to ensure that no sparks might kindle anew.

   ‘He must be more done-in than any of us,’ she thought, ‘running from blaze to well and back again, managing the whole job. All with one friend dead and the other vanished! Thanks be for him and thanks be for Ben Floxleaf and his Rosie, too!’

   Her aunt Pansey and the other maids and cooks had all worked hard under Collum’s orders as well. Too young or, like Pansey, too old to help much with the fire, they had laid out all the necessary support they might give during the past eight hours of the clock. All available water stores and large vessels at the inn had been used to fight the blaze of course, but compresses and rags to be used as breathing masks the women had soaked in beer for the men who worked closest to the flames and smoke. The Breelanders had been surprisingly fortunate with the wind that night as well. Although the stable was in some places only a pace from the eastern side of the inn, no flame had rushed through that narrow alleyway and spread to this larger, provisioned and occupied building. Once it was clear that the wooden roof of the inn was not also in danger of catching, Pansey and her girls had set up a camp of sorts under the Clock-tower on the inn’s west side. There they started laying out biscuits, cheeses, fruits and dried meats or any other cold dish they could think of (for everyone felt it bad luck indeed to start a cooking fire).

   ‘Well, there’s wisdom enough in that I suppose,’ Buttercup thought as she examined the foods being gathered, ‘but with the morning chill, these tired men will want something a bit more bracing. There’s fortified wines and meads stronger than beer still in the commonroom and I’m sure Collum will want to offer those as well.’

   The room itself was abandoned in great haste when word of the fire was first heard, but some of Pansey’s girls must have come here in their early job of protecting the inn. The fireplaces had been smothered, the curtains and draperies removed from the windows and the shutters of the rear door pulled. Drinking vessels still sat on many tables where the customers had left them when all the folk that were present, Big and Little, had gone out to fight the blaze. A few stools were overturned and the little gate that separated Collum’s workspace from the rest of the patrons sat open. ‘The man must have rushed faster than most at the first sound of trouble,’ Buttercup thought admiringly. ‘But it's not like him to leave the Henhouse door lay open.’

   She stepped into the enclosure and started to gather as many drinking vessels as she could carry, noticing that the three small delicate cups she had served the kind old gentlemen earlier were strangely missing. ‘Now that is curious,’ Buttercup said to herself. ‘I hope no thief has come here in all the confusion.’ It was then that she looked down to see that Collum’s pack, and his longsword, were now also gone.

 

*****

   When Collum had first heard the noises coming from outside he suspected the worst. ‘Flomi has been followed, as I guessed, and while I’ve had to waste my time dealing with all these strangers he has met with some entanglements,’ he thought. Instinctively he reached toward his longsword, now prepared to shed his tired and troublesome guise as an innkeeper and follow his better nature as a soldier protecting his charge. But it was Milo that came bursting into the commonroom at just that instant, shouting, ‘Fire! Awake! The stables are afire!’

   Collum saw the dumb-struck expression on the faces of the six or seven of the Big Folk still in the commonroom, yet the hobbits, to a man, lept to their feet immediately and were at the door even before he was. Bert Thistleberry, the cooper, and Ned Appledore, a farmer from just east of the Hedge, where right at their heels. ‘If this town, and even much of the North, is to be taken over by these rather silly, sturdy, but hard-working folk,’ Collum thought running after them, ‘well then, it could be in much worse hands.’

   From the commonroom to the stables the fastest route was out to the street. Already there were people of the town (once again, mostly Hobbits) heading towards the trouble and calling loudly; ‘Fire! Awake! Fire! All awake!’ It was not so many hours past the sunset, but Collum could see many a sleepy shopkeeper of his unfortunate acquaintance standing in doorways scratching their heads and the more intimate creases of their bed-clothes while looking to see what was the trouble. Awakened suddenly and fully, they set down their lanterns or candles and ran headlong to help their neighbours. ‘I have talked poorly of these folk and, no matter what this trouble might turn out to be, it was likely our own enterprise which has brought it on the Breelanders. They deserve more goodness than I have shown them!’ he thought. And then they ran, Collum and his neighbours, headlong to the smoke and the flames and the danger while up this same street, in the other direction, braying and prancing and raising as much alarm as she might, a frightened white pony did her best to kick and neigh and alert the town.

 

*****

   ‘You should breathe, Little Benbow,’ Beothalion said, ‘just lay there and breathe!’

   And the wildman was quite right of course, Ben could not deny that as a bit of sound advice. And he would certainly tell Beothalion so, if he could ever manage to stop coughing.

   For over six hours Ben had worked side-by-side with his new companions and the other Breelanders trying to control what had looked like a rather hopeless situation; for the stables had caught fire unnaturally fast. When he had plunged through the burning entranceway (a brave act that Ben, choking now as he was, had come to think of as quite foolish) the hobbit had no idea what to expect. From the outside there had certainly been a great amount of smoke, but only one post and the lintel of that egress, which was rather broad so as to accommodate the occasional wagon, was on fire at that time. And the whole portal was quite high also, so that Ben had no trouble running in at the point furthest from the flames.

   But the inside of the building was more perilous than he could have foreseen. To his right the entire wall of the first stall was engulfed in flame, rather high up in fact, so that the thatched roof had begun to catch and there the fire spread rapidly, filling the loft area with a thick, dark smoke. Inside the poor remaining animals were screaming with horrified voices and Ben could see Beothalion, whom he had followed into the conflagration, rushing to and fro across the row of carrels towards the back, throwing wide the gates of each stall as quickly as possible and shouting to the animals in a language Ben could not understand. The young Elf-lord, on the other hand, stood very near to the worst flames there at the first stall, speaking calm words to a great huge mare (Collum’s horse, if Ben’s memory was aright) and cutting some hard knot of her bridle so that she might escape certain death.

   ‘Sîdh, Beleg Heryn! Sîdh!’2 he said and, miraculously, the horse was quieting, shining up to the little Elf-prince who stood barely as high as the great beast’s haunches. Once the horse was freed, Tawarengil stepped lightly away from her and cried, ‘Noro lim, Beleg Heryn! Noro lim!’3 and with that she burst toward the open entrance and past Benbow, her eyes still bright with the terror of the fire but no longer panicked as all those other animals that were still trapped in their carrels.

   ‘Tawar!’ Beothalion cried from the gloom at the rear of the stables and over the roaring sound of the growing blaze, ‘there are other frightened beasts here who will not listen to me. We must help them!’ But the Elf had already come forward to do just that when he spotted Benbow.

   ‘You are brave, little Perian,4 but these poor beasts are too great for you,’ he said as he paused for only a moment to take Ben’s shoulder. He had looked very much like a child before, despite his high talk and his courteous posturing, ‘just some smart youngster playing at being a lord,’ Ben had thought before when they were all assembled in the outer hall. But now as Tawarengil stood before him Ben could see how very wrong that first perception had been. For the Elf now seemed completely without fear of the fire growing around them and his whole bearing, here and now in the midst of great peril, exuded a confidence unique to his kind that Ben had seen only a few times before in those High Lords at Rivendell. Tawarengil was no taller here than he had been before in the commonroom, not much taller than Ben himself in fact, but in the midst of danger he grew very great indeed and Ben had to wonder at the age of this ‘youngster.’

   ‘Leave this to Beothalion and myself and go amongst your own people,’ Tawarengil said. ‘You seem not only a great deal braver but some degree smarter. Lead yourself out and lead them to return with buckets!’ And with this he ran to the rear of the stables to help his friend.

   Ben followed the advice and sped through the burning entrance way to see a good number of townsfolk (mostly hobbits) assembling and calling for shovels and buckets and pails. Collum was among them, the great grey mare at his side, as he gave orders and set up a line from the inn to the main area of the flame. He did not see Rosie, but was comforted in knowing she was safely away from the fire.

   ‘Milo!’ Collum shouted, ‘run door to door from here to the well calling for water and vessels, and shovels with hands to work them. Go, lad!’

   Laying his eyes on Ben he called, “Floxleaf? Who else is in there? Did you see the stablemaster? Was Flomi...’ At this, and as if they had been called forth, Ben was nearly knocked to the ground as three great pigs came running and squealing from the blaze and into the street around him.

   ‘That great wildman and his Elf friend are freeing the animals,’ Ben replied, ‘but I saw no others.’

   ‘We are in their debt then, and I should like them to get out here where I might repay it,’ Collum replied. ‘Go, Ben, if you will, straight down to the well and get folks there to draw as much water from the pumps as they can. This fire grows fast and if the wind rises we will lose the inn and much more!’

 

*****

   Tawarengil and Beothalion had managed to rescue the remaining livestock in a relatively short time; four other miserably terrified horses and three angry pigs had been discovered by the wildman and he could not handle them alone. They were dumb beasts all of them, not like the tall mare or that first pony they had seen, and they could not understand the old language when Beothalion spoke it to them. So terrified were they that the two companions had to take them one at time out of the burning building while their screaming continued; not the pigs of course. ‘Swine are more clever than the trained beasts of these people,’ Tawarengil thought, ‘and their sense of danger isn’t dulled by docility like these townsfolk.’ Once Beothalion had thrown up their gate near the rear of the building, the pigs went scampering for the front, following the hobbit Floxleaf to safety.

   With the ponies now free the wildman and the Elf could see the townsfolk starting to gather, setting up a chain of buckets from wherever water could be had and bringing shovels and barrows to gather earth which might smother the flame. The innkeeper was among them, ordering the others about, and the great grey mare that Tawarengil had saved was standing near to him. The three Istari were nowhere to be seen.

   ‘The flame grows fast, Tawar,’ Beothalion said. ‘These Little Folk are brave to fight it. How can we help them?’

   ‘Find and follow the brave one named Floxleaf, brother,’ the Elf replied. ‘He and this innkeeper seem to be organizing things here. I go to talk to our other new acquaintances. They have their own means against disaster.’ At this, as he did with the perian, Tawarengil awaited no answer but sped off to see what had become of the others.

   This haste and purpose during peril, a quality that Benbow had found quite brave in the Elf-lord just a few moments before, was indeed a characteristic of his personality, though it had not always served him well. Now, in the face of the unknown, it was more instinct for him than valour. Tawarengil had never seen a raging and uncontrolled fire before. Unlike inside the stables with the saving of the threatened creatures, he now had no practical idea of what to do or how to fight such a catastrophic blaze. ‘We do not burn things unnecessarily as the Orcs do, and our Halls in the Greatwood are carved into stone, unlike this place,’ he thought. ‘Water from handheld pails? Shovelfuls of new turned earth? How will that hold back this disaster? How do we keep this conflagration from overtaking the whole of this town?’ But he did not wish to show Beothalion, his friend of many years, how unprepared he was for this new situation and he did not wish to put himself in the position of following these townfolk whom he still considered feeble-minded. So he sought the advice of the Wise.

   Leaving Beothalion and the rest behind, he had gone back around to the alley which ran between the stables and the inn. He was certain that the Istari had followed them that far before Tawarengil and Beothalion, alerted by the pony, had sped forward into the burning building. Where they had gone next, and why they weren’t among the others fighting this blaze he could not guess.

   Rounding the turn into the alleyway he saw the dark figure of one of them framed against the growing light from the blaze. It was Alatar, the one he took to be their leader, standing still with a curled wand raised just a bit and muttering softly to himself, his eyes focused on the glowing flames. The most surprising thing for Tawarengil, who had studied the Old Tongue throughout his life, was that he did not recognize the words.5

    ‘Hláranyë ringa Formessúrë,
 

   asúy' aldassen úlassië, 
 

   alussa olbalissë nornë,
 

  alamya ve Nuru-nainië.

    Formessúrë-yalmë quéla,
 

   ar Númello holtan hwesta
 

   nísima asúya ninna,


   ar nainië ahya lírinna.'6

   ‘What is that he speaks? Did he say númen súrë?7 Does he call for favour of the Valar?’ Tawarengil thought. And he halted there beside the old man, ‘Old, yes, but much more than Man,’ and even with the blaze roaring beside them, he waited there in rare silence, bowing his head as if to join the Istari in his plea. For he did not know what else to do.

   It was then that Tawarengil noticed the dead body laying just a few feet behind them.

 

*****

   ‘I shall never escape this town in time,’ Collum thought, ‘and now I am greatly needed elsewhere.’

   As the townsfolk worked around the growing fire the body of Guldir, the stablemaster, was soon discovered. The Elf and one of the old travelers had found him there in the alleyway and gossip, much faster than wildfire on the tongues of Breelanders, had circulated very quickly that the man had been murdered. Collum had the body covered and removed to safety away from the fire and, seeing the cause of his death, his face grew grimmer.

   ‘Guldir was a good man in my charge and I fail him now by remaining here,’ Collum thought. But still he remained. There were questions left unsettled and he could not just yet abandon these townsfolk.

   When the blaze was finally contained to the inner structure of the stables, Benbow Floxleaf, Beothalion and Collum had led most of the Men in town to beating and smothering the outer walls. Ben, who had done a wonderful job organizing the workers at the well, had returned on his own pony and insisted that Hobbits could do this work just as well as the Big Folk.

   ‘I’ve no love of roasted toes, mind you,’ he said to those around him, ‘but I can’t, kaff! stand on my own feet easily while others walk into dangers for me.’ And, to Collum’s joy and surprise, some other hobbits, upon hearing this, did likewise.

   The Elf-child, whose name Collum had not yet heard, did not participate. He seemed unafraid of the flames, indeed, more unaffected by the heat and smoke than all the other people around him, yet he acted somehow aloof of the danger they still posed for the town. He had instead spent his time gathering and calming the nearby animals (and he had saved many of them, including Collum’s own horse Caitelyn), the whole time talking with the three travelers.

   ‘I know only a little more of wizards than any man may, and these woodland Elves are new to me,’ Collum thought. ‘But they remain here, watching, and I cannot but think their continued presence will cost me even more time in departing. But why are they here? What brings them to the Bree-land?’

   He should, or so he thought many times within this past hour, depart now while all the attention is on the fire. Though he had no real assurance yet, his heart told him that Flomi had gone before the fire had started and perhaps this, though Flomi would never do such a thing himself, was just the diversion they both might use for their escape. As the Breelanders tamped down the remaining flames, Collum had sought for any evidence of the dwarf’s escape. His three ponies were surely gone as was the saddle and all other belongings in Flomi’s usual carrel. He saw the charred remnants of his own saddle, most likely where the fire had been started, and took a few concealed moments to examine it in the hopes of some remaining message. The fire had taken much, but the slow burning of the worn leather had indeed protected a small paint brush concealed in one of the pockets. ‘Better than a note,’ Collum thought, ‘for this was surely not here before. Flomi is gone then, and I must, with all possible haste, join him.’

   He had even snuck back to the inn at one point to gather his sword and his pack, including the three small drinking vessels that were precious to him, stowing them somewhere that he might grab them quickly and escape while the confusion yet lasted. But Guldir’s murder, the finding of this brush, and the disappearance of one of Sarnside’s friends told him a cautionary tale; Flomi had escaped, as he believed, but was followed, and the murder and this fire were set to confuse the trail.

   ‘I should leave, this very instant,’ he thought, ‘for if he cannot reach the safety of the Foundations all of our work will be lost.’ He looked towards the Elf and the three wizards standing off to the side and thought about the questions they would have; wise questions that he would be hard-put to avoid. And then he looked to Ben Floxleaf who, coughing and ready to collapse from the smoke, was still bolstering Milo and a few of the hardiest hobbits to keep up with the dangerous task. And with him, Beothalion, the wildman who had never seen a community of people before and yet was so ready to help them fight this disaster.

   ‘I shall never escape this town in time,’ Collum said to himself. And then he ran forward with the others to quell the last flames that threatened the community of the Bree-land.

 

*****

   Some hours before, unaware of the fire in town behind him or the peril that now watched him from just outside the gate, Flomi left his small house at the stoneyard never to return.

His provisions were light, easily carried from here to his meeting place with Collum, so he now had to give a thought to his ponies. ‘They have served me well, all three, but they are not all fit for the travels ahead,’ he thought to himself. ‘I shall take Corlar, stoutest and fleetest of the three, and leave the rest with provisions and room to wander. No doubt some inquisitive Breelander will be here in the next day or two and take them into his care.’

   But when he left his mason’s house and went back to the place where they had been, he found that the ponies had all gone. His saddle lay nearby, just where he had left it after dismounting Corlar, but the beasts themselves had seemingly wandered off. He checked the outer building, a kind of tool shed that served as a stable to his ponies when the weather was harsh, but they were not to be found.

   ‘Now this is unusual,’ he thought, and gripped his maddock tighter as he looked around the stoneyard for some sign of what had occurred.

 

******

   Just before the sunrise the strangers began to assemble again in the outer hall that they had left so suddenly at the start of their fellowship. Out in the main yard under the Clock and before the inn the townsfolk were eating and drinking, congratulating one another on their bravery and trying their best to understand just what had happened. None present blamed the strangers, not as yet, for certainly they too had worked bravely to stop the conflagration from spreading. But surely there were some Breelanders who believed that the coming of these odd people into their quiet little town was somehow near to the heart of the problem. ‘Trouble follows trouble, I’ve been told,’ old Tom Truetunnels, with a new audience and new flagon of free beer was quick to point out in the smoky pre-dawn light, ‘and I’ve never heard of Elves nor Wassirds who brought nought but troubles with them.’ But the tall grey-cloaked wassird who argued with him earlier was not there to debate with old Tom this time. He had much more pressing matters on his mind.

   ‘You should breathe, Little Benbow,’ Beothalion said, ‘just lay there and breathe!’

   The hobbit had fought the flames bravely alongside his larger companions and had nearly succumbed to the smoke as they moved further into the wreck of the stables. Beothalion had swept him up and carried him out, that much Ben remembered, but how he had arrived here in the outer hall with a compress on his forehead was lost to him. He would ask, perhaps, if he could manage to stop coughing. Across the room the three old men and the Elf-lord were standing over the large body of a man who was now wrapped in a burial sheet.

   ‘This death is a decision,’ Olórin said to the others, ‘and not without purpose. A course of action and new measures were taken here with this man’s demise.’

   ‘Yes,’ said the third member of their group. ‘And this fire was started after, to cover another purpose beyond this murder.’

   ‘Fathers,’ said Tawarengil, ‘are these small troubles worthy of the Wise? A man is dead, yes, and a town was emperilled, but what does this mean as the Witch-king threatens all towns and all folk here in the North? When we stood in this room last it seems to me our talk was on weightier matters.

   ‘Beothalion and I travel west to join others from Greatwood who have answered Círdan’s call. It is said he will assemble a force in the westlands against Angmar. Are you not bound this way also? Will one small death remove you from your course?’

   ‘No death is too small in any matters, lord Tawarengil,’ Alatar said, ‘and our course within them is not set. As yet. No, I agree with Olórin that there is something occurring here which may change all of our courses.

   ‘That you plan to go west you have told us, and you have made your purposes there plain enough. I commend you for them. Círdan has indeed called upon all the just Peoples of this land to aid the exiled Númenórean king and repel this Witch-king who seems so terrible a threat. We have heard this, yes, though it is not principal to our own concerns for Arda,’ at this Alatar looked to Olórin, as if this was a continuance of some private debate between the two.

   ‘There is wisdom and bravery to be certain in such a venture, though it is yet uncertain how many of the North People, your own included, will rise to this calling,’ Alatar continued. ‘You say that “others from Greatwood” have gone forth, but you have not mentioned why you, a very young lord of some great lineage, travel so with only this man as your companion. This is also unusual and not beyond our wonder.

   ‘We three travelers,’ Alatar said, continuing quickly and indicating the other members of his order, ‘who have been parted for many, many long years, have met here in this same small town to decide our own paths and whether to participate in these actions against this Witch-king. Do you not find it peculiar that this should happen on the same day that you and your friend arrive? On the same day of this fire and of this man’s death? Nay, lord Tawarengil, these are no small incidents, and I should like my own time to measure their meanings.’

   At the end of this speech Ben, being particularly polite in holding things in up until now, let off another series of loud coughs.

   ‘And we have not forgotten you, Master Floxleaf,’ said the grey-cloaked Olórin. ‘Meeting a brave hobbit who has also been welcomed in Rivendell on a day when we have considered traveling there ourselves is no mere chance- should you believe in such a thing. You, and your folk, have some part to play in all of this yet, I think...’

   ‘Perhaps this is true,’ said the third member of their party, ‘but I am continually interested in this innkeep-‘

   As if on cue (though in fact he had been listening outside for some time and awaiting this very moment) the door to the small outer hall was thrown wide and Collum Gilleyfoil and Milo Fastknots stepped inside carrying a large jug, cups and a board filed with meats and cheeses.

   ‘Masters!’ he cried, ‘you have not joined the others outside in their late supper though you most certainly deserve our great thanks. Much that was accomplished this night is better through your assistance. Will you sup with us?’

   ‘We must talk, master Innkeeper,’ Alatar said, ‘and I do not think it can wait through any time for the niceties of feasting. You seem to stand at the center of many mysteries, this man’s death not being the least nor the last.’

   ‘Guldir was my friend for many years, Old Father, and none in this town knew him nor will mourn him as I do,’ Collum replied with some flash of a seriousness that Ben had not seen in the man before. ‘But you speak accurately when you say we must talk, and talk frankly now before the Sun rises. For much more is at stake in our meeting than a stable or even a town.’

   At this he turned to Milo, his young servant, and gave him instructions to leave. ‘Go see to Caitelyn, Milo, and Benbow’s own pony as well, I think. If decent saddles can be found for each then pay whatever price is asked. But quietly, please. Make no show or talk of our leaving. Once this is done, take them out of town and away from sight beyond the hedge a league or so to the west and just north of the Road. Await us there.’

   ‘Yessir, I will,’ the young hobbit said, ‘and I’ll have another pony for me and some provisions ready as well.’

   ‘Not this time, my friend. You’ll be needed here and my own way looks long and uncertain,’ Collum replied with a smile to the youngster. ‘The Bree-land, and the Four Greenfields, will need a steady hand to watch things while I’m away. Tell no one where you are going, but have Buttercup attend us here with more drink and some paper after one hour is over.’

   ‘Yessir, I will, sir,’ Milo said in return as he hurried to the door. There, as if forgetting something, and blushing in a way that Ben had never seen the quiet young hobbit do before, he paused for a moment and looked back at the innkeeper. ‘You can count on me, sir. I’ll hold things down.’

   ‘I know it for certain,’ Collum said, and then Milo quickly hurried on his way.

   ‘Again we see that you have a gift for inspiring confidence, master Innkeeper,’ Olórin said as the hobbit left the room. ‘But it is said; Dolen pâd tur- still tul- estel na i lom bachor.’8

   ‘Ah! ”yet uncertain turns oft prove unwise”’9 Collum replied with a broad smile. ‘I am to be tested it seems. Very well. Pedathanc hi sui vellyn?10 This is just and wise, fathers, to ask that I know the Fair Speech, but I fear we shall have some time catching our friend Benbow up in this method. Though I suspect it might be easier for you, Beothalion,’ he said, turning to the wild man. ‘I apologize now for any insult I might have given you earlier in the commonroom, but the townsfolk here needed distraction for my own purposes and the arrival of you and your friend came at just that moment.’

   Here he turned his attention to the Elf, bowing at the waist and touching his palms to his brow, saying, ‘And I greet you, lord Tawarengil, when earlier I had no chance to do so properly. Ai! Le nathlof hí!11 Happy am I to learn that the Silvan Lords of Greatwood join with my own people against our enemies.’

   ‘Mae g'ovannen!’ Tawarengil replied. ‘You are courteous beyond my estimation and so I hope that you will forgive my earlier comments as well. But it is certain that you are no simple innkeeper!’

   It was Ben who now felt somewhat simple. He had known Collum for nearly a decade, had, after many long conversations, even come to think of him as a rare friend, but there was a change in the man’s manner now that seemed truer somehow than any behavior he had seen before. ‘I knew him to be keener than the rest of these Breelanders certainly, and more traveled too,’ Ben thought, ‘and he spoke some Elvish with my Rosie that one time, and had many long talks with that Dwarf who he looks after. Does he speak that Dwarvish talk as well? And now here he is as lordly as this young Elf or these old pilgrims. What is a man like that doing here in the Bree-land? And,’ Ben reminded himself, ‘more importantly, why did he send Milo for those saddles? One for each of us?’

   ‘Kaff! Kaff, kaff! Now excuse me for a fool, Collum,’ Ben interrupted, still coughing as he arose from the other side of the room to enter this very surprising conversation. ‘But I think- kaff, kaff! -I think I’d like an answer to that question more than most of these folks. Just who the blazes are you- kaff! -what is going on here, and just where do you think that you and I are going with that order for new saddles?’

 

*****

   ‘I’ve no time for truants,’ Flomi had muttered angrily as he wondered about the ponies. He was, it should be said, quite suspicious of their disappearance. But, having little time and the original intention of setting them loose anyway, he spent only a few moments looking for them.

   ‘I shall miss the opportunity to ride to the Foundations on such a long night,’ he thought to himself, ‘but they are likely more weary than I. Corlar, who I would take along, is smarter than most ponies and has probably hidden himself and his partners from further work.’

   ‘Very well then, my lazy friends,’ he said aloud into the night. ‘I wish you well with your new masters and, should you serve them more handily, I hope you will live long lives of less labor, that you will grow fat and old, and perhaps learn better obedience.’ At this he went back into the outer building and spread a good supply of feed into their open manger. He poured out fresh water into their troughs from the well and then, once more, went out into the yard to search for any sign of their appearance.

   He saw nothing.

   ‘Ghrrm,’ he muttered loudly and, shouldering his maddock, walked forward to his front gate. The moon was not so high and he hoped to make good speed away from the Bree-land before midnight.

 

*****

   Buttercup had seen Milo and Collum take food and drink to the outer hall and suspected that the other strangers were to be found there. ‘And Guldir,’ she thought. The women had taken poor Guldir there away from the street once they knew that the inn was safe. ‘His throat was cut, they say. Who in the Bree-land would do such a terrible thing to that kind man?’ she wondered.

   That indeed was the very thought that most of the tired Breelanders were having as they sat in the street, eating and drinking and talking and watching as the sun came up through the smoke of their ruined stables. Collum, through Buttercup and the cooks of the Four Greenfields, had set out as much as the fire-fighters might need or call for, but now, with the danger over and the spectacle still to be commented on, many new faces joined in the occasion. And as word spread to the waking folk of the town and just outside it, as smoke and signs of calamity met with occasions for gossip and perhaps a free breakfast, the number of the attendees grew quite as large as the number of buckets carried against the fearsome blaze. For what citizen, Hobbit or Big Folk, could wake before the Sun (as most did in those early days of Astron,12 when there was much work to be done) look toward their town’s center and not be curious about the great cloud of smoke which lingered there in the dead winds of this morning. People drew from far around, like wraiths in the haze, to discover what had happened. Rather than question their involvement Buttercup did her master’s bidding and made sure that all were provided for who gathered there under the Clock as the smoke lingered. It was not a feast exactly, for no Breelanders were so rude as to see death and destruction as an occasion for feasting, but it now had certainly become a gathering. And any gathering in the Bree-land quickly became a feast for rumours.

   Old Tom Truetunnels was back of course (though Buttercup saw no sign of soot nor ash on his face as she did many of the other younger hobbits), and he was ready as always to provide his own insights on the event. ‘I was not present myself, you see,’ said Tom, ‘for there is important work to be done at the well when fire comes and I’m one for that kind of work.’ (No one could quite recall Tom’s presence at the well during the night’s events, but few other than Buttercup seemed to think that should stand in the way of his venerable opinion.)

   ‘But some things seem clear to me even from the other side of town,’ he continued for all those who would listen. ‘The stable-master is murdered and his house set to flame. Who would do such a thing you may ask? Well, who was there last who is not here now? That’s what I’d be asking.’

   All the townsfolk assembled knew, or (more exactly) they had heard, that Flomi, the Dwarf stonemason, and his ponies, had departed hastily just before the fire had begun. It did not take much more than this first suggestion by the old-timer Truetunnels to make the Breelanders, suspicious as they were of any outsiders, forget that Flomi had lived among them as, if not quite a friend, then certainly a neighbour for thirty years. Busy as she was calling for more provision, Buttercup heard this nasty proclamation and turned hotly on it. There was, after such a long and terrible night, an anger and a resolve in her that was quite newly awakened and much beyond her usually quieter nature.

   ‘Now that,’ Buttercup said to the old hobbit, fists balled at her sides, ‘is perhaps the most stupid and unkind thing that I have heard you say, Mr Truetunnels, in a long list of your stupid and unkind sayings!’

   This was quite shocking to all those who heard it for Buttercup, favored by Collum as she was and by most accounts praised for her politeness, had never been known for speaking so hotly. She was tired, dog tired of course, and the death and the fire and the long hours of work and worry had taken much out of her patience and perhaps (as it seemed to her later) had left her with a different kind of energy than that which normally led her through long work days. Many long hours now she had kept herself working when fatigue or fear might have forced her away. ‘Because it is needed,’ she had kept telling herself, ‘not because it's my job or I need to do it, but because the work here in front of me needs doing and it would be wrong and selfish to walk away from it.’ And that feeling, more than the examples of Collum (whom she thought the bravest of Men) or Benbow (who had surprised her with the bravery of Hobbits), kept her going when she was tired and afraid or unsure of what might come next.

   ‘You are wrong and selfish to say such a thing,’ she continued, shaking with a bit of exhausted and indignant fury as she glared at Tom Truetunnels and the whole of the town seemed to be watching. ‘One neighbor who was our friend is dead, murdered it's been said, and another has gone missing, most probably in fear and flight. Just because he is gone you call him guilty? We, those of us who were here and close and worked hard against destruction, fought fire to save the town as neighbours do, or as they should do. Are you so in need of an opinion of things that you’ll forget Flomi was our neighbour as well?

   ‘I have listened to you long enough, Mr Truetunnels, and your meanness. I’m tired and scared for my friends here and all that we almost lost. And I’m scared for master Flomi, who was kinder than you have ever been and is now probably fleeing for his life from whoever tried to set this town to blaze. But, no matter Flomi’s fate, he is lucky to be gone from your own manner of meanness,’ she said, her rage subsiding, ‘a meanness that makes any folk doubt their neighbour, and makes the whole town all the poorer.’

   It was at this point that Buttercup looked about and saw so many of her townsfolk staring back at her, many with their mouths and eyes open awaiting more. They were hanging on her words, shocked at first by her surprising impertinence but, exhausted as they themselves were, ready for more of her frankness. ‘This is what being Collum must feel like,’ she thought in the moment, and that thought both excited and embarrassed her, for she realized this was the quality she admired most about the man; his ability to make people listen to and respect him.

   But she did not know what happened to Flomi of course, did not know how the fire at the stable had started, and did not have any idea about who might have killed poor gentle Guldir. Beyond scolding old Tom’s ignorance and malice in her own exhausted fury, she did not know what else to say to these people who sat waiting to hear more. And she would not do as old Truetunnells had done and offer empty opinions.

   Yet they continued to wait. She saw Bert Thistleberry, covered in ash and rubbing a tired foot, look up to what she might say next. Youngsters Andwise Brockhouse and Mungo Gawkroger sat by the base of the Clock tower in midbite of their cold sandwiches, mouths agape at her telling off the venerable old Truetunnels and anxious for more. Even the usually distant Ned Appledore took notice of her bold redress and Geoff Mallow, Guldir's sometimes stable hand who had never seemed to notice her before, seemed to smile at her newfound boldness.

   At the edge of her tired voice, holding her right hand aloft in a position that felt, well, accurate if not familiar, she cried out, ‘Lacho calad! Drego morn!’ just as Collum had taught her earlier and that same warm flush returned to her body, quieting her rage and calming her in her tiredness amidst the stares of her neighbors.

   But of course neither she, nor the very most of the Breelanders, had any idea what the words meant.

   None perhaps except Fern Sarnside and his one darkly-dressed remaining companion who sat well outside the gathering and whispered to themselves after her saying it.

 

*****

   ‘I have been an innkeeper here, certainly, Ben,’ Collum said to all of them as he took a seat by the fireplace, ‘and in that respect true to you and others in this town for all the time I have spent here.’ At this point he paused briefly and his dark eyes seemed to land on the winding sheet of Guldir, the murdered stable-master.

   ‘And I have tried to be both neighbour and friend, proprietor and consul, to these Breelanders and yourself with all the integrity I might while keeping my other purposes apart from those duties,’ he continued, looking up again at Ben. ‘But innkeeper is my guise and not my true service and I am sorry for any mistrust this ruse now revealed might cause between us. Particularly tonight when you and your Rosie have risked and suffered so much in the face of troubles which my own work here may have wrought.

   ‘Masters,’ he continued, ‘my time here in the Bree-land is ended and I come to you now largely out of thankfulness but also with some small hope for further assistance. I will depart shortly, and in all likelihood never return, for I am charged with a task that cannot be long delayed as it moves away from this formerly quiet hiding spot and onto the open road. Yet this little town and its foolish, honest folk will remain dear to me and tonight much of it might have perished without your involvement. Perhaps we may have business together elsewhere, for your arrival here on this day suggests as much, but my purposes and my way forward must remain guarded for a time. I will not explain them idly nor directly.

   ‘Yet each of you deserve much, perhaps more than my oath allows, so I will afford one question from each of you before we part. This, and whatever other kindness the Four Greenfields can offer, are yours until I am no longer its master and when our hour together is finished.’

   ‘Oh, this is no mere innkeeper indeed!’ said Olórin with a mighty laugh. ‘He traps us in our own inquisitiveness. One question each, but he uses it to take our measure! I like these Breelanders, and their consuls and their gamesmen,’ he said nodding to Collum and Benbow with a smile, ‘much more than I had anticipated. A chance-meeting once again proves to be nonsuch!’

   ‘Ben, you have asked me first,’ the not-such-an-innkeeper continued with his smile open and friendly, ‘and though it was in fact two questions, I’ll answer both in favor of our friendship.

   ‘I am not called Collum by others outside this town and took that name here only to serve other purposes. My true name is Ohtar and, though you may have guessed it already, I am not of the Bree-land but a soldier of old Arnor.

   ‘As to where you and I shall go next, I will not give our most direct route, but I will say that I need a guide in the Wildlands and you are the best that I know of. I have many reasons to hope that you will help me, some based upon the urgency of my task, but mostly because I am in need and believe you to be a friend incapable of abandoning a friend in need.

   ‘Does this answer your questions?’ the man said.

   ‘No innkeeper indeed, as the elf-lord here has said -kaff! Kaff!’ Ben replied looking Collum long in the face, ‘but I know you’re no scoundrel as the man I’ve known. I will want for more answers later, but you’re a right judge of folks to know I’ll not -kaff!- deny a friend in need.’

 

*****

   Some hours after leaving the stoneyard, Flomi had found and made surprisingly good time on the ancient pathway he had ridden with Collum just four days before. It ran on surprisingly even ground through the low hills and the trees on either side became younger and thicker as he moved westward. As the lane, if that is indeed what it had once been, went lower running down the fold of the hills there were many deep brakes of new grass on the rising slopes. If he could keep to it now that the moon had risen to light his way, he should make the glade of the Seven Birches by sunrise. Tree and stone were quiet all around him, his belly was full, and his pack was light. A dwarf such as he makes very good speed over open lands in these conditions and his need was great; for now that he was alone and in flight from danger, his mind grew wary and suspicious.

   It may very well have been the appearance of the young Elf that evening which had set things into motion, but Collum had thought that some newcomers to the Bree-land earlier, friends of the very inquisitive Fern Sarnside, were folk to watch. To this, Flomi readily agreed; for he had never liked Sarnside and had on many occasions thought the man watched Flomi and his work a little too carefully.

   ‘This may be so,’ Collum had said in response. ‘He is certainly wealthier in his spending than a modest tanner should be in the springtime, and surprising wealth is often a cause for suspicion. But I am satisfied to know that he is unlettered and so can have no idea of your true work. I suspect he has watched you for many years before I came here to the Bree-land, and so I have watched him steadily since.

   ‘No, our troubles are more recent, Flomi,’ Collum had said, ‘and though I’ve little doubt that Sarnside is part of them, he at least is the part I can fully understand.

   ‘Do you remember that visitor to the Four Greenfields last month? The one Gildur told me of?’ 

   ‘Aye, I do,’ Flomi had replied. ‘As you well know for asking me so often.’

 

   On the eleventh day of Rethe (March in our current calendars) the Bree-land had encountered a sudden and chilling rainstorm, one that all the Breelanders hoped was simply the last roar of a particularly harsh and dreadful winter. For in Blooting (which we call October) of the previous year the Witch-king had moved on Fornost and a rash of sharp winds, deep snows and crippling hailstorms had seemed to invade the North alongside him. In the early days of the new year, with Fornost overrun, the Breelanders then held their breath and waited to see what might come next.

   But Solmath (our February) turned mild and no news came from the North. Surprisingly few Northmen fled south along the Fornost Road through the Bree-land. Some dwarves that Flomi spoke to at this time claimed that Arvedui, King of Arthedain, had fled further north and west when the city fell, and the Witch-king’s forces and his magics had turned that way in the fullness of his wrath, making the Great Road safe for them again. They brought some small trade and some brighter chances down the Road with them. But by any reasons, theories or accounts, that late month of winter and its milder days gave the Breelanders a little hope that a troubling time filled with the wars of Men might well be behind them.

   Then, despite all hopes and with the beginning of Rethe a fierce mix of snow and stinging rain came out of the north and all the peoples surrounding Bree-hill hurriedly barred their doors against it. With the weather so hard, Flomi did not return to the stoneyard that morning as was his usual habit and stayed at the inn working beside the fire with a solid breakfast and, as the afternoon wore on, a good belly of wine.

   Collum was away then, for he had ridden out a day earlier on one excuse or another. None but Flomi knew that the man left each month to gather information on their secret cause, and not even Flomi knew where these short trips took him; but each month, even through the dangers of this past winter, Collum rode out of town and returned a day or two later with some secret news or scrap of a clue for the dwarf to examine.

   ‘I have always thought it significant that such a man as this rider would come while I was away,’ Collum had said to him those six nights before Flomi’s departure from the Bree-land. ‘I should have arranged my trips with more care and less regularity, had I thought there was anyone in the Bree-land to notice.’

   But on that particular day of the storm, as Collum was away and as Flomi was comfortably working beside the fire at the inn and all the rest of the Bree-land was shuttered against new troubles, a black rider had come to town.

 

*****

   Buttercup, having said her piece, turned her back on Tom Truetunnels and her other neighbors to go back toward the inn. ‘Might as easily stop the Moon13 changing his shape as keep these folk from talking,’ she told herself, ‘but I’ll sleep easier tonight saying what I have said.’

   Pansey and the other girls eyed her and smiled as she walked past and Buttercup could tell that they were surprised, and more than a little happy, for her outburst. At this she flushed again and it was then, exactly then, that she realized that their looks made her feel just the way Collum’s secret words had done. It was not like the flush of girlish desire (as when she first saw that young and beautiful Elf-lord), or an angry flush of righteous pride (for it certainly felt marvelous to speak her mind to mean old Mr Truetunnels), but something else entirely; something that she had no words for before tonight and was even now trying to put sense to.

   ‘What I said meant a thing,’ she concluded, ‘not just a thing to me, but to others. And in it being said other folks were with me, not just for me, but together with me and being together was...’ She didn’t have a word yet big enough for what that meant to her. ‘It was like being part of a song,’ she ventured, but even that did not quite feel deep enough.

   As she reached the porch of the inn, Milo, from the shadows within the building, motioned her to enter.

   ‘Why are you lurking here, Milo?’ Buttercup said. ‘Don’t tell me that something else has happened, for I’ve not a scrap of strength left to do much about it. Where is Collum? Does he need something else for the Elf-lord and those other strangers?’

   ‘He told me to come find you, miss,’ Milo said in a low voice. Though he was actually more than a few years older than Buttercup, Milo had always referred to her graciously, as ‘miss’ or ‘mistress’ rather than by her own name. She found this behaviour sweet in the young hobbit. He did not talk to people much other than Collum, Pansey and herself, and treated all three with a special kind of dignity. ‘Our master wants you to come to him in the outer hall bringing more drink and some paper for him and Benbow and those five other worthies. After an hour of the clock has gone. Not before, mind you. They seem to have some private talk to be doing.

   ‘I’m to be off now and to be quiet about it,’ he continued, glancing around from his place in the shadowed doorway. ‘There is, as you put it, something else tonight, and our work is not over for many hours it seems. You’ll need to find more of that strength, mistress, for he has need of those that he can trust and we seem to be all the fewer this morning!’

 

*****

   ‘Thank you, Ben. I will answer all that I may when I may, but your friendship does me honor.

   ‘So one questioner is appeased,’ Collum said, taking up the mugs Milo had poured and passing them around to his guests. ‘And the morning rises. Would that you may rest after the night’s work, but Ben and I cannot tarry. We must leave when the hour is finished. Who,’ he said, taking a short drink of the wine, ‘shall ask the next question?’

   None spoke immediately. The wizards seemed to engage one another again through long glances and the young Elf-lord, looking their way, seemed content to let them decide. It was the wild man, Beothalion, who broke the silence.

   ‘I would still very much like to know, Innkeeper,’ he said, ‘what drink those other three friends had earlier and where I might find some of it.’

   At this Tawarengil scowled, Ben looked puzzled and the three wizards showed a calm hint of surprise (if that is something they ever truly felt). Collum could not help but laugh a little and smile broadly at the big man.

   ‘Do not think your friend has wasted a question, lord,’ he said to Tawarengil. ‘He speaks with haste and appetite, but his question falls near to the mark of what I suspect you yourself might ask.

   ‘For the thing he speaks of, that his surprisingly keen nose (and no doubt your own) noticed was indeed Miruvor, the cordial of Imladris, that hidden land which you were discussing. Fearing troubles earlier this evening and wondering at what strange turn of fate brought three wizards to the Bree-land amidst those troubles, I carefully used a small portion of that precious spirit to enlist their aid or, at the very least, their notice.’

   ‘That you certainly gained,’ replied Olórin, ‘for not lightly does the dew of that hidden valley come to be shared in the wider world.’ At this the grey-clad figure and Collum watched one another for a moment; each taking the measure of the other’s words.

   But no question followed from the old man, so Collum, nodding his head at the subtlety, continued.

   ‘I apologize, my friend,’ he said as he returned his talk to Beothalion, ‘after your bravery tonight I would gladly offer you some of the cherished drink, but it is no longer with me here at the inn. It has been moved in preparation for my departure. But who can say? Perhaps we will have other chance-meetings?’

   ‘You have been very kind, innkeeper,’ the wild man said, ‘being as you are one of the first Men I have met on this side of the mountains. And,’ he said, lifting and smelling his mug, ‘your own wine is very pleasing on my dry throat. I should be glad to drink with you whenever we meet!’ At this he drained his vessel and Collum, raising his own in kind, did the same.

   ‘I myself should like to know how you came by such a treasure,’ Tawarengil asked in the moment after. ‘For not even in the halls of Thranduil do we have this elixir in store, though its property and its history is well-known to all the Elves. How is it that you, innkeeper or not, have gained such favor of the Lord of Imladris?’

   ‘Ah,’ Collum said, turning to the Elf but refilling his own drinking cup. ‘The third questioner speaks.’

 

*****

   In the hazy dawn light, aided by some lingering smoke and the tired eyes of sleepless fire-fighters who were now busy with their breakfasts and their rumours, Milo Fastknots was able to quietly leave the inn and round up the animals. Caitelyn, his master’s horse, would not leave the nearness of the inn without Collum and, to his great luck, Ben’s own fat white pony had seemed to take a liking to the great grey mare. Coming out the door on the west side of the building he saw them standing there together, as if they had been summoned, on the northern side of the Clock tower and away from assembled townsfolk.

   The Clock was rather close to the Hedge here as Breelanders were not entirely certain of the tower’s ownership. The Hedge came quite close to its western base and provided a kind of close shelter away from the smoke which the animals seemed to enjoy.

   The pony, he knew from experience, was skittish of strangers, but Caitelyn knew Milo’s hand well and shinnied up to him as soon as he approached. She still wore her halter, and the hobbit could see where it had been chewed at and then eventually cut to save her from the fire. ‘Thanks be to that,’ he thought, ‘for she’s too great a creature for me to lead otherwise.’ He patted her great head as it came down to meet him, and he took the lead in his hand wondering now what to do about the pony.

   ‘She’s not saddled nor bridled and I don’t think she lets anyone but Ben ride her,’ he thought, looking hesitantly at the creature who, from what he could tell, looked him over with the same distrust.

   ‘You’re a lovely, great grey giant you are, Caitelyn, and I’m grateful to see you both saved from the fire,’ he said aloud to his master’s horse who stood by him willingly. ‘But how do we make your friend here trust me?’

   ‘Oh, she’s a smart one, there,’ a woman’s voice answered from behind him. He had not seen her earlier in all the haze and smoke, but she was resting against the tower base and also away from the gathering. She sat there calmly and breathing deeply, and Caitelyn seemed to stir gently at her voice. The woman’s dark hair was loose from long labor, her garments were black with soot and, while he was not sure of where he had seen her before in the town, Milo recognized her as the first person he had heard raise the alarm over the fire at the stable. She was an outlier perhaps, from the growing areas around the Chetwood and Archet, but she still had a familiar look on her that Milo could not quite place and he rubbed his tired, smoke-filled eyes in hope of remembering her better. But nothing came to his mind at that time.

   ‘She’s the one saved this town from the fire, should you ask me,’ the woman said, standing easily and looking quite taller than he had at first imagined. ‘Saw her burst from the stables prancing and shouting for all to come. She’s a smart one and knows your talk, for certain,’ she said, wiping her face and coughing quietly. ‘You just ask and see.’ And at this she left Milo and melted off into the haze towards the south side of the Clock tower.

   ‘Well, alright then,’ Milo said. He turned to speak to his master’s horse while pitching his voice for the pony to hear. ‘Caitelyn, we’re to be going. For your master has need of you and has sent me to do his will. So I’ll lead you now and I’d appreciate it much if you’d help me and tell your friend here likewise.’

   At this he turned his eye back on Benbow’s pony and said, ‘and, if you’re truly listening, your master wants you as well, girl. Saving the town was good work, if that’s you what done it, but you’re needed for more. We three will not see much rest before the morning is long, but there’s work to be done. C’mon, now, if you’re listening!’

   And at this he took Caitelyn’s reins and going wide west of the tower turned down the lane toward the Great Road and the Hedge-gate on the town’s western side. His back was sore and stiff but, as best he could manage, his posture was commanding. Milo was no horsemaster, but he knew that strength and resolution in manner, something his own master had such great supply of, was needed to lead anyone; horse or neighbour. He tried not to weaken and look back. Caitelyn came easily in his hand, letting off a loud neighing of complacency or, he hoped, some suggestion for the pony to follow.

   Bravely continuing forward, Milo did not look back to see what the pony would do and walked many yards in this way not knowing if he had fulfilled his master’s wishes. But his ears were sharp as any hobbit’s, and he heard uncertain movement behind him.

   As he turned from the lane into the Road he looked back to see Benbow Floxleaf’s white pony following, hesitantly, at her own proud distance.

   ‘Now to find those saddles,’ he thought, rubbing again his tired and smoke-filled eyes.

 

*****

   ‘I fear that my answer may be less fulfilling than you might wish for, Lord,’ Collum said to the Elf-child, ‘for it seems you have an interest in being guided to Rivendell and this I cannot do.

   ‘Do not mistake me,’ he continued, holding up his palm, ‘for I understand your need and your cause. But my own way lies elsewhere. And master Floxleaf has agreed to accompany me, so another potential guide has also abandoned you. Perhaps there are others you might beseech,’ and at this he looked again at Olórin, but the old wizard did not speak.

   ‘Yet it is my history with Rivendell which was your question and, I fear, that may also prove disappointing,’ he said. ‘Like Benbow, I have been to the Hidden Valley on two occasions in my life, on other business. It would not be accurate to say that I have “the favor of the Lord of Imladris” as you put it. More so that my family has enjoyed that distinction for many generations past. The Miruvor was given as a gift to the one I serve and my family has carried some portion of that gift for 245 years.’

   At the mention of this amount of years, Collum’s gaze left the young Elf-lord and went again to the three wizards. If they made any notice of this certain date, they did not remark upon it to the others.

   ‘Moreover, though it is not specific to your question, Lord,’ Collum continued, addressing again the Elf with a grave manner, ‘I will offer something of my own insights on Rivendell;

   ‘Elrond will not ride out. He mourns the loss of Arnor, but has placed little trust in the North Kingdom since its sundering. Arvedui and Fornost and the kingdom of Arthedain are shadows to him of his former friendships and he views their loss with regret but, I fear, little involvement; he will not risk his own to protect a thing which he feels that Men have already abandoned. He is aware that this move by the Witch-king cuts him off from the Grey Havens, his people in Lhûn, and the way to the West. This he will look to remedy, and maybe the help of you and your Silvan kindred will aid in this. But he will not ride out as a defender of Man’s lost causes.

   ‘And who should?’ Collum said with a smile, taking another drink of the wine and offering more to his guests. ‘What other hope can we the folk of the North have,’ he said looking at Olórin, ‘unless others should come to our aid?’

 

*****

   ‘An hour to wait,’ Buttercup thought after her talk with Milo. ‘The way I feel now, I should be asleep if I stood in waiting that long. So. Busy hands are wakeful hands,’ she told herself and went back into the commonroom to see what quality stores she might still gather there for Collum and his guests.

   The room was just as it had been, still a mess from folk who had left it in their haste to fight the fire, so she started by gathering up the drinking mugs and tidying things a bit. She raised the long stools that had been overturned. She threw open the shutters to allow the hazy light of morning on her work. She noticed again the missing pack and longsword from behind the counter and, thinking of Milo’s words, knew with a certainty that Collum must be leaving for a long time. That he had, in fact, been prepared to leave since midday before and well in advance of the fire.

   ‘It’s not just Guldir’s killer or Flomi’s flight that worries him,’ she now realized, ‘for he was packed and ready long before. And with a sword beside him! Will he tell where he’s going? Would he have told me before all of this fire and death had happened?’

   She had no idea. Trusted though she may be, most of Collum’s ways were still as much a mystery to her as they were to the rest of the Breelanders. But she had given up on waiting for him to reveal them. Her job, for which she was grateful, was to keep a careful eye on his needs and manage to match them as she might.

   There were still some bottles of Shire winyard she had not taken out to the Firefighter’s Feast of Tongue-wagging (for this is how she had come to think of the party outside that was now abusing her master’s neighborliness) and these could be easily brought to Collum and his guests in the outer hall. ‘Paper now,’ she thought, ‘Well, that’s a harder thing. There’s some in the front room, I think, but those are scraps for bills-of-sale and surely not fitting to any use with that Elf-lord or those three older gentlemen involved. I should think of a finer paper than that, and,’ she told herself rubbing her eyes to keep herself awake, ‘and I should find it now while I’ve the time and the sense to do it in.’

   She rummaged through the shelves and stacks at Collum’s serving area first, for she felt she had more place there than in his own quarters. As she thought, there were but a few scraps of birch vellum to be found there, but not very suitable to the kind of finery that Elves and other lordly gentlemen might require.

   ‘Perhaps they are using it to draw some wonderful map for some very great errand or, even, imagine if they are recording some song or story on this paper before they depart. Oh, how wonderful that would be!’ She thought. ‘I can’t bring him scraps of rough barks for such finery.’

   Collum had no other private space at the inn other than his quarters. Curious as she was about this room, Buttercup did not believe paper, paper like the kind she wanted, could be found there. Her master had never been seen to work on the inn’s accounting far from his serving area. She had a mind to visit his room on this pretext (serving her curiosity more than her task) but, sensing Collum’s impending departure, she worried that it would already be empty.

   ‘But Flomi has also gone hastily. Would his room be empty?’ she thought. ‘And I know where to find the key.’

 

   None of the staff of the inn were allowed to visit and clean the stonemason’s room without Collum present. This was a long known (and greatly spoken-of) tradition at the Four Greenfields and it had gone some way in generating the rumour of the dwarf’s wealth. Collum himself had a key that was used to let in one of the maids when the room needed tending each week, but he promptly locked it as soon as the task was completed. None of the maids could attest to any store of gold and gems there, only that the room was a mess with books and, more to Buttercup’s immediate needs, a scattering of papers. If the key was kept somewhere other than in the innkeeper’s pocket, none could attest to that either.

   Until last week, when Collum had suddenly ridden off on business for the day. Flomi was also out at first light, and it was Milo Fastknots who came to let the maid in to clean the room. As the story went among the inn’s employees there was some great confusion then, for Dilly Mugwort, the hobbit-girl to whom this task was usually given, saw that many of the books and chests were now gone, and she was worried that she would be blamed when her master returned.

   ‘“Now, don’t you have no worry of that,” he tells me,’ or so Dilly had recounted to all the other girls later that afternoon, imitating Milo’s quick and impatient way of speaking. ‘“What a Dwarf does with his things is no business of ours,” he says, and, “I’ll make sure the master knows you did your job and nothing more,” he says as well, and so I did.” Dilly had made this clear to Buttercup and the others. ‘I went in with clean sheets and a clean broom, a clean mop and clean pails with clear waters for washing. I came out with nothing but dirty sheets, dirty pails, dirty mops and dirty waters, and I showed them all to our young master Fastknots there at the doorway just to be certain.’

   As to Dilly’s own great adventure, Buttercup had no interest whatsoever. But the idea that Collum had entrusted Milo with this very important key was much more interesting indeed. Later that same day, as Collum had not yet returned and Buttercup was preparing the commonroom for its usual collection of townsfolk, she saw Milo back in the service area, the top of his brown fuzzy head just over the counter and his hands beneath it.

   ‘Early yet for you to be at the barrels, Milo,’ she had said, ‘even if the master’s away.’

   ‘Oh! Heavens, not me, mistress,’ he said, looking quickly over the ledge and pulling his hands away, stammering just a bit like a boy caught in a lie. ‘I just... needed this... this knife here,’ he said, picking up a small paring knife that his eyes lit upon.

   ‘Well, then,’ she said, ‘just have it back before it's missed. Now go out! Collum’s still not back and I’ve much to do getting ready before folks start wanting more of this place than paring knives.’ He withdrew right away, without the knife, and she watched him go with a smile.

   Now, standing behind the high counter where she had then stood talking with Milo a week ago, Buttercup bent down low and in the dim light of morning saw an iron key hanging on a small hook far to the back where no one would find it.

   No one, of course, who did not know where to look.

 

*****

   ‘You give us many interesting things to consider, whether it comes from an innkeeper or a soldier,’ Tawarengil said, ‘But not so many answers. I welcome your opinion, and it matches with some of the thinking of my own People. But I do not see that there is much which you mean for us to learn by your responses nor advice to be taken in hearing them.’

   ‘Indeed?’ laughed Collum. ‘And this surprises you? Is it not said; go not to the Elves for counsel, for they will say both no and yes? Elves, and other wise folk that I have know, seldom give unguarded advice, for advice is a dangerous gift to both parties.14 No, I have answered each question fairly, lord, as I promised, and did I not say that I have not the liberty to reveal all my purposes?’

   ‘Aye, that is true, Tawar,’ Beothalion said. ‘You cannot blame the rain for small drops just because you are thirsty.’

   ‘So, fathers,’ Collum said, turning back to the three old men, ‘what would you who are so wise ask of me before we part?’

The three looked at one another for a moment and then Alatar, the taller of the two blue-clad figures, spoke up.

   ‘You have not told us much that we did not already surmise, Ohtar,’ he said, ‘other than that honorable name which you were given outside this guise. And I also would guess that it is your true name and so tells some people, some rare few, of your lineage. Your free revealing of such a name in these circumstances speaks well, very well indeed, of your intentions.

   ‘Of your use of the Old Tongue, of your knowledge of lord Elrond and of Imladris, these things too were not outside our reckoning. For, as you said, the sharing of miruvor in so strange a setting drew our attention if not quite our confidence.

   ‘Indeed, there is little that you have said thus far that served our purpose rather than did serve your own, should we examine the results; you have enlisted a guide that you needed,’ he said indicating Benbow, ‘made a peaceful connection with two strangers who might have reason to doubt you,’ at this gestured towards Tawarengil and Beothalion, ‘and drawn all six of us travelers together, trusting, into a room with you where we might each reveal our own courses.

   ‘So I commend you on your statecraft,’ he continued, ‘for it seems clear from more than just the serving girl’s oath-speaking that the blood of the Three Houses is strong in your line. No, there is but one thing you have said tonight that is news to me and that might precipitate a question with useful answers.’

   ‘I thank you for your kindnesses and commend your observations, Oldfather,’ Collum said. ‘But, unless my ears were too flattered by all of these, I have not yet heard a question.’

   ‘Hah!’ Olórin let out a quick laugh at this clever response.

   ‘You have named yourself as “a soldier of old Arnor”,’ Alatar continued without paying attention to his friend’s laughter. ‘And that is a kingdom long fallen. That you do not call yourself a “lord” or a “knight” or some other title intrigues me, for I have been told that there are few left who would claim allegiance to “old Arnor” who then do not hesitate to make some great proclamation of their worthiness. Certainly one can learn much from the histories of knights and lords as they are recorded in books and learned in song, but it seems to me that it takes a soldier’s perspective to know a battle, and its effects, all the better.

   ‘So,’ he said, pausing for a moment to let the seriousness of his question register on the man, ‘for my own purposes rather than yours, Ohtar, tell me how stands old Arnor these days for its People?’

   Collum looked long on the old man for this and Benbow, quite stifled by all that earlier bit about lords and statecraft, felt the tension run out of the innkeeper’s body.

   ‘I thank you again, father, for allowing me words that I do not need to measure so carefully,’ he said. ‘And I hope that my insights can prove worthy to your purpose.

   ‘The condition of the North Kingdom at this time is sufficiently miserable.15 King Arvedui of Arthedain, the accepted descendent of Elendil the Tall, is absent and in exile from the land by the onslaught of the cruel and perfidious Witch-king in Angmar. Even the very place of this king’s exile is uncertain, and his fate but very imperfectly known to the generality of his subjects who are, in the meantime, a prey to every species of oppression.

   ‘Arvedui, amidst whatever other claims, is himself but a short breath in the lungs of the great house of Isildur, Elendil’s heir. Three sons Arvedui has who are as misguided without him as the North country has been for some time. For wherever this exiled king may now be he is also the fourteenth successor of Eärendur the Foolhardy, who, some 1100 years ago, fractured the kingdom among his own three sons, rather than steer a truer, older course of estate. At that time, with the lands mostly emptied by the Great War and the sundering from our own kin away to the south in Gondor, three new flags arose from Eärendur’s squabbling sons to further divide our unhappy people; Arthedain, under Amlaith (who is grandsire to this unfortunate Arvedui), Rhudaur under one of his brothers, Tarondor, and Cardolan under yet another who was named Valandor. Also at this time the numerous class of lawless resolutes, once lordly but now impoverished in substance and hardened in character, roamed between the kingships, selling their swords and their honor and placing their hopes of harvest in civil commotion.

   ‘To these causes of distress in those days must be added the number of outlaws who, driven to despair by oppression, banded together in large gangs and, keeping possession of the forests and the wastes of our once vital land, set at defiance of these petty kingships. So for generations the nobles themselves, each fortified within their own castles, played petty sovereign over all that was within their reach and each of these three kings held lesser and lesser control throughout their wider regions.

   ‘Under the various burdens imposed by this state of affairs, the Witch-king came full to power in Angmar,’ he said. At this a shadow came over him and the room was silent.

   ‘Would you still say more?’ Alatar asked.

   ‘I will, Oldfather, and I do not count this as a second question,’ Collum said, collecting his thoughts and smiling a bit slyly while taking another small sip of his wine. ‘For you have asked me of how the North Kingdom stands today and I have, as yet, only offered insights on histories that you may already know.’

   ‘The histories, yes,’ said Olórin, ‘but the insights are welcomed. For you talk of the land as divided yet still one, and this is refreshing to my ears.’

   ‘I have always seen it so,’ Collum replied, ‘though my neighbors here in the Bree-land would be surprised to hear it said. I have traveled much for my oath and my People, and I believe that we Northmen feel some kinship with the land that our brothers to the South do not share. Great cities and great buildings have Men wrought throughout Middle-earth, and we take great pleasure in these works of hearth and hand. Yet to a Man of Arnor Evendim, the Lake of Twilight, is long in our memories, recalling as it may different shores of our forgotten past. There Elendil, after his flight from the wrathful Sea and the fall of Númenor, built his majestic and brooding city of Annúminas overlooking the calm and pale waters. It has since been abandoned in our strife and as our People have dwindled since the Great War. Yet to a Northman the image of peace and restfulness is not found solely in that lost city but remains in our hearts as a scene of a clear sunrise over cold, still waters.

   ‘We shall not depart these lands, bitter though our plight becomes, for brighter halls as other Men might, nor shall we stand to see them long divided by kinstrife,’ he continued. ‘For to us the land itself is Man’s solace from long travels and many turmoils.

   ‘Yet we were too few to hold these open lands after Isildur’s time and we are fewer now. The grand halls of our great kings are now wasted, and if the sight of the land still gives us comfort it comes with a deeper remorse.’

   ‘We have visited some of these halls of the Númenóreans,’ Alatar said. ‘Their escutcheons have long since mouldered from the walls of their castles. Their castles themselves are but green mounds and shattered ruins: the places that once knew them, know them no more, and this is not unfamiliar- nay, many a race before theirs has died out and been forgotten in the very land which they occupied16 and if the land here echoes your remorse it gives little sign of compassion.’

   ‘But hard lands breed hardy folk, and not all of them wholesome,’ Collum continued. ‘If the forests and empty plains were given over to outlaws from desperate means in our decline it was, perhaps three hundred years after Eärendur, that the more embittered Men and Orcs and other creatures of evil inclination were, as if by some long-remembered and unexplained impulse, drawn to the northernmost peak of the Misty Mountains in the far desolate corner of Elendil’s old kingdom.

   ‘Then, strangely in the midst of hostility between kings who should be kin, the open lands became safe for any who might dwell in them and folk left the remaining large cities to better opportunities. Armies, once needed for protection of these fertile but formerly dangerous lands, became naught other than trains of extravagant display for braggart lords and the men of quality left their service of these three petty kings to protect old homelands which they had not visited in generations. Some, homeless but truer to their heart’s calling than most, wandered freely on solitary missions through the North to ensure that order was kept in an otherwise empty land where these petty kingships held no sway.

   ‘Yet the relative peace this seemed to bring only made matters worse for the North,’ he continued. ‘For as the three kingdoms squabbled, each trying to claim their own importance to an emptying land of farmers more in need of a local market than a high king, Arthedain, Cardolan and Rhudaur grew more separate from one another and likewise from the stability brought by intercourse with our kinfolk in Gondor. Grass began to grow long over the South Road and few in our land looked that way for commerce, friendship, or even tidings of the larger world.

   ‘This seeming calm lasted for a generation or so and the hearts of Men within the courts of these three nations were turned to greed and malice. Some in Rhudaur, it is said, fell into the practice of dark sorceries, old rituals which never came over the Sea with Elendil or his folk but were somehow learned again. It is believed that the Witch-king, having openly announced his presence at the edge of our old lands during the reign of Malvegil in Arthedain,17 had been infiltrating the neighboring courts of Rhudaur and Cardolan for many years, his agents sowing great dissent between these kingdoms and sponsoring skirmishes which would further set them at odds. When Malvegil died, his son took the old Adûnaic name of Argeleb, the Silver King, claiming again dominion of the old North Kingdom and offered open hostilities with Angmar and Rhudaur. He went with all force to the aid of neighboring Cardolan and saved many of those people so that some of the land was again united.’

   ‘Argeleb the First was indeed a brave king, if not far-sighted,’ Olórin said. ‘Many good folk of the North were emboldened by his example and drew forth to his banner. I was sad to hear of his fall in the Weather Hills, but he lacked the strength of numbers to assail Angmar.’

   ‘This is true, Oldfather,’ Collum replied, taking another small sip of the wine, ‘or so our histories report. He never saw his way to the gates of the Red Maw,18 but he did indeed kindle the spirit of the Northmen in ways that had not been done since Isildur’s days. His son Arveleg was wiser perhaps, and held much of the Northlands for fifty years before the Battle of Amon Sûl.’

   ‘Kaff! I’m sorry if I’m interrupting, Collum,’ Ben said, coughing now more for the chance to speak than out of other distress, ‘and I’ll ask this gentlemen here rather than risk another question of you if I must, but that old battle in the North Hills was five hundred years ago or more.’19 At this he turned toward Olórin and asked rather frankly, ‘what do you old gentlemen know of that and, well, just how old are you?’

   Olórin smiled at this, whether from the frankness of the question or from the directness of the questioner or, perhaps, some older memory. Then, briskly, he said, ‘to answer your second question first, master Floxleaf, I am no older than my mission here makes me and none the younger for this lengthy night of inquiries. As to the first question, which is much more useful to our purposes, I had some personal involvement with Arveleg’s flight from Amon Sûl20 before I departed for the South. Perhaps,’ he said, looking toward Collum with a questioning eye but carefully not phrasing his statement in a questioning manner, ‘perhaps this is known to some in the North who have not had their heads in holes for those hundreds of years.’

   ‘Hah! Now that is harsh, father,’ Collum said with a laugh. ‘Ben and his sires are not like other hobbits and live on the open lands unlike the tunnelers and bolted-door shopkeepers of this town. And they have lived in these wider lands for many long years, just one quick and quiet step away from darkness and battles and plagues and much distrustfulness. Their memories may not be long, but their eyes have been more open than most.

   ‘Of your own involvement at Amon Sûl I was unaware,’ he continued, ‘though I doubt it not. Much was lost on that day, but much more and worse might have happened if fortune, or some other aid, had not interceded. For the Red Maw was opened for the first time then and all the great numbers of Angmar poured forth into our lands. Here were all the old enemies of the North that had collected there, and multiplied while we thought the lands were safe and as the petty kingdoms squabbled. Then our troubles came forth. Orcs and Wolf-riders, now in great strength of numbers, sorcerous Men and wild folk who had come to despise the legacy of Númenor, Trolls and even Drakes came forth under the banner of the Pale Sword as Carn Dûm was emptied and all of the North was set to be despoiled. Amon Sûl was razed and Cardolan ravaged and the Witch-king rode across all the land to a great siege at Fornost Erain. Arveleg died in this year and it seemed that the North would now be lost.

   ‘But Arveleg was a king wiser than most and had shown a gift of far-sightedness. Renewing old bonds, he had sent his son and heir, Araphor to the Havens to be reared by Cirdan. This act, and the boy’s own good nature, had much effect upon the Elves of Lindon. On word of his father’s death Araphor, still a boy of eighteen, rode out with a great Elf-host at his side and broke the siege at Fornost.’

   ‘Glorfindel himself led these armies, I have heard,’ Tawarengil added, ‘and it was a very great host indeed that retook those lands. But the greater force that set Angmar back came from Imladris and Elrond himself rode in the vanguard.’

   ‘Yes,’ Collum replied, ‘or so I have also heard. Rivendell, and even the Golden Kingdom21 recognized the threat and pushed the Witch-king back to his fortress in the Hithaeglir. Though no siege was possible, for the land is mightily cruel and desolate there. But for a time he was subdued. Silent, brooding perhaps on victories that eluded him, diminished, or so it seemed, but still the Witch-king was not broken. Halted, but still waiting.’

   ‘Is this Witch-king deathless, Tawar, as your People are?’ Beothalion asked.

   ‘I do not know, brother,’ the Elf replied. ‘It may be so. Often the great evils of the world are so, and this Carn Dûm rises at the very edge of the broken fortress of Arda’s oldest evil. Perhaps, as some old dark creature awake again from the Elder Days, he comes fresh into these lands from some deep pocket of shattered Thangorodrim to do terrible works of malice upon those who overthrew his Master. Perhaps this malice and vengeance have granted him many powers over age and diminishment. It is not known. But mortal, as you are brother, this enemy is not.’

   ‘Grace! But this is better talk for a brighter morning,’ Ben said, opening the shutters wider.

   Collum sighed softly and continued. ‘There are as many theories of the Witch-king’s nature as there are foes of his actions. In this way many of us who might join to oppose him are conflicted. And by this conflict his powers grow wider.

   ‘The young king Araphor re-took much of the Northland and held it in peace for 180 years. Rhudaur was gone, and Cardolan was nearly empty, any claim of its lineage shattered, as so it became vassal-land to Arthedain. The North was Arnor again, even if they still lacked the political integrity and force of numbers to call it so. Araphor’s friendship with the Eldar brought trade and some relative safety from the lands surrounding Fornost and to the West towards Lindon. Dwarves walked the East-West Road again. The Elves, feeling their passage West safe for a time, returned to their meditations. Your own folk, Benbow,’ Collum said, ‘flourished well in this time in the North. So well in fact that they petitioned the King at Fornost for lands of their own across the Brown River. Peace returned and brought some hope with it. And still the Witch-king waited.

   ‘In 1636 the Dark Plague swept all the Western Lands. It was worse in the denser cities of the South, or so I have been told, but many of my People of old Arnor perished and the lands were further emptied. Here many of our hopes foundered. The folk of Cardolan vanished almost entirely and for over one hundred years Wights wandered the lonely hills from Tyrn Gorthad to the North Downs east of Fornost. Many feared to travel then, and even the Great East- West Road was vacant and grass began to overgrow some of its path. The North became silent and its People withdrew from their cities to lonely places. Even the Bree-land, quite usually resistant to such troubles, was nearly emptied. Fornost Erain, under Argeleb the Second and his son Arvegil, worsened the matter and shut their wide gate permitting no one, under penalty of death, for one hundred years. If the lands had been won back from the Witch-king in Araphor’s time then they were emptied, poisoned and neglected in the three generations which followed him. And still the power in Angmar waited.

   ‘Now as I have said,’ Collum continued, ‘hard lands breed hardy folk and many, other than the Dúnedain, have claimed this lonesome land for their own. The Hobbits are of stronger stuff than most credit them and the lands between the Baranduin and Mithlond, remaining peaceful as it did, sustained much of the North. The doors of Fornost were eventually opened again, trade resumed on the Roads and relations were opened once more with our kin to the South. In 1940 Arvedui of the North (if not exactly king of Arnor) wed Fíriel, daughter of Ondoher of Gondor and our future looked brighter for a time. ’

   ‘And now our tale shifts South it seems,’ said Olórin, interrupting their host, ‘and, if I’m any judge of accents through my travels, our Ohtar here, I should say, has spent much time there himself and there is much he might say about Arvedui and his claim of the Throne of Men.’

   Collum looked at him gravely and said, ‘is that to be your question, Oldfather?’

   ‘Hold!’ the old man said quickly, raising his hand to Collum’s eager eye, ‘for I know this game too well! I simply mean to offer my observation to our fellows and do not give that as another question here. No, our time here together grows short, I think, and I’m not one to squander your useful tokens in haste, soldier. Of the failed bond between the North and South Kingdoms of Men I know much. For when Gondor’s king Ondoher and his sons died then Arvedui of the North Kingdom laid his claim and it was said, “Elendil had two sons, of whom Isildur was the elder and the heir of his father. We have heard that the name of Elendil stands to this day at the head of the line of Kings of Gondor, since he was accounted the high king of all lands of the Dúnedain. While Elendil still lived, the conjoint rule in the South was committed to his sons; but when Elendil fell, Isildur departed to take up the high kingship of his father, and committed the rule in the South in like manner to the son of his brother. He did not relinquish his royalty in Gondor, nor intend that the realm of Elendil should be divided forever.” But Gondor rejected this claim and answered by naming a king of their own.’

   ‘And it was also said,’ Collum replied, ‘“Moreover, in Númenor of old the sceptre descended to the eldest child of the king, whether man or woman. It is true that the law has not been observed in these lands of exile ever troubled by war; but such was the law of our people, to which we now refer, seeing that the sons of Ondoher died childless...”’

   ‘Hah! Wonderful news indeed!’ Olórin exclaimed, leaping to his feet with renewed energy and clapping his hands in a robust manner that the others found surprising, ‘I will now interrupt your history lesson if I may, Alatar.

   ‘My friends,’ he said, looking at his fellow travelers and the Elf and the wildman and even poor confused Benbow, ‘This is indeed a propitious meeting to be had on a day in which we all may have doubted our courses! This soldier of Arnor has much to conceal,’ he said, placing his hand on Collum’s shoulder, ‘but still much involvement in our own concerns. Ask him no more for the time, Pallando,’ he said, turning to his quietest companion, ‘for we will save that boon for a time when it may reward us all better through our better trust.

   ‘He may, given the opportunity, report much more than any other you might meet on the subject of Arvedui’s remaining forces. Perhaps he knows if the sons of the king have joined with Círdan yet or even have some plans of their own to rescue their father. For I believe that this man has eyes and ears at his service well beyond the Little Folk of this town and those who travel through it.’ Here he raised his own cup to the innkeeper, who watched him with a cool and wary expression.

   ‘In the meanwhile I will offer my own question to speed our fellowship;

   ‘Ohtar, son of Ohtar, servant of the secret lineage and riddle-solver and protector,’ he said, turning his frank, grey eyes upon the man’s face, ‘how might we aid you?’

 

*****

   The door was ajar when Buttercup got there, and that was the most frightening thing she had encountered in all this long night of terrible surprises. She stood there staring at it for a moment; so odd a thing to see this so private a room left open to anyone with the only key that she knew of pressed in her own frightened hand. She was uncertain what to do next, and quieted herself, watching.

   ‘The bolt is not broken,’ she thought, looking at the small gap of the doorway. ‘Someone got in without forcing it. With another key? Is Flomi here and not fled as we all think?’ Every wisdom in her body, instincts of flight and fear that she’d learned to control or rely upon in her time here serving men at the inn, told her that there was danger in this open door and that she should flee immediately and seek help. But she had hoped to be better than her own fears and had, in fact, just spent a difficult time chastising her own neighbors for giving into them.

   ‘I should like to see what the fuss is in here,’ she thought, ‘and I should like to think I’m strong enough to see to it myself.’ So quietly, hesitantly, she stepped forward and placed her hand on the door. ‘Lacho calad! Drego morn!’ She whispered under her breath as she opened the door and moved into the room.

 

*****

   ‘Lord Olórin,’ Tawarengil said, ‘I should not wish to suggest you are unwise, but my own errand is, I believe, of some importance. Do you suggest I stop it to align myself with this...’ and Tawarengil’s words, usually quite fluid and assured for someone of his boyish appearance, became cautious. ‘...this... innkeeper?’

   ‘I do not, my lord,’ the grey traveler replied, ‘your courses are your own to decide. But I do suggest that we all have stumbled upon things here this night that none of us would have expected. You might call it heren,22 governance that should guide your decisions and Men might call it amarthan,23 “to be fated”, but here we are together with much to learn. Shall we question the grace that has brought this meeting out of some stubbornness for our earlier plans?’

   ‘Oldfather,’ Collum said finally, speaking directly to the old grey wizard, ‘you do me great honor. If you have learned things about my quest beyond these histories I can only hope it is through your shrewdness and no fault of my own that something of my deeper purposes are revealed. “How can you aid me,” you ask?’ he said with a much longer pause.

   He took one lasting drought of his wine and answered to the room, ‘Friends and lord and fathers, despite your offers of kindness, or your plans to meet with the Elves of Lindon or Rivendell,’ he said, motioning to Tawarengil and Beothalion, ‘I believe that the Northlands cannot at this time be regained; we are too few and the land too vast for those that remain. We fight not just the hard armies of the Witch-king, but also against our own dwindling. Our lands have become emptied and our People, few as they have become in the North, have no king of Argeleb’s stature to rally them.

   ‘Such a king might come, as many foresighted among my People still predict. Of this, I cannot say. But rescuing Arvedui will not, I believe, save the North Kingdom and the hope I hold for my People lies elsewhere-‘

   As Collum spoke his quick eyes, and Benbow’s, caught a dark shape drop from the sky past their now open window just as a scream of terror came from the floor above them.

   ‘A woman’s cry for help!’ Tawarengil said, as he burst towards the door, faster than the others could react. Beothalion, dropping his cup and seizing his staff, was at his heels without hesitation. The old travelers had all come to their feet, but Ben and Collum had rushed to the window just as the cry from above had been heard. Nothing could be seen from their small vantage of where the figure had gone and the alleyway here was quite close to the ruin of the stables where the air there was still filled with a smoky haze. There was no direct exit here as there was in the commonroom, and they would have to go out to the hall door to see their way through to the alley, following behind the Elf and the wildman in their own haste to the stair.

   ‘More troubles still, and with my sword hidden far from my hand,’ Collum thought. ‘I shall never escape this town in time.’

   Rushing out the door with the others, he went right towards the stairway (for the woman’s voice who cried for help was surely Buttercup’s) but he knew in his soldier’s heart that the trouble should be met left toward the alleyway and the figure fleeing there.

 

*****

   The door was not open for a heartbeat, quick as her heart was in the moment, and Buttercup’s new oath was barely spoken, when she saw a black figure rise from the corner of the room, hissing loudly as if angered, or perhaps even wounded, by the words she spoke.

   Light came in through the eastern window of Flomi’s room, and the trespasser was silhouetted there against it, staring at her, as if determining how fast he might close the distance between them and tear out her throat like some animal. Or at least this is how she felt, recounting it later, and she could only recall how dark he looked, dressed all in black and with the window behind him, and how frightened he made her feel. She could not, try as she later may, see his face in that moment.

She turned her back on the figure and fled, unwisely perhaps, for as a wolf he might be right behind her before she could reach the stair. Then she remembered to scream.

   ‘Aiiee! Foes! Robbers! Awake!’ she called at the top of her voice as she ran to the stairhead. ‘Foes! Awake!’ She plunged down the stairs not hesitating a moment to see if anyone was behind her.

   The handsome young Elf lord suddenly was on the stair beneath her as she hurtled down. He caught her in arms that were surprisingly strong for someone who looked so young.

   ‘Where, girl?’ Tawarengil asked, looking into her frightened eyes. ‘What have you seen?’

   ‘A robber, sir, or a monster,’ Buttercup replied, catching her fear and looking back at the Elf. As she did, Beothalion, Collum and the others came to the bottom of the stair in front of her. ‘A man all in black in the Dwarf’s- Master Flomi’s room, which should be locked and wasn’t.’

   ‘Ben,’ Collum cried, instantly taking charge, ‘go with Beothalion out through the alley and give chase. That must be what we saw. Tawarengil and I-’

   But the Elf had already bolted up the stair. All that Collum could do was follow. Buttercup was left with the three wizards who were coming up behind.

   Clearing the landing, Collum saw Tawarengil at the top of the stairhead turn left towards Flomi’s room. ‘Perhaps they really can smell dwarves,’ he thought, and followed the fleet young figure just as fast as he could.

   As he reached the open doorway he saw Tawarengil standing in the room’s center, a long knife in each hand, looking for an enemy. ‘If it was just the one,’ Collum said, ‘I think we saw him drop to the alley just as you heard the girl cry out.’ Before the sentence was even finished, Tawarengil rushed to the window, its shutters thrown wide open. He then leapt upon the sill, gazing down into the alleyway below.

   ‘It is a hard drop for a Man,’ Tawarengil said to Collum as the innkeeper joined him at the window. ‘Not many would risk it.’

   ‘And he ran quickly after,’ Collum replied. ‘Ben and I saw his shape fall, but could see no one in the alley from our window below.’

   ‘It would seem, master Innkeeper,’ said the deep voice of Alatar behind them, ‘that your house is filled with curiosities this night.’ Turning, Collum could see that the old traveler had followed with Buttercup beside him. ‘And, with this new occurrence, it also seems unlikely that you will now leave as quickly and as quietly as you had hoped.’

   Buttercup, her eyes wide and startled, looked at the old men, and at the young Elf and at Collum, who she had trusted and cared for so long. ‘I will never escape this town in time,’24 he said, this time for all the rest to hear.

 

End of Chapter Three


Chapter End Notes

Notes on Chapter Three

1)  The subject of pumps and fire protection here brings up one of the most difficult aspects of writing fiction in Tolkien’s universe; just what kind of technology did common people have access to? The story here is some 1300 years before the War of the Ring, but I’ve decided to keep much of that same late Medieval technology employed in those books. Tolkien’s world, to my mind, seems to be one in which technology does not move forward. Instead it is a static and rarely changing fantasy of the Medieval in which old advances have been lost and are carefully protected by the Wise.

2)  “Peace, Great Lady! Peace!” in Sindarin, or so my online translator app informs me. I’m doubtful about the overuse of this resource of course, and welcome any corrections.

3)  “Run swift!” in Sindarin. Of this one, given its use in The Fellowship, I am certain.

4)  I’m having some trouble, as of this writing, determining the singular form of Periannath, the Sindarin word for “Halflings”. Hopefully I’ll sort this out before the whole book is finished.

5)  A study of The Silmarillion suggests that the Quenya which a young Elf of the Greatwood might know should be quite different than the original Noldorin form refined for the Elves in their contact with the Valar. I have entered a very lovely poem here found on the internet, but I would like to go into this passage at some later time (as I’m currently trying to study Quenya) and make something of my own. In any case, it seems reasonable that the Wizards here would speak a much more pure language than Tawarengil might find familiar.

6)  It is my hope to eventually create a passage like this in Quenya, but I am only just learning the language and far too inexperienced at this writing. This poem comes to me through the language site I have been using and is credited to a poet named Tatyandacil using their own translations. It’s quite lovely and suited well to the situation as it includes a prayer to the wind. It is a bit longer, but I’m including here just the first two stanzas.

“Hláranyë ringa Formessúrë,
 (I hear the cold Northwind)


asúy' aldassen úlassië, 
(blowing through the leafless trees,)
 

alussa olbalissë nornë,
 (whispering in the twisted branches,
) 

alamya ve Nuru-nainië.
 (sounding like a Death-lament)

Formessúrë-yalmë quéla,
 (The clamour of the Northwind fades,
) 

ar Númello holtan hwesta
 (and from the West I smell a) 


nísima asúya ninna,
 (fragrant Zephyr blowing towards me,)
 

ar nainië ahya lírinna.
 (and the lament changes to song.)

7)  Númen súrë is “west wind” in Quenya.

8)  “Hidden paths bring hope to weary travelers” or as close as I can get to it in Sindarin at this writing. I can find no direct translation as yet, so I apologize to those of you out there who undoubtedly know the language better than I. But if I wait to learn the language in full before beginning the story, well, I’ll certainly be too old to ever finish it.

9)  To help enforce the idea of this exchange as a proverb, and to exhibit my own failing in the Sindarin tongue, I’ve decided to let Collum finish it in the Common Speech.

10)  “May we speak as friends now?” in Sindarin (according to Google).

11)  “Hail! We welcome you here!” in Sindarin.

12)  “Astron” corresponds to the month of April (actually March 23rd to April 21 in our modern account) within the Shire-reckoning. The Shire calendar is based acutely on the Saxon calendar so I wanted to use it here in place of the modern date (April 12th, for those who are keeping track). This does hark back to the idea that most of the best developments in Hobbit society probably happened in Bree first, but the idea that Bree, during the time of this story, would have developed its own calendar apart from Númenor, seems very likely. The Saxon calendar seems particularly appropriate in this case, but in a supporting work, "In the Shire-reckoning", I comment on the more elegant naming of the months which the Shirefolk use.

13)  In Middle-earth the Moon is considered male and the Sun female.

14)  This is a paraphrase of the conversation between Gildor and Frodo in The Fellowship. I like that Frodo's response is in italics in the original, as if he was quoting from someone (Bilbo perhaps?). But it helps to create another link between this story as apocrypha and the idea that these sayings might have gone into things which Bilbo heard but did not write about.

15)  This, and much of Collum’s description of his lost kingdom of Arnor, is cribbed from Sir Walter Scott’s Ivanhoe. It is the first direct inclusion of that text that I’ve used here, but there will be many more.

16)  This, also, is unapologetically pulled from Ivanhoe.

17)  This would put the date about 1300 of the Third Age. That Collum delineated some of these dates through reigning kings of Arthedain rather than the other nations will be relevant later.

18)  It is not entirely certain, and some internet debate seems to be present, but this is, for my purposes, a useful translation of Carn Dûm, the Witch-king’s fortress in Angmar.

19)  Six hundred really, but Ben’s knowledge of history is sketchy at best. Olórin and Collum are referring to Argeleb the First's last battle in the Weather Hills in 1356.

20)  There is some conflict on the idea of whether Arveleg died at the taking of Amon Sûl. Since the notes in the appendix for LoTR do not indicate death in battle I default, as usual, to that original source. The Fall of Amon Sûl was in 1409.

21)  A useful name for Lothlórien.

22)  Quenya for “order”.

23)  I was unable to find an Adûnaic translation for “fated” and originally went with umbarto which is also Quenya. But I did want this to be from the language known to Men and have defaulted to the Noldorin translation here, it being the closest to old Númenórean. The written Númenórean language itself is closer to Sindarin of course, but I need a greater distinction between Tawarengil’s language and Collum’s.

24)  This often used expression was, for a time, a working title for the whole chapter. I never intended to spend this long in Bree-land and had quite hoped to get on with the adventure a bit by this point. But the history lesson here was needed, I feel, and I’ve fleshed out other characters who might have remained incidental as a way of giving the exposition some room; Milo and Buttercup, the yet-unnamed woman who witnessed the fire, even Collum’s horse, have been given much more attention through the writing of this chapter than I had ever planned and many new subplots have suggested themselves. This is just a byproduct of the pleasure of walking around in the universe and I try to remember that it took Tolkien more than seventy pages to get Frodo out of the Shire. In this way the chapter here echoes some of Fellowship’s second chapter “The Shadow of the Past”, which is likewise long on history and tone. But Collum is, in this case, a perfect “non-player character” for me as the author, for like him I can’t wait to get things moving.


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment