The Fall of Arnor; Book One "Out of the Bree-land" by Diane Finnis-Robb  

| | |

Chapter Eight; "As They Waited"

-In Which a Wizard Departs, a Peculiar Passage is Discovered, and Preparations are Made.


   Ohtar hoped that Flomi would be well enough to take long counsel by the third sunrise1 since his battle with the orcs. But three days of waiting and confinement would be hard upon such uniquely self-directed and inquisitive folk as these others; there were Elves and Men here on their own missions, Wizards going about their mysterious business and one lone and quite baffled hobbit following along at Ohtar’s lead, but still always wondering about his friend’s secretive background and desperate request.

   There were none in that small group who doubted for a moment that Flomi needed rest and healing before all of them might better benefit from longer counsel. They were all held there (with the possible exception of the hobbit) because they knew that something unique and powerful had drawn them to this moment and each felt that their way forward was less certain than it had been before their meeting.

   Three days of wondering what might come next would weary a few of the party greatly and certainly make some of them anxious, make them question Ohtar about his mission and also make them very, very curious of one another’s intentions. They did try, each of them in their own way, to speak with one another and learn what they could about the concerns of the larger world on that first night since finding that Flomi had been attacked. The three wizards, who knew matters of the larger world best, were, quite unsurprisingly, the least likely to speak and seemed to be taking the measure of the other companions. It seemed that the wizards, despite their talk of the importance of patience, had quite settled their own arguments almost immediately on the idea of staying with the group. One left on the very first morning after their arrival and then, by the middle of that next long night, there would be other quite pressing matters that the party would attend to.

   But throughout this time and with little interruption Flomi slept and slept deeply. Great care had been taken at first to not overburden the dwarf with unnecessary questions and great attempts were also made to force him to rest when the party had first arrived. To accomplish these things Ohtar had worked in his own quiet way to separate Flomi from the Bard as much as possible; for the Bard’s song had become a great fixation for his friend and Ohtar would rather see Flomi sleep and heal under the wizard’s powers than try to solve this new and most perplexing riddle.

 

*****

   ‘Crows will come,’ the Bard had said to the soldier on the night of their meeting. ‘But the wall is wide and they will have their feast on the other side without rumour of us here.’

   ‘Crows we will manage,’ the soldier said to him then in the dark hours as they had talked while moving the orc-bodies. The wall was taller here than where the Bard had known it in the south, but with the help of the giant forester, they had been able to move all the orc-bodies to a great heap on the other side.2

   ‘Crows should not be trusted, Collum Ohtar,’ the forester said gravely.

   ‘I shall remember that, my friend,’ the soldier had said with a smile, ‘but for now, I had rather be back inside where crows, and other eyes, may take no notice of us.’

   This giant forester was uncommonly strong and had proven to be of great help in disposing of the bodies. He could not scale the wall as nimbly as the soldier or the Bard may, but he could throw orc-bodies easily to the top, and sometimes cleanly over the wall on his own. It had made short work of a very repugnant task.

   ‘Come now, Unnórenean,’ the soldier said, turning in his direction, ‘for I will share with you a great secret of our ancestors that has been forgotten by most and is entrusted to few in this age.’

   The three then went to where the door lay open and the soldier, reaching up his arm, showed a small sign on the stone of the wall. ‘Just here,’ he said, ‘is the mechanism of the doorway to our Secret Path; to the place we call Tauma, or the Foundations. Mark it!’

   ‘Tauma...’ the Bard repeated slowly, his face alight with a wonder of the forgotten past.

   ‘Press your hand to the stone,’ the soldier commanded. ‘Your kindness towards our friend and your ancestry have brought you to this secret and now you must know how to keep it!’

   He did as he was bidden, for he could tell that the soldier was a great commander of men, but also because he felt a great need within his blood to be part of this secret.3 The stone was cold but, how strange! it yielded to his hand and moved softly, very slightly beneath his palm. Then there was a quiet grinding like that of many small scraping knives as the two doors within the wall began to close without aid.

   ‘How is...’ the great forester said from behind him. Both of them stood in caution and great amazement as slowly the doors locked together before them, showing no stitch or division; a solid wall of ancient stone once again.

   ‘This is no spell, my friends, but the art of our ancient peoples of Númenor,’ the soldier assured them. ‘Long has this great skill of building been forgotten by our people in the North and I confess it is beyond my understanding as well. Dwarves are said to have such skill and even greater but, as you all will come to see, dwarves are great keepers of secrets.

   ‘A touch to the same exact spot, hidden from all except those few who know it, will open or close this passage. I will show you another such on the inside. There is no strange power to be feared in this, Beothalion,’ the soldier said, turning his gentle smile on the forester, ‘only the great learning of a once great people. You might touch the stone as we have and accomplish the same. But the Unnórenean and I are descended from those ancient builders,’ and at this he turned back to the Bard. ‘We have the very great responsibility to guard this Secret Path. For it leads to Tyrn Gorthad and the sacred halls of our mighty forefathers.’

   ‘I have stood my watch at Tyrn Goerthaid, Soldier,’ he responded. ‘I have heard their pleas and whispers and still keep the secrets of my grandsires. And I will keep this doorway you have shown me with the same care.’

‘This is good to hear, Oisín Na-Glirhuin,’ the soldier responded. Then, smiling smartly, he said, ‘and it is funny that you should mention standing a watch...’

 

*****

   ‘He seems to have a keen eye in a wood, that’s certain,’ Ben said of the Bard on the first morning of their waiting. ‘Scouting out the area is one thing, Collum, but do we need to leave him at watch? That door closes marvelously and none could find it that doesn’t know it’s here. Are we not safe without an outer guard?’

   ‘All that you have said is true, Ben, and should make us feel safe,’ he said in response. ‘But it seems that you have lost count in the story our new friend has told; one lone orc-tracker left this battle alive.’

   Ben’s brow wrinkled at this news a bit. In his life as Collum Gilleyfoil, innkeeper, Ohtar had known this hobbit many years, and knew that he was now counting things out in his head and wishing it was possible to use his fingers and perhaps even his toes for the process.

   ‘Stars, but that’s so!’ he said after a moment. ‘And, to hear your man tell it, there may be three scores of these foul folk arriving soon after only one night’s run from here!’

   ‘Yes,’ Ohtar said without excitement. ‘He is to be trusted in that, I believe.’

   ‘And they’re to march on the Breefolk?’ Ben said.

   ‘It did sound this way,’ Ohtar replied, trying to keep any affect out of his voice so that he might hear Ben’s unsolicited thoughts all the better.

   ‘But... should we not ride to warn them? The troops would arrive tomorrow, or so I would reckon from his talking, and may come to the Bree-land as soon as the day after!’

   ‘Or..?’ he asked quite softly, turning his fingers almost theatrically to draw his friend out further.

   Again Ben worked his brow for a bit. This hobbit led a strangely solitary life and was not experienced with strategies and war bands. But he was sharp, Ohtar knew, sharpest among any of the hobbits that he had met these past dozen years.

   ‘Or, if the other little hunter who has escaped comes to them, having really nowhere else he might go, those three score orcs...’

   ‘Yes.’ Ohtar encouraged him to make the assessment and waited for it to settle.
It didn’t take long.

   ‘So we can’t warn the Breelanders because we can’t lose folk in case the attack comes here?’

   As they stood up near the top of the stair before the open doors talking, the sun was rising on the first morning since Flomi’s battle. From what Ohtar and Benbow had heard from the Bard, sixty orcs would arrive sometime on the following night southwest of the Bree-land with orders and intentions to take the town. Tomorrow or the next night at the latest. Either of them might ride now, ride quickly, and marshal those sleepy Breelanders against such a terrible force.

   Or, knowing that an orc escaped yesterday’s battle and had no other place to run to, knowing that the slaughter of his band and the importance of the dwarf might weigh heavily on any new commander, there was quite an equal chance that the three-score war party would come here.

   And those who held the doorway numbered but nine.

   One of them might ride back now, hurriedly, and warn the townsfolk. But to do so would mean that the rider must stay and marshal everyone there against the orcs. Milo and Buttercup were not ready for such a great task on their own. Ben knew that if he or Collum went back, they would have to stay and lead the town in its defense.

   ‘Ben,’ Ohtar said quietly and slowly, ‘I will not constrain you with promises if you had rather go back. I will say again that I and Flomi are on a gravely important task which I hope to have your help with. But if your honor calls you back toward the Bree-land...’

   ‘My honor!’ Ben said with a growing anger now that he realized what might be at stake. ‘Well, that might seem a precious thing to some of these mighty folk here I suppose, but it's not been a thing I carry so closely. Honor be stoned, for it’s of no more use to a fellow like me than a chamberpot!’ he said.

   ‘But it’s my care those Breefolks have, Collum, my care and some friendship. How can I know what I know and not go to share it with friends, what few of them I might have leastwise, who are so emperilled?’

   ‘Do you suggest that I find this same decision easy?’ Ohtar said. It was, he knew, a bit unfair of him to say such a thing. For it required Ben to challenge his own decisions in the matter against his sense of Collum’s own loyalty; and they both knew that Collum’s attachment to the townsfolk, no matter what new information Ben had learned, was sincere and that his friendships there went much deeper than Ben’s own.

   ‘No,’ the hobbit said, screwing up his face again in thought, but this time his voice softened with respect, ‘no, it’s a proper, or even true I suppose, life which you made there and a hard decision to not ride back. I did not mean to suggest you were beyond care for the Breefolk.

   ‘But if I, or some other, should ride-’

   ‘I believe that it is I who shall ride, master Floxleaf,’ said a loud and deep voice behind them. Olórin had, they now saw, been noiselessly walking toward them up the stair while they were talking.

   ‘You’re own way, it seems,’ he said, smiling in that odd way that he had, ‘is to follow your friend here and learn some of the many things about him which he has chosen to keep hidden for many years,’ He then turned the same smile on Ohtar.

   ‘No simple innkeeper, indeed,’ he said, ‘but no less true in his friendship, I should think.

   ‘No,’ he said in a resolved and steady voice as he looked east towards the doorway, ‘I shall warn the town, if they will listen, and I shall, if time and the situation permits, deal with this orc-band myself.

   ‘But,’ he said looking back to Ohtar, ‘I will have far to travel quickly afterward and I’m afraid I must borrow a horse.’

 

*****

   ‘A most wonderful rest, Tawar!’ Beothalion said to his brother as he came to meet him near the well. ‘We have traveled far and slept in many wide spaces that I have enjoyed greatly. But I have never felt such peace and dreaming as I did last night under our new friend’s song. Such power there is in music!’

   And at this he laughed loudly and plunged his head neck-deep into the trough of the clear-flowing well. The water was cool and bracing. He drank long of it, enjoying the wakefulness it brought to his body without forgetting the comfort that the night’s sleep had given.

   Lifting his great head he shook it violently, casting cool water all about him, laughing loudly again as he did so. His great voice was, however, overwhelmed by the caterwauling of the strange beast, Duncan, who was the dwarf’s friend.

   And even Tawarengil was laughing. ‘It seems, brother,’ he said with a broad smile on his still-young face, ‘that you have found a new supporter for your customs and wisdoms. This could help us greatly, if only an ass could be called to counsel.’

   ‘You should not call him that, Tawar,’ Beothalion said quite seriously in return. ‘The innkeeper tells us he is from the South- imagine that, brother, a land where winter never comes! They must have queer ways in the South and do not speak even the Old Tongues there.’

   To Beothalion’s eyes the beast named Duncan (though he did not respond as if this was his real name) was yet another of the many wonders this trip had shown him. He was no pony certainly, and as different from horses as the Little Folk like Benbow Floxleaf were from Dwarves.

   Perhaps that was wrong. Beothalion had really only seen the one Dwarf as yet and that one was too wounded to be judged rightly.

   But certainly this Duncan was different. Louder than the horses he had known, but clearly of deeper and more ribald humour (for Beothalion had met many horses in the past weeks and generally, without seeming unkind for their offered friendship, found them to be much more boring than the Men and the Little Folk). Horses, other than Benbow’s wise pony, seldom seem to laugh in this wider world that he had seen lately. But the beast called Duncan laughed and champed and shat at everything he encountered whether he understood it or not.

   If Duncan was an “ass” as Tawar called him, then Beothalion himself felt even simpler beside him.

 

*****

   He had been made to wait. There was great comfort for him in coming out of the tunnel and into a wood again before dawn and he let his senses be filled with the joy of it; but he was not entirely unwise to statecraft and knew that he had been decidedly and singularly made to wait. And so, wise as he was, and in want of friendship, he accepted this assigned position, believing it came from a distrust that was born more of caution than disrespect. He had been made to wait and in his wisdom accepted this.

   ‘Orcs may come,’ he thought, ‘but not in this day or even this night. Tomorrow. Perhaps. Orcs may come, yes they may or even may not, before three more dawns. But not today in this full sunlight.

   ‘I have been asked to watch empty roads during warm sunlight, and it is a tiresome task,’ he thought. ‘But I have been mostly asked to stand outside while these great worthies talk. I have been made to wait.’

   So he had settled himself to a place in the high branches in this birch grove, marveling at the shape and whiteness of these well-tended trees. He began to watch with his eyes while letting his mind sleep to the rhythms of the wind.

   And, seeing no other way, he waited.

 

*****

   As Collum and Olórin went outside to discuss the matter further, Ben, feeling more troubled than before, turned back down the shallow stairway leading toward their encampment.

   ‘Well so the worthies have gone off again,’ he thought rather glumly, ‘discussing their great plans just as they should. I’ve no complaint there, for I’ve had trouble enough keeping up with all of this high-talk and newness in a long four days of discoveries. But I do wish I was given the time to know Collum’s purpose. Each time I feel I’m closer to hearing it one of these high-folk takes him away to some new counsel.’

   Ben very much would’ve preferred to be outside under the trees with the Bard whom Collum had deployed as a scout. Like his father, he was always more comfortable in an open wood than any other hobbit he had heard of.

   ‘What a queer place this is,’ he thought, ‘not that any hobbit has a trouble in a hole, but this is not, well, this is not any old hole built to comfort.

   ‘Oh, it is old, yes, greatly old I should say, but that’s not how I mean it,’ he thought as he walked quietly down the stair. ‘Hobbits that I know build holes for comfort and this seems like a hole built for... now what’s the opposite of comfort, I wonder....’

   While not the direct opposite of comfort, "despair” was the word that Benbow would’ve liked to use here, but he could not. Perhaps that word had come into the Westron speech by this time. Perhaps many of the Northmen had used it, for they had come to know it so well in their ongoing conflict with Angmar. Despair was certainly not an unfamiliar feeling in the North at this time, and Benbow was widely traveled in the North-lands. 

   And despair would be a well-suited word for the feeling this place brought on; for though they only stood at the doorstep, this was the Tauma, the great Path of the Dead for Númenóreans of the North Kingdom and Men have ever despaired at the thought of death. 

    But there may be no specifically less-Hobbitlike word than “despair” and we can say with a great degree of certainty that Benbow would know nothing of it at this time of his life.

   He would, having experienced the crushing weight of despair in his very near future, try very hard to describe this feeling without benefit of a broader vocabulary. He would say, ‘terrified-to-stillness’ and ‘stonified-by- worrisomeness’ but none of these were ever right and, of course, Benbow Floxleaf was never a wordsmith.

   Hobbits, joyful as they were to receive the world’s rewards for a good day’s work, had no real place for "hope" in their language or as something separate from their lives. And then, therefore, there was no reason why anyone would ever want to describe its opposite feeling. In this condition, hobbits, and even very unusual hobbits like Benbow Floxleaf, live rare lives quite different from the concerns of Men.

   As he came to the bottom of the stairway, Ben’s sharp hunter’s eye caught a quick, furtive movement towards the far corner of the landing; some small creature, he thought, that had snuck inside while the doors remained open. His bow lay inside the grazing area still, so he drew his knife and, on soft-padded feet, crept over to investigate.

   The antechamber at the base of the long shallow stairway, where the shattered remnants of a pavise still lay strewn about, had just the one door on the right where Flomi had made his desperate battle. It was not a large space, maybe going ten or more strides along past the door and, like the rest of the stairway above, unadorned and low-ceilinged. As Ben moved silently towards the rear he saw a fairly large rat, or perhaps a chuck, standing still, its eyes fixed on the hunter. It was not a dangerous creature from what he could see, but Ben thought it very odd that a scavenger like a rat would find its way down here so quickly. The orc bodies had not lain here long and were moved many hours ago.

   Their eyes remained locked for a moment more and then, with a quickness surprising for its size, the creature turned and ran straight toward the western wall of the chamber and abruptly disappeared.

   Cautiously Ben followed it and saw the open seam there between floor and wall that had provided the creature’s escape; a regular slot in the construction two paces long and as high as Ben’s own hand.

   ‘Now I’m no hole-dweller,’ he said to himself aloud, ‘but this does not look comfortable to me.’

 

*****

   ‘In regard to the Bree-folk I can offer very little assurance,’ the old man said, ‘other than to say that I will aid them if they will listen. In some places of Middle-earth that offer should seem assurance enough.’

   ‘I doubt it not, wisefather,’ Ohtar replied as they walked out through the parted doors, ‘and I thank you for it. They are a sturdy enough folk in their own short-sighted way, but there is no guard or militia that you might call upon other than my own people at the inn whom you have met, and some others of my own kind who are still placed secretly within the town. I fear for their safety greatly, but they will, I do not doubt, answer your call.’

   ‘It may be that these orcs can be diverted,’ Olórin said, ‘but your folk at the inn shall be warned of them in any case.

   ‘Now then, of your main endeavor, if I have guessed it rightly, I have shared my thoughts with my brothers of the order and convinced them it is indeed of great importance. Pallando, I believe, shall accompany you. No!’ he said, holding his hand up and keeping the man from answering. ‘This was not a request nor another question that I need you to confirm nor deny. You have played your game of questions very well, Ohtar, and I commend you on it. If I have guessed wrongly and am simply granting our great aid to a simple graverobber, then the fault shall be mine.

   ‘Either way,’ he said with a small smile, ‘I will reserve my last question with you for some time when we meet again.’

   ‘I pray that it may be so, wisefather,’ Ohtar said, bowing respectfully with open hands at his side and a look of great hope on his face.

   The day was still quite young and the sun had not yet topped the Glade of Seven Birches just east of where they stood at the gate of the Foundations. In the glade the Bard, Oisín, had taken his position of watch, but even Ohtar’s sharp eyes could not see him there amid the branches. If Olórin saw him he did not say, though he turned his conversation to this topic next.

   ‘Of the Unnórenean,’ he said, ‘I’m afraid I have little counsel to offer. I have heard of their people living in Eryn Vorn and have some suspicions regarding their deeper origins, but cannot foresee their role in the world at this time. Still,’ and at this he paused for a moment, focusing his eyes there to the east as they both had, before saying, ‘I do sense that some great purpose lay about him.’

   ‘Flomi, too, believes this is so. The song he sang is of great age and may, Flomi thinks, speak to our-’

   ‘He brings more than song, I am certain,’ Olórin said, cutting him off, ‘but his path and his purpose may lie another way. It will be upon all of you in your counsel to decide how these purposes are aligned.’

   ‘His people are known to us,’ Ohtar said. ‘Some of the great families of old Arnor had settled into the land that became Cardolan when the kingdom was split. When that land was overrun some 500 years ago a remnant of the Dúnedain of Cardolan held out in the Barrow-downs and the far forests. But we have heard nothing of them in many long years. To think that his fate could somehow bring him to aid Flomi at such an hour-’

   ‘Your mission and your path is not the only one, Ohtar,’ and again the soft kindness crept back into the old man’s voice. ‘I have read the signs of this occasion and I caution you to do the same. To have three of our order appear by what you may call a chance-meeting and discuss our future paths is a rare occurrence indeed. To then be served three glasses of Miruvor and introduced to such a diverse group of folk running in three different paths is no chance at all.

   ‘Some here may desire to go west yet to answer Círdan’s call. It is there that the great thrust to undo Angmar must gather and it may be that the Unnórenean will wish to join it.

   ‘Your path is still undetermined but, if I have guessed rightly, it must ultimately lead north,’ he paused there looking for any contrary gesture in Ohtar’s eyes or his manner. ‘Yes,’ he continued. ‘North to undiscovered places and great rewards.

   ‘I will take the farther path to the east,’ he continued, ‘and while it will lead me through the Bree-land and these orcs, I must quickly come before lord Elrond and petition him to join the fight against Angmar. To do this and still save the Bree-folk I will need a horse. How fortunate then that, quite beyond your orders or expectations, your young master Fastknots has provided us with a spare. Fastknots indeed! He has tied things up nicely without knowing!’

   He laughed loudly at this, the very surprise and act of his laughter seeming to warm the grey of his whiskers and the color of his face. It lightened the heart of Ohtar, who had been listening so intently that he now felt foolish for his own seriousness. The laugh was sudden and large and a bit startling, but overhead he heard the songs of morning birds, who seemed not frightened at all but echoed the joy of his laughter. And so Ohtar found himself laughing as well to some new, lighter feeling of purpose, some secret pleasure of knowing that he did not completely understand, but that somehow, beyond all fear, warmed him still.4

 

*****

   ‘Yes. I see. Most discomforting indeed,’ Alatar said as he gazed at the narrow strip of escape that Benbow had shown him and the others. As he spoke his nostrils wrinkled ever so slightly and, even in the very dim antechamber, Ben thought he could see an eyebrow of the wizard being raised scornfully. It was hard to be certain. Ben had known him only a few days now and thought the scornful cast of the old wizard’s face might be his regular expression.

   ‘This chamber is nothing like my own home in Authengroth, of course,’ the elf-lord said as he came forward to examine the area, ‘and I am no expert of cave-making. Alas that our dwarf is still resting. But it does seem to me that the stone here above is different than the rest.’

   ‘Indeed it is, lord Tawarengil,’ Alatar responded flatly and without looking. His eyes instead had turned up to the ceiling and searched around the edges of the floor to each side of the slotted opening. ‘For it is a door. And not, I believe, of original construction.’

   From the sleeve of his robe he then drew a small wand, long as a huntsman’s dagger, white as bone and curled like some braided rope. As Ben watched, the old man lightly touched the tip of this strange object, and a soft, blue light like moonshine came forth and surrounded his hand, lighting the darker corners of the room.

   For all his years in the wild, Ben had never seen anything like this; the old man had done it so simply, in such an easy and commonplace manner as he stood just a foot or two away from the hobbit’s unblinking eyes. Ben looked around to the others to see if they had seen it too, to make sure that he was not in some strange waking dream. Tawarengil's young-looking face betrayed, or so Ben thought, a familiarity with such things; for he now looked at the wizard with grave seriousness as if the wonderment of captured moonlight suddenly transported into the cave had just made matters more interesting for the Elf-child. Beothalion, who had been lingering cautiously back from the place the wizard had been examining, now stood with his jaw open, his head tilted in disbelief, rubbing and blinking his eyes as he stared at the glowing wand. At the sight of this, Ben realized his own jaw hung open as well.

   ‘Does it not seem unusual to you that this antechamber is so large and has only the one door to the east?’ Alatar said as he looked carefully around the western wall of the room.

   ‘I know nothing of the designs of Men, wisefather,’ Tawarengil replied, ‘but it does seem impractical. Would the Innkeeper know more of this perhaps?’

   ‘Not of this place, I think,’ the wizard said. ‘The tales of the Foundations and its construction were lost even in king Eldacar’s time and, for some reason- and I believe it to be quite long ago- this door seems to have been added or repaired in secret. More troubling, perhaps,’ he said gravely as he paused, kneeling on the floor before the edge of the opening, ‘I can find no trigger for this portal; no mechanism, inscription or device.

   ‘Perhaps you are correct, lord Tawarengil, and our dwarf-friend inside may provide better investigation when his health has improved. Perhaps Olórin will know more of this, for I have not traveled so much as he in the realms of Men. And I am no lockpick.

   ‘But the troubling idea, it seems,’ and at this Ben could see the wizard’s nostril crinkling again and his eyebrows arching a bit more, showing a subtle distinction in his rather steady emotional state of disdain, ‘is that the door may be made to open from the other side.’

 

*****

   The laughter of the wise one rang through the boughs, lifting the hearts of the birds and all the other creatures who felt it. He felt it himself, even at the glade’s edge where he slept peacefully among the branches, and it woke him with gladness and his joy was the joy of the morning before the dew is dry, when every leaf is green.5

   It was the laughter of magick,6 of course. The Minhiriathrim spoke of it often; the power of the old Forest-folk7 to shape the seasons, halt the rivers and move the trees with their laughter. The men of his own family did not believe in it much, for the Minhiriathrim have many such old, old stories that seem to come from a world different in shape and manner than this one. The wuduwasa8 of those old stories had such laughter and it seemed that the old grandfathers, the wassirds, are like unto them.

   Turning his eyes to the sound of it, he saw one of them, the one clad in dusky grey, standing with the Soldier before the doors. He came down from his high place in the trees to speak with them.

   Stepping quickly through the morning light in the glade, he called, ‘Good morning to you, friends! I have done as you asked, Ohtar, and kept watch. The land has been quiet, and not even the crows have arrived yet to the feast we have left them. But now, Old One, the land and the trees feel the sound of your laughter. I have never witnessed such magicks before and it delights me now. Foul things will not come this way while such blessings echo!’

   Ohtar had been feeling the same way; though exhausted by concern he was now relieved in spirit and hoped that the spell would carry over the doorway by which they stood long after the wizard had left.

   ‘Nîr tôl erin baded lîn,’9 he said to Olórin, though his eyes also looked to see if the Bard knew the Sindarin which he spoke.

   ‘Mas athradannech?’10 the Unnórenean said. And then, as he bowed to his two companions a bit, he said, ‘Sílo Anor bo men lín.’11 There was an uncomfortable quality to the action of which Ohtar’s keen eyes immediately took notice; he looked as if he had never done such a thing before, but had heard of the manner from others.

   ‘You are both too kind and indulgent of an old man’s sense of humour, and I thank you for it,’ Olórin said, still chuckling. Turning to the Bard he smiled a bit more and then took on a more serious and direct tone.

   ‘Master Harper,’ he said, ‘I feel that I have not had the opportunity to also thank you for the beauty of your playing last night. Many in our small party were sorely tired and care-worn from unexpected troubles. Your skill was a balm to our wearied hearts.’

   ‘I thank you, Great One, for your kindness,’ the Bard said, his eyes fairly beaming with happiness at this praise from one so lofty. From alongside them, Ohtar, wise in reading the small gestures of many men, watched as the wizard drew the eager and naive young man further out.

   ‘It is honestly given,’ he said. ‘You have a skill that I have rarely heard in many years of far wanderings.

   ‘And I am sorry that I shall not hear it again for some time,’ the old man continued, his face now taking a more grave aspect to further affect the seriousness. ‘For Ohtar and I have just taken counsel over the news that you have brought us. We are concerned for the people of the Bree-land, and it has been decided that I will ride now to warn them of the orcs that you have reported. I will need more information from you on the position of their camp.’

   ‘You shall have it, Great One,’ the Bard responded, ‘or, perhaps, if I do not offend in offering, I might accompany you? It may be that I was meant to find these orcs and, in doing so, be led further on my own path.’

   At this comment Olórin looked briefly at Ohtar and, smiling, replied, ‘We were just speaking of that very subject, friend, and wondering, if we may, what destination your own path might lead you.’

   ‘Ah, this is an easy question, Great One,’ he said calmly, ‘for I go North, West, or even into the East to kill the Witch-king of Angmar.’

 

*****

   There was a gathering then, not too many hours after the sunrise, as open light came through the cleverly laid holes in the earthen roof of the Grazing Field. All were present, but they kept their voices low and kept their distance from the sleeping dwarf, as so many discussions of their future relied on his speedy recovery.

   ‘He looks to be of very good stock, though somewhat thickened by his restfulness,’ Ohtar said to the wizard.

   ‘Oh, he is a great-heart, Ohtar,’ Beothalion said, nuzzling up against the horse with his own bearded face and touching him gently under the jaw, ‘he is not wise, and I cannot hear his real name, but he is- walna... gwal...’12

   ‘“Of anxious spirit,”’ Tawarengil finished. ‘Yes, I feel that in him too, brother, and confess that I feel much the same in this place. He will serve you well, Grey Wanderer, but perhaps not patiently.’

   ‘Let us all hope so,’ Olórin said, ‘for I’ve little time for horse-breaking and we shall have far to travel together. Still,’ he said as he moved forward to place a gentle hand on the beast’s brow, ‘I think you have chosen a name for him, Beothalion. “Awalna” will suit him well.’

   At this sounding, Ben’s Rosey neighed gently and tipped her head. Ohtar’s own horse, Caitelyn, followed suit, and even Duncan, some distance apart from the others, whisked his head in agreement. If Awalna understood as much as they did, no one knew.

   ‘So, Olórin now has the agreement of these beasts and his own plan to move forward,’ Alatar said to the others. ‘In a few days we will each decide plans of our own. I will hear this bard’s tale in its fullness, and speak with Ohtar’s dwarf friend on the matter. We may hope in the likelihood that Olórin’s mission will keep the orc-band from coming here, but I believe this place is not so safe as it seems.’

   ‘Yes,’ Olórin said in thoughtful agreement. ‘I do not like that curious patch of doorway you have shown me.’

   ‘Nor do I,’ Ohtar said, ‘nor do I know any reasoning for its purpose. My own folk use this place rarely and only in time of need, for its history brings us no comfort. I know no rumour of this door, and can imagine nothing of its purpose.’

   A moment passed then, one which Olórin would consider long into his time in Middle-earth.13 What he thought or felt in the reaction of his companions and their inquisitiveness can not be guessed, but Ben saw him look long into the eyes of Ohtar and then those of his fellow travelers. The old man considered a long moment and, with a ruffle of the whiskers around his mouth, looked as if he was about to speak. Then, lowering his head and pulling at his long eyebrows, he looked aside. The questions and needs of the others, it seemed, so troubled him that he looked away and busied his mind that they might not notice. Ben knew very few people well, wassird or no, and spent very little time among company other than his Rosie. But he thought then that he had seen grave concern in the old man’s eyes as well as the loneliness that he himself knew as a fellow outsider.

   With renewed purpose Olórin walked over to the equipment which Milo had brought them, laid out and organized in the cavern by Benbow earlier in his impatience. There Olórin chose a bridle and a harness.

   ‘I hope you will be able to lend me this leader, Master Floxleaf,’ he said, ‘for I will have little time to fashion one of my own, and it might be best if Awalna here followed a familiar harness.

   ‘I’ve no need of a saddle. He seems wide enough to hold an old man easily.’ He said with a chuckle, ‘and that extra saddle might indeed serve you on the flatulent donkey, if any can put him to it.’ As he said this, he walked back to the horse he had chosen and gently put the bridle and lead around his head.

   ‘So Awalna I will lead, but the rest of you, I may not. In the question about this other doorway, I have no history to offer. I have spent time with many of Isildur’s heirs here in the North, but I’ve never been to this place until Ohtar led us yesterday. I should think that originally, back in the lost history of this site’s making, a “left-hand door” such as the one you have shown me would have been a storehouse or pantry, a space into which long provisions might have been kept and, perhaps, in the last years, arms against Angmar’s incursion to the south.’

   Awalna answered well to the wizard’s gentle hand and the bridle was comfortably placed on his head. Olórin led the horse forward toward the ramp, and the other members of the party followed him as if they all wore leaders as well.

   ‘Why such a door would be refitted,’ he continued, ‘as this one surely has, is quite beyond my knowledge and also quite troubling. The stonework there is not so ancient as these halls, yet it is not recent either. I can think of no reason this should have been done and doubt very much it was done by the Edain who know this place.’

   ‘Then who could have found it and why have they left no sign?’ Ohtar said with a combination of anger and surprise.

   ‘I do not know, Ohtar,’ Olórin said gravely, pausing to look toward the others who also were following him in a long train up the ramp from the Grazing Field to the door, ‘but I do not like the smell of the door’s other side.’

   ‘Yes!’ Beothalion said loudly, as if someone had finally spoken to an idea he had earlier felt too uncomfortable to mention. ‘I smelled it also, and it is a foul, foul smell, grey stalker! I do not know this smell, but I do not want to go near it!’

   ‘I thought so too,’ Ben said quietly. ‘It has a troll smell.’

   And all were quieted by this observation.

   They had reached the top of the ramp and Olórin led his horse outside the doorway as the others looked to their right at the problem they were now discussing. In the gloomy distance of the antechamber, there was very little to be seen; a door was there, they knew this now, and it opened only from some secret on its other side. How it had come to be there was a mystery, but the danger it presented was obvious to everyone.

   ‘Trolls do not build, Master Floxleaf,” Olórin said, ‘but I do not doubt the wisdom of your senses. No, the more troubling thing is knowing that some other skilled hand did build this door long ago. Why? I cannot answer that. But I should caution you all to be wary in the face of this knowledge.

   ‘Now,’ he said briskly, turning his face toward the shallow stair, ‘I must go. I wish all of you well and hope against all outcomes that we shall see one another again. We have had a chance-meeting in peculiar circumstances and precious little time to know each other well. But my heart tells me some of us will meet again and I wish each of you wonderful opportunities in the days to come.’

   At this he turned to each of the party individually, offering whatever words of advice that he may.

   ‘Lord Tawarengil, I pray that you will find all of the adventures you seek and so prove your mettle to your own self, even if no one else is watching. There are adventures to be found at every turn, my lord, but I would caution you to learn and exercise patience that you may grow to meet them in the way that you wish.

   ‘Beothalion here carries a heavy burden of your errantry. You are fortunate to have found such a brother as he. But he has another path, I think, and one of great discovery. Perhaps, lord Tawarengil, as you come into your own learning you will aid him in his.

   ‘Master Floxleaf here,’ he said, looking long into Ben’s face, ‘is a great surprise that I would caution all of you to appreciate; for many wonderful qualities can seemingly be found in hobbits if one takes more than a moment to look. I confess that I had not done that before, master Floxleaf, and I thank you greatly for making me reconsider. While my mind is quite occupied by more than a few problems at this time, I must say that hobbits like yourself make me hopeful in the most surprising of ways, and I will think of this surprise for some time into my future.

   ‘Ohtar I have spoken with,’ he said, turning towards the soldier. ‘There are many thoughts I have about your quest but, I remind you, the future of any people is only guided by their past and not ruled by it. The past can be a true and useful mirror, but the future moves forward whether a People recognize their reflection in that mirror or not.’

   At this he turned to the Unnórenean. ‘Your past has been veiled, I think, but not entirely forgotten. You have been given a great goal, young one, and I am uncertain what counsel I would have which might serve it. Perhaps only that you should never let wisdom counsel against bravery, but remember that bravery often needs wisdom’s temperance.

   ‘Of we three,’ he said, turning to Alatar and Pallando, ‘my heart tells me that we shall not all meet on this shore again.’ The two wizards looked long toward him at this and some unspoken agreement seemed to pass between them all.

   ‘Our service draws us each away, but our greater goal remains between us. We shall never know the answers for all Peoples by standing in the same place and asking ourselves the same questions, and our separate roads present a greater hope for all. Finding the Enemy, I think, is not so important as helping others to find their own strength against him.’

   ‘You are bold as ever, Olórin,’ Alatar responded, but even Benbow could see that his face and brow were not drawn into their usual disdain at the comment, ‘but I have come to believe you are more far-sighted regarding these People in the North than I. Your wisdom and experience serve you well here, and you are well-suited to this disincorporated age; you wander through the lands touching the spirits of many folk without charting or demanding a way forward for any of them.’

   ‘Or,’ Pallando said then, in surprising disagreement, ‘you have been wisely learning their natures and kindling them together for the fire to come. For who among us knows what will be needed when that day does arrive?’

   There was then a long silence that few felt any urge to break. Ben, normally very comfortable in long silences and certainly quite used to them, ended it quite abruptly.

   ‘I’ve no wisdom to lend to that, sirs,’ he said, ‘and I wish you all a chance to meet again, I suppose, if that is what you’d like, only...’

   ‘Yes, master Floxleaf,’ Alatar said, now raising that eyebrow again. ‘What is it?’

   ‘Well,’ Ben said shyly, ‘I’d like to know why the Bree-land is to be attacked, you see. If they came for master Flomi is one thing, and from the few things I’ve heard, that seems the way. But why are they taking the town? I guess that what I might ask is this, are they here for the dwarf or the plunder? It may be, knowing why they’d go there, tells us some purpose of that enemy you’re speaking of.’

   ‘Hah!’ Olórin said with a new light in his face. ‘I had not even thought that myself! Bravo, master Hobbit!

   ‘See there how unexpected these folk are! He makes a battle-savvy point we all have missed,’ Olórin said. ‘What exactly brings these orcs to the Bree-land? This dwarf may be uncommonly important for a reason we have glimpsed and that we believe the Enemy knows. But why send a force to the Bree-land when a small group of infiltrators might take the dwarf? Why should the quiet folk of the Bree-land fall?

   ‘I do not know this answer, master Floxleaf,’ Olórin continued, ‘but this is a question I will ask of the orcs.

   ‘Farewell, friends!’ Olórin said then as he gathered the reins of Alwana tighter in his hands and began his trek up the stairhead.

   ‘May we meet again in happier times! Or,’ he said, smiling to the others in the dim light of the cavern, ‘may better times draw us together to our happier meeting! I await good news of your greater fortunes!’

   And at this Olórin turned his face from the others and strode quickly up the stairhead. And in his long, long time in Middle-earth he was seen by only four of them ever again.

 

*****

   After the grey wizard had left the party new strategies were made. Benbow Floxleaf and Oisín Na-Glirhuin were sent out into the surrounding area to scout and gather provisions for the group beyond those which Milo had acquired. Ben would take whatever small game he might find here along the eastern side of the wall and Oisín would go over the wall and into the more deeply wooded area to its west. The discussion of trolls made the party worry that there might indeed be a cave in these nearby woods that had breached the other side of the mysterious door.Oisín would proceed with great caution in this search and also collect firewood and herbs they might need (he and Ben would also gather more gingergrass as it seemed to help greatly with Rosie’s fever). Both would return to the Glade of the Seven Birches within an hour of sunset.

   In the meantime, uncertain as to what might come through this newly discovered doorway, fortifications were to be made within the antechamber and the Grazing Field. Beothalion and Tawarengil, using leather stripping from the old orc weapons and what other easily cast-off items they could find, devised a very keen net of alarm to surround the breach and its surrounding seam. In this way any movement from that direction would warn them all immediately.

   Ohtar prepared the other door, the place of Flomi’s battle, for defense. The wood of the door was stout enough, but surely no guard against a troll or even a great-axe. The remaining pavise (two were still undamaged) were set below and at a raised angle in the Grazing Field to afford cover for archers. Some small store of bladed weapons (for they had salvaged what they could, even from the orcs) remained in the pantry at the top of the ramp, but the majority of better weapons and arrows were kept below. For if it came to desperate measures, they would need to defend the rampway at all costs. Ohtar had even taken some of the timbers from the grazing corrals below and used them to set brakes along the rampway which might slow down any large attack. Flomi and the beasts would need to be moved as well, but there was decent cover for them nearer to the Great Door and the fountains which surrounded it.

   Alatar and Pallando, when not checking on Flomi, spent their own afternoon near to the Great Door on the grazing floor below, deliberating in their usual silent way.

 

*****

   Decent hunting was found by Ben not so far from the wall and just north of the Glade (in those shallower lands where Flomi and Collum had left their own mounts to rest not a full week before), but Oisín had less luck. He gathered ample firewood, of course, for the trees were much older and thicker on the west of the wall, but no sign of caves or diggings could be found. He was unfamiliar with trolls through anything but the tales of his grandsires, but he could find no evidence of any large creature within a league of this part of the wall.

   Together the two met Ohtar at the secret doorway and told him their news. ‘Both of you bring good tidings then,’ Ohtar said, ‘for no wolves or trolls about is as welcome to hear as those fresh rabbits Ben carries for our breakfast.’

   They went inside and Ohtar again showed the Bard the trigger for closing the door. Then, as he pressed it and the door began to slowly shut, he was reminded of Flomi’s discovery and the rubbing the dwarf had made last week. His friend had not woken since last night, and Pallando had explained that his body was now in a deep state of healing. They all knew their best chance to leave this place came from the dwarf’s rest, his quick recovery, and his peaceful sleep, and no one had spoken with him since the previous evening. But now Ohtar felt that Flomi’s discovery, that carved inscription which he and no other man he knew had ever bent to notice, may be of some importance to their safety.

   ‘I would counsel now that this door remain shut until our own decisions have been made,’ Ohtar said as they began walking down the stairs. ‘I trust the grey wizard to divert the orcs from coming here, but even if he cannot this outer door will not be held against anyone who knows its secrets. The orc-scout might lead others here, but none of his folk would know how to open it.

   ‘You will see that we have set defenses to hold the Grazing Fields as Flomi himself did, though we are greater in number now and better prepared than he.’

   ‘It seems that one large rodent has set a flurry of concerns, Ohtar,’ the Bard said. ‘Though I trust your instincts, and Benbow Floxleaf’s nose, is all of this necessary?’

   ‘I cannot know, my friend,’ he said gently to Oisín, but Ben could sense Collum’s irritation at being second-guessed by someone he barely knew; he could see the corners of the man’s mouth curl into the old familiar and disarming smile he gave to many of the ignorant patrons of the Four Greenfields (and Ben, for just a moment, was shocked to realize that he himself had been treated to this same smile on a few occasions).

   ‘While you wait with worry,’ he said, ‘what is it that you do? Ben here hunts, and has done well in that. The Elf-lord, I can tell you, is very restless and anxious to move while his friend is quite content to sleep and eat moss and drink from the clear fountain waters. Of these wizards I cannot say, for if they show concern it seems quite unrelated to our own most pressing needs.

   ‘We two battle-ready men have just met, Oisín, and while that has been a fair thing so far, I do not know what you do when you are worried,’ he said as they came through the door to the Grazing Field, ‘but when I worry over a thing and have time for nothing else, I fortify and I prepare.’

   Below them Ben could see the changes made in the great open space of the Grazing Fields. Cover was set. A great deportment of arms was stationed. Traps were laid in any easy path forward. While no veteran himself, Ben had lived long in the North and seen many a battlefield before and after a major skirmish. His eyes were sharp, of course, and his understanding quicker than most accounted for. He could see that the restructuring of the room looked much like an encampment preparing for a siege and, because he was a good judge of character in his own remote and isolated way, he could see the expressions of wonder and wariness on the others as they came into the room; they didn’t skulk behind cover, but they too had been prepared for attack.

   ‘Well, I don’t know much about battlements, Collum,’ Ben said loud enough for all the others to hear, ‘but I’ve brought us a fresh brace of conies large enough for all our breakfast in the next two days,’ he said, holding his catch aloft, ‘and I don’t know many travelers who would say no to that.’

   A great ease went through the group then which everyone could feel. Beothalion laughed loudly, Rosie neighing with him, and Duncan shat again to show his own appreciation. The wizards held their quiet demeanor, but Ben imagined he saw a smile cross Pallando’s otherwise calm and placid face.

   ‘Thank you, Ben,’ Collum said softly as he started down the rampway. ‘You’re better at this than you know.’

 

*****

   ‘Rune-master, I do not mean to disturb you, but it seems I must ask you a question,’ the old wizened and pinched face said to Flomi as he came again out of dreams.

   ‘Hmmmrm,’ he said, rumbling deeply from a newfound hunger in his belly, ‘I have seen you. You are one of those who were at the inn the night I left.’

   ‘Yes, yes, that is so,’ the old man said impatiently, ‘and my brother Pallando has looked carefully toward your healing since we have come here-’

   ‘Yes,’ Flomi said sleepily, ‘he has the Eyes of the Sea... How do I know this? I do not know the sea...’

   ‘All who live in Arda harken to the call of Ulmo, Rune-master, though Aulë’s Children fear him greatly. The Sea is within all of you still,’ he said with some careful gentleness.

   ‘But I come to you now about stone, Rune-master,’ he continued, ‘and not the song of the Sea. I understand that you found an engraving near the door of this place when you first came here.’

   ‘Yes!’ Flomi said, his voice a bit clearer as he tried to sit up more at the question. ‘The script was the Tengwar script, surprisingly fluid and discreet for its carving, but the language was...,’ and he paused here, not through weariness or effort (even though he was still greatly wounded), but through a kind of embarrassment that he was formerly unfamiliar with. ‘The language was completely foreign to me,’ he said calmly.

   ‘And I understand that you have made a rubbing of this engraving?’ Alatar asked.

   ‘Indeed!’ Flomi responded, ‘it is, or should be, just there, within my bag. A small roll of parchment in a brown tie-string.’

   Alatar, now being invited, searched the worn leather pack of notes that Flomi had kept by his side since the battle. The pack held many items of great curiosity, but the wizard extracted the scroll quickly and began to open it before them.

   ‘The rubbing was made in haste,’ Flomi said, ‘and I hope to get a better one once those stairs intimidate me less, but I think you will find...’

   His talk stopped as the wizard had opened the roll, staring at the letters with a creased brow. Flomi did not know wizards before this day and had only met the two of them in a rather confused and feverish state, but he could sense the concern deepening in that old drawn face.

   ‘Do you know this language, Old One?’ he asked.

   ‘I know of it, yes, Rune-master,’ he said slowly, concentrating on the inscription, ‘but I do not speak it, if that is what you mean, nor do I suspect that any of the Wise here in the North do.

   ‘You are correct that it is written in the script of the Elves, but Elrond himself would be loath to see your little discovery,’ the wizard said, ‘for the words, of which I recognize only a few, are the Black Tongue of Mordor.’

 

End of Chapter Eight


Chapter End Notes

Notes on Chapter Eight

1)  Flomi’s defense of the Grazing Field took place shortly before dawn on April 13th (the 21st day of Chithing in the Bree-land calendar) and Collum and the others hoped that he would be ready to travel by the 16th.

2)  The removal of the bodies of the orcs and assassins happened during the early evening of the 13th. This was not shown in the previous chapter, which focused on Flomi’s feverish view of events, but doubtlessly occurred before Flomi woke to meet Beothalion and Tawarengil.

3)  The Unnórenain, “landless Men”, are of the blood of the Men of Númenor after all, and this place goes back to the ancient days of those people in the North before the division of Arnor. They are my own creation, of course, something I dreamed up specifically for this story, and while Collum seems to know of them at this point, I will be sharing more of their history as we go along.

4)  It has been a singular joy of this experiment in fanfic for me to try and describe the power of Gandalf’s laugh. Thanks for getting this far with me.

5)  This is a quote from The Silmarillion.

6)  This is a tricky word to use. I very much like the idea that there is a supernatural in the Legendarium but that those who participate in it regularly, elves and wizards and such, treat it in a commonplace manner. Having Oisín (and Ben and Beothalion) encounter it for the first time is important to the storytelling, but it seems only a character like Oisín would have a ready expression for it. The “magick with a ‘K’” thing seems appropriate, but there is no direct link to it in Tolkien’s languages.

7)  We will see more allusions to the relationship between the Minhiriathrim and their magical providers, the Pukel-men, in the future.

8)  An early derivation of Tolkien’s “woses” and the Pukel-men.

9)  ‘Nîr tôl erin baded lîn,’ “A tear/weeping comes on your going” -Sindarin

10) ‘Mas athradannech?’ “Where did you travel?” -Sindarin. Note here that the past tense use indicates Oisin’s poor grasp of the language for conversation. It is not used often among his people for anything other than stories. 

11) ‘Sílo Anor bo men lín.’ “May the Sun shine on your road.” -Sindarin

12)  The translation for “of anxious spirit” comes from many sources here, indicating Beothalion’s confusion of languages and mingled histories.

13)  This proved to be the most difficult section to write in the chapter. I wanted some musing here from Gandalf on the other wizards, but could find no way to do it without giving access to his own interiority. Tolkien never gave us the interior mind of wizards (except on one strange occasion), so to do it with Gandalf would border on sacrilege. I hope I’ve found a decent answer to the problem.


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment