New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
-Here Fellowships are Formed, Gifts are Given, Escapes are Made, Provisions are Sought After and the Science of Growing Mushrooms is Briefly Explained whilst the Visit of a Black Rider to the Bree-land is Recounted.
‘It was just a spark and a startle! I saw no robbers or killers! I was tired and I was frightened by fire, so I was louder than the spark was important and now, staring into your faces, I very much regret alarming the rest of you as I was alarmed myself,’ Buttercup said to the assembled townsfolk on the porch of the Four Greenfields. ‘So, please, take my apologies back to your homes and let the rest of us here alone to clean up after a long night’s work!’ All the Breelanders (all those who were not otherwise preoccupied by feasting, of course) had come running to the door when she had screamed from the second floor and had become quite aggrieved by being told to stay out by two of those old pilgrims who had met them before she had. They did not necessarily believe these tall old, sour-faced men who told them that everything was fine, but the Breelanders had prudently backed down from the strangers’ firm manner and their harsh stares which had forbade them to enter the inn.
After Collum and the Elf-lord went charging up the stair Buttercup had gone back to Flomi’s room with one of the old men (their leader, perhaps?). She realized that she still did not know any of their names. But this taller one in paler blue (who had been much quieter earlier in the evening) had asked her many questions along the way that she could not answer. The questions had made her feel foolish. She could not describe who she saw. She could not say if she had seen him before. She did not think she would know him if she saw him again. She could not say if he held a weapon. It was “no” to all that he asked. All of these questions, and her conclusions upon them, made her feel terrible. Surely Collum, if she might live up to his example, would have had more information to give. But she did not. She was tired and frightened and she had gone into a place that she was not permitted to be. Her panic at seeing a threat (and she was beginning to realize from the grave expressions on these men’s faces just how great a threat she had encountered), now made her feel weak not out of fear (though that was certainly part of her feelings), but out of disappointment. She had disappointed Collum and these others somehow by not being more observant, and so disappointed herself as well.
‘Buttercup,’ Collum had said to her in a gentle tone as they stood with the Elf and the old man in Flomi’s room before the open window, ‘you have risked much tonight, girl, and worked hard as any, but you dared much more by coming in here.’ His voice was low and caring, but she still felt embarrassed by it, for she knew she was forbidden to be in this room and had not made a good account of herself regarding the thief she had seen here. She avoided his eyes, and those of the young Elf-lord, as he spoke to her.
‘But the long hard night is over, girl,’ he said, ‘and hope comes with the morning.
‘Go back to the door for a short time, please,’ he continued, ‘and rid the house of our troublesome neighbours. I fear our newfound friends are not as up to that task as you are and may set new buildings ablaze just to discourage nosey hobbits. I’ll need a few short minutes with Benbow and the others and then you and I will meet in the commonroom.
‘I’m sorry, Buttercup,’ he said, lifting her chin and looking into her eyes, ‘but I’ve not much time and more than a few things to say. Can you help me a bit further and bring some short peace to the Four Greenfields at the end of a long night?’
‘Yes, sir, I will go to the door now,’ she had said, trying to look brave and even smile a bit to seem daring, ‘I’ve got wine for you all, but only just came here seeking proper paper as you asked-‘
‘No time left for wine I fear, girl, and I’ve papers enough for what must be done,’ he replied, grabbing three random sheets off of Flomi’s bedside table. ‘Just give all those busybodies at the door a proper thank you and farewell and then you and I shall talk soon.’
And she had done this, not that those outside the door were too happy about it all. Many wanted Collum himself to come out and give an accounting. They wanted his answers for the recent cries from inside, the goings-on within the Four Greenfields and just who these tall strangers thought they were to prohibit good neighbours from entry (these opinions, Buttercup noticed, were only offered after the old gentlemen had gone back inside).
‘I should like to hear from Collum himself, miss,’ said Andy Brockhouse, one of the young hobbits, ‘why, for all we know them old wassirds have put some spell on him and the inn itself will be the next thing set to blazes.’ There was a general agreement on this from the others with the exception of some grumbling from a few of the closer neighbours who had seen the strangers fighting the fire. It seemed that any good services these gentlemen had offered through the long night were being swept away in an hour’s worth of rumour. Towards the back of the crowd Buttercup could see Tom Truetunnels sitting amongst his other friends and watching slyly as the crowd on the porch grew more agitated.
‘How are we to know,’ another said rather loudly, ‘that these strangers haven’t put a spell on you, girl? You seem to have been talking to them quite a bit, and talking very strangely to the rest of us I’d say, ever since they came to the Bree-land.’
‘That,’ Buttercup thought to herself, keeping her anger in check, ‘is really quite too much.’
‘If you find my talk strange, Tom Birchfield, it’s for want of rest and freedom from such silly questions. So, for want of patience, let me talk with all of you all the more frankly:
‘The very kind, and I should say very hospitable, owner of this inn and provider of your morning’s meal is my master,’ she said, raising her voice to be heard above the rest, but keeping her tone even and polite as possible, ‘and he has told me to come here and say to you how thankful he is that so many Breelanders came to the aid of their town last night and how happy he has been to feed and to show his respect for so many worthies.
‘But it has been a very long night for everyone,’ she continued, ‘and all of us here need to get back to work! The Four Greenfields, by order of your host and my good master, is now closed to all but our traveling guests and the rest of you must hold your continuing questions for some later time. Should you show the courtesy to wash or stack your plates before you go then you will make our jobs here all the much easier but, if you can not find the kindness to do that, we trust you will finish your breakfast and leave the plates and cups behind you. While we’ve too much work and therefore no time for so much gossip, we thank you for last night’s bravery and wish a gracious good morning to you all!’
At this rather stern pronouncement she turned and slammed the large oak door of the inn and loudly threw the bolt. She paused there for a moment, breathing calmly as she may and then walked briskly away thinking, ‘So it is with our neighbours and customers. The best of them will know they’re time at the table is up, finish the food we’ve provided, and go about their business. The worst of them will do us no worse than steal a few plates or tankards and then arrive early to supper with more questions than they have coins.’
*****
‘He landed hard there, just near our window,’ Benbow said as he and Beothalion rejoined the others in the small outer hall. ‘But he clearly made it to his feet quick as a coney and there were some tracks to follow away down the alley. We gave chase, but lost any sign of him in all the wreckage of the stables and on the street behind.’
‘Little Benbow and I were quick, my friends, but this fellow was quicker,’ the big man added. ‘And I could not catch any smell of him with all the smoke still in the air.’
‘This is very bad news. Is there nothing else your sharp eyes could see, Ben?’ Collum asked.
‘Well, most folks are out in front of the inn now, so the streets back behind were clear when we came to them. I think we must’ve followed pretty close but saw no one and no discernible sign from here to the Hedge. He would have to be quick indeed to get out of town that way. No,’ the hobbit said, taking off his unique three-cornered hat and scratching his shaggy head in thought, ‘I think he either doubled back to the festivities through the smoke or slipped inside one of the other buildings. Either would be a neat trick for a sneak; makes him sharper than most I’ve heard of.
‘But I didn’t see enough of him to know what to look for, Collum. He was one of the Big Folk certainly, long strides and the tracks we saw were made by boots with a heel, so that’s something maybe. I might recognize that track again while walking the ground behind him, but I wouldn’t know the fellow himself if he turned and I looked straight into his face.’
‘The girl has no better description,’ Alatar said. ‘Dark clothed and taller than she herself, but she is not certain of the face.’
‘Could we not have her search the crowd outside?’ Tawarengil suggested. ‘Perhaps she might recognize him there?’
‘I’ll not risk her in that way,’ Collum replied, looking over to the wrapped body of the murdered stable-master. ‘No, I have my suspicions as to who is involved and am reassured that my people at the inn, and these rather uncomplicated, bull-headed yet still-admirable townsfolk, are now safe from any troubles I may have brought them. So all of this just makes my task the more urgent.
‘Friends,’ he said, reaching for his abandoned wine mug and lifting it to them, looking long into each of their eyes as he handed them back their own cups, ‘Ben and I will leave now while the townsfolk are distracted. If any of you, through all that we have discussed, would deign to join us, we will be found a league west of town just north of the Great Road at dusk. We will not tarry long there and then our way will change. I would be honored by your company, but can afford no longer time for debate. If you should stay, you will have the hospitality of this tavern and its new innkeeper for as long you should like. This we will do as Northmen, in respect to your great efforts at saving a town that is too stubborn to know what is good for them. If you go elsewhere, I wish all the blessings of my own house on your travels and good ends to all your works. Na lû e-govaned vîn!’1
And at this he raised his mug, but the others in the room (besides Beothalion who began to but was halted by Tawarengil’s quick and harsh gaze) did not.
‘We thank you for your kindness, Ohtar,’ Alatar said, ‘but we will not drink a cup of parting. We have every intention of coming with you, for a time at least, and, I believe, all are ready to depart now.’
‘This is so,’ Tawarengil said. ‘I have unanswered questions and many reservations, but I will follow the Istari, and you, for some time as this road leads West to my own purposes.’
‘This is good, Tawarengil,’ Beothalion said, ‘for I rather like these new friends that we have found and would be happy to walk with them further. But,’ he said, looking rather pitifully at his mug of wine, ‘does this mean we should not drink now?’
‘Drink we shall!’ Collum said with excitement. ‘And joy be with you all for your offer. A more proper word of salute then and we shall be on our way; Amatúlië!’2
At this hearty blessing in the Old Tongue (which Beothalion and Benbow did not understand) all seven of those present lifted the remains of their wine and responded ‘Mae g'ovannen!’3 then drank to their newfound fellowship.
*****
Walking back into the commonroom Buttercup, hoping to put aside her anxiety with familiar industry, began again her earlier task of tidying things up. She righted the overturned stools and collected the abandoned drinking vessels on a tray for washing up later.
‘I’d do it now if there were only some fresh water,’ she thought to herself, ‘but it must wait until that crowd has lessened a bit. Collum will want the inn shut until dinner I imagine, yet I’ll want something to do if I’m to stay on my feet much longer.’
She had wiped down the tables and was beginning to sweep when Collum, dressed in an old hooded traveling cloak, entered the room.
‘Getting ready for a room full of boasters and inquirers, I see,’ he said to her with a smile.
‘Oh, I’ve had quite my full share of our neighbors and their questions for one day, sir,’ she replied, ‘I’m mostly just keeping myself ready, and awake, for whatever work’s to come next.’
‘Leave that work to others, Buttercup, for you’ll need some rest now and your wits about you for later tonight.
‘I suspect half the town will be at your door once it opens,’ he said, taking a seat at one of the tables and motioning for her to join him. ‘And by then their theories, and their rumours, will have turned into quite a tidy little mess for them to argue over.
‘That’s the biggest part of the job here, you see,’ he told her as she sat down on the stool opposite his own, ‘let them do the talking. And only invest enough of your own wit and personality, and precious little of your own opinion, as to make them keep doing so. They’re decent enough folk, your neighbors here in the Bree-land, we saw that last night as they worked bravely and tirelessly to save the town. That was indeed something to see. Don’t forget it when later you hear the things they’re likely to say about Flomi, myself or the others.’
‘After you leave,’ Buttercup said, looking him squarely in the eye. ‘You mean to say that you are leaving now and not coming back, don’t you?’
‘I do, girl. My time here in the Bree-land is done,’ he said, ‘and I will admit that I shall miss it more than I had expected. But surely you know by now that I have concerns beyond this little tavern? You’re far too sharp to have not seen that much by now.’
‘I have, sir, at least I think I have in these past few months,’ she replied. ‘Flomi and yourself have been closer than ever it seems, and then when all these strangers started coming-‘
‘Those old gentlemen that you have met,’ he interrupted, ‘as well as Benbow, the young Elf-lord and his companion, will go with me in search of Flomi. This much you can tell your neighbors tonight and I don’t doubt that they will be happy to hear it. Let them say what they will about the fire in the stables. Flomi would have a laugh at their presumptions. But you should know for yourself that he was not responsible for that, and certainly not responsible for Guldir’s murder. We, all of us, go to aid Flomi now while he is in danger.’
‘I couldn’t believe that kind of talk for a minute, sir,’ Buttercup eagerly replied. ‘Master Flomi, though stand-offish to some, was kind to everyone who knew him, and Guldir more than most. Did-‘ she hesitated here, looking around the room and lowering her voice, ‘do you think it was the thief I saw that killed poor Guldir?’
‘Perhaps,’ he said. ‘Or one like him. I believe that Guldir was slain and the stable set to blaze as a diversion. I believe that Flomi was being watched and is now being followed. I’ll remind you, there have been other strangers in the Bree-land over the past few months.’
‘Sarnside’s friends, you mean! They have been a curiosity I’d forgotten with all these new travelers about,’ she replied. ‘But what interest would they have with master Flomi?’
‘That I won’t say, if for no other reason than your safety,’ Collum answered. ‘But be wary of master Sarnside and his friends tonight, should you see them. Have a care to never be alone amongst them. Milo will be gone for the rest of the day, but I’ve set some other friends from town to help if it should be needed. My own suspicion is that Sarnside and the others have already left and so you, and our nosey little neighbours here in the Bree-land, will be quite safe for now. And the Breelanders will now, quite happily, have something to argue over for much time to come.
‘Let them talk, Buttercup. Learn to listen, not just to their stories and their grumbling, but also to their needs. Let them talk and learn to profit by it.’
‘Where will you go?’ she asked.
‘This I also will not say,’ Collum replied. ‘Once more for your safety as well as other reasons. But I was a soldier when I came here and I go to be one again.’
At this he stood up from the table and Buttercup thought that he looked taller, and grander somehow, than she had ever seen him look before. It was as if the easy-going, relaxed manners of the innkeeper had been completely washed away. Who he was now was in fact closer to how she had come to think of him in the past few months; confident, wise and capable beyond the reckoning of others. It made her glad (and proud) to see it; as if she was proven right about a thing that people around her had missed. But it made her sad also, for this more than anything made her believe that she would never see the man again.
‘But,’ he continued, as he left the table and walked to his old position behind the serving area, ‘these bothersome but well-deserving folk of the Bree-land will still need an innkeeper and,’ he said as he reached under the counter and placed his well-known cudgel on the surface between them, ‘this inn will need a Peacekeeper.
‘These I leave with you for Milo,’ he continued, taking a sealed note from his pocket and placing it alongside the weapon. ‘Big for his size perhaps, but I’ve no doubt he’ll come to handle it. Milo is a friend to be trusted, Buttercup, and you’ll learn that trusting him will bring him closer to your service. Like you, he has a talent for listening better than most, but of greater value is his talent for keeping what he hears to himself. This letter, signed and sealed, will make him the new stable-master once the place is rebuilt and also your most loyal confederate in times of need. Have him carry this little deterrent openly for a time,’ he said as he lifted the cudgel, ‘and people will know that order, of the kind I may have provided, still remains in the Bree-land.’
‘Yes, I will, sir,’ she said, ‘but with you gone and poor Guldir now dead, who shall run the inn, let alone rebuild the stables?’
‘Why, girl,’ Collum said with a grin as he took a second sealed letter from his pocket, ‘that’s to be your job, of course.’
*****
The six travelers, having left Collum behind to attend to his last bit of business in the Bree-land, now made their way quickly and quietly out of the town. Ben knew the streets quite well of course, and the Breelanders were still distracted enough by what remained of the morning’s victules and their own competing rumours so that none saw the six companions steal their way out the side door and through the maze of low buildings westward to the Hedge. Ben himself did not reckon time as the other Breefolk did, but the angle of the sun told him it was still before what they considered nine of the clock and he hoped to be clear of the town as soon as possible.
‘We’ll cut a bit north at town’s edge to keep out of sight from those closest to the western gate. The Hedge is still thin there,’ he told them, ‘high and sharp enough that a horse wouldn’t win through, but a Man, even one as big as Beothalion here, can manage it. Once we make the other side we’ll use it for a time as cover before striking west. There are a few farms to cross out that way, but I reckon those farmers close enough to have seen the fire’s smoke this morning will be in town.’
They were clad much as they had been before, though Ben had put on a long grey cloak to protect himself from the brambles he knew they’d be encountering in the Hedge. He had returned his long peaked cap to his head, pulling it low to provide shade for his keen eyes as he searched their surroundings for any witnesses. He still had his small pack with water, hunting knives and some other essentials, but much of his usual gear was now lost in the fire at the stables. He hoped that Milo had been able to secure provisions for just wherever it was Collum meant them to travel. But his bow was back at his side and he had a quiver full of good arrows. He’d gone into much wilder lands before and been just fine carrying much less.
Beothalion and Tawarengil had little more than the clothes on their backs. The big man carried a large water skin, a small waist pouch, his quarterstaff and nothing else; no sign of food, or bedroll or change of clothing could be seen among them. Ben might not have found that peculiar in Tawarengil’s case, for Elves (at least as he had seen) enjoyed but did not need such comforts. Yet Ben had never known a Man to travel in the open with so little as this big wanderer had clearly done. And for them to have come all the way over the Misty Mountains in this way seemed all the more incredible.
The elf-lord’s own gear Ben took notice of as well. The leather of his doublet and boots was brown-grey and supple, a hide or a curing process Ben was unfamiliar with had made them light as cloth though he was certain they were much much tougher. On his belt, a simple but bright white sash bound by a wooden clasp, hung two knives in leather scabbards. They were small to suit his stature, but Ben did not doubt that they were keen and that the young lording could be quite deadly with them. The fire and the flight into danger this morning had made him all the more curious about Tawarengil’s actual age. Now as in the stables he looked less like a boy and all the more like a warrior of some experience.
The most curious part of the elf-lord’s gear however, came as quite a surprise. From among Beothalion’s other gear he lifted a long wooden shaft, nearly as tall as Ben himself, and on a cord of some kind he wore it on his back. At first glance Ben thought it might be a bow and was glad to have another bowman in the group. But as Tawarengil turned to address the others Ben could see it was no bow at all but a great wooden training sword much too big for anyone of his stature.
‘What he’ll want with a thing like that is beyond me,’ Ben thought to himself, ‘but Elves have strange customs of course, and I doubt he’d like to hear me ask of it.’
The Istari (or so Ben began to call them, having heard it so often from the Elf-lord and thinking it a much more respectful word than wassird) also seemed to be comfortable on foot and with little need of provision. Olórin, the more talkative of the group, carried a rather tall staff, and a large well-worn knapsack of a tough-looking and grey-colored thick hide that Benbow had also never seen before. He wore the same dark grey traveling clothes as he had earlier, and a wide-brimmed, tall-pointed felt hat that shielded his eyes just as Benbow’s own did. His leather boots were high and showed the scars from long years of walking rough lands, leaving the hobbit to wonder at the age and contrasting hardiness of these grey-haired and wizened folk.
Alatar, who very much seemed to be the leader of the three odd gentlemen, had no other baggage than he did when Benbow first saw him the night before in the commonroom. No waterskin nor kitbag, no cap nor outer cloak. He held a short rod in his hand that Ben had not seen before; smooth and white with blunted ends, it looked as if it had been carved from some great horn, milky white, curling like a great braid.
The third wanderer, whose name Ben thought was ‘Pallandin’ or something like, had put on a large, dark grey traveling cloak that concealed his deep blue robes. He had produced it from the leather shoulder bag he carried and, at his hip, he now carried a longsword in a finely-tooled leather sheath. Where this weapon had come from Ben could not rightly say but, old as this wassird looked, it was comforting to have another armed companion with him on such a curious adventure as the one they were now beginning.
In the earliest days of the Bree-land, at the laying of Tharangond which was the crossing of the two roads, the surrounding countryside had been fertile but wild. The Kings had come out of the sea and built or fortified their great cities to the north and to the west, but here, around Bree-hill, the descendants of the First Men then still roamed freely through a great wood which filled the valley on either side of the Old Road. There was peace, if not full trust, between these two peoples at this time and, for many a year before the Great War in the South, much commerce. As traffic moved safely across the roads in the early days of the North Kingdom the valley was cleared for farmlands and the Bree-land became a center for trade. It was in this time, although the Breelanders had certainly forgotten it, that the Sea-kings had set the Clock into its short tower so that all travelers might see it from the Crossroads and know that here was a place of the King’s watch and the home of a peaceful and industrious folk.
But as the Bree-land grew and the Sea-kings diminished, as dark things roamed the lands to the North and to the East, and then particularly since the coming of the Little People like Tom Truetunnels’ own industrious grandsires, the town, recognizing no real lord or king, quartering no armies nor standing any organized militia, found that it had no real protection from the increasingly dangerous countryside. Many citizens at this time had proposed the building of a surrounding wall to ensure their safety. But, having no government and therefore (thankfully, to many a Breelander’s thinking) no taxes with which to begin such an enterprise, a wall was an expense quite beyond the scope of their agreements. The Hedge then became the best solution the simple farmfolk of the Bree-land had been able to manage and they began building it with tremendous seriousness.
A great furrow had been dug along the perimeter of the town and all of the surrounding farmers participated in a great planting and long tending of bramble bushes; the first real public work of these independent people. A rather surprisingly sophisticated system of irrigation (introduced by those same industrious Little Folk who gave the Truetunnels their family name) was then created and the Breelanders, who usually disagreed on much, all took an uncommon pride in their shared duty for the building and maintenance of this barrier. Now, many centuries since its planting, the Hedge, while by no means as formidable or as easily defended as a wall, was indeed the small town’s only outer defense and one of which they were the most proud.
As Benbow had described, the Hedge that the party now approached was as high as a man was tall and about ten or more paces (if regular paces could be made through it) in its depth. The thicket of bramble-thorns and dark foliage was an obstacle to any large assault from across the open farmlands, but was not impossible for earnest and experienced travelers (or particularly nimble-footed hobbits) to pass. As the party came to it they could see that the thicket was closer and more tangled than it had appeared from a distance. There were no paths visible in the undergrowth, and they found it encircled by a stream running down from the hills in a deeply dug bed with steep slippery sides overhung by brambles.4 One could not jump over the stream, nor indeed get across it at all without getting wet, scratched and muddy.
‘A rather fine parting courtesy from these townsfolk for all our service,’ said Tawarengil. ‘Is it meant to keep their enemies at bay or their guests and neighbors from leaving?’
‘In springtime the stream runs a bit faster,’ replied Benbow, ‘but it is not much deeper than my own knees are tall. It feeds the Hedge through the summer months and the water here is cool and clean.’
‘It is, little Benbow,’ Beothalion said, as he bent to take a long drink from the clear waters. ‘It is quite refreshing!’
‘I’m not sure what Collum has in mind for our travels, nor what provisions his Milo might have found sufficient to all of us,’ Ben said to the others. ‘So I suggest you fill your waterskins here. We’ll be in open lands in a few hours, and the day looks to be quite warm.’
The others took this advice and, indeed, Beothalion had already begun to do so. When the wildman’s great vessel was but a quarter filled, he handed it, in a most perfunctory manner, to Tawarengil who took a long satisfying draught and handed it back to be refilled. The Elf then turned his face up at the early morning sun and closed his eyes, looking quite refreshed.
‘Have you no drinking skin yourself, my lord?’ Benbow asked. ‘Or, perhaps, no need for one?’
‘Oh, he will drink, little Benbow,’ Beothalion replied with a hearty chuckle as he continued filling his water bag, ‘though he does not like to admit to needing it. He will drink from mine when the rare need is on him, and he is well pleased that I am strong enough to carry water for two.’
‘And thirsty enough to drink it for four,’ the young Elf-lord replied with a smile. ‘But it is true, Master Floxleaf, that my people of the Greatwood need little of such sustenance when we walk in the open lands under Sun and Stars and amid things green and growing. We do take delight in clear drink and hearty foods, of course. I do not know how it is with those you have met in the House of Elrond, but my people reserve feasting for our halls and allow calavénë, eleni and laicolassë5 to bring us strength during our travels.’
‘We hear that Sun and Stars grow dim in the South of Eyrn Galen these days, my lord,’ said Alatar, ‘and one of my brethren did accordingly set his watch upon the land there.’
‘This is true, lord,’ the Elf replied. ‘Radagast he is called among us, though we did not give him that name nor know its meaning.’
‘That name is old,’ Olórin said. ‘The First Men gave it to him long ago before they met the Elves and their language from that time is lost in these and all other lands. Perhaps he alone in the world still recalls it. But he remembers those First Men fondly. He uses that name again, I believe, in their honor, for he loved them more than any other folk on two legs in the Elder Days. But we three have not heard from him in many long years and are glad to hear he remains at his vigil.’ At this the grey wizard looked long at his companions as if in some assurance of a past discussion.
‘Radagast does not come to Authengroth,’6 Tawarengil replied, ‘or has not in my young lifetime, but many of my folk have met him in the Greatwood or at his home in Rhosgobel in the western eaves. He has a queer manner, some say. More apt to speak the languages of birds than the Ancient Speech in polite company, and more apt to screech warnings than to give judicious advice, say others. Thranduil accords him great honor, as he is certainly due, but asks from him no consul. This makes many of my folk sad as the Greatwood grows dark. We do not doubt his wisdom, but we do not understand his mind and are therefore wary of his assessments. We should welcome sage advice as the Wood grows dark but, alas, where shall it be found?’
‘Does Elrond offer no opinion on these matters?’ Alatar asked. ‘Or have relations become cold between your two houses?’
‘I do not know, lord,’ the young elf replied. ‘For while Thranduil is my uncle I am still counted as too young to be in his councils and know nothing more of Rivendell than is told in our songs. But few of my people ride forth from the Greatwood since the Last Alliance and fewer still of other houses come to speak with us.’
‘Surprising, then,’ suggested Olórin, as he looked westward through the Hedge, ‘that Thranduil should send forth a force now against a foe so far from his own borders.’
At this Tawarengil had no response. But after a moment’s pause, the old man continued speaking.
‘But the call of Círdan the Shipwright is, of course, no small urgency and I’m sure the lord of Authengroth knows this,’ the wizard said. ‘Hopefully many more of the Eldar will feel as you do, my lord, and answer it.
‘Now, Master Floxleaf,’ he said, smiling as he changed the conversation abruptly, ‘I believe we should be on our way.’
*****
An hour or two ahead of the company an impatient Milo Fastknots had made his way out past the Hedge-gate and onto the Dwarf Road. The small farmlands and rolling hills that surrounded the village of the Bree-land on its western side were quiet in the early morning light. A few stray Breelanders encountered him as they were coming toward the town, but of course they were more interested in news of the smoke than to have any suspicions of Milo and his master’s horse leaving the fire behind them. Those that Milo had met he sent quickly into town with the barest of information as he himself went steadily in the other direction. If people asked him only a few questions it was because Milo had acquired a reputation for giving very little in the way of answers and, in this case, that reputation served him well. During this whole time Benbow’s pony had lingered twenty to forty paces behind, keeping Milo and Caitelyn in sight, but refusing to be seen in their company.
Having passed the Hedge-gate, the Big Hill (itself called “Bree”) that defined the area sat at the north-east corner of the two Roads’ crossing and now lay behind him. Along the hill’s southern and eastern faces, opposite Milo’s path and to the other side of the town, the most populated parts of the Bree-land had developed; Staddle, the Combe, and Archet. There beside the Hill and bordering the Chetwood, Breelanders kept a watchful eye to the north yet lived still in great peace. West of the Hedge, as Flomi had noted in his travels some days before, the farms were fewer and the series of low running hills to the west of the Crossing were growing more wooded. There was a line of trees that indicated the North-south Road and Milo could see them clearly just half a mile ahead as he left the haze of the village.
‘That pony friend of yours is sticking with us still,’ he told Caitelyn, his master’s great grey mare that he led, ‘though she wants nothing to do with me. She must be half-smart, spending so much time with Benbow as she does, and a good judge of company.
‘Well, come along then,’ he said, half turning back to speak to the pony. ‘Your master wants you just like ours does, and it won’t do to keep either of them waiting for a time when you and I might become friends.’ He quickened the pace a bit then, partly out of a hope to speed the pony along and partly out of a desire to keep himself awake.
‘There’s much yet to do,’ he thought to himself, ‘before there’s to be any rest. I’m to meet Master Collum and Ben a league from here, and that much is easy. Providing for them both is another matter. Probably I might borrow some light stores from old Master Peoninny’s place up the Road there. He’s friendly enough to my master and won’t ask much in the way of questions.’
‘But a saddle for you,’ he said aloud, returning to his conversation with Collum’s horse, ‘now that will take some doing.’
Most hobbits, it should be known, were not quite comfortable even on the backs of small ponies and seldom would they ride for long distances. Some of those Shirefolk Milo had seen were known to come back into the Bree-land with ponies from time to time, and rumour told that they traveled quite some distance that way along the Dwarf Road. But like most of the Little Folk, they used their ponies mostly for provisions and only occasionally had Milo heard of them riding up into the town. Maybe they rode in saddles all the time out there past the Brown River. Shirefolk, it was said, had queer ways and Milo knew nothing about them and their behavior in their own lands. Milo had his own pony of course, and he was big enough to ride her at need whenever she was kind enough to allow it. But he had no saddle for her as a saddle for a pony seemed a right uncommon thing to own.
Ben was the only hobbit who Milo had known to ride in the saddle and this made him, and his pony, all the more unusual to the Breelanders. Saddles were not for ponies, as they saw it. Saddles were for horses and horses were for the Big Folk like his master. The problem was that not many of the Big Folk lived west of the town and Milo had not believed that setting out in any other direction would be possible, not if Ben’s irritable beast was expected to follow. So he decided to leave with the greatest haste and in the direction of least notice, taking his chance west along the Dwarf Road.
On this more direct path Milo knew of only one horse’s saddle between here and the Shire. For just past the North-South Road lived Motho Greenhands and, as Motho was happy to tell any who might listen, he was a rare hobbit to own a horse. And that horse had a saddle.
‘Any farmer worth his crop might own a pony,’ Motho would say to any neighbor who would listen, ‘And my own ponies are friendly souls that I’d never part with for nothing. But a horse, a good horse and one who knows who is his master, mind you, a horse like that is worth three or four ponies to a hard-working farmer.’
Now in the opinion of most Breelanders Motho was only barely a farmer, hard-working or otherwise, and his name, Greenhands, was the subject of some fairly unkind jests. For he had changed the family name recently, as many of the Little Folk did when they came into the Bree-land, and no doubt he saw this new one as an improvement in regard to his reputation as a well-to-do farmer. But his old name was known to be Brownbottom, so ‘old Bottom-to- Hand’ was what some of the townsfolk called him in their own talk. Seldom within his own hearing of course, for Motho Greenhands, odd in manner and eccentric in tastes though he may be, commanded that certain respect and snide disapproval that all people of a small town seemed to have for the wealthiest among them.
As to his farming abilities, Motho had a good sized field not a quarter mile west of the Crossing where he grew mushrooms almost exclusively. Mushrooms were always in great demand amongst the Little Folk of the Bree-land, but Motho had somehow wisely cornered the market with a relatively small plot of land here west of the Hedge as the crop did not grow nearly so well upon the eastern slope of the Hill. Others had tried of course, but Motho had bought or developed a very unique process for handling the crop and, if it had lasted much past his own life, this would’ve been a marvel to other farmers for many years to come.
Mushrooms grow in cool, dark places of course, requiring little maintenance and, if conditions are right, yield three to four good crops in a year. They’re often planted to grow wild alongside large groves of fruit trees; a kind of extra bounty of the deep shade in an orchard of apples or pears popular in the east of the Bree-land. When Motho purchased the land of his farm he did not invest in any other crop but mushrooms. He built (or, more precisely, had built for him) two long sheds made of stone and mortar, forty paces from end to end and not much taller inside than some of the taller men among the Breefolk. The building had unique coverings of living earth and grass, like tunnels that had been raised up out of the ground and then covered again for protection from the sun. Alongside the eastern edge of each of these buildings, or ‘vaults’ as he called them, large shade trees remained so that structures remained both hidden and cool throughout the day. Inside of each building there were three shelves filled with soil, of a ‘special blend’ Motho told all the other Breelanders, and this provided the excellent conditions of temperature and darkness that made his crop into a wealthy industry even in such a small town as the Bree-land.7
Just how Motho Greenhands, in his former days as Motho Brownbottom, had come upon such advanced and progressive farming techniques is still unknown. He had been known to talk with many travelers and merchants in his younger days, but had no true friends within the town who could recount his earlier experience through anything other than gossip. With his closeness to town, he did not need to tend to the farming much himself but trusted local hands while he himself spent more of his time in a mushroom specialty shop not far from the Four Greenfields. With the other shop owners and townsfolk there as his constant clients he had become one of the wealthiest of Breelanders; and this certainly had gone a long way toward why so many seemed to dislike or to gossip about him. For in the Bree-land too much success was usually a cause for suspicion, and the price for Motho’s mushrooms still ran a bit high for anyone’s sense of fairness.
The story of how Motho, a collector of many odd things from foreign parts, came into the ownership of a horse and saddle was also a bit unclear. There were many tales (mostly told by old Tom Truetunnels) which floated around the Four Greenfields of Motho meeting with foreigners and dwarves and other outliers whenever they came to town; of helmets and swords, scrolls and spices and other surprising things which he had purchased that no other Breelander could see any practical use for. ‘Oh, he loves the stories of those old warrior folk,’ Tom had been heard to say, ‘but what a mushroom vendor like Bottom-to-Hand needs of a tall and shiny helmet I can’t imagine. Maybe he dresses in high boots with stirrups and cuts those mushrooms with a sword in those long dark halls of his. Maybe he’s built a ladder, block and tackle to put him on that horse he brags so much about.’
One version of the horse’s origin was that it had belonged to one of the Big Folk in Archet, another competing mushroom farmer, who had lost the beast somehow in an outstanding debt. Maybe he was a failed business rival, some said. Or maybe, said others, he was some mushroom thief Motho had caught and sent running, wearing his helmet and hauberk, brandishing his frightful (but, in terms of the story, quite hilarious) sword. This much more heroic version was one Motho himself liked to suggest but never would attest to. ‘I’ve a very great horse, a warrior’s horse if there was one,’ he would say, ‘and I have taken him fairly,’ he would finish mysteriously.
Milo, however, doubted that any hobbit as short and overweight as old Bottom-to-Hand might be sending any of the Big Folk running and keeping the horse he rode in on for his own. That much seemed much less than true and much more about him building a big story.
Either way Milo had seen the horse led into town last harvest with a huge wagon coming behind him. He was a great red-colored fellow, a horse leading a wagon way too large for carting mushrooms. Since that day he’d heard Motho talking about this horse most every chance he got on nights at the Four Greenfields. Whether the farmer hoped to sell the horse or whether he was simply bragging about his ownership of it, Milo did not know. Perhaps the rumours of the horse’s origins just added to the price of mushrooms.
But none of that mattered to Milo now as he walked west down the Dwarf Road and considered how he might get the things that his master required.
For his own part Milo had no real opinion about Motho Greenhand and, if pressed on the matter, he did not really care much for mushrooms nor was he willing to dislike a merchant simply for his prices or personal eccentricities. His thoughts were much more direct and much more simple; his master needed a saddle (two, if another could be found for Ben’s unsociable pony) and the mushroom farm of Motho ‘Bottom-to-Hand’ presented the young hobbit with his first (and possibly only) chance to procure it quickly.
*****
The six travelers, one at a time and with Benbow going first, made their way across the stream and through the Hedge. Any clever path that the hobbit may have discovered through his small size and great agility was of little use to the others as Beothalion, coming second, simply lumbered through the thicket behind him breaking branch and limb and cursing each scrape. The others followed, each at their own pace, with Tawarengil bringing up the rear in his own relaxed manner.
‘Well, brother,’ he said to Beothalion with a smile, ‘you have quite made a mess of these poor folks’ outer fences. I might’ve ridden a good size pony through this hole you have put in their fortifications.’
There was, as Ben could see, very clear evidence of their passing for any curious eye to notice. ‘Well, I don’t believe there’s so much worry from that, my lord,’ Ben told the Elf. ‘The Breelanders won’t have any reason to follow us and are likely to be glad we’ve left them. Certainly that Hedge will mend itself fast enough in springtime so that this path we’ve cut will be no more than a good story for the Bree-folk by fall. But I would caution you all,’ he said, looking about at the others and trying to affect a tone of command, ‘to show some better care as we travel. I’ve no idea where it is Collum means for us to go, but I know him well enough to not doubt him that danger is involved.
‘And I should further remind you all that we’ve no idea what happened to that fellow Beothalion and I chased after’, he said looking at the wildman. ‘Likely it was he or one his comrades that cut the poor stable-master’s throat for little reason and he or they seem to have some purpose in all this trouble. I should not like to make our presence known to such murderous folk as we move into the open lands ahead.’
‘Wise consul, master Hobbit,’ said Olórin. ‘I believe we should all do well to follow your lead for a time.’
And so Benbow led them across the open farmlands and pastures surrounding the western edge of the Bree-land. It was still the early spring, so they were able to cut a mostly straight line through the small fields and low rolling hills. They walked along in silence and Ben found himself rather pleasantly surprised by just how quiet they all, most unexpectedly and especially the Wildman, could be. The trees here became sparse and the first thing that came to the travelers eyes as the ground began to level was the North-South Road.
From their vantage point, just a mile or so north of the crossing and still raised as they were by the Hill’s gradual slope, the “Fornost Road”, as the Breelanders called it, was a wonder to behold.
‘Tawar,’ Beothalion said in a quiet voice as they all stood for a moment in clear view of the opening lands before them, ‘what is that?’
‘It is the work of Men, brother,’ the young Elf answered, his own voice lowered with an uncharacteristic awe, ‘and I must confess that I have never seen its like.’
Benbow had seen it many times before of course, but he could still appreciate their wonder.
Here, in this part of the North, the landscape was not level as in some plains of the South of which Ben had heard. The land before them ran as far as the eye might see in low and undulating hill country. To the far west, and moreso away toward the north, the hills continued and some tips of mountain peaks were seen, the Emyn Muil, rising behind the distant hills and catching the light of the morning sun. Ben had not been to those mountains, for at this time in his life he had never gone west of the Brown River, but he knew those mountains were great and, so rumour told him, at the very edge of the world. To the north and away east he knew the land much better, and even now, behind Bree Hill, the Weather Hills and even the nearest faces of the Hithaeglir were familiar to his experience and from the stories of his fathers; for the Floxleafs had hunted and trapped for many generations in this rolling countryside below the snowy lands between the western river and the eastern mountains.
Ben had never gone south of the old Dwarf Road much, for the South Downs were said to be haunted and the forests of the lands there had been stripped and made bare long before the formation of the North Kingdom. Strange tales came up the Road from that direction in older days, but now, in Benbow’s time and on that spring morning, a haze lay beyond those furthest hills and the land there stretched forth into an unfathomable mystery. Looking there he wondered at something Olórin had suggested earlier; had Collum really come to the Bree-land out of the South? What stories had he to tell of lands there which Ben had only half-imagined?
Against all this massive and open country, here, in this part of the North that Benbow Floxleaf knew very well, the Fornost Road, untended as it was for many long years, ran straight as a pikestaff for as far as keen eyes could see, never yielding to nor interrupting the landscape which surrounded it. And nothing in the natural shape of the world could quite compare with the experience of its vast orderliness.
‘I do not understand it. Did the hills themselves obey these Men?’ Beothalion asked. ‘Do hills rise or fall for this thing, or is it perhaps older and deeper even than they are?’
‘Old to some eyes it may be, Beothalion, and I am glad to be here and see the wonder of it touch your young heart,’ said one of the Istari. This was the third and most silent of the group and Benbow, who was yet unsure of this quieter wassird’s name, was surprised by his sudden speaking and the soft frankness in his voice. There was a light, even a kind of sadness or joy, in the old man’s deep green-grey eyes as he looked at Beothalion which Ben had not yet seen in the others; as if he had somehow been kindled to the wildman by his wonderment.
‘And old it may seem,’ he continued, ‘but as brief as a bud in the flowering of these lands which surround it. For here you look upon one of the last great works of the Dúnedain that was laid in an earlier age of the world, in this their time of Redemption, but yet the hills make little notice of things which are so fleeting.
‘Great in learning were your People when they came up out of the Sea and, as the innkeeper has recounted, a great love of the land was in their hearts. They brought with them much of the wisdom and wonder that was to be found in the high tide of their realm, of which much is forgotten,8 and with these lost arts they could read many designs of the order of the world.’
‘My People?’ the wildman said with even greater surprise in his voice. ‘This cannot be so...’
‘I have walked this road many times in my days here,’ Olórin said, ‘and it stretches many more hundreds of miles than your own trip here from the Carrock, Beothalion. And for all that walking still I marvel at its scope. To build such a marvel and to so readily abandon it is a thing I cannot yet understand...’ And at this his voice trailed off as if he was lost in some deeper thought than he had meant to speak but chose to wait on.
‘And so it is with the works of Men,’ said Tawarengil. ‘And the Elves understand it no better.’
‘We’ll not be traveling by the Road,’ Ben told the others, ‘at least not unless Collum has some plan I can’t guess at, and its way north to Fornost is dangerous these days. But we’ll cross it straight on and then meet our friends about a league or so on the other side. Come, but have a care for noise as we approach the Road and keep a sharp eye for travelers!’
*****
Collum’s own way out of town was faster, if more clandestine, than that of his companions. He concluded his business with Buttercup as quickly as possible, leaving her to her astonishment and worry, as he departed through the same rear door of the common room that Flomi had used on the previous night.
‘Far too hastily,’ he thought. ‘I have watched her for many years and hoped to leave her ready for much. But we leave too hastily. I would, given time, have given her more.’
Buttercup would, he hoped, be fine with the two letters under his seal. ‘She and her kin will now own that wretched little inn for generations to come and, through her kindness and care, her neighbors might yet be happy despite the wars that would go on around them.’ He would have prepared her better, if he could, but his service here was not to the inn nor Buttercup nor the townsfolk. His service was to his Princess and to the task she had set him.
‘But the girl is strong in her quiet way. Stronger than most and perhaps she will find her better qualities without my guidance.’ He left hoping for Buttercup’s success, hoping for the continued safety of the whole silly little town of the Bree-land, but he left them all the same.
The haze was still fairly thick in the alleyway behind the inn from the fire’s smoke, and Collum went west out the door, away from the wreck of the stables and toward the Hedge-gate. Under a small cluster of overturned crates at this alley’s end he had hidden his pack and his longsword many hours earlier, when he had then hoped to use the fire as a distraction for his departure. Now he recovered them quickly and strapped the pack fairly low in front of him and the sword down the center of his back where it would not draw undue attention. He then threw his travel-worn cloak over the pack, the sword and himself, covering his head with the hood, stooping a bit and turning one shoulder higher than the other. He also took two of the largest crates from the pile and tied them to a makeshift yoke which he might carry across his broad but now slanted shoulders. Walking from the alley in this way he looked much like any of the other Big Folk who lived among the Breelanders carrying supplies home from town; his frame appearing to be a little bent by labor and his middle seeming a little thicker from long nights of peace spent among friendly neighbors.
In this manner he moved steadily, though not too quickly, toward the Hedge-gate, his eyes on the ground and his body exaggerating the weight of his burden so that no one would see his face. He would be seen by many but, as he had come to manage in his past dozen years of service, recognized by very few. Now his mind was burdened with what steps to take next.
‘I had not reckoned for such a large party to join me,’ Collum thought, ‘But how can I refuse such noble assistance? Is it even within my power to decide? More than chance seems to have put three wizards on my doorstep for the day of our departure. Still, I must not let their questions slow me.’
The grey wizard, Olórin, had surely guessed much from Collum’s talk earlier. He had also shown a certain closeness about his observations that made any further questioning easier for just now. But surely the others would begin to make these deeper inquiries about his mission; the young Elf-lord most of all. “How then shall I face such questions,’ he wondered. ‘My oath is clear, but they’re assistance may be vital. Shall our task then be finally revealed?’
He came to the Hedge-gate quickly enough and the few people he saw on the Road were intent on the smoke and still hovering around the town and their own conversations. A dark-haired woman stood there beside the Gate watching him, her clothes darkened by soot and her hair disheveled from a long night of fire-fighting. Collum, who was also Ohtar, knew her well but in his secrecy their eyes could not meet. He would think of this parting for many days on his own road ahead.
Soon, not ten minute from the gate, the Old Road curved right towards the north and he left it. He abandoned his yolk and his disguise in the first group of trees that provided him with cover. Putting the yoke down, he removed his cloak and his pack. At his feet there was a small reddish stone and he lifted it, but found nothing there. He drew the third of his morning’s letters from his pocket, folded it carefully and, drawing a small ring of bone from another pocket, placed them both beneath the stone. He then took the longsword from his back and righteously, for the first time in many years, buckled it gladly to the familiar spot on his left hip. He was now prepared for the road ahead and had given over the duty of his service for those behind him. He swung the pack over one shoulder and replaced his cloak, now with his hood pulled back that he might look long at the western lands which finally lay before him and his mission. Then, uncharacteristically, he spoke aloud when no one was there to hear him:
‘West now to serve. The innkeeper is gone and I am once again openly the son of my Fathers in the service of our line. ‘Voronwë siluva ep’ eleni’.9 At this he smiled, and went quickly, quietly into the wild lands west of the Hedge-gate to meet his comrades. If he ever looked back with longing for friends at the Hedge-gate this tale does not tell.
*****
Earlier in the night the stars were bright and the moon was high still behind him to light the way. There were bird sounds, or Flomi thought them birds at the time, but otherwise it was quiet and his way was easier. On both sides of Flomi the woods pressed on, thicker and growing denser as he had noted before; but northward he knew that the ground fell steeply and the tops of the dark trees, growing at the bottom of the slope, were from this vantage quite well below his feet. Beyond them, north, the lowlands of old Arnor lay dim and flat under the dawn and there, perhaps thirty leagues from where he now walked, lay the conquered city of Fornost Erain. Did the Witch-king himself now sit in the darkened halls of that mighty fortress, so perilously close? The dwarf quickened his pace at the very thought of it.
‘Guldir was certain that this rider was from the Enemy, Flomi,’ Collum had said just a week before, ‘and I trust his appraisal. He does not speak lightly of such things.’
Thinking of it now, Flomi felt foolish and, subsequently, angry. Many things were becoming much more clear to him on this journey through the night’s darkness. How had so many generations of his family’s toil come to this? How had he not heard Collum mention ‘the Enemy’ and not known the dire implications of his labours?
Twelve years ago, when there had been a burglary and Collum had come to town to serve as his new companion, Flomi had been excited; for the idea that burglars had come to take an interest in his work was a certain, albeit dubious, measure of his success. All dwarves hated burglars of course, but the rumour of wealth that good burglars have such an uncanny nose for was, to a young dwarf like Flomi, some assurance that his long and chiefly silent works were not made in vain. How someone had come to know of his research was frightening certainly, but that some burglar thought it worth investigating was (in the very least of Flomi’s estimation) reassuring and (if pressured to speak of his more fanciful assessment of the situation then) more than a bit exhilarating.
But the man who rode into the Bree-land on that stormy day in Rethe10 was no burglar. And if Collum’s suspicions were correct, then Flomi (and his sires) had become involved with Collum and his predecessors in something much more dangerous than he had previously believed; much more dangerous than treasure-hunting. Every dwarf, of course, knew the folly of Men; for Men were always aggressors, without learning the lessons of their own history. They were always engaged with the Darker forces of the Enemy. So often in fact that they believed their own better nature might only be evidenced in this ongoing struggle. Durin’s Folk (or so Flomi believed, though he had long been away from his own People) did not live in this way; they carved and they forged and they sung deep songs of pride for the work of their own hands and for the depth of their own voice and the glory they felt in their own connection to Middle-earth. Their honor, and it was a great part of their lives, was not formed out of some ancient battle within themselves to do right, as Men seemed so taken by, but out of a call to make greater works with the Gifts they had been given. Men were not like Dwarves, certainly. The Doom of Men in Flomi’s day was not, to his dwarvish mind, arrogance (as it had been said in ages past) but trial; for they chased not life nor art but only to measure their honor against the Enemy, and they let this chase define them.
Collum Gilleyfoil was the tallest, strongest Man that Flomi had ever known. He had a warrior’s bearing that made the dwarf feel safe from the moment he arrived at the Bree-land and an assurity in his nature that made him feel protected and at ease. In twelve years they had become friends, Man and Dwarf, and of that bond at least Flomi felt certain; Collum was a good man who gave him fair appraisal of their need for secrecy in their shared endeavor. But now, walking along the pathway to the Foundations and thinking back at his time in the small town, Flomi knew that Collum Gilleyfoil was not a man one sent to watch over a simple charge and he was certainly not a treasure-hunter. Collum was the kind of Man one sent to watch against the Enemy, and his coming, even as long as twelve years past, meant that the Enemy, not some simple burglar, knew of Flomi’s work.
And now, walking alone towards a fate that seemed suddenly much more dangerous, Flomi’s mind turned back to that day when a Black Rider came to the Bree-land.
*****
Ben’s eyes were sharp, but Tawarengil’s were much sharper.
‘A Man moves west ahead of us,’ he said as they both crested a low hill, ‘he has paused just past the Crossing. He is looking about, but also keeping to cover. I believe it is our innkeeper companion, yet the manner of his walking is much changed.’
Ben did not see him first and, despite his previous experience with Elves, this fact bothered him more than a little. Just a few hours into their journey and Ben already felt as if it was his responsibility to guide everyone and to read all the information on their road ahead.
‘I’d agree, my lord, and believe that it is indeed Collum away there,’ he said. ‘He may wait for us in a place near to the Road, for his knowledge of these lands west of Hedge-gate I can’t speak to.’
‘Your friend's knowledge of these lands is far greater than he lets on, Master Floxleaf,’ said the grey wizard. ‘If he waits it is because he is doubtful of our own. And Tawarengil is correct; he moves to find cover, I believe, and to suggest a spot for our company to meet.’
‘Yes,’ Tawarengil replied. ‘This seems so. He makes for a small cluster of young trees there below us, but out of view from the Road. Admirable woodcraft for an innkeeper, I would say.’
‘More than I’d have credited him for,’ Ben said, happy to be getting on with things. ‘But good. Maybe now, away from the ears of snooping Breelanders, we’ll get some answers.’
*****
The sleet and hail had poured against the windows of the commonroom on that afternoon six weeks ago in Flomi’s memory. He had just completed his usual large dinner menu as a well-looked-for and robust lunch; a bowl of the Greenfields’ famous fish chowder, a small salad (something that the other Breelanders found most peculiar for any patron, let alone a Dwarf, to order) and a great large pasty that he had taught the cook to make, stuffed with rich and earthy seasonal vegetables and spices quite unknown to the Men of this area. Had this been any other day and the weather more seasonable, he would have only returned from the stoneyard by late in the afternoon and, waiting to settle some few and local accounts that might help disguise his other greater purpose, only then would he be able to settle into this familiar and much-anticipated meal shortly before dusk. But with the weather so harsh on this early spring morning, Flomi had foregone his usual ride to the yard, indulged himself by sleeping unto a surprisingly late hour past the dawn, and treated himself to some drawing time before coming downstairs just shortly after noon.
Drawing is not, in the way we might think of such things, a habit nor a hobby for the Dwarves. Some folk and historians there are in the greater world, presupposing as they do to understand dwarves and their culture through the works that they have seen and traded or that now survive even to this day would, undoubtedly, be quite surprised to learn this fact. But drawing, which is to say the representation of scenes, designs or characters onto a two- dimensional surface, is not to a dwarf as it is to others; an acceptable handcraft useful for communication or trade or pleasure. Instead, to any dwarf and most particularly to one like Flomi, it is a great and private (and, to the outside world, wholly secret) passion.
The great Dwarven sculptors and architects knew the skill well of course, as their works, which have long outlived their People, certainly reveal to this day. But no drawings have ever been found, no plans, no prototypes nor models of their works have ever been known to exist so that the now popular opinion (if one can indeed settle upon such a thing as a “popular opinion” regarding the Dwarves) is that they fashioned their great works almost entirely by instinct and intuition; one brilliant hammer-stroke leading to another so that they formed halls the size of modern cities, statuary the size of hillsides, mechanisms of so intricate a nature and armor of so many varied and articulated pieces less out of plan than out of their natural kinship with stone and metal. But how can this be so?
Many fine tools and ornaments the Dwarves have also left us, and with them many reasons to suggest the cunning of design that we might, for any other of the known races, believe had come from years of drawing experience. Complex locks and devices, ornate structures of weaving and of machinery, of war devices and of delicate tools, the working of gears and the marvels of combustion that seemed incredible to other people of their time, and indeed to us today, should seem impossible to create and to pass down to others without plan, diagram or illustration.
Yet no drawings by Dwarves survive and no record (yet to be found) speaks of them. If the Dwarves did draw, as anyone would surmise from their other arts that they must have, then they left none of it for other people to see.
There are no paintings that survive the Dwarves either and no mention of that art in their histories. There are sculptures of course, and many in relief which evidence a great understanding for depicting three-dimensional space on a shallow plane. These lead us to believe that the dwarves had an aptitude for drawing that may have even exceeded that of the Elves, who we know regard the skill very highly. How is it possible then, that no dwarven drawings were ever seen?
The answer is quite simple; dwarves do not regard drawings as exceptional because all dwarves, from a very early age, draw exceptionally well. And dwarves do not ever reveal their drawings to others because, as in so many things, dwarves are exceptionally private.
So, with that solitary and very gratifying part of his morning complete and the heavy ballast of a good meal inside him, Flomi happily settled into his regular study many hours earlier than usual. With Collum still away gathering new material, the extra time, or so Flomi hoped, would prove useful; for many of the latest passages which he had received had proven incomprehensible when compared to earlier breakthroughs and Flomi had begun to doubt some of his own work in the translations.
The commonroom was quite pleasantly empty of nosey townsfolk so early in the afternoon as the fierceness of the storm seemed to keep even the hungriest and most inquisitive of these Breelanders shuttered up in their own homes. Buttercup, the serving girl, usually happy to talk to any strangers who happened to find their way into the Four Greenfields, seemed quite startled to see him walk into the open and empty room.
‘Well, hello and good day to you, Master Flomi,’ she said, ‘I did not know that you were here with us. Kept in by this blustery weather, I should think.’
‘I am no more bothered by a sudden storm than any other of my race,’ he replied with a smile, ‘but my gentle pack animals and, indeed it seems, my neighbours and your customers, certainly are. So I thought I should give us all a comfortable and unexpected day indoors. Is your master still away?’
‘He is, sir,’ she said, looking cautiously about and lowering her voice just a bit, ‘and I shouldn’t expect him soon. For I suspect it's only desperate and dark folk who travel the roads today.’
‘Well, then, leave them to sort their own ways and let us keep ours,’ Flomi said, smiling all the more broadly. ‘I shall be very glad for the quiet of this room, the coziness of its fire, and a chance to read. In fact, the only thing that might make me gladder is a tankard of your hearty red wine.’
The girl smiled back and went to fetch a drinking vessel as Flomi settled into a spot beside one of the large fireplaces. Even then, in the early afternoon of an early spring day, a small but steady blaze had been lit to stave off the unexpected storm and the wind could be heard roaring through the chimney. Flomi drew writing implements and paper from his satchel as Buttercup delivered the wine and, looking up briefly to thank her, he pulled out some of the latest, most troubling pages of translation and settled his brain into work.
The concentration powers of a dwarf at work are not a thing to be overestimated. As Flomi looked into the three lines of the puzzle that Collum had most recently recovered, the surroundings of the room and of the inn and even of the Bree-land itself became lost to him. The warmth of the fire or the taste of the wine (often forgotten by his attention to the work), even the movements of the serving girl and her coworkers, became distant comforts as Flomi’s mind became concentrated on his work.
The Adûniac on the latest pages was beyond dispute; Collum’s source seemed to be correct in placing the origin of the work in Rhudaur. It had the hints of an Eastern style to the language and the crude yet flourished script that he had seen in a few earlier fragments which had come from that fallen land. Rhudaur had been conquered and absorbed into the Witch-king’s realm nearly six centuries ago, so why would anyone in that dark and unwholesome land be writing in the language of Old Númenor?11 He did not know much of the Men of Angmar, doubtless there were few in Middle-earth who did, but they were said to have many private languages, little learning and only used the most basic elements of the Common Speech. To see the Lost Tongue of his own people translated into this version of Adûniac by such an unsavory person filled Flomi, perhaps for the first time, with the full danger of his task.
‘Pssst- Master, sir!’ someone then whispered loudly near his shoulder, quite startling the dwarf from his thoughts. ‘Psst- Sir!’
Young Milo, Collum’s readyman amongst the Breefolk, was bent beside the hearth, stoking the fire and trying to cautiously get Flomi’s attention. How long he had been there the dwarf could not say. Milo was a strange one amongst the other hobbits of this little town; quiet as a cheesemouse in his movements and quite uninterested in gab and gossip. If the hobbit had said three words to the dwarf in the last year beyond an obligatory, ‘good day, sir,’ Flomi could certainly not remember them. Yet he always seemed to appear whenever his master seemed to need him. ‘An excellent quality in the servant of a spy,’ Flomi had often thought, ‘at hand, at ready, and as unwilling to idyll speech as he is to unwanted questions.’
‘Boy,’ Flomi said, much louder than with a whisper and with some degree of briskness, ‘you quite startled me and have broken my concentration! I’m not sure if I am more angered by the trespass than surprised by this sudden change in your behaviour!’ He tried to smile at this to lessen the sharpness of his tone; Milo was a good sort after all and perhaps had important news of his master. It was at this time that Flomi noticed the commonroom was empty, dusk was coming on, and the hobbit was dressed in a wet cloak as if he had just come in from the storm. ‘Has your master returned then?’ Flomi asked.
‘No, sir, he has not,’ the boy said, ‘and the weather is still harsh. All of the townsfolk are shuttered into their homes, but...’, and at this the hobbit lowered his voice again and looked cautiously about the room, ‘but there are others come to the Bree-land who take no notice of ill-weather.’
‘Travelers, boy?’ Flomi asked. ‘Here at the inn? Is this not the purpose of your business? Surely a traveler is lucky to have found such a place on so harsh a day and I should think that the business of your master is lucky to have him. I’ve no idea why you have disturbed me with this...’
‘I’ve no desire to disturb you, sir,’ the hobbit interrupted, ‘but this traveler is surely not here on my master’s business. We have, well, that is to say mistress Buttercup has, thought of closing the commonroom for the night, if we may. Would you take dinner and more wine in your own room, sir?’
At this suggestion Flomi looked about the room again. It seems that only a few hours had passed since he began his work, but the time was truly hard to establish on such a dark day and he had a way of letting time slip aside when focused at his task. The tankard of wine at his side table was full, but the girl was well accustomed in the habit of seeing to this whenever it emptied. He was not remotely hungry, and the warmth of the fire beside him was more comforting than he had previously noticed. The wind still howled outside, more fiercely now perhaps, but the sleet had ceased and the rain now beat a steady rhythm on the shutters. He looked at the earnestness on Milo’s young face and, for a moment, he felt as if the hobbit was trying to tell him something quite beyond his ability to put into words.
Then, as if by chance, his eyes fell on the translation beside him and, while he regretted it greatly later, he quite neglected the caution that others of Collum’s people were instinctually heeding. ‘The Breelanders are not wise,’ he thought to himself a week later, walking the long dark road alone to the Foundations, ‘but they’ve a sharp sense of danger that I myself have lately been found to lack.’
‘Now, Milo,’ Flomi said politely then as he picked up his quill and unfastened his ink bottle, ‘it is indeed an unseasonable day with little prospect of a busier night. Your master is away, and I would not begrudge you or your fellows a chance to close the inn early to seek your own beds. I am quite content and will not, I promise, tell your master.
‘Let the kitchen know that I have enjoyed my regular meal and would forgo anything further. Perhaps a bit of cheese might be left here on the table for later? And Buttercup could leave me with some more wine, as well. I should be very happy of that. You have left ample wood here in the bin should the fire grow low.
‘Close the room to all and the inn to anyone else if you’d like. If your master should learn of it, then it shall not come from me. But I have now the rare chance for quiet and for study and here I will stay. You are a good and kind servant for asking,’ he said then, smiling dismissively and taking up his pen, ‘but I shall be quite comfortable here on my own.’
Milo, as was his way, said nothing further. He hovered at Flomi’s shoulder for an uncomfortable time and, when the dwarf looked up to wonder at this, he could see the hobbit’s mouth hung open as if he should say more. Their eyes caught for a long moment, but Milo said nothing until, eventually;
‘Yes, sir. As you will.’ The hobbit quickly left his place at the hearth and went to the front entrance of the commonroom. As Flomi’s eyes followed him, he saw Guldir, the stablemaster, waiting by the door. The two spoke quietly for a moment and then, looking back hesitantly, they both departed.
‘Finally,’ Flomi thought to himself on that unlucky day when thoughts of the dangers involved in his task had only just begun to enter his mind, ‘finally I shall be left alone for a while with my work!’
But, of course, he was not alone.
End of Chapter Four
Notes on Chapter Four
1) “Until next we meet” in Quenya.
2) Literally “Blessed arrival!” In Quenya.
3) Okay, now the fun begins; I’ve given you this translation before. Who’s keeping up?
4) This description is cribbed from Fellowship in the chapter “A Shortcut to Mushrooms”. I often try to sneak one or two of these into a chapter to keep my ear crisply attuned to the style.
5) “calavénë, eleni and laicolassë” translates to “sun, star and green leaf” in Quenya.
6) It was difficult determining a name for Thranduil’s halls in Mirkwood as there is some dispute on the matter.
7) This little discussion on the origins of Hobbit mushroom farming came quite unexpectedly and quite late into the writing of this book. I wanted Motho, who was a much more insignificant character early on in my design, to make a profit from mushrooms. But later chapters of the story return us to this farm and so forced me to look at it, and Motho himself, in greater detail. Mushroom farming itself is actually more of a 19th century invention and it became clear to me that for Motho to be successful he had to somehow be an innovator. This is probably the first really big instance in which the book was redesigned with its ending finally in sight.
8) This is a paraphrasing from The Akallabêth. Beothalion is not, as we will see, Númenórean, but Pallando seems to regard all Men as one People.
9) “Faith shines brighter than the stars” or as close to the Quenya of that as I can manage at this writing.
10) This is the name of the month that we call March from the Shire calendar. The name represents a modernization of the Old English name for the same period of the year, Hreþmōnaþ, meaning "rough-month”. I chose to use the Shire calendar here because Tolkien wrote no Dwarf calendar (though there are some interesting attempts by others online) and because it indicates Flomi’s attachment to life in the Bree-land.
11) It is something to wonder about regarding Middle-earth; how many lands or Peoples there would actually have their own written language? Rhudaur was part of Arnor and, as we see in Gondor, they preserve the Adûniac language but the writing of its histories is largely Sindarin. The languages of Angmar would be a mystery. But there’s going to be more on this later.