New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
-Wherein the Party Meets a Helpful Stranger and Learns New and Important Information
‘Lo! The North lords and their glory through splendid achievements we have heard of in our distant homes,’1 the stranger sang softly in the half-muddled daze of Flomi’s woundedness.
‘Of Westernesse and their far-off home now faded we have harkened,
‘How prince-sons of Sea-kings displayed their prowess-in-battle and their former fame we have heard of.
‘Elendil, their mighty king, in honor of whom my teachers often call them Elendilings, came forth from the Sea to bring Hope to the land. But what Hope he held is gone with his sundered line and what Hope he portends has not yet come,’ the man said, switching from the older language to a heavily accented version of the Common Tongue. ‘You may not know these words, traveler, but I would sing them to you to bring you hope. Will you listen?’
Here the singing grew lower and more rhythmic as the Man looked to Flomi’s wounds, wrapping and binding what he could and looking grievously on those which Flomi knew, even in his daze, to be poisoned.
‘Eärendur the Foolish is oft named and known,
‘By many Men who in their mead-benches have heard.
‘Of how first he found himself friendless and wretched,
‘In terror of age and of death, and forswearing the Gifts of Man.
‘Sea’s Servant who never sailed,
‘Last-great scion of those great Sea-kings,
‘Mighty and mad and failed,
‘Was father to three kingdoms,
‘And three failures he bred in hearth and state.’
The man put a cool rag on Flomi’s head at this, softly patted his chest, and looking rather quickly aside, went on, now singing:
‘This king had sons:
‘Small and no comfort he got from them,
‘And waxed ’neath the welkin, world-honor gained,
‘No safety but his sovereignty.’
‘“No safety had from his sovereignty...”’Flomi corrected him. He knew this phrase somehow, from somewhere, but in his current state he could not place it.
‘Hmmmn,’ the man said in his deep and resonant voice, a broad smile on his face as he paused in his ministrations to the wounded dwarf. ‘You speak the ancient tongue and have heard this tale? Mae-govannen! I do not speak this tongue openly except with my family, and that has been many years past. But should we sing the tale together? ’
‘No, no... I do not think so, my friend,’ Flomi replied drowsily in the easier common talk. ‘I should rest a bit...’
‘No, no, and I do not think so, my friend,’ the man replied, looking more serious. ‘You are gravely injured and you must stay wakeful or you will fade. So I will tell you this tale and we will talk of it as I do. I like the sound of your version, but it does not make sense of the tale as mine does. Where have you heard it?’
Flomi groaned at this; he felt the healing power of whatever this man had put on his leg and on his chest, was thankful for the coolness of the wet rag the man had placed on his brow, but he was far too tired for academic debate.
‘There was another... somewhere... I cannot remember,’ Flomi said as he started to drift off again.
‘Then I shall tell you the tale as I know it,’ the man said as he took more items from his pouch and placed them in the small pestle beside him.
‘His sons, high in their pride of parentage,
‘Had marked the misery with malice that their father’s fear had caused them,
‘So that reaved of their ruler they may come to glories of their own.’
‘“But another was born to him, daughter of Eärendur, an excellent heir by all accounts, who would be made famous...”’ Flomi said to the man, his eyes opening a bit more in the talking.
‘Yes, yes! But you rush the tale,’ the man said excitedly. Flomi could see that he was grinding with great care something in the small pestle he had produced, and halted the motion to look at the dwarf. ‘Tell me, my friend, can you remember this excellent heir’s name?’
‘The heir?' Flomi asked, trying to maintain his focus. Eärendur's heir was Amlaith. It signifies “up”... something... raised...’
‘I confess that I did not know the meaning in the name,’ the man said. ‘You are uncommonly gifted in tales! Are all your folk this way, I wonder?’
‘Moreso than most people expect,’ Flomi replied with a small and tired smile. ‘We are makers by our nature and as such appreciate great tales for their making. I myself...’ he found that he was drifting here, less aware of his surroundings than by memories of times that he could not quite recall, and his voice trailed off as if following his thoughts down darkened roads of an unknown past.
‘You yourself,’ the man said, returning to the delicate grinding of some herb in the small bowl with his pestle, ‘shall come to comfort and in time tell me these things you know of tales, and I myself will certainly rejoice to hear them.
‘But for now, my friend, I shall do the telling. Correct me when you will, for I delight to hear new songs, but your powers are better spent fighting the poisons. So, we return. Where? Ah! “An excellent heir”.
‘An excellent heir he had.
‘Sent late in Eärendur’s life was sent the sire as his solace.
‘Bold-minded, beautiful and bright, marked by all to be
‘An excellent “Elendiling!”
‘And three sons also, the first of whom was Amlaith.’
‘Yes,’ Flomi said softly, ‘“up” something. What is “laith”? I don’t think that I know this...’
‘At the hour that was fated,’ the man continued in his singing;
‘Elendur-king and father then departed,
‘For such is the Gift of Man,
‘And so then warlike they wend him,
‘Away then they bore him,
‘Through under-deeps, his fond-loving comrades carried,
‘For great forefathers he had been named and so should be return’d.’
‘Yes,” Flomi said softly. ‘Yes, yes, I do know this tale... and have bent my life to it. I will do my best to listen.’ Yet he found it increasingly hard to keep his eyes open.
*****
‘Patiently and cautiously I did watch the orcs for some hours, undecided about their importance, but unwilling to leave them to run and bring havok to the peace of open lands. My hatred toward these folks is high, but carefulness had been taught to me and all my People, and reckless wrath is not within me.
‘A small band it was, under a score of foes, yet too many that I might attack openly without some few escaping. And too near to my destination were they that they may be disregarded.
‘A rude camp they had made and that in my traveling I had discovered. In shaded wood and soft earth such lean-toes and short diggings they had laid down which save such debased folk from their fear and hatred for Sun and Light, sheltering them by day as they moved and destroyed only by night. Watchful of this camp I was, patient as my People have taught me, though as ever wrathful we are to all their orc-kind and all of their ways. A great burden it was to my heart to watch quietly and not slay these enemies of the woodlands with ready hands. But these are not the woodlands of my birth, and I am not their guardian. What brought this small band here, so near to my destination, so close to where my own cause had bidden? Hard-bought prudence bid me wait my vigil. I might move on, leaving behind what I had seen and alerting the townsfolk, but knowing the ways of these fearsome creatures, I would fain leave any orc alive in fair woods. So patiently and cautiously did I keep my watch as the night fell.
‘Perhaps in my hesitancy to travel to that other place, the town ahead, I held my hand and made to watch these orcs rather than slay them. Forbearance there I beg you grant me; for I had never, nor had my fathers, any cause to visit a town before this time. A courageous man may go heedless of peril into a wood by night, I think, and still pause before meeting the unknown men and the unknown customs of townsfolk.
‘But orcs I do know. They had camped close in that wood, closer than they preferred to come to the large dwellings of a goodly people and there they had remained so for some time. Certainly then there must be some dark purpose which stayed them.
‘“Such a dozen or so could not take a town,” I thought while watching. “Why do they wait here so?”
‘I would go to this town in time, for such was my determined course, but thought to know more of these foes first. Warnings I may bring, but news and proofs I would be the better for having.
‘Orcs in our open lands have their regular rhythms. Sleeping by day under any long shadow or rough encampment, quarreling raucously at dusk and stamping about impatiently by moonrise. Paralyzed as they were by fear of daylight, more anxious they were to run freely and rampage wildly with the night. No enemies nor victims had they for the distraction of their distemper yester eve and so when night fell their disquiet grew greater.
‘Patiently I watched and waited, doubting and deciding what to do about gorgûn in the green fields so near to the town.2
‘“The captain I might kill,” I thought, and the others of his folk so then might be caused to scurry. Trophy of him I might make to take before the townsfolk so that they should learn the peril of their position. This settled into my mind the more whilst watching.
‘So, I watched and awaited the opportunity of their captain.’
*****
‘Was then that this Eärendur, Servant of Seas namèd,
‘Renowned prince of north lands,
‘Bairn of the Elendilings, son to Elendur,
‘Belovèd Eärendur, for long-lasting seasons
‘Was famèd amid all his folk.
‘Once great-minded, twice madness-driven,
‘Four times fathered, four times betrayèd,
‘As last North-king, he graciously governed,
‘And grew grim-mooded, as agèd.
‘Four bairns of his body born in succession...'
‘Yes... there were four, yes,’ Flomi said from some deep corner of his mind. ‘There were four... though few now remember of it...’
‘The Unnórenean remember much, my friend,’ the man said to him from somewhere Flomi could not quite see. Above him he could see comforting cold stone, and light coming through it in narrow wells along a great cavern roof.
But he was finding it difficult to turn his head to follow the man’s movements and still keep enough of his wits to understand the tale that was being sung. Flomi knew the language well, having made long study of it, but had never heard anyone other than his father or Collum speak more than a few words. This man’s voice was rich and fair, but his manner of speaking was... confusing.
‘We remember more of the North-kings in our songs,’ the man said, ‘than they themselves do in their halls. And now they have no halls! I wonder, will they now heed our songs?
‘Four bairns of his body born in succession
‘Woke in the world, to a war-troops’ leader.
‘Tarondor and Valandor were last,
‘Twin-sons without title or virtue.
‘Amlaith, first-son, who was up-standing..’
‘Standing?’ Flomi said. ‘No... no I think laith may mean “laughing”...’3
‘I confess that I do not know this either,’ the man replied. But now Flomi realized that the man seemed behind him somewhere and he could, just slightly, feel the man’s touch on his back near the numbness of his left shoulder. It was then that Flomi realized he no longer faced the stone roof overhead but a great open space covered with moss and small shrubberies. He could not account for the time between his last look at the roof and now, nor could he account for how he came here. But he could feel the man tending to the wound in his back, that which was the first of so many that he had almost forgotten their number.
‘If it indeed means “laugh” then I feel the name is tragic,’ the man continued. As he said this there was a great and startling noise from above but near to Flomi’s ear:
‘Breaafu-oi-yananen-briare!’4 came the great sound. Flomi could see now, lying on his side and staring ahead into the open space, the yellowed hooves of the beast step tentatively forward.
‘Hoho!’ the man said, ‘I think your beast here laughs better than any soggy Sea-king! He rejoices to see you awake again. Tell me, my friend, do you have a name for this uncommon companion?’
Flomi felt the warm nuzzling of the creature against his brow and was comforted. He closed his eyes again, at peace in his pain, and sighed softly.
‘He was called Ducan when he was given to me,’ Flomi said, ‘and he shall probably answer well to you with that. But he is my friend now and...’ sleep was coming up on him again fast in his comfort, ‘I shall call him Inbar...’5
There was a soft wet exhalation from the creature at this, and Flomi drifted back to sleep.
*****
‘There was indeed a rather stout and fearsome leader to the small and unwholesome band of brigands. Taller than the others, as is often the case with their captains, and more clear-spoken than the others, which is also often so. He carried a great hammer and perhaps a greater wisdom than his fellows; for he seldom left his tent for anything other than the giving of discipline, and this he and his hammer delivered upon the others most readily and most harshly.
‘The trees near to these wandering ruffians welcomed a wise hand; they offered one with my woodcraft good canopy and high vantage over the rude encampment of the interlopers. I held my watch in high places all the day under strong cover and wanted for nothing other than a stout strong bow as I awaited the time. Had I a good bow in good wood like those I would need wait no longer. A dozen foul creatures as these might fall in less than an hour and I might have the captain’s head and well be on my way.
‘Having neither bow nor quiver I waited and I watched and I counted my patience as preciously spent.
‘When the blessed Sun fell low enough and the dusk-shadows grew long enough for their comfort these orcs became restless. It was their way. And so now the captain had become more active to keep them in some order whilst their nature told them to run and to pillage as they should in their regular humour. A Dark Will had put forth its power upon all of these folk to fill them with a lust for ruin and rampage, death and disorder.
‘Orcs stay only as they are told to do. They have no home and, moreover, hold no home to heart as other more wholesome folk may. It is said in some songs by my People that they live in long-lost palaces that were plundered from ancient races. So it may be that in the former tunnels and holes that were great halls to Elves and Dwarf-folk the greatest of these goblin-kings now sat on sumptuous mouldering caches of old conquests, like dragons and wraiths may do, and there they bred and they boasted of old victories by their valiant ancestors and so too, it may be, they schemed of future glories which they were themselves too timid to try. I do not know to a certainty. For in the forests of my birth we know nothing of Dwarf-holds and Elvish-kingdoms other than what old war songs will tell.
‘Orcs, however, came occasionally to our forest home, and there from a young age we learn to hate them and have been taught to stalk and slay them.
‘Not so many came as once did perhaps, but not so few as to be forgotten. Orcs came to the forest and they died in the forest, and the Minhiriathrim still long survived. The forests they protected survived, and the orcs ran back to their holes or their palaces or those other neglected places of Men and Elves and Dwarf-folk. Many of their ugly kind I have myself slain in youth and, if the Unnórenean of my blood did learn to fear them as greatly as the Minhiriathrim of my upbringing did learn to hate them, more overjoyed was I at their deaths. They were the foes of my People’s heart, the enemies in many of our songs, and I know them and know their ways.
‘Orcs do not break camp carefully as wise woodsmen do, but seldom do they keep it into night and beyond day’s need. They will go to ground by day and leave that same foul hole before moonrise, forgotten and undisguised. Any true tracker can follow any group of orcs for many nights through their untidiness and come upon them while they are weak, worried and sun-sickened by a fresh dawn. But now, as the evening awakened and the camp grew restless, the captain could be heard ordering his folk to dig all the deeper and to clear all the wider; as if they were there as a fore-mission of more and many yet to come.
‘This would make my waiting unwise. I knew I must take the captain soon and bring his head as a herald to the townspeople. If these foul folk were driven in their purpose to stay at whiles, something seldom seen in their behaviour, then another captain of their kind might soon take this one’s place and a stronger leader arise as reinforcements come. The bloodied head of this current captain might convince the townsfolk of their impending troubles, but I could not know when another’s may replace him. So it must then happen before the night grew long. And so I waited, patiently, cautiously, through their restlessness and their scurrying. Waited for the captain’s coming to discipline his own and for an opportunity of my own.
‘It did not come with the moonrise. The captain did not leave the camp nor the shelter of his lean-to as he barked and bellowed orders at his battalion. For their own part they were, as ever, unhappy as all their kind and answered back belligerently; but none so much as to draw the captain, and his heavy hammer, into the open for dispute. Out where I hoped a careful quoit from my sling might finish this work of waiting.
‘So still I waited all the more and all the more I counted my patience as precious.
‘Three hours after the nightfall, with the moon growing high in the east, the foul folk became unsettled. News, it seemed, came down to them on the winds which I could not discern. The small snufflers felt it first, but all the orc-folk were soon raised to some new reports that I knew not from my perch in the trees.
‘There was a cautious growling in the camp of many crass and guttural voices. I know not the language of orcs, if language it may be called, but could still hear the hatred it held within.
‘“Enough of that gnashing noise!” the orc captain cried as he came forth from his hiding. “You’ll keep yourselves in the line I gave you, boys, or your fallen limbs will paint a bloodier line for your brothers to follow! Back in lines, I say!”
‘He came forward, a great-hammer on his shoulder, head high and smelling the wind. Then, with a straightening of his back and cracking of his neck, he spat commandingly on the ground before him.
‘“O, aye, I smell him too, lads,” he told them, “but our bosses like that smell even if we do not. Let him in and let’s hope he’s some work for us beside sitting in open fields when there’s plunder so close by.”
‘There were many calls of acceptance at this and it was easy to see that this captain knew very well the avaricious mood of his company. A good leader for a brigade filled with bad intentions. This made him all the more dangerous, all the more despicable and all the better a target. Moving quietly, cautiously, patiently and silently, from one high branch to one lower and with better vantage, one of straighter stone-throw, I watched and loosened the sling which I held at my harness, placing an iron-clad stone into its carriage.
‘Toward the northwest I heard, and then saw, a man come riding openly toward the camp. A dark fellow on a dark horse, with lank dark hair and a yellowish face in the clear cool moonlight. The orcs snuffled, sneered and bayed at his coming, but let him on and in as one of their own. Straight toward the place of their hiding he rode, as if surely he knew it before times. Whether an Orc-master, race-traitor, co-conspirator or hapless underling, I marked the sallow-face of this stranger and knew well to hate him for his allegiance.
‘“Draw close and stand you ready,” the rider called to the orcs in a breathless voice of one who has run hard before riding fast. “We hunt tonight!”
‘There were commanding shouts and strong calls from the camp; they did not like this Man, or so it seemed, but the captain of orcs knew their passions and played them for his purpose.
‘“Do we?” cried the captain, quieting his comrades. “What? Should we go to on your call only, while we have waited so long here for some word from your master? More of my boys will come soon and then we’ll take your little town of rabbit-folk and pig-farmers. Why should I risk my men a-walking on your lead when we can march two or three nights from now to a greater plunder? What is the take of your hunt that I and these lads should care to go with you?”
‘“The dwarf is on the move,” the man called back coldly, “and that is who you and your charges were sent here to take... at our command.”
‘The captain paused in his step to hear this. The traitor-man dismounted, gathering now his breath. Knowing that he must command these unruly folk he stood straighter to the task.
‘“The dwarf goes, alone, west, in haste and quiet,” the man said, “having no idea of his peril, though my own comrade has dogged him at every step. We shall follow and meet my colleague and then take the dwarf alone tonight as he travels. The time is tonight,” this race-traitor called louder, looking around to the grey-yellow faces of the creatures around him. “My colleague goes and prepares our meeting. This dwarf went toward the Stoneyard first and now travels west in the open lands just north of the Great Road.”
‘“My brothers are not coming to join us from the West,” the captain sneered, “but hard from the North to flood and seize and devour these empty lands. I could wait here two days and have warriors enough to take a town. A town which was promised.
‘“Why should I, and my boys, stalk some stunted rat-dwarf for your pleasure?”
‘At this the lank-haired man grew quite strict, quite hard in his manner and, despite the obvious enmity, quite a bit larger in my estimation.
‘“Because you are bidden, foul folk, because you are commanded,” he called to them all.
‘“Think you that you have some choice in our Great Master’s plans? Fools! You are driven here to do the commandments of your superiors and I am driven to use you, cattle and goat, warrior and tracker, as is my wish. This is the way of our policy; a wheel which turns to great action and we are but the cogs.
‘“No, this is near but is wrong,” he said, pausing, a sneer not quite a smile now opening on his lips. “You are lesser than cogs. You and your wretched folk are, in fact, but the rough and worn hoop that is lowest to the dirt while a cog spins above you. There is a great action in play and, if you are useful tools, you will play the part and perhaps even rise for a short time. Or you will be rolled over by those which do.
‘“We hunt the dwarf tonight,” the man said louder and now addressing the group of fighters who had gathered round him rather than their captain. He stood tall here against the many of them and put a hand to his sword to show his seriousness.
‘“We leave immediately to take the dwarf,” he said firmly, “and I’ve an answer in my hand for any who believe that they are better than such commandments.”
‘This taller-than-most and clearer-speaking-than-most orc-captain held the traitor-man’s gaze for a time. The moment hung heavily between them.
‘There was silence from the other orcs as they awaited the decision of their captain. Things could certainly go differently with any movement, any action of disregard, from their leader. This was their way. They ever awaited leadership. And this too will ever be their downfall, for they never had any good of it.
‘"I could strike the captain's head here solidly with a stone. Maybe, but not surely, killing him with a single blow from my sling," I thought.
‘"I might also take the rider, this traitor-of-Men, with such a blow." That one had no helm, no sign of hidden breastplate, and a carefully slung iron quoit at this range might take the villain rightly and directly down to death.
‘But there would be no time for a second stone. My cover was sound before but thinner as I had moved to hear their debate, and I had counted three bowmen amongst the orcs. Their bows were short, but their eyesight at night was ever quite keen. I had no bow myself nor a strong place to hide once discovered. So I must, to keep within my plan, kill one of these leaders quickly and hope it caused the others to scurry. But the moment of that plan had changed. I knew that they would not scurry if they had another leader to follow. And while I had a few stones I was only one man with but one sling.
‘It seemed then that my best chance lay in leaving. I might reach the town by the dawn and awaken the folk there to all which I had witnessed. Would they believe me? I know nothing of townsfolk and had hoped for an orc-head as some official proof of my position.
‘As the foul captain and the traitor considered one another I also watched and considered; many fates were wound into those few moments.
‘Then the orc-captain spit on the ground before him and turned his back on the man, speaking to his folk. “Grab your gear and whet your blades, boys!” he said, “we’re going a-hunting tonight!”
‘There were shouts of strong approval throughout the camp, but the captain did not finish so quickly. He turned to walk towards the rider. Continuing to address his soldiers he said;
‘“Shagrach, Muzgash and Abendego!6 You boys will stay and ready this position for the threescore of our boys from the North. We’ll assemble here with them two nights from now once this rat-hunt is done.” Saying so he looked squarely at the rider, gripping his great hammer tightly and closing the paces between them.
‘“We are ordered to help you at your needs. We don’t care a bit for your needs, but we do understand our orders. One night and a dozen boys I will give you for this hunt,” he told the traitor-man, “not because you command it,” he said slowly, spitting again with all the authority of his kind, “but because I have no orders otherwise. But we’ll be back here in two nights and we will meet our brothers to take this foolish town. For those are the orders I have and that my boys care about.”
‘The traitor-man stood evenly to the challenge. “One night will indeed bring our quarry, but we must ride now. He walks a path to no destination that we know and we will need to track him in open lands. My comrade is on the trail, but we must pick it up again at the stoneyard. If we ride immediatel-’
‘The great hammer swung wide and hard before anyone could expect it happening. The rider’s horse, his head a bloodied mess, fell terrified to the ground screaming. No second blow of the hammer ended the mare’s misery and her cries of pain and astonishment made the orcs all the livelier. The cruel captain turned hotly back to face the horse’s master.
‘“We do not ride, weakling,” he said. “We run! We run fast and long under the dark skies and through these empty, open lands. We hunt and we run! We will find for you your dwarf-rat. But now, I think, you shall have to run with us. I hope you will keep up, for my boys have no patience for lackards.”
‘At this he placed his bloodied hammer lazily upon his shoulder and walked brazenly past the traitor-man.
‘The traitor-man, his hand on his sword hilt, did nothing.
‘Shagrach!’ he cried to the other lieutenant above the calls of his party, “there is now much meat for our threescore friends. Stew it and render it as you will to make things ready.”
*****
Flomi could see the lightwells of the roof again and suspected that it was late in the afternoon. Someone had turned him. He also knew that it was Inbar, or his bleating, that woke him. But throughout his drowsing and waking hours the Man’s song was running in his head.
‘...A numerous band. It burned in his spirit...
‘To urge his folk to found a great building...
‘A mead-hall grander than men of the era...’
And later, much, much later he thought, the singing roused him;
‘Then the work I find afar was assigned...
‘To many races in middle-earth’s regions...
‘To adorn the great folk-hall. In due time it happened
‘Early ’mong men, that ’twas finished entirely,
‘The greatest of hall-buildings; Eälenea she named it...’
‘What!?!’ Flomi cried out from his drowsiness. ‘No, this could not be so! Where have...’
He was startled by the memory, weakened and dizzying from trying to rise and, lying back, he was greatly surprised to see Collum at his side.
‘Ease, please ease yourself, my friend!’ he said, taking Flomi’s hand. There was grave concern on his face, but Flomi was joyed to see him come.
‘Collum?’ he called in his weakness. ‘Am I so far gone with fever, or are you here?’
‘We have come, yes, Flomi,’ he said and then tried his famously encouraging smile, ‘but you have left us little to do upon late arrival. Are these dozen kills of your doing? It was quite a mess you left us for your first day in our new home. ’
‘Dozen, you say? I... I thought, perhaps fourteen with the bowmen...’ Flomi said drowsily. ‘The bard here helped me...’
‘He did indeed and in many ways, Master Dwarf,’ another deeper voice said from above. Flomi saw a great wise face then with penetrating eyes, staring down at him over Collum’s shoulder.
‘He has surely saved you from greater injury than you yourself have bothered to care about and I should remind you to thank him for it. Once you have slept.’ At this the old man put his hand on Flomi’s brow.
‘Your eyes...’ Flomi said as he drifted off again, ‘they are like the sea...’
‘Have you seen the Sea, brave one?’ the greybeard said as Flomi’s eyes were closing.
‘No...’ he said slowly, drifting back into dreams. ‘But now I think I should like to...’
‘Sleep, brave one,’ he heard the voice gently speaking, ‘and dream of it if you will. For sometimes the Seas are gentle and sometimes they are caring...’
And if Flomi was comforted to hear this we do not know. For he went into a very deep and healing sleep as the words were spoken.
*****
‘They did indeed run fast in the open lands. Of this, their captain spoke in truth. I would have had trouble staying up with them if they were not so boisterous and disturbing of all the ground as they went. From their encampment to the Great Road was not far and so I knew that I might follow at some distance. I then watched as the dozen ruffians rumbled loudly down in that direction. I would follow in their wake after attending to other tasks; for I could not leave these other three stand to make camp for three-score like them.
‘So I waited in the trees as the main orc-party departed, that I might make example of these three and perhaps also discourage many more of their kind.
‘The orcs fell upon the horse-carcass immediately. I fell upon them shortly after. This was no great battle; quickly I dispatched them and after felt slighted by the task. The horse still lay screaming in her miseries and I ended those as quick as I may.
‘These were not the broad-backed warriors nor the short-legged snufflers. They were rank-folk, porters perhaps, or simple spear-carriers left behind because they had no greater skill than the following of orders. I slew them quickly as I may without unduly damaging their heads.
‘For this was the work of my new intention; three pikes with three orc-heads for the three-score of orc-warriors a-coming. Perhaps seeing this the new-comers would scurry and the town might still be saved. Doubtful, but the only course I might follow in short time.
‘I wondered how I may help the town except through this act. I might wait and stand against the three-score orcs that were coming myself. There might be great songs to hear of that encounter. Such an idea very much tempted my heart.
‘And I very well might take one of these ugly, unimpressive and unfortunate orc-heads to the town as previously planned. They, the townsfolk, may then believe me, perhaps, and then they may prudently send their own folk into the field to meet the three-score. I could not know, for I know nothing of townsfolk.
‘But of those others, the orc-captain and the traitor-man, the townsfolk would likely give little regard. And the dwarf they hunted would suffer mightily before help might ever come to him.
‘I have heard of dwarf-folk. Just as I have heard of oliphants, ungolianonnar, trolls and Taras, dwimmerlaik and dragons.7 They did not come into the histories of the Minhiriathrim but lived much in songs of their fancy. The Minhiriathrim love tales and songs from the outer world and seldom do they doubt them. Great Kingdoms of Tunnels, the songs bespoke, chiseled in the hard rock of all mountains and dwarves were the children of these rock and lords and makers of these vast mountain kingdoms. Fabled these halls were, like unto high-ceilinged mead halls filled with much wealth made bright in dark places by lighted lanterns of cunning design, well-secured with great arms and keenly-made comforts beyond the ken of the woodland men.
‘When they first spoke of the dwarf I thought, standing in the tree boughs as I watched the main group of orcs depart, that I should very much like to meet a dwarf. That would be wonderfully interesting. But, moreso, I knew that I could not abandon this dwarf or any lone traveler to such foul folk whose intent I knew only too well.
‘So, after finishing my work with the fresh orc-heads and the warning they might give to their new-coming comrades, I forsook my intended errand to the town and followed the others north and west through the night to the aid of this lone traveler. I would give what help that I may and, perhaps, hope that this was payment of my patience. For I would abandon no goodly traveler to goblins.
‘Closer I came to their party shortly after crossing the Great Road. Watching cautiously and listening sharply I moved quietly downwind to escape their attentions. They had, in their hungry clamour, become easy to follow.
‘And all the louder now this orc-band had become. Whatever cautiousness may have quieted them at the Road’s crossing was forgotten by their folk now. They barked and howled and rambled out of rank, the fighters restless once more and impatient for their hunter-folks to find the dwarfish scent. These snufflers went wide of the gaggle group of the ruffians, turning their rough talents, their noses and their keener night-eyes to the task. The wind was from the West, well-omened for us and all our People, and I worked down her8 way to walk up quietly as I might behind the orc-band. Close I might come in this manner, with the wind’s favour, and perhaps pull down some weary straggler or two from the pack.
‘The wood here was opening and the hills of the land were gently rolling. I had not traveled beyond the Great Road before and my heart was now somehow struck by the placid stillness of this place. Ancestral memory was awakened as my Unnórenean blood came here to the home of its abandoned birthright. Do you know this call? Can you understand it? I could not deny its power. Keeping my practiced quiet came quickly here, naturally and to my heart’s-blood, for the silence of the land was heavier in me here than in the greenwood din of Eryn Vorn, the happy, noisome safe-haven of my childhood.
‘Always it was the North which called to Unnórenean blood, beckoning us to come from the woodhaven safety of our birth to the north and east, to the hills and lands that should be the old-lands of our lost heritage. “Deeper than Song runs the blood of Unnórenain,” the Minhiriathrim often said, “and cold but commanding in their heart is the blood which beckons them home.” I think of that now as I walk in these northlands.
‘In Tyrn Goerthaid9 four years before I had heard this call of blood so very strongly. But that land was cursed and is a home now for no Man. Many of our folk once had their rest there. Many of my lineage were there laid down. And, as all my fathers had done, I had made pilgrimage to these downlands on my twentieth autumn to hear their ancestral voices. Many hopes I then had as a younger man to understand my heritage not only through the songs of my protectors but also through the death-practices of our ancestors. I was drawn, by my own heart’s blood, to have the Unnórenain understanding for what was lost. And to all who question loss, Tyrn Goerthaid, and its inhabitants, give quiet and dismal answers.
‘“Númenórean blood is ours,” these shades told me. These wights who now held those downlands, they who laid down in death so very long ago before that blood had dried or grown watered in life throughout the Northlands. Now their home and rest has darkened, their once green mounds become dire and desolate, turned to a twisted and blighted plague-place of angered memories. An empty land of perturbéd spirits who despised their own restlessness. Yet, as graveyards might, the land itself drew its own far-folk home to its desolate bosom to taste of ancient reverie. Tryn Goerthaid was no longer a land of honor-watch and of requiem for distant families of the Sea-kings as long stories of our folk had told me. Now it was a land to be lamented. Once precious, revered by our People, it would never be ours’ again. It has been taken and darkened. Now it is a land of waste and of wraiths, a past that has become pestilent, where requiescent honors given the dead become entrapments for the living.
‘All the men of my house made their journey-rite of manhood there. Is it the same in your house? For we believe that all Men must learn to resist the call of their disturbed dead kinsmen. But some, as I am, were drawn further by their Unnórenean blood’s old, cold calling.
‘The low and hazy hills had most immediately awakened my heart’s blood from the first moment I had come to Tyrn Goerthaid. Sadness had settled into my young heart then; the unnamed disquiet of finding home and knowing it to be broken long before my arrival. Perhaps this was the purpose my forefathers had in the pilgrimage; the knowing of what is lost may bring the vision to begin anew. Good sons do all that is bidden by great fathers. I saw to the spirits, resisted their dwimmer-talk, and stood my night’s vigil at their pillar. In the bleak, still morning afterward I returned again to Eryn Vorn and my family as I should. But I never lost the memory of this great call to my blood, this awakening to my homelands.
‘Now the land here above the Great Road called me deeper and its stillness makes my heart sound all the stronger. The orcs occupied my attentions, but the empty lands filled my heart’s-blood.’
‘I have not yet seen the Barrow-downs,’ Collum said to the bard, ‘but everything you say of them fills me with the same sadness I have felt in the Northlands.’
‘No, soldier,’ the bard replied, ‘these lands are emptied and lonely, but not haunted and bare. Take joy in how they thrive!
‘But I must return to the story.
‘Before I could come too close behind the party, there came a great rustle through their ranks and more loud gross sounds of their restlessness. Then came a call from the captain’s voice and they began to run again. They had found the scent.’
*****
Light fell upon Flomi’s face and his body quietly woke with its welcoming warmth.
‘... Light-hearted laughter loud in the building...’ Flomi began to say softly in Sindarin. Some memory stirred in him of music.
‘Greeted him daily; the dulcet harp-music,
‘Clear song of the singer...’ he returned, as if in a dream of reciting.
‘He is waking!’ a great voice said near him. Flomi turned his head a bit to this and saw an enormous man, with bristling red-brown hair and bare arms and a bright happy smile on his wide face.
‘You must lie still, little warrior,’ the man said, coming closer with open hands. ‘You have slept many hours but have many wounds. I have watched over you while the others have talked.’
There was a strange flavor to the man’s talk; halting at times, as if the Common Tongue was young in him, but robust in tone like the bard’s had been. But they were not the same. Flomi thought it unlikely that this was some countryman of the man who had aided him.
‘I should not have thought it likely,’ came another much clearer voice from nearby, ‘but to be surprised by a dwarf seems a little thing in these three days of surprises.’
The voice was young and bright and clear, but filled with sureness and some small measure of disdain. He then saw an Elf-child walk up next to the man and began to remember.
‘You two were at the Four Greenfields... on the night of my departure,’ Flomi said. ‘Have you come with Collum?’
‘Yes, yes, you are remembering well, rune-master,’ the Elf-child said, ‘Pallando and the Unnórenean will be well pleased.’
‘He woke to sing a song, Tawar,’ the giant wildman told the Elf-child, ‘and in the language of your own folk.’
‘Indeed?’ the Elf-child said, this time with genuine surprise. ‘Well, I should like to hear that! I have learned lately to respect the learning of rune-masters, but an Elfish song raised in the deep voice of the Naugrim? This intrigues me.’
‘No, no...’ Flomi said, ‘you misunderstand. It is not an Elfish song, but something from old Arnor that this bard... brings us. Something important to our cause. Is the bard still here?’ he asked urgently. ‘Collum must know!’ he tried rising but the strong yet gentle hand of the wild man, and the pain in his chest, quickly convinced him to lie back.
‘He knows, little warrior,’ the man said gently. ‘They talk now and my brother here has just come from their speaking.
‘Yes. Rest yourself, rune-master,’ the Elf-child said, ‘there is great counsel being taken about you and your enterprise and I have just come from there.’
‘Tell them, tell Collum,’ Flomi said as he lay back under the big man’s gentle hand, ‘the bard brings us clues... tell him we must hear his song...’
But if this Elf-child heeded him, or had any reasons of his own in the matter, Flomi could not tell. He drifted slowly back into sleep and, at the edge of his reason before slumber, thought he heard the soft music of a dulcet-harp playing within the cavern.
*****
‘After an hour's angry run the orcs paused again as they closed upon their quarry. A short valley they had come to and I watched them safely from the distance of a hilltop as their new courses were laid.
‘In the valley’s bottom they had come upon another Man, another race-traitor, who awaited their aid. I could not hear the exchange of their voices at so great a distance, but knew they had caught up to the other villain who had been stalking the dwarf.
‘This man was on horseback, as his comrade had been. He was taller than the other race-traitor perhaps, and also held both longbow and a sword at his side. Even from high on the hill I could see that this was a man more given to governance than his companion and who would well-master the orcs. Even at a distance this was a dangerous man.
‘From safe surrounding I watched a while as the orc-captain and the two traitor-men talked and a dozen warriors rustled aimlessly around. Harsh words were likely said, though I heard them not from that high place above the valley and over the harsh crashing of the restless orc-folk.
‘Suddenly, unexpectedly, this new leader shot his hand up and let a loud dark cry into the night. This was of a crass language, unknown to me, but dark and fearsome to all who heard it. The gnashing sounds of unhappy orcs were stifled by it, the restless and boisterous wandering of their usual behavior halted. With some rough voice in some Dark Tongue the traitor-man had mastered them and all were paused before it.
‘Short was the speech (though its barely heard rhythms echoed us quietly in my head), and the traitor-man raised his sword high upon giving it.
‘Finishing the Dark Talk he spun his blade quickly, mercilessly, to cut the throat of his own horse. Rather than see the beast suffer he brought the blade swiftly down to end its life. Then, walking boldly to the orc-captain, he took up the captain’s raiment in his hand and wiped the horse-blood from his blade. Sheathing it and looking into the captain's eyes, he called loudly to the orcs in his same Dark Language.
‘They fell, warrior and hunter, upon the fallen horse, tearing and rending for all they could get of the fresh meat still hot with life.
‘The orc-captain did not move. His hammer did not leave his shoulder. He looked to this new commander with a long and sharp eye. After a long moment he spit to the side and accepted the man’s leadership.
‘A dozen orcs ate all they might of the dead horse’s flesh quick as they may and then this dark man had them on the hunt again.’
*****
‘Flomi?’ a voice called. ‘You must wake awhile, my friend.’
It was Collum, of course, and the man’s voice drew him through the darkness. But waking made him feel stronger, and he was happy to answer.
‘I am here,’ he said softly, ‘though I marvel that you and so many others are here with me. Our place of hiding seems to have become a meeting-hall...’
Collum used his old and trusted soft smile; ‘well, my friend, it was you that left open the doors.’
‘True, that I did,’ Flomi replied. ‘But such a time I had in opening and defending them that little chance came to run back up the stair to see them shut. I trust that your ancestors will forgive me for this.’
‘Oh, of that I have no doubt,’ his friend said, ‘for they are indebted to you already. Here. I have brought some stew to give you strength. Can you manage it?’
‘Yes, I shall try,’ Flomi said, trying to rise up a bit, ‘I am rightly famished...’
‘Here, friend,’ Collum said, ‘I will help you.’
So he came beside the dwarf, helping him sit up a bit and placing his saddle, which lay nearby, behind him. Flomi took the bowl from him and, proudly, managed to feed himself from it. There was a long and awkward moment between them as he tried to accomplish this, and Collum smiled softly again to break the tension.
‘Four days, I should think,’ Flomi said slowly to his friend. ‘Four days’ rest and, if he will have me, I should be able to ride a bit on your friend Duncan there. If he will have me.’
‘Oh, he has taken a strong liking to you,’ Collum said, laughing in a reassuring way. ‘Moreso than he ever had with myself or poor Guldir. All this day and night he has stood cautiously by your side. If he will bear any rider I am sure it would be you.’
There was another pause between the two as Collum watched his friend painfully slurp at the bowl of stew. Flomi did not meet his gaze, though he felt its questions. Collum could see that the dwarf’s left arm shook weakly, but that he still needed the help of it to hold the small bowl aloft with his right. He could hear the depth of the dwarf’s breathing; so much better now than when he had arrived to find him last night, but shallow still and coming much more often than it had in his health. Collum had never served beside a dwarf before, though he had heard old stories of their hardiness; but he had also seen many harsh battles and many wounded soldiers. He was wondering if Flomi would survive.
In the awkwardness of the moment Flomi tried to look about the room. The wounds in his shoulder and chest made it hard to turn about, but he saw half a dozen other figures, and some of their beasts, in the Grazing Fields around them.
‘We have much help now, it seems,’ the dwarf said. ‘Have you brought some horde of comrades for me to meet? I fear...’ he coughed a hard and wet cough here that frightened them both, ‘I fear that I have been too drowsy to offer them my thanks. Tell me, what do they know of our enterprise?’
‘Ahh, that is still uncertain,’ Collum said, drawing closer and smiling his old familiar smile again. ‘Some are here who have wisdom deeper than Men may account for. Of those folk the little clues I have given to enlist their aid have, I think, revealed much without my saying. But they are enigmas themselves, these three, and I still do not know if they consider our goal worthy of their interest.
‘Others are here,’ he continued, ‘like your unlooked-for comrade, that are about business of their own; traveling west to the mustering that Círdan calls in Mithlond. They know less of course, but are anxious for their own journeys-‘
‘No!’ Flomi said, nearly spilling his stew-bowl, ‘the Bard must come with us, Collum! He has missing pieces of the puzzle. He sang a song that I have never heard that speaks specifically of our goal.’
‘How can this be?’ Collum replied, surprise showing on his face for the first time that Flomi could remember seeing it. ‘His folk are known to us, but mostly forgotten from the North. A song, you say?’
‘Yes,’ Flomi replied, ‘a very beautiful, very long song, in Sindarin of all things. I have many questions for him... though I will need more strength to ask them.’ He took a longer draw of his stew then and Collum noticed that his left hand shook less noticeably and that his gaze seemed sharper in its focus as he looked at the other travelers.
‘And,’ Flomi said slowly, regaining even breaths after his outburst, ‘though it pains me to admit it, we would be better equipped if we kept that elf among us. The Bard sings in Sindarin, but I cannot make out more than half of it.’
*****
‘The orcs returned to the hunt after their hot meal, long and straight through the night. They rushed less, making it easier for me to keep pace, for their way was more even now and their new commander had given them all they needed to track the dwarf-scent. There were pauses to their hunt, as if this new commander was curious to see where his quarry was bound, but the hunters had no such patience. Behind them the sun was soon to awaken. I made my own hidings more carefully, aware that the fear they felt from behind might disclose me.
‘They halted on a small rise of land as the night grew short. Many looked down to see their quarry ahead, but many also looked back to see the worrisome coming of dawn. In the deep protection of trees along the hillside I moved closer to hear their speech.
‘“...so if he’s wanted, we want him now,” their captain complained as his band stood beside him. “For if the Sun is on him soon, then we won’t be.”
‘Some rumbled, gnashed and growled in approval, but none of them too loudly.
‘The race-traitors then spoke to each other in some different tongue, yet another that I have never heard before, and considered their next steps with this band of ill-tempered gorgûn. The warriors paused with their ears high while the snufflers kept eyes averted from their masters and noses low to the ground on the dwarf’s trail.
‘“He flees,” the smaller race-traitor replied to the orc-captain, “but soon he’ll make camp. He is soft; a townsfolk. He awaits some guidance from his fellows that should come to him and I’m surprised that he’s come this far. There must be some pre-arranged meeting for him to come all this way through the night. He is frightened, and I half expect him to turn back. We’ll have him soon.”
‘“We’ll have him before the yellowface comes,” commanded their captain, encouraged by his companions at his back, “or me and my fellows will be off!”
‘Grumbles and grunts came from the band of fighters behind him. A slow and quiet silence followed.
‘“We will follow,” the other, stronger commander said coldly, “and in the hour before dawn falls on him we shall. But until then,” he had said slowly, but increasing the harshness in his voice so all nearby might hear, “if you want to keep your wretched lives beyond that sunrise and if you respect the authority of our terrible masters as I do, you will follow this dwarf and you will only take him when you are told to do so.”
‘Then the grunts and the gnashing noises amongst the fighters stopped. The captain spat at the ground again, though to the side of the traitor-commander, whom he eyed suspiciously.
‘“Aye,” he said, “an hour before the dawn we’ll give it. But we’ll take him quickly then, or leave you to the job yourselves. And you can tell our terrible masters that and where to find us when you fail.”
‘At this he raised his great hammer high and beckoned his boys forward. Then, fast again, but now quiet, for they would take their quarry soon and would not have him alerted.
‘The traitor-men, their command threatened, now ran to keep up.’
*****
Awakening under early dawn light, Flomi knew that he had once again lost the track of time. ‘How odd,’ he thought upon waking, ‘that a dwarf should lose time at rest in a cavern while others still know it by the rhythms of sunshine.’
‘Sunshine is their rhythm, rune-master,’ a voice said to him from somewhere that was not quite his hearing, ‘but it is not yours or that of your People. Men rise by Sun and till the land and work their arts. They build their worlds and dream of their futures with each new morning. Elves rise by Stars, but they till and they build no longer, preferring to lament their long lives in this Middle-earth that they once thought to be only their own.
‘The Children of Aulë harken not to Stars or Sun but to the firmament of Arda itself. You awaken as the world tells you,’ the voice said, ‘and there is much to be learned from that.’
Flomi looked about him to see where this voice had come from (for he seemed certain it was Dwarf-speech and unknown to any he had previously seen in the party) and found that the old man in the deep blue robes with the haunting eyes of the sea was seated here by his side.
‘Grandfather,’ he said respectfully, ‘do I know you? Twice now you have looked after me and brought me great peace. And now I feel you know much of my People that remains unspoken in the broader world.’
‘Perhaps,’ he said softly (and Flomi was here glad to see his mouth move and to know that it was the Common Tongue which he spoke with). ‘I know well the works of Mahal,10 your Maker, though I cannot pretend to know his purpose.
‘Of you, however,’ he said rising, ‘I can speak. You will live, Rune-master, though this battle was an untimely test of your mettle. Stone, they say, must be quarried to be measured, and you have done well in your time of rough-handling and severe measurement.
‘After such a trial Khazâd like yourself, though Rune-masters are seldom counted amongst the battle-folk, either die glorious deaths or lead good long lives of great prosperity as your Maker has willed it and as Ilúvatar has allowed.
‘Rest, son of Trochi,’ he said, laying again his gentle hand on Flomi’s brow, ‘and be well. Hold faith that you are not forgotten, and live justly and proudly in the Fire of Mahal.’
And again Flomi looked long into the deep color of the old man’s eyes and saw the sea that he heretofore had no reason to imagine. And, though questions swirled about his mind as the man touched his forehead, he felt a peace he had not felt in years and fell fast asleep.
In his dreams he heard a four-worded sound he had never heard before ‘seesoo, hrss, rsseeiss, ooors’11 and was happy. No great task lay before him, no crushing weight of his father’s work controlled him. He was free to live a long and prosperous life apart from responsibility.
But this, of course, was only the comfort of dreaming.
*****
‘I had taken no stragglers for there were none. They moved tightly now as a band, under their familiar orc-captain, excited with a clear and under-powered quarry before them. The traitor-men had held them in check well for a time, but they could not hold back the dawn. Their allies were restless for want of blood. Now as the Last Wall grew nearer in the dwarf’s flight they became concerned; had he some help awaiting on the other side?
‘So, as they had promised, the traitor-men determined to take him an hour before the dawn and within a mile of the westward wall. The men snuck to the fore of the party and then the bowman put an arrow into the runner’s back. From my place of cover behind the orc-band I saw as the arrow struck the lone figure and heard the orcs’ wild cries as they broke from cover to take their prey.
‘They were still some two hundred or so strides out and I, in my place of concealment, another fifty. With the orcs in full run I would not reach the dwarf until too late. I wondered what small help I might still be, and followed the orcs as hastily as I might.
‘From the trees ahead I heard a strong call. A voice deeper than any I have experienced. I heard this dwarf as he rumbled and cursed angrily through the night with a foreign music which stirred me.
‘“Abrâfu shaikmashâz!” came the cry and I could see the lone figure as he broke from cover, his weapon high. “Follow if you dare!” the dwarf challenged them all, “I shall show you the hardness of Dwarven steel.”
‘And at this he turned and ran to a glade some small distance away that was marked by seven white trees, well-omen of our People. The orcs cursed his challenge and followed him hotly. But the ground here was open before the glade and I had to pursue more cautiously to come up behind them unawares.
‘“I shall follow to see your steel shine, master dwarf,” I thought then, “and I will aid you as I can that I might hear the deep music of your language once more.”’
‘And we are greatly indebted that you did,’ Collum said to the Bard after hearing his long tale, ‘for though he fought mightily and conquered many, Flomi would not have survived his wounds without you. Even with Pallando’s aide, his hope is still doubtful.’
The two men stood outside beneath the wall, the hidden door now shut again behind them. Dawn was now nearing and for Collum it had been a long night of dire surprises and hasty consuls before hearing the Bard’s full tale.
‘Your kindness towards my friend has brought you to a most secret place, Unnórenean,’ Collum said to the man as he looked east to the gathering light, ‘but as I understand your history, it is a place for all our People. I am glad that you have helped to defend it and I trust you shall keep its secrets.
‘Our own paths ahead are uncertain until we know more of Flomi’s health,’ he continued. ‘Will you stay with us for a time?’
*****
Flomi awoke again, after some longer time, to the sound of gentle harping. The song itself did not wake him, in fact it had quite the opposite effect on his heart; intricate in its structure but altogether soothing in its melody, the song spoke to him of green meadows and of day’s last light, of long shadows and well-trodden roads to homes with lighted doorways and warm breezes out of the South. The early glimmering of the brightest stars in the darkening sky of a day’s work ended. Though these were not, he knew, the normal comforts of his own People, the song spoke to the comforts of his life as he knew it in the Bree-land and which he also knew he might never see again.
His wetted eyes, affected by the song, opened slowly as to not break the spell on his heart and he was not surprised to see that the Bard sat beside him, playing a harp of unique and marvelous design, leaning intently to his task.
He sat up just a little, quite quietly so as to not disturb the song, and looked about him as far as his injuries would allow.
Some ways off he saw Inbar and three other beasts. One was Caitelyn, Collum’s own great mare, with another horse and fat white pony. All three seemed calmed by the Bard’s music and even Inbar, standing a little apart from the rest, cocked his head and raised his great long ears to the sound.
Three old men (if Men they were) in robes of blue and grey sat in stillness on a bench near the fountains; relaxed they seemed, but unsleeping and unspeaking. They too were quieted by the song and sat unmoving beneath its spell.
A hobbit that he knew, the hunter Benbow Floxleaf of whom Collum had spoken so well, was curled up and asleep in a tuft of the grass which grew here in the Grazing Field. Flomi could see a great light in his face which at first shocked him. Then, and perhaps for the first time, he realized what he found so surprising and confounding in his time amongst these Breelanders; their ability to seek and to show the benefits of simple peace at the end of a good day’s work. In Floxleaf’s face he saw everything that he should ever miss of the Bree-land, and he was the happier for that memory throughout the remainder of his life.
Not far from him lay the great wildman he had met earlier, also deep in slumber, the heaving of his enormous chest slow and calmed and keeping some strange beat to the harping. Beside him stood the Elf-child, not much taller than Flomi himself was. He stood straight, but without rigidness, his eyes closed in green-dreaming (as Flomi had heard that they will do) and some small, half-surprised, expression of joy on his face. Whether this was for the harping or of his own green-dreaming Flomi could not know. Elves were a subject of some interest to his research but quite unfamiliar to him, and this one seemed more queer in ways than most. But the Elf-child was as much at peace as the others as the music played. This much anyone might see.
Collum sat closest of course. His great longsword lay beside him, his hand rested nearby it, but his head had also drooped in drowsiness. He was too much the soldier, too much the friend, to not stand vigil, but his weariness and the song’s power had, at last, gotten the better of his long watchfulness.
Lastly he turned his head again to the Bard, who looked at him now while still playing intently, beautifully. Flomi blinked his happy eyes, nodding, smiling, drowsing again, as if to thank the harper for his song. The man smiled back warmly, working his fingers freely over the curving instrument in his lap; plucking now more intently.
Flomi heard the call of green fields again at dusk, felt the long cool shadows of trees, knew again the very taste of red summer wine upon his lips. He thought of his father’s silly yellow waistcoat and was happy to have brought it. He decided that he should finally take up pipeweed. He wondered where he had put that small piece of limestone and very much wished to hold it again.
As he finally relented and slipped finally down into a healing slumber, small details of the stoneyard and of the Bree-land echoed through his head. He would never go there again, but for tonight the harp’s sad music gave his heart a fond memory of that last home for one final moment.
End of Chapter Seven
Notes on Chapter Seven
1) The italics for this song, and at some later points in the chapter, indicate that the words are being sung to Flomi in Sindarin. Not all italics within the chapter will be Sindarin, of course, as this was a common device in Tolkien for relating songs and any unfamiliar tongues. But for the scenes with Flomi and the Bard, the song here is always Sindarin. It is important to note that Sindarin, and not Adûnaic, was the “cultured and written” language of the Dúnedain in the Third Age and, as such, also principal in their histories. Moreover, readers should recognize that this song is rather freely appropriated from Beowulf. It has, from the beginning, been my intention to weave legends and stories that fit tightly into the Tolkien legendarium as Easter Eggs for readers. This chapter is an exercise in just that and, I hope, I should be forgiven by classics scholars who know the work so much better than I might. Like most artists of my age, I learn just enough of what I need to steal what I want to make the thing which I believe is my own best from what I know. Honest appropriation is a sad replacement for genuine research, but can be a sincere fuel for art.
2) Some here might take notice of “gorgûn” as the name for orcs amongst the Drúedain. There are (or may be) some links between the Drúedain, the Minhiriathrim and the Púkel-men that I hope to explore.
3) Unlike many of his predecessors, there is indeed no direct Sindarin translation for Amlaith’s name. Does this cast him as less legitimate? There are some unanswered questions here regarding the name.
4) I’ve got quite a lot of Joyce on me and so I looked hard and long to see if the sound of a donkey bray had been rendered by him or any other modern author. I found very little to my liking. So this noise, built with my fondest nod to Joyce, is the closest I can come at this time to the musicality of a bray.
5) Dwarves have their own language, which is secret, and their own names for fellows and loved-ones that also remains secret. Flomi will not use this name openly much, but he is groggy here and just thinking of it. “Inbar” means “horn” in Dwarfish and is given for the loud braying which saved his master’s life.
6) Reader’s here may note the similarity to the three characters in the Book of Daniel; Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego. There is no particular link intended here except that I find the sound of those names musically appropriate for orcs.
7) Of this list, “ oliphants, ungolianonnar, trolls and Taras, dwimmerlaik and dragons” a few items need mentioning. “Ungolianonnar” would mean “children of Ungoliant” as best I can manage. Oliphants and dwimmerlaik were chosen to indicate possible commonalities in the speech of the Rohirrim and of the Hobbits which Merry writes about some thousand years later. The geographic location of the Minhiriath makes it likely that smatterings of those older languages might have come there, much like the “gorgûn” mention in note #2. But “Taras” is a new thing within the list and is a reference to Mount Taras in Beleriand, lost in the changing of the world but somehow remembered in the songs of these old, old people.
8) Though Tolkien does not indicate genders for the four winds, I thought it might be something interesting to play with. The Minhiriathrim, in my construction, give characters, if not quite personifications, to the different winds, complete with names and stories. Winds of the west and of the south are all feminine and protecting, of the north and of the east, masculine and ill-favouring .
9) “Tyrn Goerthaid” is a more ancient name for the Barrow-Downs visited (unfortunately!) by Frodo and the other hobbits in his party. Tyrn Gorthad was the name in Sindarin. It is a compound of torn ("down") and gorthad ("of buried"). In one manuscript, the name Tyrn Goerthaid was used by Tolkien. Goerthaid seems to be the plural of gorthad with affected vowels.
10) “Mahal” or Maker, is the Dwarf word for Aulë. It is unclear how much the dwarves know of the Valar, but they know Mahal to be one of the many “Lords of the West” and that, unlike the other races of Middle-earth, they know he created them.
11) This onomatopoeic bit of sound is, again, from James Joyce, this time directly. It can be found in the “Proteus’ episode of ULYSSES and I think it does rather sound like the sea.