New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
-In which Some Introductions are Made, an Escape Occurs, and a Deadly Distraction serves to Unite the Purposes of the Party
Just six nights before the fire happened Flomi and Collum had made plans for their necessary departure from the Bree-land. ‘It won’t be easy, my slipping away,’ the tall man had said, ‘and it may very well be that you will have to go for a time ahead of me if we’re to travel far in safety. I do not like the look of Sarnside’s sallow-faced friends who have so recently arrived and, much worse, I do not recognize their accents.’
The man had an uncommonly good sense for trouble and Flomi, who was never much known for watchfulness himself, had come to trust it implicitly in the dozen or so years of their relationship. Old Cradaic Gilleyfoil, the man’s predecessor, had been much more talkative, much more friendly with Flomi and all the townsfolk, but that had nearly cost them everything and the great enterprise of their ancestors was almost undone at one time through an act of petty burglary precipitated by that man’s carelessness. So Collum became a greatly improved replacement in regard to their secret mission (though Flomi did sometimes wonder what happened to the kindly old Cradaic after he was removed from his post. Men, or so the Dwarf had learned, were sometimes more fixated on the usefulness and successes of their kin than they were respectful of their grandsires).
It was Collum who had expanded the rumor of Flomi’s wealth and his extravagant payment for services. This had, quite surprisingly, shielded them from scrutiny for the past years. ‘There’s not so many thieves to be found here amongst the Breelanders,’ the man had said, ‘for thieving comes from a blend of greed, desperation and nervous courage; ingredients these folk have only in small portions. So if there’s no need for us to fear their tendency toward crime, let us find some good means to utilize their love of rumour. Let the gossipy ones believe there is money, and they’ll tell us about all the other characters they encounter who might’ve heard likewise; all those coming through town who might inquire after you, all those we might need to watch for.’ It was a very peculiar plan (particularly from a Dwarf’s perspective), to indicate false wealth as an assurance of safety, but it had worked, and worked well, for many years. Collum had nodded and winked at all their foolish assumptions of a Dwarfish hoard of gold and gems while Flomi, for the first time in two decades, found himself shielded from the many prying questions and the probing small talk of these ridiculous townsfolk. In the meanwhile to Collum they had revealed every perceived threat, every mistrustful glance which they saw and all of their far-fetched ideas regarding suspicious strangers. A wise judge of character, Collum had succeeded in turning their interest away from the dwarf himself and outward to any who might threaten his well-being. And all at the cost of a few well-given drinks, knowing gestures and carefully-placed questions.
‘He was right, I am certain,’ thought Flomi as he moved hastily towards the stables, ‘the time of our departure has finally come and I am most heartily glad of it. Thirty years here amongst these dim-folk might dull any person’s brightness!’
‘Now when we go,’ Collum had said, ‘it must need subtlety. For now, through no desire of my own, I’ve grown too large a figure to all these small folk of the Bree-land. There must be a reason for my departure or it will become suspect. You and I leaving together, especially now, is even more dangerous.’
‘What do you then propose?’ Flomi had asked. ‘Many of the roads we would travel are uncertain since the fall of Fornost Erain.1 Our journey must go North, even if not from the first, and there is no safe haven to be found there any longer.’
‘True,’ Collum had said, ‘and to the North Fortress and Lake Evendim we cannot go alone. But other of my folk are gathering again beyond the Baranduin and I’ve heard some rumour of travelers we might confide in now coming along the road to the Bree-land. People of great wisdom.
‘But west or eastbound I do not know. Many forces are being marshaled there between the Brown River and the Lhûn to create a fresh defense,’ he paused for a few moments, deeply considering the options laid before him.
‘I believe that our road must lie West before North,’ he continued after some time. ‘But still we must hear more of who remains in Arthedain2 if we are to travel there and solve the Riddle. You cannot yet devise the place on Evendim that we seek, so we must hold a safe place for a time in which more clues might come to guide us.
‘The Baranduin and the lands west of it are safe and untampered with as yet, but the next strike will likely come there rather than here to the south. The Witch-king cannot allow the remaining forces of Arnor to regroup with the Elves of Mithlond3 or your own folk in the Blue Mountains. He will cross the Baranduin in force soon while the days of sunshine are still short. He will need to hold the Stonebows to cut the forces of the West from attacking. I believe his attack there will come soon. The Bree-land here, and these happily ignorant people, will likely remain safe for some time, while hobbits to the west, in their beloved and unprotected Shire, will see war. The west will be a dangerous direction for travel.
‘But we are watched here, Flomi, I know it if I know anything. These new and suspicious travelers, the disturbance at your stoneyard last month, and all these increased questions of your wealth, they surely point to something bigger than burglary. And those who watch you now are no mere thieves any more than I am an innkeeper.’
The inn of the Four Greenfields was shuttered now behind Flomi as he made his way down to the stables through the connecting alleyway. ‘And that wise innkeeper (who is indeed no innkeeper) owns these stables too,’ he thought, ‘though most of these foolish townspeople do not suspect it.’
Collum’s predecessor had no such head for business nor innate understanding of how a town works. For twenty years of his indenture here Flomi had taken money from his own purse to use these same stables. It was a necessary part of his rather superficial function as a stonemason and an explanation of his need to return here to the Four Greenfields for the real work of each day; translating text. In truth he was somewhat embittered toward the old man (charming though he was) for this expense. But Collum had removed this obstacle almost immediately upon hearing of it by quietly (and, to Flomi, quite surprisingly) purchasing the stables and installing his own people there. ‘My own engagement, rune-master, is to your well-being,’ he had said at the time, ‘but our shared safety relies upon knowing who comes and goes. As an innkeeper I can discover much when a traveler will sit to talk, but a stableman can also tell us much more with less conversation; for any traveler who sits, alone or in groups, for many days on his end, will meet a stableman first, telling him of all his troubles, revealing to him all of his wants, and asking him, as first contact in a new place, all of his questions. I’ll have them in their comfort of sitting, but a wise stablemaster will understand their needs better for meeting them in their long days after travel and discomfort.’
Flomi knew that the man was charming him with the small witticism and, not unremarkably, with the decreased personal expense he would need to make in the stables. He laughed at the joke, was pleased by the savings, but immediately knew this new manager of his was to have more resources and more concern for their shared enterprise than his predecessor. And this, more than anything personally dangerous to himself which may have brought Collum to the Bree-land, let Flomi know that they must be drawing much closer in their mission.
Now, as he approached the stables, Flomi was remembering their planning from six nights before. ‘In the best version of our story that I might construct,’ Collum had said to him then, ‘I would leave first, most suddenly and unexpectedly, and you would make a spectacle here in the town about how I had stolen from you and how you must storm out to find me. This is the story I’ve been building towards for years, my own mysterious character creating a plausible end to our created fiction.’
‘Ah! I hope you’ve written me a wonderful monologue,’ Flomi laughed, ‘ I raise my maddock high in the commonroom and swear some oath on my grandsires of well-deserved vengeance! Who, in this small-thinking town, could deny that?’
‘Yes, a good laugh in its way I suppose, and in its ability to play on their own joy of gossip. And for long I wished that you might have it. I believe you deserve the glory of such a grand exit to keep these dull-headed Breelanders talking of your departure for many years to come.
‘But we cannot do this, Flomi, for my role as information gatherer in this place has surpassed your own as the extravagant but wealthy miser. They have come to trust me, these Breelanders. Once, when we started out together perhaps this would do, but in these many years I am now seen more as a warden by the Bree-folk than a transient. None will believe that any thief who had been given this much trust would wait this long to strike.’
This was true. Collum had gained and cautiously manipulated their trust in these past dozen years. He had skillfully managed to minimize his own mysteriousness by letting others do the talking. Even the most cautious and quietly-guarded Breelanders had come to feel that they knew Collum well simply because of all the personal things that they had unwittingly told the man of themselves. Very few in town, if asked, might be able to tell you his second name, yet all were somehow certain of his trustworthiness because of conversations in which he had managed it so that they reveal themselves much more than he ever had. Flomi had watched this happen over the years with some amusement and, in truth, had fallen into the same easiness with the man. Collum was an attentive listener and had a keen way of understanding another person’s troubles. But when Flomi’s thought about it now, well, the days of Collum acting unscrupulous in the eyes of the Breefolk had somehow long slipped past them, and Flomi, a resident in the Bree-land for three decades, had now become the outsider while this, ethir4 (Dwarves had, of course, no word of their own for ‘spy’) had become the friend of every rumour-monger the town had to offer.
‘I’m sorry my friend,’ Collum had said, ‘but when the sign comes, as I believe it will within these next few days, you must go first. Go quickly to the safest spot we can devise, and wait there for me to resolve things in the Bree-land and join you. It will not be easy, for it may happen quite suddenly.’
The lantern in the stable was low when Flomi entered and old Guldir, the stablemaster, was nowhere in sight. Outsiders might have found this a bit unsettling, for the stable itself had many stalls and was, it seemed, quite prepared to service many travelers passing through the Bree-land; in this way it was much like the Four Greenfields, a way-point that was seldom left unattended. But while there were quite a few unexpected travelers in the town this evening it appeared that many had come on foot, for many of the stalls remained empty. ‘The old man has probably stepped out for his own bit of sup,’ thought Flomi, ‘but that might make my own work here just the easier, if done with haste.’
The three ponies Flomi owned had a respected spot near the front of the stalls as it was his custom to take one, two or the team of them each morning with him on his return to the stoneyard. They were directly across from Collum’s own tall mare, Caitelyn, who had her own reputation amongst the townsfolk. Collum’s saddle, well-worn from whatever his life may have truly been before the Bree-land, hung unsuspiciously behind the mare and had, for years, provided a hidden drop point for messages between them; for Collum was one of the only four living individuals who had learned Flomi’s secret written language. And, if they were successful in their enterprise, he would be the last Man to ever use it.
‘I must check there again for any message before I go,’ Flomi thought, ‘but do I dare leave a note for him? How much danger are we in?’
*****
Rosie heard a very curious sound as the dwarf entered the stable. She did not see him of course, for she hated this terrible little town and all of its gathered smells and noises and people. Only her love for Benbow Floxleaf could make her endure the place, so, at his bidding, she hid in a stall of this terrible covered building with no sight of the stars. At the least, the cool late shadows of the day had helped her endure her own fever. But, she still knew a dwarf by his smell. And she was glad that he did not see her as she hid behind the high walls and listened. Her eyes were cloudy these past few days as the fever started and she no longer trusted them as she once had, but she listened and she smelled just as sharp as ever and she knew with great certainty that a dwarf had come.
The old Man had left some time before and she was happy about that; he had been kind to her when she and Benbow Floxleaf had entered, but she did not much care for his smell despite his kindness. As anyone knows, Men can well seem kind in the first, but might change in a moment and without a bit of warning; one had to watch a Man carefully and might still never be certain of their intentions. And if, like Rosie, one relied on smell and hearing lately more than eyesight, men were a caution; for their smell was usually less than pleasing and their words were often no true indication of their intent.
But the noise she heard now was soft and muffled and came from just outside the door behind where the dwarf had entered. Were there more of his folk outside? There was no threat in the small and suspicious sound, and Rosie stood there quite still hoping for some other clue to help identify it. She strained her ears and her nose, and even considered peeking over the protecting wall with her eyes, to learn more. And perhaps she might have, and perhaps things might then have gone quite differently, if she had learned to trust dwarves just a bit more.
*****
Flomi hesitated and looked sharply around the empty stables. There was no one, but a low burning lamp implied that Guldir or some other stable-hand might return soon. ‘I’ve no time for a proper message if, as we both have agreed, the time has come. I must take the ponies and set out and be thankful that no one is here to see me.’
He went hastily to Collum’s saddle which they had wisely hung within easy reach of Flomi as he might pass it near to his own ponies. Placed there each day it had served them usefully over the past decade. He looked about and then reached up to the hidden pouch for any last message.
‘Nothing there,’ he thought. ‘But I must not get stuck here writing or waiting.’ He knew Collum would look here for some sign. He hastily took a small and, in this town, quite unique brush from his jacket and placed it within the saddle’s pocket.
Entering the other stall he threw his own smaller saddle on Corlar, his favorite and the fleetest of his three ponies, and attached to that the long reins of the other two animals. He made very few sounds as he led them out the forward doors of the stable and paused for a moment under the shadows to look at the lane before him. There was no one in sight, no danger that might be seen as the lane wound toward the Hedge-gate and then on to the Great Road. A still night in which Flomi’s senses were awakened. For a moment he looked behind him.
‘I must go, while the time is quiet,’ he thought. ‘But some foreboding yet stays me. Am I watched?’ he looked quickly about and then back into the stable, seeing nothing but the dark lanes of the Bree-land before him and long shadows of the stables to his rear.
‘I will ride you, friend,’ he said softly, stroking Corlar’s neck, ‘for if we are watched they will need your own fleetness to follow.’ And at this he drew himself high into the small pony’s saddle and left the shelter of the stable at a brisque and, or so he hoped, unsuspicious pace.
*****
‘That is the smell of blood,’ Rosie thought, ‘or I am no friend of a good hunter. It is not from the dwarf, and he neither seems to notice it nor fear it, but there’s fresh blood which follows behind him. And he leaves it there without concern. Does he run from it?’ she wondered.
With no sight of the stars and the smell of fresh blood in the air she felt even more confined, even more anxious for Benbow Floxleaf’s return. The dwarf had left and no person seemed to be in the stables, so Rosie, in her discomfort, her fear and her curiosity, did a very foolish thing and raised her gaze over the protecting wall that she might, despite her poor eyesight, look for danger.
There, back in the darkness to the place from which came the smell of fresh blood, a nearly silent man, dressed all in black, peered through the rear doorway back in the darkness just at the edge of Rosie’s eyesight.
And, as her head peeked over the wall, his own turned sharply. The black man, she was sure, saw Rosie, alone, in the stables, and knew that she had seen him.
*****
‘Masters and travelers,’ Collum said in a voice large enough for any listening Breelander who might be lingering at the edges of all these strange folk’s conversation, ‘it is good to have so many of you here with news from our neighbors in the wider world. We are, and have been, a place at the Crossroads and do often build our own entertainments off of your stories and reports.
‘Now many of my friendly folk here do indeed like ‘news from outside’ as we call it, while many more prefer the goings-on from just a few houses down; for our entertainments and our politics are simpler here than you might have encountered in your travels. And we Breelanders are quite comfortably accustomed to our simplicity.’
This drew a few favorable noises from the townsfolk who were always happy to let Collum do the talking. But the humour of it was not lost on his new guests.
‘Now you, sir,’ he said, indicating the tall old gentleman in grey who had asked about a separate room and given Collum a coin, ‘have put many of my patrons in mind more of their own business and that of their neighbours with your talk of kings and allegiance. While I can’t say that you’ve not piqued my own interests with these words, I cannot truthfully say that you will find much support here in the commonroom for such sentiments.’ At this there was much affirmative grumbling from the previously skittish patronage for they seemed, somehow, to feel as if Collum had eloquently defended not only their right to gossip but also that longstanding Bree-land tendency to remove themselves from controversy.
‘I’ve a room for you all, sirs,’ he continued, ‘where you might share such tales as are your right, as travelers all, without disturbing peaceable-minded folks here who do not wish for such sad stories.
‘But,’ he said lastly to the whole group of strangers, including Ben, ‘I myself should like to hear better and wider stories of the surrounding lands from such wise folk as yourselves and, if such an opportunity should arise on a busy evening, I will join you there shortly. Milo!’
He called loudly to a young Hobbit who came quite immediately from the other side of the room as if he had no other task there but to wait on his master’s call.
‘Take these six fine gentlemen to the outer hall,’ he said to the servant, ‘and bring them a cask of the winyard and board enough for all. This,’ he said just a bit more loudly as he held a large gold coin aloft for a moment and then hastily tucked it into his own belt, ‘shall pay for all and I will, myself, happily attend to whatever else you gentlemen might desire later.’
*****
There was a thing which happened there that few of the folk assembled noticed, though it did not escape the sharp eyes of Benbow Floxleaf; for that old man had not given Collum a gold coin just the moment earlier and Collum, quite clearly on his own, had decided to make the switch.
Ben was less than familiar with coins than most townsfolk certainly. A hunter and trapper in the Northern realm all his life, he dealt mostly in barter. But he was not naive enough to be unfamiliar with the differences between gold and copper. Had no one else seen Collum palm the old man’s coin so quickly and then offer this gold one in its place during all his talking? And why should an innkeeper create such a bold lie about a payment which was clearly not in his favor? Surely the old man knew the ruse that was happening, but did the young Elf-lord and his large companion catch the substitution? Why was Collum going so far out of his way to make excuses for all of these people that they should meet apart from the other Breelanders in the common room?
‘None of my own concern, I suppose, but curious enough for anyone to throw guesses at,’ he thought. And so, cautiously, for he did not have a good face for deceit, Ben looked quickly around to see if any others might have noticed the switch.
It was then, quite by accident, he noticed the three sallow-faced and dark-dressed Men near the rear door, huddled and watching. ‘There was another of them earlier, I remember,’ Ben thought. ‘Where’s he gone to?’
As a friend of Collum’s and a good judge of danger from his time in the wilds, it worried him. For he knew at a glance that these men were robbers or criminals from the way their eyes lighted upon that gold coin.
*****
Flomi left the town at a cautious but happy pace. ‘I shall never return here,’ he thought, ‘and that is a pleasant thing to know.’
It was still early in the evening and not many Breelanders were around to see him go. If they had been, not many would have bothered to speak with him or have remarked on his departure. He had remained an outsider to these people for many years and, other than in their stories, he would not be missed.
The ride to the stoneyard was not long and the ponies knew the ground along the way. Once he left the last group of houses to the west of the Bree-land near the Hedge-gate, he quickened Corlar’s pace, secure in the thought that none had seen him depart and that now his real flight should begin.
‘I cannot decide on our going west or north just yet,’ Collum had said six nights past. ‘Perhaps something will present itself to me before we are forced to leave. But I am certain we will need to leave separately and so must arrange a safe meeting place. But where is safe now as the North is overrun and Fornost has fallen?’
‘Should we go to Sarn Athrad?’5 Flomi had offered. ‘Many of my own people come that way now and a few might be empressed to our cause.’
‘That would seem safest, yes, but it is more than seventy leagues from here to the Southern Crossing, many long days of travel in what is certainly the opposite direction of our goal,’ Collum replied. ‘And much of it would be open country that I do not think you ought to travel through alone. No. We will need something closer. A waypoint from which we can plan our next move.
‘The way west of Bree-land is clear,’ he said, as if thinking aloud. ‘The Shirefolk keep the King’s bargain and still hold the Stonebows Bridge at the Baranduin safe in his name. But it is also two days' ride that you would need to venture on your own. I’ve no doubt that you might do this quickly and that even as a stranger you would find some safety there, but if the Witch-king pushes West to pursue the scattered men of Arthedain then our road north from the Shire will most certainly be blocked.’
‘Aye,’ Flomi said. ‘It is a safe haven, but also a snare against our greater purpose.
‘There are some small villages east along the Road, are there not, where we might meet? Smaller even than the Bree-land and further from the attentions of Angmar,’ Flomi asked.
‘A scattering of villages still remain open near the Weather Hills, yes,’ Collum replied, ‘but that area before is marshy and damp, and few travelers strange to those lands would choose to stop there. A lone Dwarf would draw much attention from the folk who live just beyond the Chetwood. And you might need to await my coming for as much as a week or more with no explanation of your purpose. You would certainly be noticed.
‘No, my friend,’ he said, after a long pause to consider. ‘There is still one better and well-hidden option to be utilized. It seems that you may get the peace and solitude among cold stone that you’ve wanted for these past years. While it is still revered by a small group of Edain and still quite secret amongst the most of my people, there is a tunnel not a day’s ride from here that might suit our purposes perfectly.’
*****
‘The hospitality of this innkeeper is astounding, Tawar,’ Beothalion said to his friend as they entered the much smaller outer hall, ‘I have spoken but a few words to him and been given drink, an offer of food and a chance for more of the Westron talk. This is a mighty greeting to give a stranger! Will there be coin expected at the end? Will we have enough to match the price?’
Despite his friend’s naive enthusiasm, the outer hall into which they were being led made much less of an impression on Tawarengil. ‘It is just another dingy and squarish structure in an asymmetrical maze of blandness,’ he thought. It seemed frequented less, so the stench compared with the previous hall was somewhat diminished, but two small windows looking on the alleyway and a tiny fireplace indicated that this was not a Greeting Hall as his people were accustomed to; no, this was a place suited more to conspiracy than poetry, and that is just not the kind of hall that Tawarengil and his people would ever call hospitable.
‘We have ample coin, brother,’ he responded in Sindarin, ‘for, good-natured as he seemed, he is still just a simple innkeeper, and this hovel is certainly nothing beyond our means or our deserves.’
‘Are we to continue in the Old Tongue then, my lord,’ The grey-clad Istari asked in Westron as his friends followed silently into the room, ‘or would you like to seem even more distrustful to these humble townsfolk?’
Benbow had been ushered to this outer hall with all the rest of them by Collum’s page and apprentice, Milo Fastknots. Milo was tall for a young hobbit and so, like Ben, fairly comfortable on a pony. It may be for that reason that the two had encountered one another many times in the past few years as Milo had often ridden back-and-forth to the kitchens of the Four Greenfields with fresh game when Ben would set up his spring hunt in the Chetwood. Milo was probably the least talkative hobbit that Ben had ever met (outside of his own father, of course) and he thought that beyond the young hobbits’ size this was likely the main reason that Collum had hired the boy. Whether the youngster was bored or dim Ben could not ever guess, but Milo had an oddly impenetrable nature that kept him apart from the other Breelanders and quite clearly apart from gossip; a quality most certainly to Collum’s liking. He had sandy brown hair and uncommonly large hands for hobbit and while he had a tendency to stare forward at the emptiness in any room around him, Ben had come to realize that Milo was quite a good listener.
As Milo lit the fire in the hall, Ben drew close to him and away from the others. If he was to be identified as ‘townsfolk’, as the old man had just said, then it might just be worth using that to get a message to Milo’s master.
‘This is as odd a collection of guests as I imagine you have ever seen here, Milo,’ Ben said, pitching his voice to a low, even conspiratorial tone. ‘I’ve seen some very queer and still very kind folk out in the Wild, but not many such cross the door of the Four Greenfields these days, I suppose.’
‘Some do maybe, Ben,’ the hobbit said cryptically, looking up as he kindled the small fire, ‘but not all at once and not so talkative as these ones here. How do you know them? Seen them in your travels, have you?’
Good, Ben thought. Even the normally distant young Milo was curious enough about these strangers to raise a question or two when the chance arose.
‘Never before this very hour,’ Ben said, drawing closer, ‘but your master’s offer of some wine and a bit of food only makes my own curiosity the wetter. And I’d dearly like some news of the troubles surrounding us, which these wise folks might just have. Still, if I was to speak caution to your master, I’d mention those troubling scoundrels at the rear of the commonroom. One of them disappeared quite suddenly and the others took too great an interest in that gold coin Collum held up for all to see.’
‘Sarnside’s fellows? They’re up to no good, that’s for certain, and certainer it is that my master knows of it. Still,’ Milo thought aloud, ‘I hadn’t seen one of them put off quietly. That might be something. I’ll look to it. Thanks.’
He made a soft nod to Ben and, the fire being lit, he then went quietly out on his other errands. Ben returned to the others.
‘I should like to talk the Westron-talk, Grey-stalker, and I thank you greatly for the opportunity,’ Beothalion said as he strode to the center of the small room, addressing the most outspoken of the three old wanderers. He put his tankard of wine on a table and placed his open hands out and then down in front of him in an offer of peaceful greeting.
‘My words in this talk may be rough and slow. I am sorry, for I am told it is the talk of many people and I wish that I knew it and all of them better.’
At this one of the other old travelers came forward. His beard was also quite long and bristling with grey though his eyes matched the brighter blue under his dirty traveling cloak, and he spoke to the Wildman in return.
‘You have a clouded practice of very old ways, young one,’ he said in a quiet, slow and rumbling voice, ‘and I welcome the memory it awakens.’ At this he lifted his flattened, upturned palms to his shoulders, let them drop slowly to his sides and then brought them forward and out to be seen before his own waist. In all, it looked to Ben like a more formal, more ceremonious, version of the Wildman’s greeting.6
‘I greet you, happily and peacefully on our Roads to the West,’ he said, in the Westron tongue, but with a certain implicit ceremony. Ben felt a strange flush in his own cheeks at this grand gesture and simple talk; there was deep sentiment here and he could immediately feel it. Though the words were quite common there was an undiscovered history in their speaking of how people, a civilized and kind people, should meet in strange lands and form fair company. There was, to Ben’s ear at least, a kindness in that statement that he would remember (and hope to use) in the rest of his days.
At this act of civility the Wildman was quite taken aback and, as he stammered for a fair-seeming response, his friend the young Elf stepped forward.
‘Lord and Oldfather,’ he said (but keeping to the Westron as the other old man had requested), ‘your ancient greeting is apt, for west my friend and I are now bound on a hopeful errand for the northlands. If your words are more than symbolic, may I hope that you also travel this way?’
‘I am no person’s lord, master elf,’ said the blue clad fellow, drawing himself up a bit at the inference. ‘But I thank your own cordiality in addressing me as such. We three folk are, despite what you may have heard of us, travelers only. We have come to meet and speak with and know the folk of Arda.’
‘And maybe help them to their own better purposes,’ the other grey fellow added.
‘Often we are more quiet in that regard,’ the other continued with a reproachful glance to his fellow, ‘and while we are caring, seldom would we wish to be lordly.
‘I, for it seems names shall be needed, am in this land called Alatar.7 I greet you, lord, and welcome your news from the Great Wood and the Halls of Thranduil.’
This was grand talk to be sure, no matter the language, and Ben had some time there puzzling it all out. ‘It seems that these old gents, quite deserving of lordliness on their own, are traveling as beggars and that this young Elf-lord -for surely he talks with lordliness on him well beyond a discernible number of years- he respects them very highly,’ Ben thought. ‘Elves calling someone else ‘lord’ is not a thing I have heard before. Most curious!’
It is true that this was a curious thing indeed, not so much because of Elvish pride (and Tawarengil’s own pride was indeed quite great at this time) but for reasons that Benbow Floxleaf, or any other inhabitant of the Bree-land for that matter, would not be expected to know. For these ‘travelers’ were quite unlike anyone else in Middle-earth and their presence, at this point in its history, was only understood by a very small number of the Wise. They had not, at least not yet, had much to do with the affairs of lands and kingdoms and few mortal folk had marked them as anything other than pilgrims or sorcerers of some kind. Not yet at least.
Tales of these odd old men (or others quite like them, for the tales went back some many hundred years) often came to the crossroads of the Bree-land from many sources. But as no respectable Breelander was himself such a source of these tales then, of course, no self-respecting Breelander would choose to believe them. But even the most doubtful of the Bree-folk came to accept that there was something quite different about the old ‘travelers’ who occasionally stopped in their town and so, accordingly, they kept them at a fairly wide distance. Tall they were, tall as any of the Sea-kings (not that many of those folk had come to the Bree-land in recent memory either), but these pilgrims were bent from advanced age and long years of wandering. Their clothing was always quite drab, mostly dull-colored cloaks, broad hats and dirty boots, and they were generally (or at least until the earlier part of this very evening) not given to idle conversation. But often they carried with them, as old men often do, a great walking stick or staff, and by this item the Breelanders had come to refer to them as ‘Wassir’,8 though no one ever made attempts to learn anything more about them.
Unlike the Bree-folk, Tawarengil, young immortal that he was, knew more of these travelers than anyone else at the Four Greenfields on this particular evening. But Tawarengil’s youth did not make him incautious and so he continued their conversation without offering further hints on the subject.
‘You are gracious, visitor,’ the Elf-lord said, bowing a bit and raising his empty hands at his sides. ‘I am called Tawarengil, and as you have correctly said, I come from Thranduil’s Hall, and of Oropher’s kin. I, like many of my Silvan folk, move West to join our people against the Witch-king.’
‘This is true,’ the wild man continued excitedly, ‘Together we are moving through lands unknown to meet the Elf army and then, together with what Men and others will join us, Tawar and I will push the Witch-king and his folk back to their cold mountains! We shall crush them completely and then they will never come down the roads or lanes to these pleasant green fields or to trouble these fine little folk again!’
‘My dear friend here,’ Tawarengil continued with a laugh to Ben and the others, ‘has great enthusiasm upon seeing his first great city, Master Perrianath! His folk live a rather solitary life between the western eaves of the Greatwood and the High Pass and very few tales of your splendor come to them there.’
‘Well, that is something to be heard!’ Ben replied, feeling a bit called upon. ‘I’ve never traveled over the Misty Mountains myself, though I’ve been many times in their morning shadow.’ At this he came forward from his place by the fire and offered his small hand to the towering Wildman.
‘Benbow Floxleaf is my name, sirs,’ he said somewhat shyly. ‘My own family has hunted in the lands between the Mountains and the Brown River long as we recall, and, while I’ve no great taste for cities myself, I should be glad to tell you any stories of this land that you might like to hear.’
The big man took his offered hand and then bent to one knee so that he might take a good look at Ben’s upturned face. There was a deep curiosity in the Wildman’s eye and Ben could almost see there a moment of recognition, a kind of kindling, as they turned from wonder to deep trust.
‘If little folk of this land are so generous to strangers it must be a great country indeed!’ Beothalion said. ‘Well met, little friend Benbow!’
‘If you know much of the lands toward the Baranduin, master Hobbit,’ the old man in grey said, ‘then it is indeed good that you have joined us. But I suspect this was, in some part, the plan of our host.’
‘Yes, it would seem,’ said Alatar, slowly, ‘speaking up as you did has played its part, Olórin, but the part of this innkeeper I cannot yet perceive. I cannot believe that Lord Elrond would employ such an agent.’
‘Elrond?’ Tawarengil said, ‘this is the second time within this hour that I have heard such unexpected reference to Imladris in such a queer place. Does the host of Elrond ride out? For that would be great news indeed!’
The three old men looked at one another a moment, silently considering this new information.
‘This we do not know, my lord,’ said the grey fellow, ‘but that is our hope also. Tell me,’ and at this he looked long into the Elf’s face, ‘in what other context did the innkeeper or his servants mention Imladris?’
‘Oh, it was not the innkeeper,’ Tawarengil said, ‘but this very Floxleaf here who wished to talk of it.’
*****
There was trouble here, and the smell of blood, yet still Rosie kept her calm. She had no business with any Man but the stablemaster and no Man had any business with her. She lowered her head and clung a bit closer to the protecting wall of the stall, her eyes now turned to its door.
The Man was very quiet and, by her experience, Men were seldom ever quiet. Even with her sharp ears she could only sense his location through his smell -it was strong, for Men never realized just how strong they smell, and his scent was particularly gamey and unwashed- and she could tell he was moving slowly into the large stable and slowly inspecting his surroundings. He moved to the building’s rear, away from Rosie and the large doors left open when the Dwarf departed. There he remained for some moments and no sound, not even a breath, came to Rosie’s attentive ears. Yet still she did not panic, for she was, despite her current illness, of very proud stock and would not disgrace her parentage with panic. So Rosie kept her calm.
Then, somewhat suddenly, the Man made a noise; the rumbling of some gate-door near the rear and a loose footfall as if he no longer cared to be quiet. Rosie thought, for a moment, this was a good sign and that perhaps he would now leave.
The next few minutes seemed to bear that out. She heard the opening of three gate-doors and the saddling of three horses -noisome and uncouth beasts, half-panicked (or darkly excited) by the still lingering smell of blood- and she heard the sounds of the Man leading them out toward the main stable doors that the Dwarf had left open. They passed in line that very stall in which Rosie herself stayed hidden and she drew herself quietly closer against the supporting wall as they did; but still she would not allow herself to panic. Not unless that Man opened her own gate- door and came to find her. Then, if that should happen, she would bolt quickly through the open door and make such sounds of alarm and such a flash of speed that her sires would be proud. But she would not panic.
But the Man and his horses passed her door without a pause, and she remained safe.
Then the Man stopped the horses at the doorway, just as the Dwarf had done with his ponies, and, pausing for a moment, she heard him say one small word, a Black Word, and though she did not know its meaning just the speaking of that language sent deep shivers through her body.
‘Gnash,’ the Man said.
And still she did not panic.
He came back towards her stall, and now the small light of the one lantern in the stables came with him. She remained still and ready should the gate-door open, but he did not come so far this time. He stopped at the stall of the great grey mare close to the front. The horse, wiser and of better breeding than any other Rosie had seen in this building with no sight of the stars, let out a loud braying as he approached.
‘None of that from you,’ the Man said, ‘for pretty as you are you won’t be under me and I won’t want you behind me. So, there it is. Sad it might be, but you’ve got to go, love.’
The horse was Wise. Rosie had not seen her but once or twice before here in Bree-land and knew she understood the language of Men. Even from her own stall many yards away Rosie could feel the mare’s body trembling at the danger this Man surely brought to all of them in this building.
‘Your a strong, proud girl, to be certain, but this is a gate you’ll not leave,’ the Man said, and then there were some noises of metals and latches, and Rosey knew that the mare’s gate had been secured beyond the simple latch that all the stall-doors held. Any Wise creature might normally escape if they so desired, but the Man had secured against that..
‘A waste of good horseflesh, but I shan’t be followed, and if your master tries he’ll now be doing it on foot.’ And at this there was a loud crash and the sounds of liquid sloshing around near the stable door. Then the mare began to cry out as the Man made his way hastily toward the three horses at the door.
And then the light in the room changed, even to Rosey’s failing eyes, and the smell of burning and panic came, and the mare let out a scream of terror that was echoed by all the other living animals in the stable. The Man swung quickly into the saddle of one horse and took the others in tow with him.
But Rosie did her sires proud and still, even still, she did not panic. She let out a loud and terrifying call for Benbow Floxleaf to hear and, raising up to her highest and strongest, hit her own gate-door (which had never been locked) with all of her strength. She left her (formerly) safe enclosure and went to the mare’s stall; towards the new burning fire.
The mare was roped in tight. Someone, maybe the Man, had taken her bridle and tied it to a turnbuckle. The Wise horse, frightened as she was, was chewing desperately at it in hope of escape. Behind her, in the straw corner of the stable and high up along the walls, the shattered lantern had started a small blaze that was catching all too quickly on the wood interior of this building with no sight of the stars.
Other beasts in the stable, feeling the fear and smelling the fire, started screaming. Their gate-doors were not locked, but they had no idea of how to escape them. Blood and fire and terror had seized all those who remained in the stable.
But still Rosie did not panic. She could not open all the gate-doors. She could not free the mare who stood so horribly close to the growing fire.
So she ran. Not in terror, but straight out of the open stable doors and toward help from Benbow Floxleaf or anyone else who might hear her call.
She remained calm and she did her sires proud. And she cried louder than she ever had, and she ran prancing through the streets of Bree-land, so that people might come.
*****
Flomi rode on to the stoneyard making a mental accounting of all he must gather and the time that he would allow himself there to do so. ‘Just a smattering of heirlooms. It will take little time out of my way. I shall not be leaving anything of value behind, for I value my life in that yard very little, and will want no memory of it after,’ he thought to himself, ‘but some things that I have acquired here cannot be neglected.’
After their decision to move quickly, Collum had ridden out the very next morning to scout the proposed meeting place. He returned to the Four Greenfields late that same evening with good news and firmer plans.
They had met late in the outer hall after all the other townsfolk had departed. ‘As I had hoped,’ Collum began, ‘the way is presently clear and the old entrance that I know of remains undiscovered. I placed some small provisions as I had there for you, but I will ride out again in a few hours with more ample supplies; for you may have to wait a week or more for me to join you.’
‘Weeks or months are no hardship for me if the place is anything as you have described,’ Flomi replied, ‘and my work can continue there uninterrupted.’
‘Yes, Collum said, ‘and I fear it now need go faster. But tomorrow you must have it packed and ready for transport. We will meet a mile or so west of the stoneyard at noon and take things to the Foundations together.’
Flomi, his curiosity and his sense of adventure now fully engaged, had done just that and rode out on Corlar to meet Collum at the appointed time four days ago. The man rode up to their meeting place along the Great Road on his grey mare at some haste and, at first, Flomi feared some trouble had already found them.
‘No, the way is yet free,’ Collum said, ‘but we must do this with some speed. I rode into Bree-land late last night and left again before light this morning. If I’m to avoid much suspicion it would do well for us to return to the Four Greenfields before nightfall.
‘I have left one of my beasts9 at the Foundations this morning. He is a good animal in a climb and does not seem to mind the confined spaces. I do not know how that might be with your own ponies, and we will have need of steady pack animals where we will be going. There is some good store of food there now and no lack of cool, fresh water. But you shall see! Let us go.’
He led them away from the Road on the northside and into a rolling region of low hills that were sparsely wooded. The day was bright and mild and Flomi, who was no experienced rider, found it a pleasant enough and surprisingly straight course, though the pace was a bit faster than he and Corlar the pony might have preferred. The land here was quiet and untended, but many of the trees (and Flomi was no experienced judge of trees either) seemed young and fresh, but resilient and hardy, even to the point of seeming aggressive.
‘How is it,’ the Dwarf asked as they rode, ‘that this land is so empty? The Bree-land grows and grows in the decades that I have been there and yet no one from that land will move north and west to what seems a perfect home for farmers and herdsmen.’
‘It is a rich land and, yes, sadly empty,’ the man replied, ‘and few travel into it now. Perhaps the sadness frightens them. Some enterprising Hobbits went further west of course, to set up their own community over the Baranduin, and there they found great resources that had been some of the oldest farmlands before the world was broken.10 It may be that we will see that land together before we finish our task, Flomi, and it is more lovely than any other land in which I have yet traveled.
‘We ride now through old town lands and fiefdoms that, while much younger than “the Shireland”, have more recently and more completely gone empty. Once this was the Southern Fields of Arnor, the Emyn Ubra,11 a province far in the outside of the great city of Annúminas that my people founded here in the North. These lands were once filled with estates of the great lords of Arnor who still had dealings with the Elves of the lands between the Misty Mountains and Greenwood the Great and traffic from your own People coming over the Road when Elendil first established the North Kingdom. In that time, before the Great War with Sauron, the Dúnedain of the North lived here in great numbers and one would only have to crest the nearest hill to greet their neighbour. Much of the old forest here was cleared in that time and some good roadways, the shadow of one which we now follow, still lay beneath.
‘But we of the North are fewer since the Great War and those lordly families have long since perished leaving this land desolate,’ Collum said sadly. ‘Perhaps these trees will regain it and the memory of Men will be lost in these hills. Who can say?’
‘The kingdoms of Men are fleeting things indeed,’ Flomi said, ‘unlike the halls of my own people that are carved in the very bones of the Earth. Many great cities and works of Men of which I have read are lost to time beneath sun, seas and wood while our own halls delve deeper to the unchanging roots of Middle-earth. It seems to me that your Princess was foresighted even among her people to seek the aid of Dwarves in a lasting hiding place for her great treasures.’
‘We are away from the Bree-land, Flomi,’ the man said sharply, ‘but we will talk no more of the task, or of her, in these open lands than we did in that town.’ His face grew dark at this and Flomi, who believed he had come to know the man better than any Breelander had, felt that this darkness was not solely out of anger. Sadness, a sadness of loss, had come on Collum as he talked of this land just the moment before and it seemed exacerbated by the mention of his Princess. Flomi did not, nor had his father before him, know anything of this Lady’s background even though their pact had gone back for many a century. He knew only that Collum served the Princess and that her will was aligned to, and had even determined, that of his own grandsires’ for many generations. But curiosity (a rare trait among Flomi's people) often got hold of him and he occasionally looked for opportunities to learn more of his mysterious benefactor.
‘As you will,’ he said, and they rode on for a while through those lonely hills in silence.
The stoneyard outside the Bree-land was a quiet place, decently apart from any outlying farms, and set into one of the longer limestone hills west of the town and north of the Road. There, for thirty years, Flomi had made a meager living doing a journeyman’s task of supplying the Breelanders with hard cut stone for foundations in their seemingly endless and (so he believed) largely purposeless building. Nothing more intricate than a keystone or a cornerstone was ever asked of him by his customers and the hill he inhabited gave up her bones for these small demands easily enough. For there was good stone here, nothing like the ore-enriched mountains of his birth of course, but good, simple stone for these simple people and it yielded itself readily, and most willingly, to Flomi’s deft hand.
Most of his service to the Bree-land builders could be fulfilled in a short time of the morning, and this left him free to puzzle out the mysteries of his real task after the noon hour. For want of privacy he only met with customers in town at nightfall or in the earliest morning for deliveries. He had purchased his first cart and team of ponies in the early days of his business, hoping that by bringing stone to town in a drawn wagon he could avoid the unwanted visitor often found in an unneeded customer. It had also created more reason for him to stay each night at the inn, which he found much more safe and favorable to his sense of comfort. This practice had continued and so the stoneyard, while known to all, had not seen a visitor (other than Collum) in some years, or so Flomi had believed.
It was but two hours gentle ride from the Hedge-gate of the Bree-land to the yard and Flomi and the ponies reached it without consequence while the moon was low. From his years in the Bree-land Flomi came to measure the day as they did, by their own unfunctional clock and thought it to be about ‘ten of the clock’ as he rode up the lane to his, and his father’s, old property. There was a deep cut into the hillside there on its southern face and there Flomi’s father had set up both yard and quarry. There was a low stable and a grounds-house built to serve the ponies and as a mason’s offices respectively. Some dozen or so years before those offices had been ransacked and looted and the thieves had searched through the mines believing there might be some great hoard found there. They found nothing of course, for Flomi was not often present at the stoneyard at the time and was no fool to leave the very real and important work of himself and his sires laying about. What thief could know or appreciate such subtle work if he had? But after this incident, and at Collum’s suggestion, he had abandoned the perception of having living quarters in the stoneyard and moved his regular residence to the Four Greenfields. This made it easier for Flomi and his work to come to the Bree-land each evening where he might remain under the man’s watchful eye. Nothing like that had happened again, but the buildings had been disturbed again near the end of Nénimë, just one month ago. There were signs of a large animal, a bear or even a great-wolf, rumbling through both the stable and offices, but there was no disturbance of any of his papers or theft of his goods, and so Flomi simply cleaned things up and did not pay it much concern. Collum, careful and suspicious as was his way, felt less certain.
Now, miles away on the night of the fire in the Bree-land stables, all of his discoveries of these past thirty years, based on the work of Flomi’s father and even his sires before that, treasures to his own people and to Collum’s Princess, had been removed to the Foundations in their desperate attempt to keep the great enterprise one step ahead of discovery.
‘I should not have returned here,’ Flomi thought as he dismounted and let the ponies walk freely outside the stable. Quietly but briskly he walked toward the low building which he used as an office. ‘Collum would certainly disapprove of my being here and rather that I went with all haste towards our meeting spot while the moon is still low. But there are some things I must not leave behind.’
As he entered the low building he did not see, hidden in the trees on a slope of the land in the direction from which he had come, a rider, dressed all in black, and slowly leading a dark horse behind him.
*****
‘That’s true enough, sirs,’ Benbow said as he looked into the questioning eyes of the three old gentlemen and the child-seeming Elf. ‘For I was lucky enough to have met the lord Elrond as a boy and, with my father, had even visited Rivendell on a time or two.’
‘This is surprising indeed,’ said Tawarengil with a hint of distrust, ‘for even my own Silvan folk, brethren though we are, have not been so carelessly welcomed into that valley for many long years.’
‘And, remember, you don’t know where it is, Tawar, or maybe we might have tried,’ Beothalion interrupted, looking earnestly at Benbow, ‘ Maybe this Little Benbow friend of ours knows the way and may tell us.’
‘Knowing the whereabouts of such a place,’ Alatar said, ‘and being welcomed there are two very different matters.’ At this, he approached Benbow with the same open-handed gesture he had given to the Wildman. ‘Lord Elrond has shown you great honor and it would be unwise for us not to trust him in this. It would seem that fortune more than this innkeeper has drawn us together, Master Floxleaf, and I greet you on our Roads to the West.’
Ben felt that flushed feeling again and tried to meet the tall Man with the same gesture (accompanied by an awkward bow, something his people were more familiar with in this kind of situation).
‘I agree,’ said the grey-clad man, ‘and greet you also, master Hobbit, lord Tawarengil and master Beothalion...’
‘Ho!’ said Beothalion with a laugh. ‘I am no master either, Grey-stalk, but I thank you for the courtesy.’
‘Well, names, as Alatar has reasoned, seem appropriate to our meeting,’ the old man continued, ‘so know that I am Olórin to some here and to others yet in the wider world. To some Men of the South, and also to some of the Elves, I am called Mithrandir. To others there who regard my counsel less I am called Incánus. But I am a “grey-stalker” here in the Northlands as you suggest,’ he said looking to Beothalion, ‘and that title too suits me well.
‘But I should still like to know more of that other missing person in our chance-meeting, this Innkeep-‘
‘Hold!’ Tawarengil interrupted, thrusting up his hand and moving towards the window. ‘There is a cry of terror outside. Have you horses?’
‘From the stables?’ Ben started, grabbing his bow. ‘ But I’ve left Rosie to wait for me there!’ he cried as he ran through the door.
Suddenly there was a flurry of action and the others followed quickly. The outer hall was at the edge of the building and there was another door there which led to the alleyway alongside the stables. They sped quickly this way and, coming into the narrow alley there between the inn and stables, smelled the smoke and caught the light of the blaze. About forty feet to the left and up this alleyway, there was another door leading into the stables (the same one that Flomi had used earlier), but the main entrance was closer and to the right. Now that he was outside Ben could clearly hear Rosie’s cries in that direction and, running towards them, he could feel the heat of the burning stables on his left side. Beothalion and Tawarengil were right at his heels, but only the Elf was small and quick enough to overtake him in the narrow alleyway.
‘Fire!’ Tawarengil heard someone call as he rounded the corner. There he saw a woman drawing back away from the new blaze and he also saw a terror-stricken fat white pony prancing back and forth near the stable’s entrance as the fire grew.
‘Go!’ Tawarengil called out in Westron as the woman saw him. ‘Alert the people of the inn! Fire! Awake!’
Ben rounded the turn just behind him and saw that Rosie was safe. Relieved, his eyes immediately turned to the job at hand. The posts and lintel of the stable’s entrance had already taken flame and he knew that the town’s main well, and the necessary number of buckets, were hundreds of yards away and too few to keep more of the building from catching. Then, to his amazement, he saw the young Elf-lord run straight into the stable through the blazing doorway. He heard beasts, pigs and ponies and horses calling in terror.
Beothalion saw this too. He had paused for a moment to comfort the panicked pony but, without another second lost he ran inside as well.
‘Glory!’ Ben thought, ‘they’re saving the other poor beasts. Well, don’t just stand here, you fool, help them!’ And he himself, showing the uncanny bravery that hobbits were too seldom noted for in his time, ran headlong into a burning building with people he had only just met.
*****
The inside of his offices were dark and, though Flomi’s eyes were quite accustomed to such darkness, he decided to light a lamp for his final look about the place. It had the characteristic orderliness of a dwarvish dwelling; to the rear, built into the hillside, there was a sitting area with a great drawing table, a small chair and smaller nook for the rare occasion when Flomi would sleep here at the stoneyard. Normally this area would be divided from the main room by a partition of some kind, but there wasn’t a need for such where almost no person ever came to disturb him. A small space to the left of this was allotted to cookery and a pantry, but no food was ever left here for in the past years as Flomi now spent his nights in the Bree-land and dined exclusively at the Four Greenfields. Closer to the door on that left side there was a small closet for traveling clothes and, beside it, a short, strong bow for hunting (a thing that Flomi had not done since he was beardless). The bow had been his father’s however, and no matter what came next, he must not leave it behind.
Collum and Flomi had not ridden long in their uncomfortable silence before the hills began to recede toward a long line of bushes that could be seen ahead; straight this was like the Greenway near the Bree-land, but heading northwest and away to the distant mountains of Emyn Uial and the Hills of Evendim. He knew these places only through his research, for Flomi and his sires had grown in the Blue Mountains to the southwest of Arnor and none of the Longbeards there traveled north to Ered Luin, their ancient homes beyond the Gulf of Lhûn from before the breaking of the world. Ice-drakes lived there now, it was said, and worse things that had fled the ending of the ancient world and lingered still in the cold, deep places of the earth. But Men, in their great days of power, had returned to the shores of Evendim and built their doomed kingdom nearby.
‘Is that a new road ahead,’ Flomi asked, breaking their awkward silence. ‘I have seen no map that suggests it.’
‘Nor shall you,’ Collum said, ‘unless, perhaps, we are lucky enough to complete our task and discover old histories. That is no road ahead, Flomi, but the remains of a very old border, the base of the Rammas Armaro,12 Arnor’s neighboring wall, and the ancient edge of the great domain of Annúminas and old border of the North Kingdom of Men.
‘It stretches, or did in its day, from the old Downlands to the South, across the Great Road, and then northwest to the feet of the Ered Luin. There it was built high indeed for, as your People well know, that is a dangerous land and it may be still that those ancient walls hold terrors of the old world at bay. I know no tales from that far North. But here, south of the Baranduin’s origins, the Kings of Arnor had great friends in the West so that the wall was low in these lands, a marker only, or perhaps a sign that here one might find safety. And that is just what we have come for!’ At this he rode a bit faster prompting Flomi to keep up.
What refuge might be found in a low barrier wall Flomi could not guess at. Collum had described their hiding place as a great cave or tunneling that the dwarf would feel comforted in, but the hills here had become much lower and the earth that he could see surrounding the wall looked soft and sometimes marshy; inhospitable to such dwellings. But he knew Collum to be a person of deep secrets and his own curiosity led him on to see just what the man might come up with next. ‘Probably no true hall after all,’ Flomi thought as he rode to catch up, ‘and like to be some niche or cellarway that Men had cut into this old fence as a guardhouse or even a tool shed. But he has never seen a true Dwarven home of course, so I should forgive him his naivety. Still, I do not relish the idea of a week, or even a day, spent in some crude stone bolt hole that Men have roughly fashioned.’
They came to the remains of the wall and turned with it towards the south. Through the hedge and trees that had grown up there Flomi saw great stones, each tall as a man, covered in ivy or brambles and other creepers as the land tried to scale the barrier and reclaim its mastery. Roughened though these stones were by weather, they had once been evenly cut and were of enormous weight, set two or sometimes three high in a very regular manner, straight and level still though the land around had done all it might to resist their orderliness. Their color was reddish, not like the native limestone of his own quarry or the hills he had seen between here and the Bree-land. Flomi had to admit that there was keen work here, even in its ruin, and in his head he began to reassess all of his beliefs about the lost works of the Númenóreans; for, as he had thought of Collum just a moment before, he had never visited them and should be forgiven for his naivety.
‘There is strong work here, indeed,’ he marveled to his friend. ‘And this stone is not native. They have been quarried far from here, I think, and traveled long to their new home.’
‘They are from the beginnings of the Rammas in the feet of Ered Luin, carved from those cliffs which border our land. Here the Rammas is low and wide, like a raised roadway towards Arnor’s ancestral burial places in the south. We are now about two leagues north of where it once crossed the Great Road and, it was said, a town much like the Bree-land had formed there in Elendil’s days before the North-South Road was built. If so, then that place is lost now and the forest has taken it.’
At this, Collum halted his great mare and dismounted, encouraging Flomi to do the same. It was at this time, and maybe for the first time, that Flomi’s sense of curiosity turned to an awareness of their peril; for Collum had brought his longsword, which he routinely kept hidden, and took it from the horse and fastened it on his belt. ‘We are close,’ he said, ‘and should proceed now on foot to leave less trail. Caitelyn knows this area well and can do with the rest,’ he said, brushing the horse’s nuzzle and giving her a carrot or some other treat he had held in his pocket. ‘She will watch after your own pony and there is water for them nearby. Come, I will help you carry your packages the remainder of our way.’
There were in fact not many bags for them to carry as Flomi had only brought the work that he was engaged with, as Collum had asked, and nothing yet of his own belongings. ‘Time enough,’ he had thought, ‘particularly if this bolt hole is as spare as I worry it may be. Though if he carries his sword it seems I shall be prudent in bringing my maddock along on the next time.’
They moved south through the land near the wall, avoiding small streams and occasional muddy passages where the land grew soft. It was still not long past noon and very few living creatures moved through the land or marked their passing.
‘It is quiet,’ Flomi said. ‘Quieter, I believe, than passage on the Road itself.’
‘We are inside the Rammas Armaro here, still within the old border,’ Collum said, returning to his history lesson, ‘and along the other side the trees have grown thicker for more than an age. Small beasts and birds move freely through the lands going east and north, but the forest is retaking the western face of the wall where larger animals might be found. To the south,’ he motioned far ahead in the very direction they were moving, ‘five leagues south of the Old Road to the edge of the old Kingdom, is the burial place of the Men of Arnor and it is both sacred and desolate. Little wildlife ventures there, and much of it is unwholesome.
‘If there had once been a town near where we now stand, and I believe it so, no name was it ever given. The building of the North-South Road, and the laying of the Tharangond, subsumed its usefulness. The Bree-land then became a place of commerce better located than this and my people, greatly diminished in number after the Great War, left these western parts and drew closer to Annúminas, Fornost Erain, and Arnor’s center. We grew in number again for a while, slowly, but there were never again enough people of the North to hold the lands claimed by Elendil when he came out of the Sea and founded the North Kingdom.’
He halted, pointing southwest towards the wall. A great stance of very old trees stood there, taller than all the others, with straight branches forming a sort of glade apart from the younger foliage closer to the barrier. They were birch, Flomi thought, not uncommon to this land, but seemed to have a nurtured shapeliness which quite separated them from the landscape; regular and even like the wall itself, as if they had been reared and tended once and were now resisting the chaos of growth surrounding them.
‘Mark this spot, Flomi,’ he said, ‘for you may well come here next on your own. Look then for those seven trees, older than the rest. They were planted, I should guess, when the Rammas was built. It is a sign to my people that a spot here is special, lasting, protected and should not be overlooked.’
‘Aye,’ the dwarf said, ‘there are many such indications, many such sevens, to be found in the histories which I have read. I am bristling with anticipation! Show me where these seven shall take us!’
Placing the lamp on the peg near the low ceiling, Flomi began to work quickly. Other than the bow, most of the small heirlooms of his father were already on his person; the writing implements and ink vessels his father had fashioned to their task, the pouch and clay bowl he had made here in the Bree-land for the smoking of pipe-weed (a habit Flomi himself had not yet fully adopted but still admired), and the very unique ocular device that he expected came not from his father but even further back from his sires. Also, in another pocket and still unused, he kept the pen which he had been given by the mysterious Rider some weeks before.
He now began to repack them gently among a warmer change of clothes in preparation of both hard goings and cooler weather that he expected in the North. He then immediately went to the small closet and gathered the last two items; a light green traveling cloak and, most surprising, a bright yellow waistcoat. The former Flomi knew well, for his earliest memories of his father saw him clothed in this hood and cloak and going on one of his numerous long walks away from their home. Flomi had never worn it, saving it for now, for the time he himself would leave the Bree-land behind and, in this small way, take his father with him.
The waistcoat was a bigger conundrum; who had ever heard of a dwarf in a waistcoat? Clearly this was a gift from someone, likely some hobbit, that his father had met here in the Bree-land and politeness (something Flomi credited his father with solely through rumour) must have obligated him to keep. Yet when Flomi arrived to take over the task from his father no other article of clothing (beside the aforementioned cloak) was left behind. Why had he saved such a garish and impractical item? Should Flomi do the same now?
There simply wasn’t time to decide. With a grumble and some haste he wadded the yellow material up and thrust it into his bag. Now, the heirlooms attended to, he focused his attention on the more practical matters of his departure.
There was no food here of course, but there was some cookware that might serve him well. He took it with him. Beside the change of clothing he took his own favorite bit of luxury, a second pair of boots. Extra quills and tools for grinding pigments from his work table. Blankets, of course. There would always be a need for blankets. And he had a small kit of medicinal herbs and bandages in the stable that he must remember. All in all, a very light pack for a dwarf of his hardiness.
His mental inventory now completely fulfilled and the time he had allotted for this trip nearly spent, Flomi took a last minute to look around the small garret where he had spent nearly thirty years of his life in the service of his family. He breathed slowly and loudly then for a moment; not as a sigh or any such outward expression of apprehension, for such was unbecoming to a Dwarf in even the most private of situations. He simply took a moment to look to where he had been rather than where he was going and while that might seem peculiarly sentimental it was certainly not uncommon to any of his People.
‘Thirty years amongst these dim folk...’ he said aloud to no one but himself.
He then put his father’s cloak around him, took up his father’s bow and small quiver, and slung it on his back and then, his maddock over his shoulder, he was ready, and happy, to finally depart.
But at the last, turning out the lamp, he halted for a moment. Near his work table there was a cut of limestone, small as an acorn, that some time before -years ago, surely- he had pulled from the bones of the hill and found pleasing for its color and its shape and porous texture. He stopped his departure and, moving quickly as if to make the act seem less important, took up the limestone and put it in his pocket.
Then he turned out the lamp and exited, turned his back on the stoneyard, and on the Bree-land, forever. Or so he hoped.
End of Chapter Two
Notes on Chapter Two
1) Fornost Erain is a Sindarin name, but used by the men of Arnor. It means "Northern Fortress (of the) Kings"; from forn "north" and ost "fortress", and erain is the plural of aran. It was translated as "Norbury of the Kings" (from supposedly Old English norð-burg, which represents its Westron name. That’s a lengthy description, but it shows how the interplay of where names come from is at the core of Tolkien studies.
2) Arthedain lay primarily between the Lhûn and the Brandywine in northwestern Eriador. However, it also claimed the land north of the Great East Road from the Brandywine Bridge to the Weather Hills. When the two other North Kingdoms of Rhudaur and Cardolan fell, Arthedain was the last realm of the Dúnedain of the North and it's great capital, Fornost Erain, fell late in the year of 1974 of the Third Age, a few months before these events.
3) Mithlond translates as "Grey Havens" in Sindarin (from mith "grey" and lond "harbour") Founded by the Elves of Lindon in S.A. 1, the Grey Havens were afterwards used by any of the Elves (whether Noldor, Sindar, or Silvan Elf) to leave Middle-earth for Valinor. But they are also a great link between the scattered people of Númenor and to their heritage and friendship with the Eldar.
4) Ethir is a Sindarin expression closely described as “spy”, though the Elves do not really embrace this term and it has more to do with military deployment. In the strictest sense it means “outwatcher”. Still, it says something of the depth of Flomi’s knowledge that he would know such a word.
5) Flomi is referring to Sarn Ford here, the crossing of the Branaduin that was at this time the southern border of the Shire. The name he uses is Sindarin for “stony-ford”, but there was some bastardization of the name there by the Hobbits which, of course, Flomi would not use. There is, of course, another Sarn Athrad in The Silmarillion which was the site of a great battle between the Elves and the Dwarves in the Elder Days. But the world has changed and that land is lost, so this would be the stony ford that dwarves of his day would know on their way south to Khazad-dûm.
6) This gesture is an invention of my own. This story will carry many threads from The Silmarillion into the Third Age and I wanted something in Beothalion’s lost history to connect with the Istari. It is used here as a derivation of the “open hand” that is used to meet new people and, perhaps, formalized in the first meetings of Elves and Men.
7) The appearance of Alatar (and Pallando) in this story does not necessarily break with Tolkien’s later reshaping of the histories. He had decided that the Blue Wizard came to Middle-earth later than Gandalf and Saruman, about 1600 of the Third Age, and went into the East to struggle with Sauron there. This is still possible within my tale (though I like the early version better) and simply means that they have not yet decided on that road.
8) The internet is a fickle place for research. In looking for an earlier form of the word wizard I came upon wassar as one who holds the staff of power. The website went on to draw some fairly fun connections between wassar and the Jedi from Star Wars and other internet culture, making fairly entertaining links between the staff of Osiris, lightsabers and wizard wands. But mostly I wanted to describe these characters, the Wizards, in a time when they would not have had enough contact with the world that “wizard” was as yet a popular expression. Bree-folk are, as I’ve mentioned, quite well regarded by Tolkien (and themselves) as starting everything, or at least everything good, so I like the idea of the word origin coming in here. I settled on the wassird spelling because it echoes wasir, the Turkish word which gives us vizier.
9) I can’t remember any instance of the word mule for pack animals in LoTR, though it is quite possible I’m wrong about this. It seems to me that ponies played out this role of smaller beasts of burden in Tolkien’s imaging of the world and so I’ve kept that up throughout this work. But the darker powers have different animals at their use, and some versions of mules may appear here later.
10) The Shire is to the east of Beleriand most of which fell into the sea when the world was changed. As Treebeard alludes to in The Two Towers, it sounds like a lovely place for the Ent-wives, so I have extrapolated here the idea that this was some of the first farmland in Middle-earth to survive since the world changed.
11) Close as I can come at this writing o fQuenya for “nearer hills”.
12) This is a continuation of the low wall that Frodo and his companions cross after leaving the Barrow-downs. Bombadil refers to it as the border of a great nation, but it seems clear to me that the divided kingdoms of Cardolan and Arthedain would never have been able to undertake such a great building, particularly in the West of their lands, while attacks came from the North and the East. The Númenóreans in the early years of Elendil would have the resources, but why build a wall in the direction of your allies? The “Wall of Friends” seems a good way of establishing the territorial boundaries of Annúminas from those lands in the west.