The Fall of Arnor; Book One "Out of the Bree-land" by Diane Finnis-Robb  

| | |

Chapter Ten; "Two Ways Forward"

-Here at the Close of Book One Decisions are Made and Cup of Parting is Had by All. 


   And nothing much else happened, all the rest of that night.1

   There was work to be done still, for many panicked rats still scurried about in the antechamber and up the stair to the outside door. They were cornered, blinded and afraid, and Ben felt a pang of pity for them as he and Tawarengil and the Bard dispatched them mercifully and made a great sweep of their bodies down the stairway. Most, or so it seemed, had fled through the gap in the Mysterious Door and Ohtar had lit a small but steady fire there to keep them from returning. Now the bodies of their comrades were being swept in great heaps to this spot so they might further fill the span under the door. No noise could be heard beyond that Mysterious Door and, open much wider as it was, Ben thought the smell coming from it was much more distressing.

   Alatar and Beothalion had returned to the Grazing Field, but neither said anything to their companions and walked wearily down the rampway, as if any energy for conversation had gone out of them and into the battle. Alatar had the same stern and grave set to his brow, but Beothalion looked quite vacant, as one walking in sleep.

   Pallando had come to guard the old door frame in the battle’s aftermath and during the subsequent slaughter. Few of the rats approached this doorwarden even during all their terror and confusion. The wizard had unbuckled the long sword from his belt and stood relaxed with it, still in its scabbard, to bar their way; on instinct, or perhaps some other low and keen animal sense, no rat would go that way.

   The cleansing of the stairway and antechamber took some few hours as all the bodies were swept to the Mysterious Door and a pyre was lit there. This was done on Ohtar’s insistence, as he would not suffer to have the remains of these creatures any nearer to the Grazing Field. Some arguments were made by the others about the smoke and the air within the chamber, but Ohtar would not hear of it.

   Once the pyre was lit Ben could see all of the smoke from hundreds of burning rat carcasses flowing out beneath the Mysterious Door, almost as if drawn there with an unnatural force. The four comrades, Ben and Ohtar and Tawarengil and Oisín, stood for a long time before the blaze watching the uncommon behavior of flame and smoke and said nothing to one another. Eventually they turned aside and, still walking in silence, rejoined their other friends in the Grazing Field below.

 

*****

   Flomi had not woken during the fray. This concerned Ohtar much at first, but Pallando reassured the soldier that his friend had entered a deep sleep of healing; to remove him from stone and hall now would be a great hurt to his recovery.

   Beothalion also lay in heavy sleep near the watering trough to the left of the Great Door. Even now they could see the dampness in his hair and clothing; for he had plunged as much of himself as he could manage into the waters there to cool his body and scrub the blood of battle from his face and limbs. Now he lay snoring deeply beside the fountain and Ben’s Rosie stood beside him protectively, occasionally nuzzling his great wet beard and whisking her tail. Tawarengil went to him there and sat silently beside his brother. Where the Elf-lord’s thoughts went none could tell and his childlike face had a calm that the members of the party had not seen before.

   Rosie then left the slumbering Wildman and came to Ben’s side, brushing the top of his head with her jaw as she did sometimes when they were far north in the wild country and she could feel his concern of that land’s dangers almost as surely as she could feel her own. This, as it had done in so many past travels, comforted them both greatly.

   Oisín put up his cudgel and sat down with his harp, plucking gently, absently but confidently; and all those in the Grazing Field were greatly comforted by his song.

   After checking on Flomi, Ohtar went directly to Alatar, who stood very still and in silence before the Great Doors. He did not speak to the wizard, for he would not disturb him in his thoughts, and the two stood like this for many long minutes as the others fell silently to rest and the Bard’s harp found its slow and sonorous way into song.

   ‘There is safety beyond this door, Ohtar,’ the wizard said finally. ‘I can open it for you or, more correctly, I believe I can teach you to open it yourself. What lies far beyond, in the haunted South or the forsaken North I cannot tell you. But I can teach you to open and to close this door, and the wards that protect it from what we have seen this night will remain undisturbed. I-’ At this he paused for a moment and looked a bit surprised by the words forming in his head. ‘I am- sorry, for I have no advice to give you in this matter and see little that might counsel you in the road ahead. And this-’ he paused again, but the surprised look that he had turned then to consternation, then to a flash of humour and then, with a slow weakening of that knitted brow, his whole expression lightened and he looked almost ready to laugh as Ohtar had seen Olórin do earlier that morning.

   ‘And this gives me much to consider,’ he said finally, though without laughing. ‘We have had an important meeting, I believe, and I would help you as I am able. But the decision, as always, is meant to be your own. Tell me, soldier, what would you do?’

   Ohtar bowed softly in respect to these statements and lifted his eyes again to the Great Door. Many runes were written there; some he knew but most he could not discover. When he first came here with his father’s men the reading of these writings was meant to be a test of his understanding of the Old Tongue. But many things written here had been forgotten by the Men of the North and were cast in languages long lost before he or his father or his father’s father had come to read them. The Door was a secret, one of the great secrets of his heritage, and faith and awe for the larger mystery which lay behind it held sway over his heart.

   But still it was but a door; a gate they might go through to find safety in their need. And tonight’s attack had shown him that their need was great.

His eyes left the door then and looked to the others, his comrades-through-chance in the room around him. His soldier’s mind knew their mood as well as it knew their resolve and their strengths; but they could not stay here four more nights while Flomi healed. They would not survive it. He wanted to respect the Great Door as all the generations of his fathers had, but they and he had all been soldiers coming here for a day’s rest and some acknowledgment of the past glories of their people. To his understanding, they had never been in the kind of danger that Ohtar had brought these comrades to now. He respected the mysteries that lie behind this door, but as a captain of soldiers, or so his father had taught him, he had to think of the needs of his men.

   ‘I am a soldier, Wisefather, and not a king,’ he said finally. ‘Without a king’s command I must speak to these good companions of ours and let that decide our way ahead.’

 

*****

   ‘And now the time has come for our last debate,'2 Ohtar said just a short time later. All were awake in the Grazing Field now, even Beothalion who sat quietly on the ground beside the fountain and spoke with no one.

   ‘You all have done such great service to me that I cannot hope to reward, but my own way forward is to protect my friend, Flomi son of Trochi, and so I may not leave this hall until he is well enough to travel.

   ‘Many of you have joined me out of our chance-meeting,’ here he gestured towards the Istari and Beotalion and Tawarengil, ‘others from old vows of friendship,’ and here he gestured with a smile toward Ben, who sat rather patiently outside of what he considered a circle of High-talkers, ‘and others have fallen into our adventure through turns both surprising and illuminating,’ and here he singled out Oisín by hand and eye.

   ‘I can ask none of you to go forward with me after what has occurred tonight, and would, for friendships’ sake, encourage you now to leave with first light.’ There was a stirring from many assembled there and Ohtar, who was also Collum and also an Innkeeper, knew well how to speak up over a grumbling room.

   ‘No, no, Ben,’ he said, ‘even you. For your pledge I hold dear and your help I might sorely need. But Flomi cannot be moved, and until he is well, here I must remain. I’ve no promise of what tomorrow brings and expect no vow. Another night here may prove deadly, yet I must stay.’

   ‘I do not know who cares about my judgment in such matters,’ Pallando said slowly, and all eyes looked upon him as he did, ‘but this is wise. If the dwarf is moved from here I believe he will die.’

   ‘And so I am pledged to remain,’ Ohtar said, ‘and all of you, even you brave Benbow, are free of any bond to remain with me. Therefore I entreat you, as a friend who has been glad for your kindness, that with the coming Sun you should quit this place and go forward to your own adventures.’

   ‘Well, I’ll not do that!’ Ben said from outside the circle. ‘I don’t have adventures to go on to as these other lords might, and I’ve said that I’ll follow and that I’ll help. I’ve said it,’ and here Ben’s public speaking, never a thing he was particularly keen on, faltered just a bit. ‘I’ve said I'll do, and so I'll do as I’ve said. Tomorrow night will come as it will, Collum, just as it does here and elsewhere. But you’ll not be facing it alone.’

   There were smiles and calmed faces at this response but very few deep surprises. Many looked at Benbow, this small and rustic hobbit, and considered his bravery as they thought long on their own. More surprisingly, it was Pallando who was the next to speak;

   ‘I have taken this dwarf as my charge, Ohtar,’ he said with grave concern in his voice. ‘I and others of my order all agree that there is something worth our interest in your mission. That may still bear out. But, for now, that is not my principal concern. The dwarf is my charge now, as he is your own, and I will stay with him through his healing.’

   ‘Yes, this is for the best,’ Alatar said. He did not seem alarmed by this news as the others did. ‘It will be strange to be parted from you, my friend, but I agree. This is best.’

   ‘Then you will not remain with them, Wise One?’ Tawarengil asked.

   ‘No, I shall not,’ the wizard said. ‘Olórin has taken the East road to Rivendell. If any might counsel lord Elrond to come forth, he has the greatest chance.

   ‘But the road West must still be seen to. Arthedain’s forces are still gathering from their rout and lord Cirdan’s call must be answered. Olórin was correct. There is a grave threat here in the North. It is not our principal task, of course, but it must still be seen to.’

   The two wizards looked at each other in a long moment. There were none there willing to break the silence of that moment or who knew the deeper seriousness of it.

   ‘Agreed,’ Pallando said.

   ‘Lord Tawarengil,’ Alatar continued, looking away from Pallando, ‘if you and your friend wish to travel with me and answer Círdan’s call, I would be happy to make introductions for the both of you to that great lord.’

   Tawarengil looked at Beothalion for some response. The Wildman was awake now, but he had spoken very few words since the battle and still had a vacant look about him that no one there wished to disturb. Benbow had seen this look before on soldiers and refugees that he’d encountered in some of his more dangerous travels, and it made him sad to see it again here. In the short time he had known him, Bethalion had seemed to Ben one of the most joyful of all the men he’d ever met. Now, since the night’s attack, that lighthearted spirit seemed, well, gone and a strange wariness or surprise had come to replace it.

   ‘Your offer is kind, Great One,’ Tawarengil said in reply, ‘and I have greatly looked forward to seeing the banners of my people assembled as stories say they were in our past. I am still young amongst my folk and have no memories of those older days. I and my brother went forth hoping to make such memories for ourselves.

   ‘But, I wonder now,’ he continued while looking back at Beothalion, ‘is the road East closed to us? If Olórin is still in the Bree-land, if we could find him, might he take us with him? My brother would, I think, be happier being closer to his home and—’

   ‘I would not!’ Beothalion interrupted sharply. He did not raise his voice, but the suddenness of it silenced all others. ‘I do not want to leave these people and their troubles, or this great large world that I am seeing, Tawar. To be sent home! Like a child! I miss my home and I miss very much my friends there, brother, but I will not leave you, and these new friends because of things that I miss. I will go where you go, brother.’

   ‘That is very kind of you, young one,’ Pallando said, his voice low and rumbling, but gentle like the continuously running water of the fountains. ‘And you have brought us all great support already. Much greater than even you expected, I think. I hope that you will come to learn more about your own surprising nature. But Ohtar and master Floxleaf and I will be fine now. Behind this door there are greater protections for us than even you might provide.

   ‘And yes, you might catch up with Olórin, lord Tawarengil,’ he continued, his voice already calming the others, ‘if that is really your wish. Just as we have indicated since our first meeting, the choice is always your own to make. But answers lie in the West for all of the Eldar, my lord, and for your brother here as well. It is the Eldar in Mithlond who still hold many answers to a past most Men have overlooked. And of your People, young one, of all of the Children of Haleth,'3 he said looking compassionately into Beothalion’s battle-shocked eyes, ‘I believe Círdan may know more than even lord Elrond does.’

   ‘Come west with me if you will, the both of you,’ Alatar said, ‘or back east if that should be your choice. But it is a choice you must make quickly, for daylight, and the chance to depart is soon upon us.’

   And this was so. No sunlight yet fell into the Grazing Field from the narrow and carefully hidden slots above, but all could feel that the nighttime was fading; it had an almost physical presence here since the attack of the rats and now, noticeable to almost everyone; the hold of night was releasing.

   ‘Oisín Na-Ghiliruin, Man of Númenór,’ Ohtar said, ‘you may also wish to depart with the dawn. I will not deter you and you are under no oath to myself or these my comrades. You have, I believe, saved my friend Flomi when the rest of us may have come too late and for that I cannot repay you. But from you still, Flomi and I have the greatest need.

   ‘You should know, as these other friends do,’ he continued, ‘that we are involved in a great undertaking for our People. Many great things were lost in the North well before Cardolan or Arthedain fell, and it has been the hope of my family, for many generations, to retrieve them. Flomi, though it may seem strange to hear, is the best chance of that hope and he believes that your song, your tale that was sung as he lay wounded, offers him clues to that great puzzle. I did not, at first, believe this to be other than the fever of his healing. But I have come to trust in Flomi’s judgment and, lately, I myself have heard you say things that might make me believe it.

   ‘You are under no bond to stay, singer,’ he said, ‘but your song is very important to my hopes. I entreat you to join us. I offer you the full protection of my arms, but also the freedom to follow your heart. My need is great, but it does not outstrip my thankfulness for all that you have done. Tell me, will you stay and teach us what we need or will you go on to your own adventures? You will have my respect and my great wishes of success in either choice. But I must prepare now for tomorrow.’

  Oisín had, in fact, stood as he had been addressed. Ben thought it a bit odd, like some of the Bard’s other customs he’d seen in the past day, but it was, in fact, a long-standing tradition of Oisín’s people. They were not, after all, the rough men of the Minhiriathrim, not the men of Dark times who hid their counsels in caves and sheltered forests and hidden glades. The men of Cardolan who came to Eryn Vorn were, blood-through-blood, the Men of old Númenór, begotten of the old Sea-kings, and while they had learned to hide and protect themselves as the Minhiriathrim had shown them, they never did less than stand when called upon.

   Oisín stared at the Great Door with tremendous fixation, much as he had shown earlier that day when they all discussed it, but now his eyes held another kind of longing look; more purposeful and more discerning.

   ‘I cannot yet say, Hothron,'4 he said softly. ‘I will need time to pray.’

 

*****

   And so the dawn came soon after and the party made ready to meet it.

   Before the first shafts of filtered sunlight could be felt within the cavern of the Grazing Field Flomi had been moved to the palette they had fashioned for him and all his gear was also assembled there.

   Tawarengil and Beothalion had gone off together to discuss their own way forward, but the decision had come fairly quickly to them both.

   ‘I am very sorry, little Benbow,’ the Wildman said to Ben, coming to find him directly after his talk with the young Elf-lord. ‘My brother and I are going otherwheres. He would have us follow Alatar into the west, and it may be,’ he said somewhat sheepishly, ‘this is good for me as well. I still have much to learn, we think.’

   ‘Well, these are wise old fathers, I think,’ Ben said, craning his neck to look up and catch the big man’s eyes, ‘and they seem to know a lot more about this world than you or I do. It couldn’t hurt to take a little advice that is offered freely from any one of these three pilgrims, I should think.

   ‘They may have great things to show you, Beothalion, great castles and green lands and such wonderful things you’ve not had sight of before,’ he continued. ‘And I hope all of these make you happy as you were on that day you first saw the commonroom at the Four Greenfields. I will remember that, and remember the surprise and joy you found there in the simple lives of the Breefolk.

   ‘I myself don’t care much about banners and legions as your brother does, but there’s a wonder to be found in those things as well, or so I hear.

   ‘We’ll be just fine here ourselves, Collum and that mister Pallando and I,’ he said, gesturing at his fellows, clearly uncomfortable with such a long speech. ‘I don’t understand much of what happened last night, but I’m sure that you saved me and many of us. Just as you did the night of the fire in the Bree-land. You’re a friend to me now on the road, mister Beothalion, and while I regret our parting, I look forward to you having everything you want in the adventures of your future.’

   Ben didn’t know quite what to do at the end of such a long speech (and, just like Milo Fastknots, it was a situation he had not found himself in very often before). So, rather sheepishly, he bowed.

   Beothalion felt likewise constrained by his lack of polished courtly manners. He resorted to his old greeting of open hands forward, down to his side and then turned palm up, the one he had shown the wizards before, three nights ago at the inn where they all had met. Then he remembered that Benbow didn’t know that gesture, so he copied the hobbit’s low bow, but went to one knee after. This brought their eyes into contact again and, holding their serious expressions for only a moment, their faces together broke into laughter.

   ‘Oh, I shall miss you, little Benbow,’ the Wildman said, laughing.

   And Ben laughed, and away to the corners of the Grazing Field Rosie laughed, and the other animals (though they did not fully understand why) laughed with her. Ben was the happiest then that he could remember in many years.

   The two companions did not see one another for a very long time, and much misery came to each before their next happy greeting.

 

*****

   ‘These runes were not all set into the door at once,’ the wizard said, ‘and there are some rendered here by crude hands. These are the most easy to read, I should think, for the words are in the modern tongue of the North while the letters are in the older forms.’5

   ‘Yes, wisefather, these I know,’ Ohtar said as they studied the doors together. ‘This place was sometimes used as a test for my people, and even myself in youth, for an understanding of our old languages which may no longer be found since Arnor collapsed.

   ‘I know the Westron written here,’ he continued, ‘and I have learned some of the Elven tongue from this wall. Studying here I learned to write it properly. There is even Adûnaic here,’ he pointed then to high carvings on the lintel of the door, ‘and while I have some understanding of their sounds, I cannot, nor could my teachers, grasp their meaning.’

   ‘I cannot either,’ Alatar said, ‘for I held little congress with those people when that language was in flower, and there is only one of my order who knows it still.6

   ‘Tell me, Ohtar,’ he said softly, ‘is there anything else written here which has drawn your attention but stands unresolved?’

   Ohtar looked long at the Great Door. He wondered how many times he had visited this spot, how young he was when first he came to the Foundations; never as a boy of course, for this was too secret and too sacred a spot for boys to know of, but certainly many times before he and his father had traveled south to Gondor. They came here to talk and to study and to prepare the younger Ohtar for the responsibilities he would carry and that had been carried by the twenty-six other Ohtars before him. He regretted how infrequently, even with his living in the Bree-land these past dozen years, he had been able to bring his own sons here.

   ‘If I am to guess, wisefather,’ Ohtar said reluctantly, but with a small grin that hinted at humour for being tested, ‘I would pick not one inscription, but two. Here, on the pedestals that support these basins, two matching inscriptions can be seen. The script is Tengwar, as the Men of Númenór used in Isildur’s day, and it is finely crafted; my own father believed it part of the original construction.’

   ‘It seems your father had much wisdom despite knowing little history, Ohtar,’ the wizard said, ‘for I also believe this to be the case. But he could not read the inscription here, I would guess. Few in the world of Men might.

   ‘It is written, as you say, in the letters Men learned from the Elves,’ Alatar continued, ‘but not in the language the Elves had taught them and that the faithful of Númenór so long maintained. No, this bit of amusing speech is in the old High Language of the Elves that only a very small number of Númenóreans had ever learned or kept. I doubt your Rune-master has ever come upon it or that our young lord Tawarengil has even recognized it. It was, I can say with all frankness, the most surprising thing that I and those of my order have been shown in these past few days of surprises.’

   ‘Can you understand and interpret the inscription, wisefather?’ Ohtar asked. ‘Does it have something to do with opening the Great Door here?’

   ‘Oh, most certainly,’ the wizard answered briskly, as if it was the silliest question he had heard in a long time. ‘And I can teach it to you. I shall teach it to you. But you made an excellent observation just a moment ago which seems to escape your mind now:

   ‘There are two pedestals with two matching inscriptions.’

 

*****

   The Bard opened the door with carefully contained excitement. He did not enjoy this underground place, sacred as he knew it should be to him and to all of his people, but throughout the last night’s battle the lack of sky and open space had troubled him greatly. He and his people did not fight in mines and tunnels but in open lands and deep forests. He could not imagine how dwarves and elves and other folk lived and died in tunnels or such places, with no sky over their heads.

   As the Secret Door swung in towards him, he saw the morning light, still way below the tree line, off to the distant east. As always, the light from that direction seemed cold and remote until, finally, the Sun burst forward to warm even that far-off, still-feared part of the world. Stepping forth onto the cool ground before the door, he could hear bird calls and other small sounds of wind and of living things as they awakened. He looked down at his feet and saw that even in the springtime of this land north of his own, frost had come to the small bushes and grasses growing near the wall. Frost came seldom to the Eryn Vorn, the land of his birth and his People’s exile; one must sometimes go high into the trees to find it. Now he looked up at the sky and saw that many of the stars were still out, still shining to light his way until the Sun may come.

   Here, with the great sky above him and the sense of great life around him, he could not imagine living, fighting and dying in a tunnel or a hall, no matter how great or lordly such a hall might be, as dwarves and even some elves were said to do. As he and his new friends fought and may have died last night.

   He could not imagine it but, truly, he had never before imagined his own dying very much.

   ‘Imagining one’s own death is a waste of imagination,’ he had thought then, and (being a collector of such witticisms) would joke about later.

   He did not wish to join the soldier and the others back in the tunnel while the stars were overhead and there was dew on the grass and the Sun would soon rise to meet his face. He did not know if his way forward should lead under the ground when he felt so powerfully the joy of another morning.

   ‘But to imagine one’s own way forward without prayer is a waste of faith.’

   As the world awakened around him, and with the anticipation of the Sun on his face, he went forward into the birch glade ahead. There he would climb the highest tree in the westernmost part of the ring, climb to the highest spot that would hold him, his face ready to meet the Sun, the blade of his fathers in his lap.

   It would be a beautiful day in the springtime of this northern land. The dew would melt quickly, no clouds could be seen as yet, and the lands around him were awakening softly, peacefully.

   He would feel the Sun on his face and on the land and hear within his heart the way forward.

 

*****

   Tawarengil joined Ohtar and Alatar before the Great Door. ‘You will go forward then?’ he asked. ‘You will open this door and go further into these dark halls?’

   ‘Yes, my lord,’ Ohtar responded, ‘my way must lie there until Flomi has healed. It seems clear that our protection in this chamber, if truly we had much, has ended. So if I cannot take Flomi out, I must take him deeper in.’

   Tawarengil took a moment to consider this. For Ohtar it was, in that moment of their last conversation together, a surprising thing to see the hesitancy on the elf-lord’s face.

   Over the past three days, Ohtar had seldom seen such a moment as this happen. The lord Tawarengil he had seen was brusque; quick to action or speech in ways that, on those few occasions Ohtar had of speaking with other Elf-lords, seemed quite uncommon. It was sometimes difficult to address Tawarengil as an adult given that he looked so childlike, and perhaps that had something to do with the lord’s impatience. But Ohtar knew better than to be fooled by appearances concerning the fair folk, even if he knew little of their ways. From the start, he had treated the Elf-lord just as the Istari had done: respectfully but cautiously. For the elf was clearly of great lineage but seemed to have unrevealed purposes.

   ‘We will not go deeper,’ Tawarengil said resolutely after a few moments, with clear seriousness written over his childlike features. ‘Beothalion and I will go west to Círdan’s call as we had intended. We will ride out under the banners of my People to destroy the Witch-king. We will learn more, as we have sought from the start, learn more of ourselves and of our People. We will not go deeper into tunnels and mysteries which only distract us from that intention.

   ‘But making this decision fills me with some... uncertainty, Ohtar,’ the Elf-lord continued, ‘for I and my brother have grown interested in your own fate and he,’ Tawarengil paused here as a gentle smile showed us his face, ‘and I myself, do not leave our interests behind us lightly.

   ‘We can wish you well,’ he said then, turning to face Ohtar with some formality, ‘but we cannot join you further.

   'Galu, Hothron. Boe i 'waen, im naer. Na lû e-govaned vîn, Sílo Anor bo men lín.’7

   ‘I am most grateful for your kindness, lord,’ Ohtar said in return as he bowed slightly in deference to Tawarengil’s graciousness and in respect for the lord’s stature. ‘And I can only thank you once again for all of the help you have given to my cause and to those short-sighted people of the Bree-land. I wish you well in your own roads to the West and am likewise saddened that my duties will not allow me to accompany you and see the lands of the North retaken by our united Peoples. I have been in wars, lord, and still my heart is stirred by banners and the ringing of silver trumpets as you speak of. Go to glory, lord Tawarengil, and, if fate permits, we shall meet again in the free lands of the North.’

   And so they would meet again, after many miseries and unexpected hardships, after long battles and heart-shattering circumstances, and they would be glad for this meeting though the cost was high.

 

*****

   ‘But she must go with you!’ Benbow said. ‘I’ll not take her further into the dangers behind that door. I’ll not!’

   ‘And she will also not, little Benbow,’ Beothalion replied. ‘She is very wise, more than any other I have seen in my travels. She knows your mind and she knows her own. She will not leave you.’

   Rosie responded by neighing loudly and rubbing her head against the top of Ben’s in that old reassuring way that she had.

   ‘Acccch! Rosie, girl,’ Ben said, reaching up to touch the pony’s jaw line and stroke the area around her cheek and below her ear in the way that she loved. ‘Rosie, if you can hear me as this friend of ours says that you can then, Rosie, my dear, you should not follow!’

   There was another loud, disgruntled neighing at this comment and it was echoed by the braying sound of Duncan, the dwarf’s beast, further back in the field.

   ‘Oh, she hears you, but she will not leave you, little Benbow, the Wildman said. ‘Why should she leave? I do not know how to answer this.’

   ‘Why? Because I want her to be safe and to live long and happy away from dangers, of course. Why!’

   ‘Yes, I know this, my friend,’ Beothalion responded quietly, ‘but have you not wanted that for her always before?’ 

   ‘Well, yes, of course I have, but...’

   ‘I understand your feelings, Ben,’ Collum said, walking quietly up behind them. ‘It seems that Caitelyn, against my better wishes, will also join us in our journey. I had offered her to Alatar that he might take her far away from this troubled place. He was... unmoved. He claims to have no need of her on his travels.’

   ‘I will take charge of your friend, Collum Ohtar,’ Beothalion said, ‘though I do not ride.’ He thought for a moment about this and, looking around the chamber, said, ‘Perhaps my brother does.’

   ‘Now that would be a sight,’ Ben said, picturing the young Elf-lord, not many inches taller than Ben himself, astride Collum’s great grey mare, his wooden sword in hand. Sensing the joke, Collum also smiled.

   ‘You do me yet another favor, my friend,’ the man said, ‘and again I thank you. If you can see Caitelyn out of this harm and on your journey west it would ease my heart greatly. There are wonderful farmlands just beyond the Brown River that she knows well and might love to see again.

   ‘Now, Ben,’ he said, turning to the hobbit, ‘while I obviously agree with your desire for her safety, your Rosie is not a simple beast like Caitelyn or Duncan there. She was raised in Rivendell and has a keener understanding than either of us has accounted her for. And she has always been loyal to none but you. I do not think she will let you go without her.

   ‘I have never heard of any of my People who has gone beyond the Great Door, but I do know this: that way was prepared long ago for horses of much greater size than even Caitelyn. Rosie will be no more trapped there than any of us.’

   ‘I appreciate what you are saying, Collum,’ Ben replied, ‘even if I don’t find it at all reassuring.

   ‘Okay, Rosie, my girl,’ he said, looking lovingly into the pony's bright eyes, ‘it will be as it has been; you and me on new roads together.’ Rosie neighed softly and nuzzled against his head again. ‘We may not see open skies together for some time, girl. Let’s go see the morning Sun for a bit now.’

 

*****

   Ohtar thought that this was an excellent idea and so Rosie and the other beasts were all taken up the ramp in the company of Ben, Beothalion and Tawarengil. Here they would be given an hour or two of morning light and air before the company was to become split and half of them would plunge further into darkness. Ohtar himself remained behind for a time to sort the provisions and to prepare Flomi’s litter. Alatar was still studying the workings of the Great Door.

   ‘Will he wake soon?’ Ohtar asked Pallando as he approached the wizard sitting there beside Flomi’s litter.

   ‘No,’ the wizard replied gravely as he touched two fingertips to Flomi’s brow. ‘No, he will remain at rest for a time, Ohtar. Their strength is like stone; growing greater in its immobility. They came forth in the days of the power of Melkor, these Children of Aulë, and so he made them strong that they might endure much. They are stone-hard in toil, stubborn in cause, fast in friendship and likewise in enmity. They suffer exhaustion and hunger and hurt of body quite as other peoples do but bear it more handily, as the stone around them, quietly resisting age and hurt. And they live long, far beyond the span of Men.

   ‘Yet not forever,’8 he continued. ‘He sleeps as stone sleeps now. In a healing sleep which his people have that I have helped him to find. I doubt that a dagger would awaken him-’ And the wizard stopped suddenly here to see the concern on Ohtar’s face. ‘Though I also doubt any daggers could trouble him here with good comrades at hand,’ he continued. ‘Touch him, Ohtar, and understand this! Feel it for yourself.’

   Ohtar was, in his heart, greatly torn over Flomi’s condition. He had sent the dwarf here to what he believed was a safe place hardly a week before and now it seemed to be one of the deadliest places he had ever encountered. Impetuous and naive as he often seemed, Flomi had become Collum’s friend and Ohtar, who should have the goal of their quest most high in his mind and above any friendship, now found himself more concerned for Flomi than he was for the mission. Had they left a week ago, as he knew they should have, all might have been different.

   The two friends had spoken a few times since Flomi’s battle; the dwarf had risen to consciousness in fits of determination and stubbornness during that first night. Pallando, the quieter of the two blue wizards, had changed that. He had spoken with Flomi, and had touched his wounds, and had said slow, unknown words over him so that the dwarf fell deep into a deathlike sleep; sitting near and listening closely, Ohtar could still hear the breathing of his friend. But nothing else; no moan or sigh, no flicker of eyelids or turn nor twitch of body could be seen in his slumber. So near death he seemed then that Ohtar was afraid what that death might mean to his Princess and how he had failed to protect his friend.

   ‘O, you Men!’ the wizard said, looking at him now and seeing Ohtar’s fear and wonder. ‘So involved as you are with death that you will not allow yourselves to notice how others face it differently. This dwarf, your friend as I take it, was grievously wounded. But he and his kind do not go so readily as Men might. Touch his skin! Do not fear what it will tell you!’

   Ohtar, responding more to the power in the old man’s voice than through any decision of his own, bent beside his friend and reached out his hand to touch Flomi’s brow. It had been feverish earlier, on the night when they first came into the Grazing Field and saw the dwarf being cared for by Oisín. Now the skin that Ohtar touched was much cooler, not cold as he had at first feared, but cooler than his own. ‘Like a stone brought inside the house at the end of a summer’s day,’ he thought.

   ‘Yes,’ Pallando said, breaking his thoughts, ‘he is quite cool as he rests. There is a fire within these People that does not need Sun nor Stars to be kindled. That fire is now directed to the healing of his body, and the skin you feel beneath you contains it.’

   Hearing this, Ohtar could feel the hardness of Flomi’s skin. Not the ruddy, leather-like quality he thought of when looking at him before, but a stony smoothness and resilience. He breathed, and he was warm still, unmoving and unaffected by Ohtar’s touch.

   ‘Yes, much like stone in his healing. And he will now be a good deal heavier,’ Pallando said. ‘We shall need that donkey of yours to bear his litter.’

 

*****

   As they stood near the wall and felt the morning Sun on their faces, Ben’s quick eye caught quiet movement in the trees of the nearby glade. He saw the Bard drop silently to the ground there and come forward to meet them. Tawarengil and Beothalion had gone off a bit to the north with Caitelyn and the other queer beast, leaving just Ben and his Rosie to meet the man.

   ‘Looks to be a beautiful morning,’ Ben said to him amiably, ‘and Rosie and I have come to take our last bit of sunshine for a time.’

   ‘Aye, the Sun smiles for us today after our long night,’ the man said warmly, pausing to look back to the eastern sky, ‘and dawn is ever the hope of Men.

   ‘May I touch your beast?’ He asked cautiously, raising his open hand to Rosie.

   ‘Well,’ Ben said with equal caution, ‘if she lets you then it’s surely fine with me. But she doesn’t take to folk easily, my Rosie-’

   Much to Ben’s surprise, the pony came and put her jaw right into the stranger’s outstretched hand. He rubbed under her chin, but cautiously still, like one who was unfamiliar with ponies.

   ‘Well, that is another surprise in a week of the same,’ Ben said, ‘she doesn’t usually take to strangers and, no insult meant, she doesn’t much care for the Big Folk.’

   ‘Do you mean the men of Númenor?’ he replied, petting Rosie and looking into her eyes.

   ‘Well, just Men, I’d guess,’ said Ben. ‘She’s seen some bad ones in her time. And it might have something to do with her being raised by the Elves. They’re fine suspicious of Men too, from what I’ve seen.’

   ‘We do not have such beasts where I come from,’ he said admiringly, ‘and not much kinship with them as I have seen here in the wider world. The people of Minhiriath, and those of my folk who have survived since Cardolan’s fall, are a forest People. We do not train nor keep beasts. We do not farm nor raise flocks as my ancestors of Cardolan once did. We are wanderers and hunters now.’

   ‘Well, we’ve certainly that in common then,’ Ben said smiling, ‘I and my fathers before me have wandered and hunted here in the North country for as long as anyone remembers.’ He patted Rosie’s side then, saying, ‘Though we’ve had good friends like Rosie here to help us in moving our feet forward.’

   The Bard turned then and looked long into Benbow’s large brown eyes. He then did the same with Rosie, still gently stroking under her jawline.

   ‘Thank you, Benbow Floxleaf, and thank your friend... Rosie?’

   ‘“Roh-so-sin-dinn”9 as I’d first heard it said,’ Ben replied, ‘but she’s just simple Rosie to me.’

   ‘Not so simple at all, I think,’ he said, smiling broadly. ‘Thank you, “Rosie”,’ he told the pony very frankly, ‘What a tale we are in, aren’t we?’10

 

*****

   The Bard came down the ramp into the Grazing Field and stood before Ohtar and Pallando as they prepared their way forward. An awkward silence fell between the two men, and Ohtar, the taller of the two, stood quietly waiting to see what would pass.

   Oisín bent his knee and offered his open hands.

   ‘I will take you as my captain,’ he said, his head low, ‘for what time I may be useful to you. I will aid you as I can by song and story and force of arms. I will go into this sacred place with you,’ he said, indicating the doors before them, ‘for as long as it may serve you to have me as escort.

   ‘Yet I must also go forward when you will release me,’ he continued. Then he drew from behind his back a dagger, long, leaf-shaped and damasked with serpent forms in red and gold. It shone very brightly in the dim cavern, the light of the early sun red upon it. Its edge was hard and keen, and Ohtar knew it to be a work of old hands.11

   ‘I will take you as my captain for what time I may prove useful,’ the Bard said, ‘but I must, when possible, be released from your service to fulfill my vow. Then I will go to kill the Witch-king with this blade. But for now I shall swear by it.’

 

*****

   And so the company was decided; Ohtar, Ben, Oisín and Pallando would go deeper into the mysteries behind the Great Door so that their friend would have time to heal. Perhaps this would be only a short way, for Flomi still needed four to five full days rest to recover, and then they might come out again into the Grazing Field in the morning when daylight would make it safe. If this were to happen they would then return as they came and depart this place with the skies over their heads and a yet undetermined way north. Or, perhaps, they would journey north through the passage; though no one knew what other exit lay ahead on that grim road. It went north, they knew, to the Silent City, Annúminas, on the shores of lake Evendim, and Ohtar and Flomi had both agreed that their mission must lead there. But Annúminas had long ago fallen into emptiness and despair, and none knew if that way yet remained open.

   Alatar would take the others west to Mithlond to answer Cirdan’s call. Tawarengil and Beothalion (and even Caitelyn) would join him. Alatar believed that the forces of Elves and Men were gathering there and that his wisdom would be needed. Tawarengil wanted to see the banners of his people unfurled. Beothalion, for his part, followed his brother but also hoped to learn more of the world and of his own place in it.

   All the provisions that Milo had brought were pulled out into the morning sun before the Secret Door and divided to the benefit of each party. This had been somewhat of a waste of energy, for no provisions would be needed for the travelers on the western road. The land between here and Mithlond was fertile and friendly with open skies and great patches of green hills and rolling rivers before one came to the Gulf of Lhûn, the mouth of the great Western Sea. Between here and Mithlond they would cross the Shire, a land of great plenty whose folk were still loyal to the King and kept the Road. They had little or no need for provisioning. Alatar and Tawarengil and Beothalion would take Caitelyn with them at Ohtar’s request. Alatar seemed unhappy about this decision regarding the horse, but the Elf-lord defended his brother’s position on the matter.

   So the subterranean travelers were given the great share of the supplies. Rosie and Duncan, who seemed strangely receptive to going on despite the danger, would bear much of this as they moved forward. They could not yet be sure of their way, so large stores of mosses from the Grazing Field and skins of fresh water from the troughs were prepared for them should they take that unrecovered road North. Dried meats and fruits, wine and blankets, saddles and rope, all of what Milo Fastknots had gathered, were given to these folk as well.

   All of these decisions were made rather quickly after Oisín had decided to follow the north party, and Ohtar then prepared quickly that they all might depart soon. He had gone to a crude pantry in the Grazing Field and found three drinking vessels which he knew of. He added these to the four others he had brought from the Bree-land: the delicately wrought cups he had shared with the wizards at that first meeting. He cleaned these all very thoroughly and, overturning a small storage container to use as a table in the Glade of Seven Birches, set them gently into a line. As his compatriots gathered and watched him prepare, he drew a lambskin canteen from his bag and slowly, with some solemnity, poured from it carefully, equally and evenly, into these seven cups.

   ‘Come, my friends, and we will drink a proper parting,’ he said.

   The last of his remaining contents were set before him in the seven small cups on the crude, makeshift table. Ben, who still thought he knew some things about the man well, watched the regret fall on Collum’s face as the last of these ingredients was squeezed from the canteen and the supply was finally drained. Collum took a long moment to look at the depleted vessel before looking into the eyes of his friends.

   ‘So we will now,’ Ohtar said, ‘drink this cup of parting that we spoke of before. To Beothalion, I have promised this, but I also owe all you others greatly.

   ‘This,’ he said, raising one of the smaller crude drinking vessels above his brow line, ‘is Mirovur, the cordial of Imladris, of which my family has been given a rather special stewardship.

   ‘Three I served a few nights ago,’ he continued, ‘and seven I serve now. Nothing now remains of what I have carried in secret for over twenty years.’

   ‘Ohtar,’ Tawarengil said, ‘you should not do this! It is a rare gift indeed to carry the cordial of Imladris, but you should not give it carelessly to others!’

   ‘Do I, my lord?’ Ohtar said. ‘Is it careless to reward such friends as we have gathered here? I go into a great unknown. Shall I take such a treasure with me, or shall I share it out under the bright Sun with bold comrades, in celebration of glad times?

   ‘Here, my friends and comrades,’ he said, handing out the drinking vessels to all assembled. ‘We must part company, yet I am thankful to my last for the company we have shared. In some few hours we will go to our fortunes, but I would drink a cup of parting with you now before that moment comes.’

   Collum, or Ohtar or whomever he may be called, then dropped his own vessel to the table, banging it there gently before he raised it again in celebration:12

   ‘Lacho calad! Drego morn!’ he called loudly.

   The two wizards repeated his call and even Tawarengil repeated it slowly and sheepishly. All drank the offered cordial and all hearts were warmed by it.

   Ben, even before he put the cup to his lips, felt, smelt, or dreamed almost immediately of the time, four years past, when he and his father rode into the hidden valley of Rivendell. He smelled again the birch and pine of the valley, remembered the roasting meats and roaring fires of the Homely House. He heard again, in beautiful memory, the singing and the laughing of happy voices in the air. There he had lost his father, but there he had been given Rosie by the most beautiful Elf-lady he had ever seen, and so the moment this draught brought to his mind was both happy and mournful. He welcomed it.

   Tawarengil, from his first scent of the liquor as it was poured out, had quite expectantly fallen into a deep reverie. The woodland Elves of his people live deeply in the green and their dreamtime often sees them wander into familiar forest paths reliving details of the sunlit trees and starlit paths. He knew of Mirovur, as all his folk did, but he had never encountered it before now.

   Oddly, it did not send his dreamingmind into a deep memory of the Greatwood in daytime and the world which he loved, but into an unfamiliar nighttime and a sky full of stars in lands that he had never seen. He felt, very acutely, the swaying of the birch trees near them in his nowtime. He felt those trees’ longing to grow and bend to the West and their commitment and faith to grow straight as their stewards had guided them in their youth. In his reverie those trees were not yet born and all the world was younger, younger than he had seen it in his small lifetime and clearer than any song had ever described. Clear and bright were the stars in these ancient times as Tawarengil saw them now. With the smell of Mirovur he dreamed beyond his own short experience of a young world which he had never known. It was night in that dreamworld and he walked alone and naked in the open and unsullied lands. The bright stars above put him farther west of the land he was in now, farther west than any skies he had imagined. But even then, in that distant world as in this present one, he felt the grass and the earth beneath his feet as it rolled westward, returning somehow in ways that the grasses could not speak of now and that he could feel only but not fully interpret.

   Still in his trance and still in his comradeship with the others in this glade of white trees, as he took the treasured drink to his lips, his eyes were drawn upward again and, though it was early morning and bright sunshine was coming into the glade, he did not see the Sun as he drank the cup of parting.

   Instead, his eyes beheld up above them the heaventree of all stars. A past which possibly had ceased to exist as a present before its probable spectators had entered actual present existence.13 He saw the moving of time and, young though he was, he felt the movement of all things West to their purpose.

   And he heard, for the first time in that dream of then which put him far west of now, the roaring of seas. And he heard the call of the West. And he resisted it then as he did for many long years after.

   Beothalion worked to contain his excitement as the liqueur was poured out. It was this smell of honey and sunshine and clear, cold flowing streams that first caught his attention three days before in the Bree-land as he was surrounded by so many very new smells and sights and sounds. It had drawn him out of his chair, away from his brother’s cautious guidance, and into his first conversation with people he did not know. The smell of its pouring, then and now, felt as a familiar thing in a very foreign world that he could not resist tasting.

   But the taste of the cordial itself, in Beothalion’s mouth, brought something quite different. It rolled through his mouth and over his tongue and, at first, brought to his memory the smell of rain. Throughout the rain, he remembered that the small island had held, for seven days it held, but all around them the orcs had taken the shores of the river in impossible numbers. His father and his brother had already fallen trying to ride out to meet them. He must hold the line against the siege. He must keep his people alive and wary through the rain and the attack. He must hold the line.

   Somewhere, unbidden though feeling very much like a memory found in the Mirovur’s taste, Beothalion thought, or remembered saying to himself, ‘The day will come when they will perish and I shall go back.’14

And there was a clear and undeniable pride which he felt in this memory, a willfulness uncharacteristic of his current nature that made him, in that very difficult and uncertain moment of his life, feel all the stronger. In all the long years of his life afterwards he never told anyone about this, not even his son, but he never forgot the road of discovery which the taste of that drought sent him on.

   Ohtar had never tasted Mirovur. There was some part of him, some voice of his father’s, which made the cordial, and his stewardship of it, so important to his mind that partaking of it himself should feel unfaithful. But here he was at a great crossroads with a collection of people who may do better work in the larger world than he himself might do under it following his own current direction; they might become warriors of the North while he and his line had been relegated to being the custodians of their own very specific cause.

   As he poured the liqueur into these assorted vessels, he resisted the compelling urge to let the aroma transport him to some memory of home; some glimpse of what his heart longed for. Memory and smell showed him fleeting glimpses of a tall, dark-haired woman and her wide but serious smile; of sons he had spent too little time with; of his father, who remained lost; and even of Guldir, now dead, who had helped him so much in younger days. But he rejected these flashes of smell’s memory and kept to the work of service. He knew this to be the trick of the potion, or so it had been called by his fathers: that it restores the heart and spirit with memories of all that it has longed for, but also reveals truths of the self that are sometimes uncomfortable.

   Ohtar did not want to drink this most special and precious of draughts with the others, but custom dictated that he should.

   Each time that he had poured this out (and he had done so three times in his lifetime before now) he had managed to avoid partaking with the others; to conserve the beverage perhaps, or, maybe, to avoid the thoughts or memories that it was purported to bring.

   As the drink came into his mouth, the smells of the birch and rowan, of the fir and nettles of the area surrounding this special place left him, and he was once again in the northern marches of a fair land far south of where his feet stood now. A country of climbing woods and swift-falling streams (as the land was to the north of his feet as they stood here near the Tuama where it was early morning yet). But in his mind and his memory the night above him became fine under stars and a great round moon, and it seemed that the fragrance of the air grew as he and the company of soldiers rode forward. They rode quietly by night. All had swords at their sides, and were clad in green and brown of varied hues, the better to move unseen in the glades of Ithilien. Green gauntlets covered his hands then and his face was hooded.15

   In Ithilien, thirty years before, he rode with the company of the Commander, Eärnil.16 He had the respect of this Commander and, though still quite young, he had a clear purpose, a known path, in the wars of Gondor and the preservation of the realms of Men. He was a soldier of Númenór then and he served a king of Gondor and a Commander he respected. As the day would open up in this memory, he and the Men riding beside him would go to the Battle of the Camps and turn the tide of war. He served faithfully then and he served well.

   But even then, in a fond memory, he could not be totally honest and still be totally clear in his duty. For he was not Ohtar then but Telumehtar, just as he is not Collum now but Ohtar once again. There were always masks to cover his purpose. Then, and now, he served not the king of Gondor but a Princess of Arnor. His allegiance, like that of all his fathers before him, was to the true line of Elendil.

   He had seen her only twice in all his years, but he had served her will all of his lifetime. He had known for long, even as he did when he had followed that great Commander in Gondor, or as he stood here before these new friends that would go to war in the North, that he was hers. He could never go to war again, never decide his own path, whilst he served the Princess of Arnor.

   And as he drank the cordial with the others, as he felt the familiarity of the ground beneath him and smelled the memories of his past travels, it was the face of his Princess which the drink brought foremost to his mind. He shut his eyes to hold the memory longer.

   Oisín Na-Glirhuin knew nothing of this custom or of drinking. The beverages of the Minhiriathrim were limited to fresh waters and animal milks found in the wild. They were nomadic hunters, so they raised no herds and made no wells. Some, and these were some whom Oisín seldom spoke with, made potions for healing and for fortune and sometimes, or so he had heard, these were to be drunk in some level of ceremony as he was seeing his new friends inact here. Perhaps. He had never been part of that sort of ceremony or spoken much with those who had followed these old ways.

   But he had watched carefully and understood fully the solemnity the Soldier used in pouring out the liquid. He saw the frank faces of those other friends around him and set his own just so, so as not to seem ignorant or disrespectful in the ceremony. But in his own heart, he knew only that he did not know anything about what was going on.

   But even in ignorance, his eyes were sharp. This was not spring water poured into these vessels and it was also not the murky slop that he had heard was given by the Wisewomen amongst the Minhiriath. The light of the risen sun behind him hit the arc of the liquid as it rolled slowly out through the skin that the Soldier held aloft so carefully, dealing it out so preciously. And the light which came off of it seemed bright and precious. He had not seen gold or gems or any of these precious things, but in the stories he knew they all glimmered as this drink did.

   Was this another custom of his family, a thing which the Soldier knew but that his fathers living in the open lands had forgotten? Was this something that he might learn? He felt the weight, the seriousness it brought to the others and could not wait to understand more.

   And then the smell of something new hit him and he was lost.

   His feet were here. No one raised as he had been would ever forget where their feet were. He could still feel the strength of the tall birches behind him and, with their help, his feet were still here. He remembered the remnants of dew on the grass which he saw earlier that morning, remembered the last stars of day as they awaited the coming Sun and heard again the birdsong when he left the underground some few hours before, remembered the dew on the grass. But smelling and seeing this potion (if that is what it was) roll cleanly into the cups and then, putting one under his nose, took him elsewhere.

   It seemed in that moment that innumerable birds chattered in the eaves: and some sang upon the treetops, while doves and pigeons circled in flights about his eyes' borders or swooped to settle and sun themselves upon the sward. All day long, for surely he spent many days in this vision, there went a hum of bees among the flowers: bees that fared about the roof of where he stood in dreamtime and along all the scented beds of the leafy mound before his house.17

   His house? No, he had no such forest house. That was for the Minhiriathrim. They had saved his People, something his line had been grateful for for many generations, but the fate of the Minhiriathrim was not the same as the Unnonóreans'.

   He pushed this idea from his mind, felt again the place where he now stood and then the Soldier raised the cup in his own hand. All raised their vessels and the Soldier cried, ‘Lacho calad! Drego morn!’ and, putting the cup to his lips, Oisin was lost again.

   He remembered now a great battle of which he had been told many times, but now with a clarity of detail that he had never before imagined.

   ‘Utúlie’n aurë! Aiya Eldalië ar Atanatári, utúlie’n aurë!’ he heard called then in the black and desolate North under skies clouded with ash. He stood then with his own fire-blackened axe and grey woolen cloak over leather armour while around him the light of the drawing of the swords of the Noldor was like a fire in a field of reeds and all the hearts of the many armies assembled were kindled.

   But on that day fate was the more strong...

   The day grew darker, and countless tears were shed as all the host of the Iron Prison swarmed against them. They fought their way back to the shadow of Ered Wethrin and all the valiant Men of that day about them were slain, the Orcs hewing their heads and piling them as a mound in the gold of sunset. He heard his captain’s call then, full in some memory’s ear, and his heart was again kindled.

   And there in the place near the birches, just as he saw it in memory or imagination, he cried after his captain saying, ‘Aurë entuluva! Day shall come again!’18

   ‘Day shall come again!’ His new friends responded vigorously, and all hearts were kindled by this.

   Just three nights past Alatar and Pallando had partaken of the Cordial of Imladris. That had not been their first time, and looking at one another now over upraised glasses, they wondered at this strange situation.

   If the drought worked on them as it did upon the other, bringing comfortable memories and important moments, we shall never know. They drank quietly with the others and stared long at one another across the crude clay vessels. For they were about to parted from one another for the first time since the very making of the world.

End of Book One


Chapter End Notes

Notes on Chapter Ten

1)  This is an almost direct quote from Bradbury’s Something Wicked This Way Comes, another favorite book of my boyhood. In Chapter 31 of Part Two, this one line, as the entire chapter, was something that taught me much about important pauses in fiction.

2)  This, of course, is meant to echo Chapter Nine of The Return of the King. But also, in an introductory book of a bigger story, every writer is aware of how much expository speech is going on. There’s been some action, but mostly a lot of drinking, toasting, and discussing future plans. But between these seven individuals, this is truly their last debate.

3)  Haleth, an unforgettable character from the First Age of Middle-earth, has something to do with Beothalion’s people. I’ll get to that. Promise.

4)  Hothron is the Sindarin word for “captain,” and in using it, Oisín has elevated Ohtar a bit since the battle with the rats.

5)  These writings that Alatar is describing are phrases in the Westron language but written in the Tengwar form as it was used in Númenor. The idea, as Ohtar discusses, is that this secret place also served as a kind of schoolroom for the few people of Arnor who knew of it.

6)  Umm, Saruman, of course. What other wizard would know the language of the Fallen People?

7)  “Good luck, captain. It is necessary that I go. I am sad/sorry. Until the time of our next meeting may the Sun shine upon your road.” -Sindarin

8)  This part is largely a paraphrase from The Silmarillion. I wanted to place a reminder here of how different dwarves are, but from the perspective of a wizard. Old school language was therefore required.

9)  This comes from two Sindarin words; “Rocco” -“meaning horse”, and “cindinn” - meaning “little one”. Frankly, Rosie is named after Rosinante, Don Quixote’s horse, and this construction is the closest I can come to that in my poor understanding of Sindarin. Ben is very likely mispronouncing the Elvish, of course.

10)  A very obvious echo of Sam’s “What a tale we have been in, Mr. Frodo, haven’t we?” from Two Towers.

11)  Oh, it is indeed a work of old hands. Most of the description here is appropriated from Aragorn’s description of the reforged Narsil and Merry’s Barrow-blade. Spoiler.

12)  This is a rather peculiar drinking custom I’ve seen here in Philadelphia that I don’t remember from my younger days in Detroit. I’ve asked a few folks in bars just where it comes from and none seem to be certain. General consensus is that it has something to do with people who are no longer there. If so, it strikes me as a quaint and appropriate feeling for this moment.

13)  This is another reference from my other passion, Joyce’s ULYSSES, found in the “Ithaca” episode.

14)  Go find this one. You know it’s just at the edge of your memory. Anything else would be a pure spoiler.

15)  These passages are, of course, some of the early descriptions of Ithilien where “the Battle of the Camps” was fought in 1944 of the Third Age. I’ve also layered in a description of the armor of Rangers of Ithilien because I felt it interesting that this major victory was also a sneak attack. Frankly, I would have put more of this in; this is one of my favorite chapters in the book specifically for its description of the land and how it revives the weary hobbits. But the story needs to move forward.

16)  Eärnil became king of Gondor and currently reigns as such when this story is set, though those of the North dispute his claim. Ohtar’s memory capitalizes the title “Commander” here out of respect, but does not do so in regard to his predecessor , Ondoher, who he calls “a king”.

17)  No, the house is not his. This layered quote is from The Cottage of Lost Play and many of Oisín’s deeper ideas, like Jungian archetypes, are housed in the primordial versions of Tolkien’s legendarium.

18)  This bit of flashback is from The Silmarillion, of course, and I should probably take a moment to explain its connection here. I don’t intend these to be Shirley McLain-style past-life experiences unveiled through Mirovur. That’s schlocky and kind of too RPG skill-role related for my tastes. And it may well seem to experienced Tolkien readers that this goes a little beyond the results of Mirovur as a “kindling of spirits,” as we saw in Fellowship. That’s probably true. But what I wanted here was an agent for unlocking the kind of cosmological visions Frodo had in Bombadil’s house. My hope is that it will provide the right kind of enjoyment for fans who have the same attachment to those other books as I do and to show and still contain some wonderment for new readers who’ve not gone far past LoTR in their exploration of Middle-earth.


Table of Contents | Leave a Comment