New Challenge: Twenty-Five
It's been twenty-five years since the release of the "Fellowship" film transformed Tolkien fandom. This month's challenge looks back on iconic lines and scenes from the film trilogy.
-Herein Some Answers are Given, Some Contingent Plans are Laid, a Great Threat is Faced, and the Truer Nature of Some of the Party is Revealed
It was not long after middle-night that the rats came.
The alarms that Tawarengil and Beothalion had set by the Mysterious Door rang loudly and then went quickly silent, as if flooded by a deluge. The Elf-lord himself was on watch at the time and sprang quickly to the sound of action. They had set guard through the night at the stout wooden door to the Grazing Field and Tawarengil had shown, or so he believed, excellent patience in the knowledge that forces of the Enemy might be so nearby. He stood silently in the open frame of the solid wooden doorway, turning his great attention left up the stair to the outside world and right toward the deeper troubles that he predicted would come from the Mysterious Door.
He stood stone still on watch, unsleeping of course, his wooden sword planted before him in perfect accompaniment of balance to his legs, which had not moved for hours. His eyes were open but unfocused, for he needed them very little in this situation and so sent them dreaming into the Wood of his youth. His ears, however, were acutely fixed to the whole of the antechamber. The motions and the sleeping noises of his friends behind him were erased, but should a small waterbug or spider move in the space before him, Tawarengil would know of it instantly.
From behind him, however, he could smell the wholesome moss and flowing water of fountains that made this most uncommon Grazing Field so special, and these things sustained him throughout his watch. In this surrounding he could stand and wait for many long hours of night, more than any of his companions, and he had told the soldier this earlier as the watches were set.
‘I need no relief as others may, Ohtar,’ he had said, ‘for the green-smell of this chamber sustains me and the hope of activity excites me. I can stand throughout the night while others may rest.’
‘This may be so, my lord,’ the soldier responded, ‘but this is not how we shall protect one another if we are to travel together. I may not command you, but I would ask you to follow my wishes while we are safeguarding a hallowed place of my people. Wake me, please, at middle-night.’
Tawarengil had meant to do this. Through the events of these past days, he felt that the Innkeeper’s arguments had been wise enough, but too often contrary to his own observations. He had proven to be an exceptionally sharp Man whom they had discovered in the strangest of places, clearly a veteran soldier, but he was a Man nonetheless and Tawarengil doubted that any Man should lead while the Istari were among them. And this also puzzled him as he stood his watch; why had the Istari not taken charge of the company? Were they not Lords out of the West?
Tawarengil had heard rumour of the Istari throughout his life. He knew that when Radagast, one of their order, had come to settle in the Greenwood, Thranduil, Tawarengil’s lord and uncle, had been greatly disturbed. Many of the king’s soldiers and scouts were sent as ambassadors south-west to Rhosgobel to speak with Radagast regularly and to hear his wisdoms. Tawarengil had himself spoken with many of these ambassadors who had found Radagast’s ways peculiar and thought little of his wisdoms; some even thought him a little mad.1 But Thranduil discounted the observations of his ambassadors and would not hear them openly spoken in counsel. The Istari, peculiar as they may seem, had been sent to Arda for a purpose, Thranduil had believed. Tawarengil, in his strange fortune of meeting three of these great folk, had decided to harken to his uncle’s point of view on this matter. So he waited for them to take charge, to lead this party as he felt they should. Yet they gave no inclination towards leadership no matter how long he waited.
In his watch he did not consider these things of course; for that was not the way of the Elves. Meditations on such matters were reserved for wakeful time and woodland elves like him, while in the Greensleep, they turned their minds to things they loved and not to worldly concerns that they held, allowing their senses to heighten and remain open.
And so, deep in a memory of the Greatwood, Tawarengil heard a black wind rustling the trees around him, felt a chill he had never known in his true memory, and snapped his eyes open to hear the clanking of alarms and traps he had set only a few paces off to his right.
‘Arise! Arise and defend yourselves!’ he cried to the others.
Through the darkness of the antechamber (which affected the keenness of his eyes much less than it would the Innkeeper’s, he thought) came a great streaming flood of rats. Numberless. Overwhelming the web of nets and noisemakers that he and Beothalion had set there; the motion of them drowning the noise of the jangling metals placed as alarm.
Their noise was great, yet they were speechless in their flood; no squealing nor calling was heard from any and the black wind of Tawarengil’s dreaming was now the sound of hundreds upon hundreds of these creatures rushing under the gap of the Mysterious Door, climbing over one another, along walls and floors and anything else in their path, to reach his guardpost at the door to the Grazing Field.
*****
‘What does this mean?’ Ohtar had asked earlier that day, his surprise at this news unbridling his usual patience. ‘How came such vile speech to be written here and my own ancestors knew nothing of it?’
‘I have looked at the inscription and agree with your Rune-master,’ Alatar said calmly, ‘it was made many long years ago and there is no reason to believe that your own People, coming here so very infrequently as you describe, should have seen it. I am, perhaps, less of a scholar of the North Kingdom than my brother Olórin, but I should think this breach happened quite long ago, during the Great Plague2 perhaps, when this roadway was used less.
‘Was it ever used by the Enemy to some unknown purpose?’ he continued. ‘I cannot say for certain but am inclined to doubt. This very chamber, and the outer door above, have been left intact and are,’ he paused here and drew a long breath inward,3 ‘quite wholesome. There is something beyond that patched doorway that is decidedly unwholesome and now, it seems, we find evidence that they have come as far as the door and perhaps into this Grazing Field before. Long ago. Will they, or can they, come again? I cannot say.’
‘What then should we do, Great One?’ Tawarengil asked. ‘Surely such evidence suggests we are not safe here.’
‘No,’ Alatar said, wrinkling his brow in certainty. ‘No, we are not safe here.’
‘But not all are safe to leave,’ his companion, Pallando, said with equal gravity. ‘The dwarf needs time to heal, and even the stairway poses a grievous circumstance to one so sorely wounded. His folk heal best here, among stone and hall, better than they may in a wood and under pressure to move. No,’ he said, looking grimly at the other members of the party, ‘the best chance of survival for our friend is that he remain underground.’
‘Yes,’ Alatar said, ‘that is agreed. We may not flee this bit of news and yet hope to save the dwarf.’
‘Then flee if you will,’ Ohtar said, ‘for I may not. He is my friend and my charge. I will not risk his health over any threat made long ago in dark chambers.’
‘Hmm,’ Alatar said. ‘Dark Chambers. Perhaps, Ohtar, this is where your best hope lies.’
*****
Ben may have woken slower than the others, but he moved no less rapidly into position. His own watch would not come until late morning (an assignment that both relieved him and made him feel a bit insulted), but he had carefully chosen a sleeping place near the left pavise, where his bow lay waiting to be strung and his quiver was full. None of them could anticipate what kind of trouble might come, if any, but Ben’s skill with a bow was something Collum knew well and respected greatly. He was given a great supply of arrows and a strong position with which to hold the rampway.
He could see Collum, longsword already drawn, charging up the ramp as the Bard and Beothalion followed, each with weapons in their hands. The wizards, Ben noticed, were also quick to rise, but were moving to the rear of the chamber where Flomi lay beside the fountains at the Great Door.
‘Nâr!'4 Tawarengil cried as he slammed the wooden door behind him. ‘A great multitude of rats dense as a flood roars toward us through the dark passage! We must hold this door against them!’ Ohtar had contrived bolts for this door and the Elf-lord threw them now and, placing the wooden sword off to his left, drew his long knife. He then rushed to the pantry and drew out the long cudgel of one of the fallen orcs. Rushing back to the door he jammed it against the bottom just as two and three of the smaller rats began to force their way beneath it. Noises of their scraping and climbing and something like the sound of rolling, like wet and heavy leaves in a storm, could all be heard from without, but yet there was no sound or cry from any one of the creatures. He stabbed at the two who had cleared the door already and even in death they made no sound.
There was a short pause then in the noise beyond the door as these two were slain. Brief, the span of a breath perhaps, but Tawarengil’s keen ears caught it; as if all as one creature they now knew of him beyond the door and knew of his knife. And then the sound of their running and scraping stopped and the sound of them gnawing upon the wood of the door began.
*****
‘We have perhaps not considered all of the options open to us,’ Alatar said those hours before when they took their counsel. ‘The new and Mysterious Door and that Secret Door above which you have protected are not, after all, the only ways out from this place.’
All eyes fell on Collum here and Ben could tell he was uncomfortable with the proposal.
‘Our histories say that none have walked the length of that path since Eärendur’s time,’ he said calmly, ‘though it was once reported that a great many folk were brought out of Cardolan this way before it fell.’
‘My folk say this as well,’ Oisín added.
‘Some great refuge was made for an escape beneath the stones;
'...Rescued and descended together, till they saw the great last road,
'The well-fashioned wassail-hall wondrous and gleaming;
’Mid-worldfolk and kindreds that was widest reputed
'To halls under heaven North went, which heroes abode in;
'South went deadfolk, in all honors well-remember’d...’5
Ohtar looked with some surprise at this recitation, but quickly turned his conversation back to the wizards. ‘It is, in all cases among my folk, a very secret place,’ he said solemnly, ‘and none that I know have ever once opened the Great Door to the Foundations below.’
‘Yes,’ Alatar said, ‘I believe it has remained unopened for many generations of Men. And therefore it may remain the safest doorway. I do not know what darksome folk have come here, Ohtar, but I do know that at that portal your ancestors have wrought a gate which many unnatural creatures would fear to pass.’
‘And I fear it too, Wisefather,’ the soldier said. ‘To the south, since Cardolan’s fall, lie only the barrows and wights and despair. The Path to our barrow-houses is not meant to be a pathway of the living. This way goes north as well, I know, but if any exit there was ever known it may be lost to us now. It was meant as a road for the dead and their expediency. Should not the living fear to take it?’
‘Númenórean,’ Pallando said, stepping forward in his quiet and singular way of choosing an argument, ‘why are you so affixed on your dead?’
There was a longer pause here as Ohtar felt the weight of the wizard’s words.
‘You recount your history, dark as it has sometimes been, and overlook the opportunities afforded you by your accomplishments. Many many hundreds of years ago your people built a roadway here to carry their dead and their lamentations quickly and in all honor south to their barrow halls. Yet you know, and have heard,’ he said, drawing attention to the Bard and the story he had told, ‘of it being repurposed to save others of your own folk from disaster. It is not, at least not now, the darksome and solemn path it was designed for. In many years before our arrival here, it has been a road of hope for your People. You show it proper respect as a mortuary to your kinfolk and, it seems, you treat it with less respect as the salvation it has been to many others. Man, do you not see? A path to the barrow-houses is a path of acceptance, certainly. But a path that saved so many has turned into a path of the living! Can you not accept that? The sacredness you afford this road I respect, but you see this place only as a relic of former glories for your dead, when it might have better acclaim for the hope it once gave the living.
‘There is a doorway here which leads to your ancient causeway,’ Pallando said with even and keen speech as he pointed to the Great Door between the fountains, ‘It may be opened. We believe that it has been safe for many, many lifetimes of Men. The dark visitors who may have come to this cave before may know of it, but they most assuredly fear it. Will you forsake its more recent and hopeful history out of your own melancholia?'
****
Ohtar reached the top of the ramp first. The landing there before the door was only a pace or so in either direction, so he held back as he watched the childlike elf-lord use his foot to brace the cudgel against the door’s bottom while he also watched anxiously for any breach in the seams. At his feet, indeed, lay two smaller slain rats. As he stopped, with Oisín and Beothalion just paces behind him, he too heard the sound of the door’s wood being gnawed at; like how a swarm of bees might sound to a bear cub with his head stuck in a honeycomb, or the grinding of a thousands of acorns under an old and dry millstone. Ohtar moved them all quickly into action.
‘Beothalion!’ he cried, ‘relieve your friend and brace this door and the cudgel! Watch the seams! Ben!’ he called loudly. ‘There’s no work for your bow down there yet, my friend, but we can use your agile hand up here with a small blade. And bring that bow and a full quiver in case they weaken a spot!’
As Beothalion replaced him, Tawarengil took his place to the left of the doorway. He drew a second knife now and watched with readiness for any rat who might come near enough for its point.
‘Stay your position, my lord,’ Ohtar said to the elf, ‘hold this door as long as it lasts. Oisín!’ he said as he turned toward the Bard. ‘Your stout club and brave heart is of no use here against such a swarm. We must look to regroup and reinforce. Bring rope from below so that we might provide a quick escape for our comrades!’
The Bard did what he was asked, passing Ben on the narrow rampway. Looking quickly below, Ohtar could see Alatar gathering the beasts and moving them closer to the Great Door while Pallando was prepared the pallet they had fashioned to move Flomi.
‘I will not take that road until this door falls,’ he thought to himself. ‘I will not.’
*****
‘I will not take that road until hope fails,’ Collum had said hours earlier as he and Ben prepared new strategies for the encampment, ‘but it seems we must prepare against the possibility.’
‘Well, forgive me for being a ninnyhammer,6 Collum,’ Ben had said to him somewhat brusquely now that they were alone, ‘but I still don’t quite understand where that door goes to or why you seem to dislike it. That blue wassird, that Pallando he is, says it leads to a great accomplishment of your old folk in the North Realm, and I don't know why that wouldn’t be a safer road for your friend Flomi there. But, and I must say it here while I can, I just don’t know much about what’s going on and feel as if I’ve been told less than these other worthies might make such good guesses at.’
Collum stopped his work at this and looked long into Benbow’s face.
‘Ben, I have done your friendship a grievous wrong,’ he said. He sat down then, next to the hobbit in this place away from all the others and, for the first time ever, Benbow thought the man looked a little sad.
‘So many new things have happened so quickly,’ he said, ‘that I have not had time to think about your response. Perhaps worse, I have relied upon your friendship and your resilience with all these changes while offering nothing in return. You are a steadfast friend in hard times, and I have rewarded your trust unfairly. But now we wait, and time is ours. Come! Ask me all that you will.’
Ben was as surprised by this as he was thankful. He took a minute to look around the Grazing Fields and assure himself that now was indeed a good time for straight talk. The two of them were beside two large stones near the far end of the Grazing Field and away from the Great Door. On one of these stones Collum had seated himself, and the other he offered to Ben. All of their companions were busied with different tasks about the room; Beothalion and Tawarengil were fashioning a pallet to carry the dwarf, Oisín was seeing to the animals and the deployment of their equipment, Pallando was treating and examining further Flomi’s wounds, while Alatar was spending more time solving the riddle of opening the Great Door.
So Benbow looked upon the other stone and, after a moment, took a seat on it. The stones were of equal height but here, as Ben sat up straight as questioner and Collum looked down a bit as contrite confessor, both of them were of even standing, meeting together alone as they had not found time to do for these past three days.
Ben sat with his friend and, quietly, almost in secret, asked him the questions that had been bothering him most. They sat together on the two stones and, unlike all the discussions that had happened before in which folk had proved themselves to others or answered questions in regard to their own merit, Ben and Collum took the counsel of friends together, trusting, but knowingly faced with hard times.
‘So you’re not named Collum or Gilleyfoil and I suppose old Cradiac was not your grandfather?’
‘No,’ he said calmly. ‘And Cradiac was also no Gilleyfoil. It was an invented name to sound more, well, Bree-like. He was a man of my People, Númenóreans displaced here in the North Kingdom since Arnor fell into three separate states.’
‘But he was the innkeeper before you came here to keep the same inn,’ Ben said. ‘Not because of the inn, but because of Master Flomi there, the dwarf.’
‘Yes,’ Collum said frankly. ‘I was sent as guardian when Flomi’s work became more dangerous and we believed that he was, perhaps, being watched.’
‘By who?’
‘Ah. Then we did not know or even suspect,’ Collum said. ‘Burglars, perhaps? Maybe rumour had spread of a dwarf making maps. Folk who travel the road are always something more peculiar and dangerous than even the Breefolk realize, and so perhaps some would-be burglar may have noticed it first. Had rumour provoked a response? Dwarf-hoards are legendary and a map-making dwarf is a rare subject for great rumour. We did not know anything about this twelve years ago when I was sent for. But more we know now.’
‘These Black Númenóreans, you mean,’ Ben said softly.
‘Yes. But the certainty of that is only recent,’ Collum responded gravely. ‘Flomi did not suspect the depth of his danger until recently, but I had prepared more than a few friends against it. Guldir was such a friend and part of that trust. He was watchful with us all and I am sorry that I was not here as the Bard was to deliver vengeance for him.’
‘It was those two we found,’ Ben said, ‘Fern Sarnside’s friends from the Bree-land, then. They’re of those Black Númenóreans you’re speaking of.’
‘Certainly not!’ Collum responded quickly. ‘No, they were soldiers certainly, and I knew them as such when they arrived in the Bree-land early this month. One of them was of higher cunning than the others surely, but none were like the Old Foes of my people.7 I met some of those in a great battle to the south and they are deadly opponents and keen-minded! As I have told you, I believe Flomi met one last month, and it was that meeting which set a fresh watch on the Bree-land and sent these men as leaders for this orc-band and spies within the town. Guldir must’ve seen one of them following Flomi two nights ago and paid his life for it.’
‘He was a kind old man,’ Ben said softly, ‘and even my Rosie liked him. You served with him, I’d guess, for I know now that you’re a military man.’
‘Yes and no,’ he replied, ‘for he was a man of the North and my own wars were mainly in the south. But he served with my father and, in my youth, Guldir taught me many things about our lands here. He was with us on the day I was first shown these chambers. Ah! If he were alive now I wonder what he might say about our path ahead!’
‘Our path where, Collum?’ Ben asked. ‘You have told me nothing of why you need a guide in the northlands.’
Collum took some time with this response.
‘Ben,’ he said solemnly, ‘I serve the old lineage of Arnor, a sundered line that our history has forgotten but that our loyalty has not. I serve the direct line of Eärendur that, in his madness, was removed and disenfranchised. So, first, I need you to accept that this service of mine is correct and legitimate as I tell you more of my purpose.’
‘Stars and toadheels, Collum!’ Ben said with some frustration. ‘What should I be expected to know about the sundered line of kings? If I’m to trust you further, and I have very much trusted you in the past and the moreso recently, just tell me who you truly are and what you’re truly looking for!’
Collum paused a long while. He looked to his hands, he looked to the other folk going about their tasks far away from them and then, for a long minute, he looked into Benbow’s very frank eyes.
‘I am a soldier assigned to serve the heir of Isildur. I am a secret servant of the old lines of kingship. My family before me and I are stewards of the history of the North Kingdom.
‘And in the north somewhere,’ he said slowly, ‘some of the greatest artifacts of my People were hidden over eleven hundred years ago. My charge is to recover these, and the gravely wounded dwarf Rune-master here with us has the best chance of understanding how to do so. Now this bard, Oisín Na-Glirhuin, who is such a surprise, Flomi believes he holds a vital missing piece of the location we seek. I was uncertain at first, but now I agree.
‘I need to find this place and to recover these items. It has been the great plan of my People over the lifetimes of many of my ancestors. It seems that now, through chance or fortune, the possibility has fallen to me.
‘I will need your help, Ben,’ Collum said. ‘Flomi must live, the Bard’s song must be heard and then soon, perhaps sooner than I had planned, we must search the north. I trust no one to help with that as I do you.’
‘And you believe it's north we’re to go?’ Ben asked calmly.
‘Yes, I do,’ Collum said, ‘to the shores of Evendim.’
It was Ben’s turn to look down at his hands and pause and think just a bit. But the pause did not last long.
‘Getting to the lake was possible a few years back, Collum,’ he said gravely, ‘but it is a dangerous, even foolish path now. Your tower city is the home to trolls and bats and the like these days. With Norbury8 fallen this winter, and the king fleeing northwest, those open lands between will be watched.
‘We might try for the Shire and then move upstream along the Brown River,’ he continued.
‘I had thought that myself not long ago,’ Collum replied. ‘But it seems certain that conflict will move that way next. If the Witch-king is to be resisted a force will have to come over the Great Road. The Shirefolk are in more peril at this moment than they could imagine.’
‘I’d not thought of that,’ Ben said glumly. ‘More folk who should be warned, I think, and more who wouldn’t listen, I’d bet.
‘We might be safe to go there now,’ he continued, listing out their options, ‘but stuck like conies in a snare as we tried to move north.’
‘Yes,’ Collum said, with a small smile on his face, ‘I had thought as much myself.’
‘And you’re sure that the Stillwater9 is where we’re bound?’ Ben asked. ‘Because north of the Stonebows Bridge10 there won’t be any folks to aid us and no news but what we find. If there’s signs of war, I’ll spot them soon enough, but buried relics in or outside of the Grey-city are nothing I know of.’
‘Flomi has believed this for some years,’ Collum said. His face was earnest, but seemed to admit to Ben that he had no real way to be certain. ‘I have stalled him in this expedition as the Witch-king pressed forward, but now it seems our time of stalling has ended. Our purposes are certainly known and, to this location at least, Flomi has certainly been followed. I do not know what else they know.’
‘And there was that one orc who went uncounted,’ Ben said solemnly.
‘Yes. And only two of Sarnside’s suspicious friends were found here in the aftermath of battle. There were three that I knew of.’
‘Well, that’s more bad news I’d not looked for!’ Ben said rather loudly. ‘Bells in a hollow, Collum! What else should I know that you haven’t told me?’
*****
Benbow Floxleaf was sure at that moment that what he heard beyond the door was the most terrifying thing he had encountered in nearly forty years spent in the wild. His ears were very keen after all, and he had none of the quaint ideas of how rats behaved that city-folk might have. In the wild they seldom grouped in large numbers and fought with one another incessantly. They were a danger to be sure, but seldom would you encounter more than a dozen or so at a time. This was nothing like what he knew.
Close by Beothalion’s right side he crouched, his small hunting knife in one hand and bow in the other, listening and looking sharply for any indication of a breach. Beyond the sounds of so many teeth gnawing on the ancient wooden surface he could also hear the constant scurrying of the animals. A countless number. He could tell that they were climbing over one another’s backs to tear at as much of the raw wood as their teeth could find; he could hear their jaws grinding away beyond the door almost up to his own height.
But what alarmed him most was not just the ceaseless buzzing sound of their countless teeth on the wood, or the quieter rustling of their bodies as they trampled one another in their purpose. It was that he could hear them make no other sound. No cries of anger or excitement as any pack of animals he had known might make during an attack. All of their intent and all of their focus, many, many hundreds of them, it seemed, was directed upon the door.
‘Just how thick is this door?’ Ben wondered, and found that even with the other preparations they had made, he himself had never really looked at this area of defense carefully. He had trusted to Collum, yet again, on this part of their defense. ‘But no manner of military training prepares a soldier for this,’ Ben knew.
‘I am growing most... anxious here, little Benbow,’ Beothalion grumbled quietly from above. This anxiousness Ben could feel, and it scared him quite as greatly as the weakening of the door did.
This gentle and very giant wildman was holding the door against the weight and force of the unnumbered rat bodies with his great strong arms. The massive stock of his right leg and his leather-booted foot held a large orc cudgel in place at the door’s base so that no creature could press through that narrow space. He showed no sign of weakening in these extremities, and it seemed very doubtful to Ben that indeed he would while the door remained intact. But his head, and his eyes and his nose were all a flurry of small and worried motions compared to the rest of his body’s stillness; it looked to Ben as if his new friend was at the very edge of a frenzy that he could not manage, something very terrifying to himself and, as Ben’s old hunter’s sense told him, of enormous danger to all around him.
‘Sídh, gwador!’11 Tawarengil called to Beothalion in a calming voice. ‘You do not want our new friends to think you are reckless, do you? Poor master Floxleaf here has grown quite fond of your better nature, I think.’
Ben had seen the elf-child’s coolness under duress not two nights before and again it impressed him. But he felt less certainty in him now as their eyes met for a moment with the wildman frozen between them. Ben saw what he felt was a genuine concern coming from the Elf-lord, an unpredictability of what might happen next, and this made Ben all the more wary.
But as his eyes were turned he did not see another small rat at the bottom tear his way into the room through the door’s corner and near to his own foot.
‘Ben!” Collum cried.
And that was when Beothalion’s anxiousness got the better of him.
*****
‘I do not understand why everyone is so...gaer, Tawar,’ Beothalion said to his brother, ‘now that the stink of orc-blood is lifting, I think this a wonderful cave we have come to.’
‘I should not say they are ‘fearful’, brother,’ Tawarengil replied. ‘No, not even the little Periannath. He seems of much stouter stuff than I had expected. But they are growing anxious with all they are discovering here.’
The two had just finished fashioning a pallet for moving the dwarf and were now walking back to the area of last night’s rest. The Istari were still locked around the Great Door between the two fountains and Tawarengil felt it best to leave them to their deliberations; he wanted to look again at the store of weapons near the door. Looking that way, he could see the Unnórnean standing quiet watch in the still-open doorframe and, below him, little Floxleaf and the Innkeeper sitting on two old stones, talking. He was curious about their conversation, but felt he must take the time now to make his brother aware of some of the dangers that had been discussed.
The recent parting words of Olórin, the third Istari, weighed heavily on Tawarengil. Had he been reckless to bring his brother on this journey? He had no greater friend in the world and now, on the verge of what he felt was his first great adventure, Tawarengil felt with some sadness that he should have never asked Beothalion to join him. Things might become very dangerous for them all much sooner than he had imagined, and his brother, in his delightful innocence, seemed ignorant of that growing danger.
‘Brother,’ he said to Beothalion as he stopped and sat before him on the moss-covered floor, ‘tell me, do you feel anxious as they do?’
Beothalion seemed pleased to have the chance to sit and talk the common talk, so he dropped loudly to the ground beside his friend. Rolling his great body a bit into the ground for comfort, he took some dirt from below and pressed it to his forehead to cool his brow. He looked very thoughtful then, as if he were worried that Tawarengil was asking a question about some very important topic that he had somehow missed. And then, smiling with his usual honesty, he said;
‘I do not, Tawar. Oh, I do not like the smell of that other door, and my belief is that we should not go there. But that seems to be what all have decided. We will not go that way, surely.
‘I do not understand this new thing, the writing from a wall which frightens them, Tawar. But I do not understand writing. I will try to in time, for I see it has great power in this larger world that you have shown me, but I do not understand how it makes them... anxious, as you have said.’
Tawarengil thought hard on this for a moment.
‘It is the marking of an enemy, brother,’ he said, ‘perhaps a great Enemy who wishes to say that this place is their own. They may have made this mark long ago, indeed the Istari believe this is so, but they may know we have come here and they may come back before we can leave.’
‘I see,’ Beothalion said with great concern. ‘They smell the blood made here.’
Tawarengil himself had not thought about this before, nor had he heard the others speak of it openly. Ohtar had come here as recently as a week ago and left his peculiar Easterling animal in the Grazing Fields for that whole time, yet it had remained happy and unmolested. Why then, some amongst them might argue, would this place be unsafe now?
None among the party had offered that argument when the carving of the Black Speech had been found. Tawarengil, in his inexperience, was just now beginning to realize what the Istari might have already known; the danger of this place was greater now that blood had been spilled.
‘Yes, brother,’ Tawarengil replied, ‘I believe that you are right in this.’
‘I see, again,’ Beothalion said, still looking thoughtful and quite serious. ‘And we cannot take the Dwarf from this place and go back into the open lands?’
‘Not for more than a few days, or so I have heard,’ Tawarengil replied. ‘Pallando is a great healer, I am certain, and if he claims this time is needed for the dwarf, I do not doubt it. He will remain here by his charge. But tell me, brother, should we?’
Beothalion looked at him with a sharper eye. ‘Would we leave them?’
‘I do not know their path, brother,’ Tawarengil said, ‘and I don’t know if it is part of our own. We have gone far from our homes to a great gathering of force against Angmar. I hoped to see great legions of my people march as they had in ages long past and to be part of a great change in the northlands of this world. And I believe that we, quite unexpectedly, have had a rare chance-meeting with these others which my... spirit12 tells me to follow. But are we to stay and defend one wounded dwarf in a hall which has long ago fallen into darkness? Are we reckless to abandon our own plans for another’s? Brother, I do not know.’
‘Well, brother,’ Beothalion said, smiling, ‘I do not know your spirit better than you do, and I should not like to. I have not really spent time with Dwarfs, and can not speak to defending them. This one seems kindly, and I very much like his friends that we have traveled with these few days. But I do not wish to be reckless, Tawar. I am, as you know, a very ordered person.’
Tawarengil laughed richly at this and Beothalion, not really understanding the joke, laughed as well for the joy it brought them both. Over near the fountains Rosie and Ohtar’s strange animal laughed with them in a way that only the four of them fully understood.
‘Master Floxleaf’s friend would not forgive us for leaving just yet, it seems,’ Tawarengil said, ‘and that other creature could learn much, I think, from your better nature.’
‘Oh, you should not make sport of him,’ Beothalion said. ‘For he is happy in his way and cares little of your thoughts of banners and legions and “great changes in the northlands.” He laughs as we do, and shits and eats and sings to show his contentment. Perhaps that is the better nature he shows to us.’
Tawarengil smiled at this, happy for his brother’s gentle needling and quiet wisdom.
‘Well then,’ he said, ‘if you will not speak to what road you think we might take, brother, it seems I must content myself with the counsel of an ass. Wisdom, it is said, comes from unexpected sources in the wild country, and that creature is as unexpected and wild as I might ever imagine.’
*****
Ben was wrong about the sound of the rats; the sound of Beothalion’s distress terrified him more greatly, almost to that point of being ‘terrified-to-stillness’ he had wondered about earlier that day. No sound in all his many travels had struck him with such fear, and it came now from just beside him, from a gentle-seeming soul whom he had counted as a new friend.
There was a rat who breeched the door, a smaller one to be sure, but fast and darting toward Ben’s foot while his attention had been elsewhere. Collum’s warning had made him turn quickly and bring his little hunting knife across that way. Perhaps he would have defended himself against the rat, even as others piled into the breach behind him. Perhaps he could have kept pace with this small flood of foes who had found a way through this small corner of their defenses.
It was not worth wondering. For Beothalion had been roused then in his anxiousness.
And so there was a cry which echoed throughout the cavern and stilled every voice, every movement, and Ben was quite powerless against it.
‘Brüllllllllllennnnnnn!'13 the voice called.
And the sound was great and seemed to shake the very walls around the Grazing Field so that Ben and Collum and Tawarengil, so near to its source, found themselves seized by terror; vengeful and exultant the cry sounded, but poor Ben and the ageless elf-child and the veteran soldier could do nothing but draw their hands and their weapons up to guard their faces against it.
There was also, though Ben was too alarmed to understand it in the moment, a great answering cry which came from Rosie and Caitelyn and the queer Easterling animal, Duncan. They were filled with fear, yes, but if Ben had full account of his senses he might have noticed some hint in his Rosie’s voice of comfort; as if she sensed something greatly, very greatly, feared but long looked for.
And as the roaring cry rang out, the noise of the rats was quite suddenly stopped.
And, lifting his eyes slowly from behind his fingers, Ben saw the door between them all demolished, splintering and flying into a hundred wooden shards as Beothalion, or some great shape like he had been, went through it, stomping, thrashing and chomping at every rat in his path. And a new noise began: the sound of the rats’ voices in terror as they ran in every direction they could to escape this unexpected onslaught.
It took time for the comrades to regain themselves. Tawarengil was the first. He reached with his left hand to take hold of the wooden sword that he had laid by the door and, with a keen dagger in his right hand as accompaniment, he barreled through the sundered doorway to support his friend. Collum ran up next to Ben and cried, ‘We must hold them here should they regroup! Ben, stand by me! Oisín! Bring torches!’
Some few, fearful now as they had not seemed before and now screaming with terror undirected, tried to scurry through the doorframe to escape Beothalion’s wrath. Ben and Collum were quick to thwart them, and Oisín, now coming up the ramp after provisioning their escape, held two torches in one hand while brandishing his long, gnarled club in the other. The rats’ fear of fire, dagger, sword and bludgeon helped to hold what was left of the doorway.
But the main battlefield now was in the antechamber just beyond the doorway, and the sound of many rat voices could be heard as they fled in terror from the great dark shape of Beothalion in his rage.
‘Brüllllllllllennnnnnn!’ the cry came again, echoing throughout the whole of the cavern, and all the rats fled from it. From his place at the door Ben could see Beothalion (though he looked to have grown to an even more enormous size and appeared as a great dark and lumbering figure in the gloom of the antechamber) as he swept his long powerful arms right and left, sending debris of many rat bodies away with each great arc. Their former single-mindedness, such a strange thing in these creatures, was gone now and they wildly sought escape from the terror of the enemy they had found here. They fled everywhere and in all directions. As Collum and Ben and the Bard did all they could to safeguard the doorway, Tawarengil ran lightly, briskly, behind his friend out in the antechamber, sweeping away great clusters of the animals with long strokes of his wooden blade and deftly slaying them one and sometimes two at a time with quick thrusts from his agile dagger.
‘Glory,' Ben thought, ‘I took him for a child by his looks, but that one is a warrior I’ve not seen the like of. Look how his wooden blade and his shining knife spin through the dark!’
They struck hard at every rat body they saw. Oisín had wanted to take the fight outside the doorway where Beothalion and Tawarengil were engaged, but Collum held him back. ‘They come for us here, Oisín Na-Ghiliruin! We must hold them here and protect our friends!’ Each of the Men had now taken a torch in their off hands, holding them low to the edges of the door while Ben held secondline against any rat who bravely or in terror came through.
Beothalion, in his loud and terrifying rage, had reached the Mysterious Door. The rats fled before him, and he stomped them and mashed them and bent low to crush them in his powerful jaws, and all were terrified of his coming. They scattered as they could and many, many hundreds, fled back beneath the door’s opening. Behind him Tawarengil destroyed many, and the rats learned to fear the wooden sword as much as the dagger.
Beothalion began to hammer at the Mysterious Door, and the sound of it echoed throughout all of the cavern. The rats who dared scurried beneath his feet to the door’s other side, but many, many fled away and up the stairs looking for escape.
‘Brüllllllllllennnnnnn!’ his cry went, frightening all. Boom, Boom! Boom, Boom! His great fists went, hammering on the ancient and Mysterious Door that was the source of their trouble.
From his place behind, destroying every scurrying creature he might reach, Tawarengil spoke to his friend; ‘Brother! You’ve opened quite enough doors tonight, I think! Please calm yourself now and let that one be!’
If they'd had time to speak their own minds, Ben and Collum might well agree. But it was at that moment the great light of the Moon entered the chamber here under the earth.
*****
‘There are wards here upon this door,’ the old wizard explained, ‘which I can read. Many are meant to hold the door, as I believe it has been held for some time. But,’ Alatar finished, ‘among them there is also a ward which opens it.’
Ohtar and Ben, after their talk together, stood beside the two wizards at the Great Door between the two fountains. Water entered the chamber here on either side of the Door and filled two large scalloped stone basins at just above Ben’s own height. In them the constant, gentle sound of the flowing water had a calming effect within this chamber that they had called the Grazing Field; all were attracted to it. Once, shortly after they had arrived here and while Ben felt he had little to do but investigate his surroundings while the others talked their high talk, he had put his hand into the basin, just above his head, and been surprised by the coolness of the water. Drawing some out in his hand, he found that it tasted fresh and cool as a mountain stream. Wisely following his father’s advice, he had filled his drinking skin immediately.
By some contrivance or design he could not hope to understand, Ben saw that the water from these basins flowed into lower troughs on either side, moving farther away from the doors. These were not ornate as the basins were. Each trough was about two spans in length and, being but chest-high to a hobbit, were obviously meant for the watering of horses. Here they had led the animals and all had drunk delightedly from the unexpectedly cool water. But, by some other design Ben did not understand, the level in these troughs seemed to change very little, no matter how much Rosie, or the horses, or that other queer animal, that Duncan, might drink at a turn. Water flowed constantly from basin to trough and, so it seemed, down from there and out somewhere else into the chamber. ‘How else were these mosses and other plants fed so long?’ Ben thought.14 ‘The place is a marvel, that’s certain. Clever like the ruins I’ve seen to the north, for Men were clever in the days of the Old Kingdom. But these wells and doors and things are working still. A marvel that is, which I’ve not seen anywhere before.’
This was, of course, quite more true than he might understand. For Ben and the others stood here, before these rare doors, at the brink of one of the last preserved works of Númenórean builders from when they first came out of the Sea and into the northlands. While Ohtar and many of his grandfathers had called them ‘the Great Doors’ for many hundreds of years, this room, with its natural fountains and its sustainable field, with its secret entrance and its guarded one, were in fact of a humble and austere design as suited its purpose; the room and the doors and the fountains were not and had never been ‘great’ by the Númenórean aesthetic, no matter what later generations might call them. But now, and for being still functional while so much of Númenórean work had fallen into decay or legend, they hinted at a former greatness; so well-preserved as they were in time when so much of the North had so obviously fallen.
The height of this chamber did indeed seem great by contrast to the shallow low and narrow steps and antechamber which one used to access it. But the roof overhead was not much greater than eight ranga,15 and the Great Doors here between the fountains less than half that in height. Tall, yes, for the Númenóreans of old were a tall and doughty folk by all accounts, but as Ben considered it now, the doors themselves were not so much taller than the doors to the Bree-land stables. Yet they were not crafted of wood like the door above. These doors were fashioned of once-polished white stone (one he did not recall seeing before), and many letters and symbols were carved upon them that Ben did not understand (though he had seen many of these symbols in other places, but never much considered them).
‘You may open it, perhaps,’ Collum said to the wizard, ‘but may we close it again from the other side? If we open it to make ourselves safe will doing so then leave it unguarded to the enemy and to desecration? For this I cannot do. And,’ he said with great concern, ‘if we cannot come out again, where might we go? The two known ends of this roadway are lost. Are there others in either direction? None of my people have said and none living may know. Do you know better, Greatfather?’
‘I do not,’ Alatar said, and Ben, for the first time in days, thought he saw a hint of compassion cross the wizard’s knitted brow. ‘I do not know enough about the history of your people to guess at this. If the doors are opened, which I believe I can teach you to do, then you should be able to close them from the other side. Through all of its defenses, this is roadway for the Dúnedain and like the secret door above, you and your folk are meant to keep it.’
Ohtar looked long at the Great Doors, which held such mystery for him ever since he first came to this place many years ago. He saw this place in a way Ben could not; for he looked past the wonderment to the order and the precision of the design. Here, in a room he had hoped to use for solace and a brief hiding, he knew, as he had before bringing Flomi here, that they stood on the verge of something greater. This ‘watering hole’ that his folk had visited and kept secret for many long centuries Ohtar and many of his family knew for its deeper history. Here was the ordered waystation for the great mystery of Men. Here, beyond this place Flomi had casually named “the Grazing Field” was the Causeway, Tauma. It was the last road of kings and symbol of how his People both exalted and feared death. Ohtar had opened a secret door above in his need, but the fear of opening this Great Door below was an answer to his faith.
‘I may keep the way best, Wisefather, and keep best my faith and my Peoples’ history best as well,’ he said to the wizard, ‘by never bringing light into that doorway.’
*****
In an instant all of the rats within sight of the shattered doorway were suddenly blinded. This did not keep them from scurrying toward torches and blades and daggers, of course, but it made them much less dangerous in their frenzy. The light came like a hard rain across Ben’s back and into the antechamber. To call it ‘light’ felt wrong to Ben, for it was more like a heavy feeling, an almost physical sensation like a hailstorm without a wind as it stunned anyone caught looking at it.
‘Lacenítë!’16 The great voice called from behind Ben. He knew it was Alatar who had, during all the conflict, come behind the three door guards quite carefully on the narrow landing. Ben could not look back to be certain, as he felt the light emanating like an unexpected storm that had come out of the wizard, fallen across his own back, to go out and into the antechamber and blind all those who would look in their terror.
Many rats were destroyed by this light. They simply disappeared before Ben’s eyes as if they had never been. They were quite simply snuffed like smoke under a bucket of fresh water, and Ben wondered if they had truly been or, as unnatural beings, were they just now banished by some spell. Most of these vanished creatures were the ones with the greatest resolve, directly surrounding their position at the door. The hard rain of light hit them and left nothing in their place; not smell nor fire nor smoke nor carcass. They were abolished quite as clearly as if they had not existed.
Alatar strode past Ben and Collum and the Bard, tall and spry and agile despite his seeming age, and out into the antechamber, his form long and dark as if the silhouette of his body was a long shadow cast by the great light held in his hand. As he passed into Ben’s sight, the hobbit saw that there was a wand there; the curious, curling, bone-white one he had seen before now glowed again, but with a light brighter and more silver than if the Moon himself had come down and been carried into this small space. Around the wizard, all of this light seemed to gather, and the blue of his robes, the silver of his hair, and the paleness of his skin were like one great, soft, comforting but terrifying blue torch in the darkness. Living rats, those who still had their wits, blindly fled from the radiance of him. The others fell to their backs, afraid, conquered, and hoping for a mercy that their kind had never known.
He strode to the center of the antechamber and, with a great rolling voice he then called to Beothalion, ‘Leave that door and your anger behind you, Young One! What lies beyond is not for us this night and your friends have greater need of you than violence!’
Beothalion’s great arms let go one last harsh fury against the door, ‘Boom Boom! Boom!’ and then grew quiet. Ben could not see much in his position of second guard, but it seems that the Wildman became suddenly still, suddenly calm, and the shadow of his great hulking figure diminished there before the Mysterious Door just as the light from Alatar’s wand brought a quietness to the room.
‘I think we shall have no more out of that door for the evening,’ the wizard said calmly as the remaining rats, still hundreds of them, scurried or writhed in blind terror around him as the young Elf-lord, leaping and swinging and stabbing with his swift accuracy drew them further into panic. But beyond his two companions, beyond Beothalion’s still form, with the light still present but not as blinding in the antechamber, Ben could see that the gap in the Mysterious Door, formerly not much bigger than his own small hand, had opened and was now almost to his own height, and he wondered what might come from it next.
End of Chapter IX
Notes on Chapter Nine
1) Radagast is much less of a blank slate than the Blue Wizards featured in this story. I don’t care much for the comedic effect that he was given in The Hobbit movies, but Sylvester McCoy did bring a bit of eccentricism bordering on madness, which I like. I hope to convey him as a sort of a renegade from the other four Istari, more accustomed to beasts and growing things than to the societies of Elf or Man.
2) The Great Plague came into Gondor in about 1635 of the Third Age, about the same time that a Shadow fell on the Greatwood. This would be over 300 years before the time of this tale.
3) I’ve completely stolen this moment from the movie Flash Gordon where the scientist, Emil Zarkoff, walks off the spaceship, sniffs deeply and loudly, declaring; “Good. There is oxygen on this planet.”
4) While “nâr” is indeed Sindarin for “rat”, it is the singular form with "nair" being the plural. But for dramatic effect "nâr" sounds better.
5) This is not part of The Tale of Eärendur, a riff I’ve constructed over the scattered stones of Beowulf, but it does use some of the same meter.
6) An expression often used by Gaffer Gamgee, of course.
7) I think that most Númenóreans would see the followers of Sauron as their great enemy.
8) Fornost Erain in the Hobbit way of speaking.
9) I’ve chosen another hobbit-like name for Lake Evendim, this time of my own invention.
10) This, of course, is the Bywater Bridge in the Shire.
11) “Peace, brother!” In Sindarin.
12) Tawarengil pauses here because “fae”, which is Sindarin for “spirit or radiance” is not a word that he thinks would translate well into the Westron tongue. He’s kind of a snob that way.
13) This curious word is not from any of Tolkien’s invented languages and to reveal its source here might spoil later surprises. For those of you who are curious, it is German. See what that tells you.
14) One of the most interesting and sometimes difficult things to write in Middle-earth is a character’s encounter with a modern or mythical technology that is quite beyond them. It gives one the chance to describe something now commonplace with a sense of wonder, but it can often sound cheap and phony. I was going for the former here and apologize if I’ve hit upon the latter.
15) Again, this is a Númenórean stride, just a little over a yard by our standards, and the principal unit of measure still in the North.
16) This Quenya word means “blind or unseeing” but it is an adjective and will need to be changed later to a command.